Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think young women just don’t realise... (TW: fertility/ TTC)

445 replies

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 14:10

Nc as this combined with various other posts would be outing, this is a bugbear I’ve thought about a lot when ttc myself and something today brought it up again...

Anyhow, AIBU to think ladies In their late twenties who freeze their eggs (or plan to as a ‘failsafe’) don’t realise it’s not a guarantee or the same as ‘pressing pause’ on biology?

This comes about as i was chatting to childhood friend (29, same as me) about kids (I have recently had DS so this is why we were chatting about kids) and she said ‘oh x (school pal) froze her eggs recently, if I haven’t had kids by 33 I’ll do the same, x is so relieved to press pause and take the pressure off’ another friend has also mentioned egg freezing recently for the same reason, both have just said they don’t want the responsibility of kids yet but are in a ‘good’ position to do so ... each to their own but all I could think was that it’s all well and good but it doesn’t guarantee anything! Sadly the demon biology also makes it harder to carry as you age too, it’s not all about eggs!

I just think so many in my generation have the attitude that it will just happen later regardless thanks to science but everyone I know who has had kids or tried to have kids later has struggled (not a guarantee ofc but a statistical probability nonetheless)... interested to hear other people’s thoughts on this. Perhaps this is more of a ‘my circle of friends’ issue than a wider one.

YANBU - it’s a concern, many may end up disappointed in the future, not to mention already falling birth rates etc
YABU - mind your own!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 11:53

I think their mentality is why so many kids are conceived "accidentally". I could not persuade partner to have a second child and I lost count of the number of women who said to me when I mentioned his extreme reluctance "ah sure you don't get their permission, you just go ahead, he'll be fine when they arrive" of words to that effect.

I know of several instances of this in my circle. I can’t fathom how it’s socially acceptable - and it is, otherwise people wouldn’t joke about it.

Reugny · 25/05/2023 11:47

RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 11:37

I’m sure that’s true for some, but for others a younger body might aid their chances? I don’t know just seems a logical conclusion.

Who knows?

There are lots of different scenarios.

TripleDaisySummer · 25/05/2023 11:40

I think their mentality is why so many kids are conceived "accidentally". I could not persuade partner to have a second child and I lost count of the number of women who said to me when I mentioned his extreme reluctance "ah sure you don't get their permission, you just go ahead, he'll be fine when they arrive" of words to that effect.

Yes - I heard a lot of contraceptive accidents, from women themselves, that were anything but that ( and many - coil one especially - that really were contraceptive failures).

I never understood it as I wanted DH fully on board but then I was never faced with a change of mind situation.

RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 11:37

Reugny · 25/05/2023 11:36

I know some women who found they had fertility issues in their 20s. In some of their cases no amount of exploring would make them be able to get pregnant and give birth.

I’m sure that’s true for some, but for others a younger body might aid their chances? I don’t know just seems a logical conclusion.

Reugny · 25/05/2023 11:36

RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 11:33

I suppose time is useful when exploring treatment options etc?

I know some women who found they had fertility issues in their 20s. In some of their cases no amount of exploring would make them be able to get pregnant and give birth.

Reugny · 25/05/2023 11:33

RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 10:51

Aren’t the issues with having children later two fold - not just fertility, but risks in pregnancy and risks of anomalies and health conditions etc?

The risks aren't as large as people make out.

Also it takes two to tango so actually we need an education for men about their sperm quality.

RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 11:33

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 11:29

I agree, people are bing disingenuous to attribute all problems with conceiving with age. The vast majority of people in their 30s will conceive naturally. The remaining 10% will be due to a whole host of other reasons, age simply being 1 of them.

I suppose time is useful when exploring treatment options etc?

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 11:29

TheoTheopolis23 · 25/05/2023 11:08

For a long time (not sure if it's still there) the NHS fertility page had a factoid that 90% of women 39 and under would conceive within two years of TTC.

That factoid, quoted on here, has resulted in me being told I am speaking "nonsense", that I am embarassing myself etc etc. When I posted the link, there was silence in response.

I think most of us, from observation and experience would also say that the fact is corroborated around us.

The problem is the 10% - some of whom would have had issues, even in their 20s, and I'm the level of pain etc it causes those women/couples

I agree, people are bing disingenuous to attribute all problems with conceiving with age. The vast majority of people in their 30s will conceive naturally. The remaining 10% will be due to a whole host of other reasons, age simply being 1 of them.

TheoTheopolis23 · 25/05/2023 11:28

*or words to that effect

TheoTheopolis23 · 25/05/2023 11:27

I wonder if the men in relationships with are ones dragging feet and they want to give them more time to get on board and keep all their options open.

I wonder that too.

Many men think (to some extent correctly) that they have an indefinite amount of time to have kids and tend, in my experience, to project that lack of urgency and tendency for delaying/putting off into their relationships - regardless of the fact that women are not in that position. Many of them would quite "unintentionally", mindlessly waste a woman's fertile years due to their mindset.

And let's face it, at the base of it, even if it's subconscious, they think they can just have kids with a different younger woman when they're older/feel totally ready and it doesn't work with this one (or not have them at all).

I think their mentality is why so many kids are conceived "accidentally". I could not persuade partner to have a second child and I lost count of the number of women who said to me when I mentioned his extreme reluctance "ah sure you don't get their permission, you just go ahead, he'll be fine when they arrive" of words to that effect.

TripleDaisySummer · 25/05/2023 11:19

Yeah, it makes me lol to think of the number of men I know who were up for settling down and having kids in their 20s ...... Absolute minimum.

DH was 30 - I was 28 - while we weren't fist in University educated peers to have kids we were very much among the first.

University education for both sexes does I think push everything back a few years - but I think DH was amenable partly because his closest colleagues were a few year older and starting families and most of his peers at school never went to university and were already dads. Plus we'd been together 10 years by then which is early to meet.

If Op friends are in their 30s and think they're with the right man does seem odd to egg freeze rather than TTC or plan to TTC at a certain date rather than pay serious money and go through medical procedures - I wonder if the men in relationships with are ones dragging feet and they want to give them more time to get on board and keep all their options open.

TheoTheopolis23 · 25/05/2023 11:17

RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 10:51

Aren’t the issues with having children later two fold - not just fertility, but risks in pregnancy and risks of anomalies and health conditions etc?

They rise but nonetheless most women in their early 40s will not have issues.

Alongside the requirement for education about fertility among young men, would be the equal requirement for education of ken that just because they can theoretically have kids til.old age, does not mean that their genetic material does not age and that they also are an increasing risk for abnormalities as they pass 39/40.

To my knowledge fertility clinics do not accept donor sperm from men over 39; a fact that I'd say most men (and women) are blissfully unaware of.

TheoTheopolis23 · 25/05/2023 11:12

Back on op's main point; if her friends are in their 30s - particularly well into their 30s, would like kids, are in relationship with partners they can see themselves having kids with ..... Yes, I agree it's a bit foolish/mind boggling to try egg freezing and just not start TTC.

Even if they don't want to start TTC, they'd be better to freeze embryos than eggs.

TheoTheopolis23 · 25/05/2023 11:08

For a long time (not sure if it's still there) the NHS fertility page had a factoid that 90% of women 39 and under would conceive within two years of TTC.

That factoid, quoted on here, has resulted in me being told I am speaking "nonsense", that I am embarassing myself etc etc. When I posted the link, there was silence in response.

I think most of us, from observation and experience would also say that the fact is corroborated around us.

The problem is the 10% - some of whom would have had issues, even in their 20s, and I'm the level of pain etc it causes those women/couples

TheoTheopolis23 · 25/05/2023 11:03

Are 20 something women supposed to settle with decade older men to get around the above?

They're usually in relationships already with their peers. And settling/having kids in their 30s.

Even if single, how depressing to pressure young women to settle with decade older men because they "must" have kids at peak fertility.

On a related point - peak is peak.
Peak oil is long past but most of the world is still running on it.

TheoTheopolis23 · 25/05/2023 11:01

Outdamnspot23 · 24/05/2023 17:12

Why is this always looked on as the woman's issue alone? While I know several women who had partners eager to settle and have kids in their twenties, I know a hell of a lot more who are up for having kids at 28/32/36 but first need to persuade the potential father that it's the right time. For many (including me) this took years.

So if you're starting a campaign to make young women better informed, please do inform the men too. They certainly have far less awareness of things like PCOS, miscarriage, IVF and so on than most women do, since we discuss this stuff (and in some cases read MN).

Yeah, it makes me lol to think of the number of men I know who were up for settling down and having kids in their 20s ...... Absolute minimum.

That's prime time for education, career, travelling, hobbies, playing the field, maybe having a relationship but not marriage and kids etc for them.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 25/05/2023 11:00

LeftASituation · 25/05/2023 08:15

She is painting a rosy view. It’s damn hard for many trainees to juggle parenthood and shift work and exams. Especially in the first couple of years. Unpredictable rotas, uncompromising consultants, need to fulfil workplace-based assessments and a certain number of oncalls, unreasonable service expectations etc. As usual, it’s the women who go part-time and have to start their consultant jobs later. Many trainees suffer burnout and stress, especially when juggling family life and work.

We are talking about the clinics presenting falsely positive information. Well I would say this doctor is too.

And I say that as a consultant of 22 years.

I too have had trainees and peers of every age have babies. Most in their thirties though. That’s ok.

There are no SpRs anymore, not since 2007.

Anyone who isn't a foundation doctor is either a core trainee or a specialist trainee.

This " new" (nearly 20 years old now) system means that doctors have far more job security and protected status from much earlier in their training. Hopefully allowing greater flexibility from an earlier stage and therefore a younger age.

I am well aware this doesn't always work in practice. However all trainees are entitled to train flexibily which Hopefully makes things somewhat easier.

RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 10:51

Aren’t the issues with having children later two fold - not just fertility, but risks in pregnancy and risks of anomalies and health conditions etc?

Sqiggle85 · 25/05/2023 10:22

Quite frankly it’s not anyone’s business, how, when or if a woman decides to have children.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/05/2023 10:18

Robinni · 25/05/2023 10:05

Two things come to mind.

Firstly, the argument about being older than most of the Mums at the school gate is null and void. It depends on location. We live in an expensive postcode. Most of the mothers are 5 to 10 years older than me - in their mid to late 40s.

They had to wait to have kids to be able to progress career and afford to live in the area.

A lot are medics who need to be within 20mins of hospital (for on call) hence having no choice to move somewhere cheaper.

Secondly, has anyone looked into the data being skewed? ie at late 30s/40s most people who wanted to have children will have done so. Ovarian reserve aside. Out of what’s left you will have more people with gynae issues - who would have had as much of a problem conceiving in their 20s… But their relative proportion of the population pool of people ttc is greater.

The only way of truly knowing the fertility rate for women at say 38 would to be prevent the entire cohort from ttc until this time.

Definitely depends on location. I don't know any parents here in their 20's when I went to baby group or now at nursery drop offs, I'd actually say I was about the average age at 35.

Usernamen · 25/05/2023 10:17

Robinni · 25/05/2023 10:05

Two things come to mind.

Firstly, the argument about being older than most of the Mums at the school gate is null and void. It depends on location. We live in an expensive postcode. Most of the mothers are 5 to 10 years older than me - in their mid to late 40s.

They had to wait to have kids to be able to progress career and afford to live in the area.

A lot are medics who need to be within 20mins of hospital (for on call) hence having no choice to move somewhere cheaper.

Secondly, has anyone looked into the data being skewed? ie at late 30s/40s most people who wanted to have children will have done so. Ovarian reserve aside. Out of what’s left you will have more people with gynae issues - who would have had as much of a problem conceiving in their 20s… But their relative proportion of the population pool of people ttc is greater.

The only way of truly knowing the fertility rate for women at say 38 would to be prevent the entire cohort from ttc until this time.

This is exactly what I see in my area too. The idea that you would be an old mum at the school gate if you’re 45, in my post code, is ridiculous.

It’s not just geography though. Our views on the matter are also conditioned by what we see around us at work, socially, etc. Among the London-dwelling professionals I work with / are in my wider social circle, it is no exaggeration to say that not a single one of them became a mother before 35. The two senior female partners in my firm both had a baby after 40.

In a way I am grateful to MN for the alternative experiences/viewpoints that are absent in my world. I feel that it helps me manage my own expectations that I may never have a baby in my late 30s, despite what I see around me.

Robinni · 25/05/2023 10:16

Ie.

50000 women, 5000 have fertility issues (10%).

30,000 (60% of total) decide to reproduce, with 27,000 (90%) being successful and the expected 3000 (10%) being unsuccessful.

The remaining 20,000 decide to reproduce, joining the 3000 who are still trying, total population pool 23,000.
You still have 5000 women with fertility issues but they now account for 22% of the population pool ttc which could skew stats.

Robinni · 25/05/2023 10:05

Two things come to mind.

Firstly, the argument about being older than most of the Mums at the school gate is null and void. It depends on location. We live in an expensive postcode. Most of the mothers are 5 to 10 years older than me - in their mid to late 40s.

They had to wait to have kids to be able to progress career and afford to live in the area.

A lot are medics who need to be within 20mins of hospital (for on call) hence having no choice to move somewhere cheaper.

Secondly, has anyone looked into the data being skewed? ie at late 30s/40s most people who wanted to have children will have done so. Ovarian reserve aside. Out of what’s left you will have more people with gynae issues - who would have had as much of a problem conceiving in their 20s… But their relative proportion of the population pool of people ttc is greater.

The only way of truly knowing the fertility rate for women at say 38 would to be prevent the entire cohort from ttc until this time.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/05/2023 09:58

TooodleOoo · 25/05/2023 09:51

@SouthLondonMum22 well I've had two babies in my early 20s and it didn't knock me off track. I got two degrees in STEM. I also know other mature student s with kids and I know people from secondary who went to Russell Group universities. So no, education or career doesn't have to send you off track. You have a rather outdated and uninformed view of how things often are.

Also, you claim to be a high earner when the majority are not. Do statistics not matter now?Confused

To be honest, I'm not sure why you're arguing with me. All I said was I don't think most people are self-sufficient at any age. Most people cannot pay for everything alone with children in tow.

It doesn't have to but it often does. I wish it was outdated but that simply isn't true.

I think the pp was talking about completely relying on someone else financially such as deciding to take a career break because nursery fees are expensive and it is almost always the woman who would make that choice.

TooodleOoo · 25/05/2023 09:53

I think it's ever harder to have kids in 20s - because it takes so long to get settled or stable.

Yes, I agree in general. I just don't think age is the magic ticket some people make it out to be. Other factors like education/income and family support are more significant.