Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think young women just don’t realise... (TW: fertility/ TTC)

445 replies

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 14:10

Nc as this combined with various other posts would be outing, this is a bugbear I’ve thought about a lot when ttc myself and something today brought it up again...

Anyhow, AIBU to think ladies In their late twenties who freeze their eggs (or plan to as a ‘failsafe’) don’t realise it’s not a guarantee or the same as ‘pressing pause’ on biology?

This comes about as i was chatting to childhood friend (29, same as me) about kids (I have recently had DS so this is why we were chatting about kids) and she said ‘oh x (school pal) froze her eggs recently, if I haven’t had kids by 33 I’ll do the same, x is so relieved to press pause and take the pressure off’ another friend has also mentioned egg freezing recently for the same reason, both have just said they don’t want the responsibility of kids yet but are in a ‘good’ position to do so ... each to their own but all I could think was that it’s all well and good but it doesn’t guarantee anything! Sadly the demon biology also makes it harder to carry as you age too, it’s not all about eggs!

I just think so many in my generation have the attitude that it will just happen later regardless thanks to science but everyone I know who has had kids or tried to have kids later has struggled (not a guarantee ofc but a statistical probability nonetheless)... interested to hear other people’s thoughts on this. Perhaps this is more of a ‘my circle of friends’ issue than a wider one.

YANBU - it’s a concern, many may end up disappointed in the future, not to mention already falling birth rates etc
YABU - mind your own!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
knitpicky · 24/05/2023 20:37

orangemagnolia · 24/05/2023 19:55

I disagree. I think the way we have organised society is a bitch. It shouldn't be the norm to have to cram everything in, work and education wise, in our peak childbearing years.

Agree with this 100%

Society is organised on a male timescale. It makes perfect sense for men to get their qualifications and work their way up the greasy pole before having children. If men had a limited fertility window, I can guarantee that the whole of society would be differently organised.

whumpthereitis · 24/05/2023 20:37

orangemagnolia · 24/05/2023 19:22

All of which is perfectly true. She's right to feel that way.

Lol. They’ve made a difference choice to her, which isn’t the same as a lesser choice. It’s far more mature to wait until you are ready for a child, than it is to rush into having one.

Who knows what the future holds? They may go on to have children, or they may not. They may decide they don’t want to have them at all.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 20:30

I was a doctor at 23, bought a flat at 26 and had a baby at 28 (v. unfashionable) We weren't rich (for a longtime) but had a home and good jobs. We had loads of energy (and family help) pregnancy childbirth and sleepness nights barely affected me.

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 20:28

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 20:25

The difference between 29 & 33 is time to start fertility treatment if it's needed when it still has a good chance of working. Start at 33 try for 2 years, your 35 when you see your GP then 18m NHS wait list, then tests etc you could easily be 37 before your 1st IVF round vs. 33 if you started the whole process at 29. That's the difference.

That’s a good point - I hadn’t considered it that way. More simply just the actual stats of how likely you are to conceive naturally, rather than the potential knock on if you do find out you would need treatment.

OP posts:
knitpicky · 24/05/2023 20:26

Blimeor · 24/05/2023 18:28

@knitpicky @strawberryjeans

Part of the problem is education is easier to access (and free!) when you're young. There should be more money made available for people to train later in life. So if you want to have kids earlier you won't lose out on those opportunities.

I had a PhD by the time I was 24. So I could very easily have had babies then!

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 20:25

The difference between 29 & 33 is time to start fertility treatment if it's needed when it still has a good chance of working. Start at 33 try for 2 years, your 35 when you see your GP then 18m NHS wait list, then tests etc you could easily be 37 before your 1st IVF round vs. 33 if you started the whole process at 29. That's the difference.

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 20:24

Tellmeimcrazy · 24/05/2023 20:13

Anything is possible but many people may not want to do it that way. I would say MOST people wouldn't want kids and work and a degree given the choice.

Agree, I didn’t say it was the optimal choice (I don’t think it is fwiw) - just countering a PP who said

“Part of the problem is education is easier to access (and free!) when you're young. There should be more money made available for people to train later in life. So if you want to have kids earlier you won't lose out on those opportunities.”

which is simply an untruth - you have the same right to higher, degree level education later in life provided you meet the entry requirements.

OP posts:
DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 20:21

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 24/05/2023 20:04

As someone who needed IVF in their 20's. don't be so superior @DespairingALittle you can have trouble at any age, and not because you were selfish either. Women are well aware of their need to choose to have children on both societal and biological times scales. It's in every newspaper!

Absolutely- in fact this is a great reason why if you know you want kids and you are with the person you want to have them with etc then perhaps delaying isn’t the best idea because you aren’t likely to know until you try! Anyone can suffer infertility at any, simply the likelihood increases.

OP posts:
DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 20:19

GeraltsBathtub · 24/05/2023 20:08

None of that is particularly relevant to what I said, but there are usually financial and time management barriers to going to uni with kids which is why it’s not a very popular option.

To expand on what I did say, everyone I know (other than literally one person) has gone to uni at 18/19, and most of them have them stayed in education or training until their mid-20s. It doesn’t usually make sense to have a baby in the middle of your PhD or training contract and it’s harder to get into grad schemes when you’re not in your 20s. That’s pretty much why maternal age at first baby tends to increase with education level.

None of that really matters to the main point of course which is that a) your friends are making the best decisions for them and don’t need your sadness and b) most women are able to conceive in their 30s just fine anyway.

Apologies - it was actually more in response to @Blimeor ’s point about needing more support for higher education later in life! That’s the trouble with all this quoting.

For the record I don’t think that ttc at 33 is massively different than 29 but it’s not a secret that by 39 the picture is very different! Many seem to have interpreted that I think that all women should have babies under the age of 30 which is not the case!

Im not sad for my friends now and I hope they don’t have trouble whatever age they ttc but would be if they have issues regarding fertility- like any friend would feel sad for their friend in a tough situation.

OP posts:
Tellmeimcrazy · 24/05/2023 20:13

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 19:17

There is nothing financially stopping anyone having kids then later going to uni in the uk in terms of entitlement to student finance (yes kids are expensive though). If you don’t already hold a degree you could have kids and work and wait until 35+ to get one provided you have the entry requirements. I am NOT saying this is necessarily a preferable/the most ideal option before my words are twisted. But it is possible. You’re no less entitled to higher education at 45 than 18.

Anything is possible but many people may not want to do it that way. I would say MOST people wouldn't want kids and work and a degree given the choice.

GeraltsBathtub · 24/05/2023 20:08

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 19:17

There is nothing financially stopping anyone having kids then later going to uni in the uk in terms of entitlement to student finance (yes kids are expensive though). If you don’t already hold a degree you could have kids and work and wait until 35+ to get one provided you have the entry requirements. I am NOT saying this is necessarily a preferable/the most ideal option before my words are twisted. But it is possible. You’re no less entitled to higher education at 45 than 18.

None of that is particularly relevant to what I said, but there are usually financial and time management barriers to going to uni with kids which is why it’s not a very popular option.

To expand on what I did say, everyone I know (other than literally one person) has gone to uni at 18/19, and most of them have them stayed in education or training until their mid-20s. It doesn’t usually make sense to have a baby in the middle of your PhD or training contract and it’s harder to get into grad schemes when you’re not in your 20s. That’s pretty much why maternal age at first baby tends to increase with education level.

None of that really matters to the main point of course which is that a) your friends are making the best decisions for them and don’t need your sadness and b) most women are able to conceive in their 30s just fine anyway.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 24/05/2023 20:04

As someone who needed IVF in their 20's. don't be so superior @DespairingALittle you can have trouble at any age, and not because you were selfish either. Women are well aware of their need to choose to have children on both societal and biological times scales. It's in every newspaper!

Ponderosamum · 24/05/2023 20:00

strawberryjeans · 24/05/2023 14:54

Does anyone know the stats generally though? Although 20s is best biologically, I thought there was very minimal difference between 29 and 33 statistics wise? Happy to be corrected. Thought fertility only declines at pace after 35

This is true, there is not much in it. Egg donors can be aged up to age 35 for this reason.

orangemagnolia · 24/05/2023 19:55

Phobiaphobic · 24/05/2023 19:46

Biology is a bitch.

I disagree. I think the way we have organised society is a bitch. It shouldn't be the norm to have to cram everything in, work and education wise, in our peak childbearing years.

Hollyppp · 24/05/2023 19:53

pontipinemum · 24/05/2023 14:51

I'm older than you, most of my friends are 32-36. Most of them do not have children yet and all assume it will 'just happen' some time. Now don't get me wrong I hear about how shite dating is and I don't want to be the 'smug' married friend who met DH at 22 so mostly keep my mouth shut.

But it took 4 years for me to have a baby. I wouldn't fancy starting to try at 40 thinking 1 month of no contraceptive and I'd be pregnant.

Yes something similar here… 90% of my friends (who are age 32-36) haven’t had children yet but want some in the next few years (some saying maybe 4-5 years) and seem unaware that it may not be straight forward

goldfootball · 24/05/2023 19:52

https://slate.com/technology/2020/08/fertility-cliff-advanced-maternal-age-outdated.html

this certainly isn’t the only article I’ve read saying the same thing

To think young women just don’t realise... (TW: fertility/ TTC)
GeraltsBathtub · 24/05/2023 19:47

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 19:26

Hmm on that. I know 2 female consultants who wanted to "get settled" in their careers. Both got their consultant posts in their 30's ( one was 34, one was 36 or 37) they both had fertility struggles and underwent IVF one of them has one child, several IVF attempts and at least one miscarriage. The other has had multiple IVF attempts and a miscarriage, so far no baby she is 43 this year...

That’s a shame for them, but most women in their 30s do not have fertility issues, nor does it justify OP being a busybody towards her friends.

Phobiaphobic · 24/05/2023 19:46

Biology is a bitch.

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 19:46

orangemagnolia · 24/05/2023 19:38

Anecdotal evidence doesn't mean anything. We can always find examples to contradict what is broadly the case.

I agree that anecdotal evidence doesn't mean anything.

I also agree with a pp who said that women should have children when they are ready, for some that will be in their 20's and for others it will be in their 30's.

I absolutely wasn't ready to have a baby in my 20's, at that point I was certain I wouldn't have children at all.

orangemagnolia · 24/05/2023 19:40

Robinni · 24/05/2023 19:27

@usererror99

I’ll be drumming into my kids that they should do what makes them happy, enjoy their lives and not feel pressured into doing things they are not ready for as ultimately this is not in their best interests.

Having a baby is a huge commitment and should ideally only be undertaken when a person can cope with it, is in a secure relationship and actually wants it.

I do think adults have a responsibility to education teens on fertility to some extent. I received 0 info on this from parents and school, and was surprised when I realised the true ins and outs of fertility and the importance of not leaving it too late. There's a real lack of education in this area.

orangemagnolia · 24/05/2023 19:38

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 19:34

My experience is the opposite.

My sister had two children in her 20's, both times took a year and both times involved 2-3 miscarriages. She also had difficult, complicated pregnancies.

I'm 35 and have a 5 month old. Conceived first month of trying, no miscarriages and my pregnancy was straightforward.

Anecdotal evidence doesn't mean anything. We can always find examples to contradict what is broadly the case.

Robinni · 24/05/2023 19:37

Agree @Tooclosetodanger

I got pregnant naturally late twenties because of gynae issues and doctors terrifying me with the spectre of fertility issues at 25.

I dropped what I was doing academically/work wise to get on because I was so scared of having the chance taken away. Thinking I could pick it up later.

One DC is disabled. It is a huge commitment and I will not get the chances to pursue my own interests again to the same extent.

Am now being pressured by docs to have a final child or have final op.

I’m not allowing myself to feel bullied about it this time.

Women should pursue having children when they are ready to, be that younger or older.

The implications of either choice are their own to deal with and it isn’t for others to petrify them either way.

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 19:34

Lorisa · 24/05/2023 18:38

I tend to agree OP. Anecdotally, I had my first at 20, and now pregnant with my second at 28. I conceived both times in the first month of trying. No miscarriages. Healthy, straightforward pregnancies.

My sister conceived two in her 20s, same story as me. Then, she tried to conceive a third in her mid-30s. It took her almost a year, with 2 miscarriages. My mum had a miscarriage between me and my sister, again, she was in her 20s with my sister and 30s with me. I have lots of friends in their 30s & 40s, and all share similar stories of TTC for a good few months and having miscarriages.

Anecdotal, but my experience.

My experience is the opposite.

My sister had two children in her 20's, both times took a year and both times involved 2-3 miscarriages. She also had difficult, complicated pregnancies.

I'm 35 and have a 5 month old. Conceived first month of trying, no miscarriages and my pregnancy was straightforward.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 19:34

Tooclosetodanger · 24/05/2023 19:31

I know plenty of people who’ve had successful natural pregnancies in their late 30s and early 40s. There’s so much scaremongering around fertility when for most people it isn’t an issue. We only ever hear about people’s struggles though.

I’m not the only one of my friends to accidentally get pregnant later on. My surprises were at ages 38 and 42, but I wouldn’t go telling people that. Yet I’ve heard the ins and outs of multiple people’s IVF/IUI journies.

This is true I know of successful pregnancies of women of 46!, 43 and 42. Although one of the little girls I am fairly sure is neurodiverse and one of the others is due in July.

Tooclosetodanger · 24/05/2023 19:31

I know plenty of people who’ve had successful natural pregnancies in their late 30s and early 40s. There’s so much scaremongering around fertility when for most people it isn’t an issue. We only ever hear about people’s struggles though.

I’m not the only one of my friends to accidentally get pregnant later on. My surprises were at ages 38 and 42, but I wouldn’t go telling people that. Yet I’ve heard the ins and outs of multiple people’s IVF/IUI journies.