Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parent & Child -v- Disabled Parking Bays?

493 replies

Lambstails · 24/05/2023 15:31

Hello,

Firstly, I feel the need to apologise for posting on here, but I'm genuinely interested in the view of any parents or other guardians of children who use dedicated parent and child spaces. The reason for my apology being that I am not, and have never unfortunately been a parent myself - this was not a lifestyle choice.

I am however, registered disabled and in receipt of the higher mobility rate of PIP which automatically entitles me to use a blue badge. The nature of my condition means that some (very few) days I am quite capable of parking in a 'normal' bay if there is one available relatively close to where I need to be, but most days I HAVE to use a wider bay to get myself in and out of my car, together with my wheeled walker. On days where I can cope ok with just a walking stick, and where there's a regular space available close enough, I steer clear of the blue badge bays, preferring to leave them for people who have no option but to use them. I also would like to add (as it's relevant further down) that my 85 year old Mother is also registered disabled (we have the same congenital spinal condition). My Mum is also sadly now in palliative care for terminal cancer and she cannot walk more than about 10 metres, so is a wheelchair user. She is rarely well enough to leave the house, but on hers and mine 'better' days, I do try and get her out for an hour or so.

A month or so ago, I was able to take Mum out and parked at a local retail park where the ratio of blue badge spaces to parent and child spaces is about 8/15 in the P&C space's favour (I find this bewildering, to be honest). There were no BB spaces free, but plenty of P&C bays were unused. I therefore parked in one and ensured my blue badge was displayed. Fast forward to when we returned to my car, having pushed Mum around the shop for 5 minutes or so, got her out of her wheelchair, into the car and the wheelchair in the boot, I was about on my knees myself. I cannot describe how difficult this is sometimes, for both of us. Anyway, before I could get myself in the car, a furious woman came over to me and lambasted me for parking in a P&C space. She was also parked in one next to me (with her suspiciously tall teenage children in the back). I tried to explain that there were no blue badge spaces free at the time we parked but she called me all sorts of unrepeatable names and "a lazy b*tch" to boot. I pointed out that she and her 'children' looked quite capable of walking, she didn't have a pushchair or pram and that my Mum cannot walk, which she clearly could see with the difficulty getting her into the car, but she was having none of it. I decided to then ignore her and just leave, she was the sort of person there was going to be no reasoning with and being yelled and sworn out in a public car park isn't really for me.

I put this out of my mind and today went to the car park to pick up some items for Mum from Boots. Once again, there were no BB spaces free and around a dozen P&C spaces unoccupied. Today is a 'bad' day - I am in a lot of pain and walking more than a few steps at a time is difficult and I needed my walker. So I reluctantly parked in a P&C space, knowing that I would be little more than 5 minutes to pick up some medication. And yes, once again when I returned to my car, there was a young Mum waiting for me by her car (parked next to me). And yes, once again I received a berating. This lady was a different model to the previous angry woman - she politely asked me if I was aware I had parked in a P&C space - I was completely honest and said yes, hence why I had displayed my blue badge. Maybe I should have lied and pleaded ignorance, as at this point she changed - having ascertained I had knowingly parked here, she promptly called me selfish and said she was off to find a security officer to report me and my selfishness. The source of her fury seemed to be that she said she wouldn't dream of parking in a BB bay if all the P&C spaces were full. I pointed out that she has a choice whether to walk a little further or not, I usually don't. I suggested she maybe should have considered this before deciding whether to have children, if it was to become so important to her, she said it's nothing to do with not wanting to walk, and everything to do with the safety of parents and their children, apparently it isn't safe for a Mother to be pushing a young baby in a pram around a busy car park. The way my legs operate most days, I wouldn't be particularly safe walking on bubble wrap!

I am more distressed, rattled and upset about these two incidents than I probably should be. With my own middle age, the impending mortality of both my parents, together with both my nieces recently having had their first babies, perhaps my own child-free status is playing on my mind at the moment, although I don't think I am the 'woe is me' type. I am not an unhappy, bitter old bag (honestly!) - I've got a fantastic husband, and a great job; I've had a lot in my life to be so very thankful for. Children of our own would have been the icing on the cake, but it's never been the be-all and end-all. On both occasions, whilst being sweetly polite to these women, more than anything I wanted to scream at them to be damn thankful for what they've got and just go and enjoy it. Having a blue badge is not a choice for me, to have had children would have been - that's how I see the difference.

I really would like to get some opinions on this emotive subject, more to try and understand the perspective of these two women. I have no idea if P&C spaces are 'legal' spaces as are BB bays, but even if they are, if there are dozens of them available and not being used, what is the real harm of a BB holder using one? I'm not convinced that P&C spaces aren't actually a marketing ploy conjured up by the retailers, as typically these spaces now tend to be nearer shops' entrances than actual BB ones!

I'm interested in all opinions, particularly those that can put a different spin on this and make me see it from the point of view of these two women. One of my 'new Mum' nieces has joined in the attack on me - she too believes that I have acted selfishly and reiterated how difficult it is to get baby/child seats out of a car without sufficient space around them. I do understand that. But thinking about it, if the situation was reversed and BB spaces were available where P&C ones weren't, I doubt very much I would begrudge a parent or guardian parking in one if it was obvious they needed to!

(I've just realised how long this post is, apologies if you made it this far down and are still with me 😂)

Thanks,

Beatrix x

OP posts:
Saniflo · 25/05/2023 09:14

Two of my children have blue badges and we always park in parent spaces as a first choice to save room for BBs in the disabled bays. Obviously sometimes we have to use a disabled bay, as per my other post, it is just a free for all here.

Crunchingleaf · 25/05/2023 09:13

I would prefer if P&C spots were moved a bit further away from entrance to be honest. It would stop the lazy, entitled people using them. The extra width is a godsend for infant carriers. When my toddler was in his infant carrier I had to use other side of car on a couple of occasions to get back into the car when using normal parking spaces. Now I have another baby so I wouldn’t be able to do that.

I would never say anything to anyone parked in a P&C spot even though most of them are doing it to save them a couple seconds of a walk.

You OP continue to use whatever spot you need to use on any particular day.

Saniflo · 25/05/2023 09:12

Anyone just parks in them here. I wouldn't begrudge a BB parking there when it is just a free for all generally.

Rosscameasdoody · 25/05/2023 09:08

HideTheCroissants · 24/05/2023 18:33

You are not in the wrong OP. However, Parent & child spaces ARE for safety - they allow the car door to be opened sufficiently for a child to be strapped into a car seat / for a carried car seat to be fixed into the car, or for the pushchair to be safely beside the car rather than behind / in front of the space where it could be hit. In an ideal world parking spaces would always be big enough for a car door to be fully opened …. but they aren’t.

Personally I have ALWAYS said that parent & child spaces should be further away from the store to stop them being abused and allowing for the spaces nearest the store to be blue badge spaces only (yes - even when my DCs were small enough for me to need the spaces). In both your examples OP I believe you were totally in the right.

the ratio of blue badge spaces to parent and child spaces is about 8/15 in the P&C space's favour (I find this bewildering, to be honest).

This shouldn’t be bewildering though… quite simply there are more people with young children than there are people with blue badges…….

If that were the only reason, there would have been no need for the OP to use a P&C space because there weren’t enough BB spaces.

ThatOnePlease · 25/05/2023 08:47

Notamum12345577 · 24/05/2023 23:05

?? I think it would be, if there are no blue badge spaces available then yes park in a parent and child. But if there is a blue badge space available, why then would it be ok to park in a parent and child? There would be absolutely no need

BB can and should park in the parking space that is safest and most convenient for them. That's quite literally what it means to have a BB. A BB has priority.

ThatOnePlease · 25/05/2023 08:41

What an awful experience, OP. So sorry that happened to you. Of course BB can park wherever they need to.

If someone ever shouts at you again, then, if you feel safe to do so, contact security. I would suggest filming the confrontation, but that could be very unsafe for you.

Some people are ignorant twats.

Asiama · 25/05/2023 08:40

You did nothing wrong.

Next time you are with your mum and someone bothers you, tell them you are ok to park there since you two are also mother and child!Grin

user1471518104 · 25/05/2023 08:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lambstails · 25/05/2023 08:33

Wow! I am blown away with the response to my post and have loved reading through all the messages. I gather there was some trolling, but I think the posts concerned had been removed by the time I got to that bit, so fortunately I didn't see them.

Thank you so much to each and every one of you who took the time to reply. I am heartened by the general consensus that I did nothing wrong - I genuinely had talked myself into being a small time criminal, and it's reassuring to read that I didn't act massively unreasonably.

Again, thank you. I plan to write to the car parking authority for this retail park and make them aware of the issues with the small amount of BB spaces and the positioning of the P&C spaces in relation. It's worth a shot, I guess.

Bea x

OP posts:
Mammadibambini · 25/05/2023 01:59

Some people are just nasty. Sorry you met two so close together OP!

Achwheesht · 25/05/2023 00:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LoveBluey · 24/05/2023 23:56

Completely out of order to be so rude to you.

I have small children but realise that even wrangling buggies, car seats, screaming babies and unco-operative toddlers is in no way comparable to needing a bigger space because of disability or mobility issues. It's easier to have a bigger space but I manage if they're not available.

For me I find it much more annoying when parents of older children use the p&c spaces. My general rule is if the child is old enough to unbuckle seatbelt and get out of car door themselves they don't need the space. I see loads of people with kids 8+ who are clearly just using for the convenience. I feel they are taking the piss and should know better as they once had small children.

Either way I can't summon the energy or anger to confront people and just get on with my day.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 24/05/2023 23:52

Notamum12345577 · 24/05/2023 23:48

Well yes, obviously. We have kids, wife has a blue badge.
But I was talking about when the disabled person doesn’t have kids with them, as per the OP

You say obviously, but the woman waiting for the OP had no idea when she was waiting if she had children or not but had obviously decided that because she had a blue badge she wasn't entitled to park in a P&C spot regardless so it's not necessarily obvious to everyone unfortunately

Notamum12345577 · 24/05/2023 23:48

Catchasingmewithspiders · 24/05/2023 23:13

Well for starters disabled people are allowed to have children

Well yes, obviously. We have kids, wife has a blue badge.
But I was talking about when the disabled person doesn’t have kids with them, as per the OP

Marths · 24/05/2023 23:15

Notamum12345577 · 24/05/2023 23:05

?? I think it would be, if there are no blue badge spaces available then yes park in a parent and child. But if there is a blue badge space available, why then would it be ok to park in a parent and child? There would be absolutely no need

Sometimes the P and C spaces are closer to the shop.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 24/05/2023 23:13

Notamum12345577 · 24/05/2023 23:05

?? I think it would be, if there are no blue badge spaces available then yes park in a parent and child. But if there is a blue badge space available, why then would it be ok to park in a parent and child? There would be absolutely no need

Well for starters disabled people are allowed to have children

Notamum12345577 · 24/05/2023 23:05

Clymene · 24/05/2023 18:35

@Notamum12345577

if someone parked in a P&C space when there was blue badge available, that would be out of order.

Nope.

?? I think it would be, if there are no blue badge spaces available then yes park in a parent and child. But if there is a blue badge space available, why then would it be ok to park in a parent and child? There would be absolutely no need

Catchasingmewithspiders · 24/05/2023 23:02

Famzonhol · 24/05/2023 22:50

Oh dear God.
A woman who clearly has mobility issues shouldn’t be shouted at by a woman with a child for taking “her” parking space.
Move your child, luv.

Where did i say she should be?

In fact I have consistently throughout the thread including in the post you quoted said she shouldn't be.

I am also physically and visually disabled.

Oh and I dont have a child luv.

Famzonhol · 24/05/2023 22:50

Catchasingmewithspiders · 24/05/2023 22:47

For some/most its a choice. But for some women its not a choice. Either through rape, abusive relationships, religious and family expectations, or an accidental pregancy and not being able to face an abortion.

None of this means its okay to be rude to disabled people of course. But that doesnt discount the fact that saying its a lifestyle choice is a bit of a flippant remark that ignores some womens reality.

1 in 4 women at a sexual health clinic reported reproductive coercion. That figure does include women who were coerced into an abortion, but it still indicates that there are a fair number if women who are not choosing a lifestyle choice, they are being coerced into having a child.

Oh dear God.
A woman who clearly has mobility issues shouldn’t be shouted at by a woman with a child for taking “her” parking space.
Move your child, luv.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 24/05/2023 22:47

Lizzt2007 · 24/05/2023 22:16

Of course it's a lifestyle choice! You're not forced to have children, it's a choice you make!

For some/most its a choice. But for some women its not a choice. Either through rape, abusive relationships, religious and family expectations, or an accidental pregancy and not being able to face an abortion.

None of this means its okay to be rude to disabled people of course. But that doesnt discount the fact that saying its a lifestyle choice is a bit of a flippant remark that ignores some womens reality.

1 in 4 women at a sexual health clinic reported reproductive coercion. That figure does include women who were coerced into an abortion, but it still indicates that there are a fair number if women who are not choosing a lifestyle choice, they are being coerced into having a child.

Lizzt2007 · 24/05/2023 22:16

Tandora · 24/05/2023 21:32

It’s not a “lifestyle choice” and it’s not rude to point that out to anyone , regardless of their circumstances.

Of course it's a lifestyle choice! You're not forced to have children, it's a choice you make!

candlesflamesandbrooms · 24/05/2023 22:15

Oh god I'm gonna get burnt at the stake for this one but

In my area the number of disabled spaces wayyy out numbers the parent and child spaces. Always tones of disabled spaces but what really gets on my nerves is older people using them (assuming because they don't have a blue badge) or don't qualify. I imagine some must be on the verge of qualifying or just don't want to apply but there are so many of them that actually it kinda annoys me because "they think won't use a disabled space but I will take up a parent and space as it's only a curtesy space"

The thing is most parents don't need the proximity to the store, we just need the space toddler and infant out of their unwelding and large car seats (are they purposely making them just more and more difficult to use or is it just me?)

Getting on a bus with small children in my area is legitimately hell, especially since I'm now totally out numbered.

Trains are the same and people glare at you when you go on a train with a small child.

Walking on the pavement with a pram is now a hazzard due to bikes hoping on and off the road randomly

It feels a bit like the world can be pretty hostile to women with small children (take small children to a restaurant) and either get eyeballed because they are making normal children noise or eyeballed if you give them a tablet, colouring books ect.
Society expects mums to work like they don't have children and look after their children like they don't work.

None of this is anything to do with you. Yes having children is a lifestyle choice and a privilege but it seems as a society we have moved away from a "it takes a village to raise a child" to a society of "you have no village, if you do it's more costly than your mortgage, and that same village is judging you by what seems to be standards no one could achieve as the standards vary person to person so if in doubt your doing it wrong"

Some of these issues I don't doubt you encountered my dear grandmother was disabled and terrified of cyclists after nearly being knocked over by one on pavement.

These people had no right to have a go at you. I certainly don't have a problem with a disabled person using a p and c space.
But if you can't already tell I think as a society we don't talk about maternal rage enough, that rage is often years worth of anger at being told not only are you doing it wrong but don't complain because parenting is a privilege and be a nice placid women. Bit of a oxymoron but it is what it is.

I think you encountered some maternal rage and of course you shouldn't have been spoken to like that there's no excuse.

But if your looking for why they did what they did, it's always worth looking at the reasons outside of a situation as to why someone might be angry. I doubt it was anything to do with you tbh. Just the grind and two people hitting out at the wrong person (because I doubt society is going to change any time soon).

I say this as someone who lost her first son and finds parenting a privilege and also recognises that that privilege can also be incredibly hard. Specially when you talk about it being hard, because people like to remind you how grateful you should be (and to basically shut up)You can be so v grateful for your children and also feel like your screaming into a void.

Lizzt2007 · 24/05/2023 22:12

Cocolatte24 · 24/05/2023 20:18

@wenfy parent and child pales are not courtesy parks and the only people using them should be parents with children in car seats.. not parents with teens and most definitely not people w/o children.

the space isn’t to make it easier to walk through a car park, it’s to provide enough room to open the door and access the child seat and set up the pram / baby carrier safely and not in the road.

nobody encourages people to use the spaces without children - you’re talking out of your arse. All Sainsburys near me have signs warning of an £85 misuse fine; they check for car seats and rightly so

There is no legal requirement to provide parent and child bays, they certainly are courtesy parking. Unlike disabled bays that have to be provided by law. The fact that Sainsbury's choose to issue fines is purely their choice and not a legal requirement.

GG1986 · 24/05/2023 22:07

Wow these women are vile, sorry you were spoken to like that! I would have no issue whatsoever with somebody disabled parking in a parent and child space! I use those spaces at the moment as I have a newborn and it's difficult to get the car seat out to put on the pram, but with my older child(7) if it was just us in the car we wouldn't necessarily park in a parent and child space as she can easily walk and get out of the car easily.

Lizzt2007 · 24/05/2023 22:03

Sissynova · 24/05/2023 16:34

I wouldn’t have said anything to you but it is annoying when people park in P&C spaces.
I’m not going to know whether you usually qualify for a disabled space in a fleeting second in a carpark.
‘You should have thought about that before having a child’ is a really weird argument. I should have thought about what? Someone parking too close to me which means I can’t get my toddler in and out of the car seat?
Personally I think P&C spaces should be further back so there’s no desire for other people to use them.

The blue badge in the window might give you a clue.