Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think young women just don’t realise... (TW: fertility/ TTC)

445 replies

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 14:10

Nc as this combined with various other posts would be outing, this is a bugbear I’ve thought about a lot when ttc myself and something today brought it up again...

Anyhow, AIBU to think ladies In their late twenties who freeze their eggs (or plan to as a ‘failsafe’) don’t realise it’s not a guarantee or the same as ‘pressing pause’ on biology?

This comes about as i was chatting to childhood friend (29, same as me) about kids (I have recently had DS so this is why we were chatting about kids) and she said ‘oh x (school pal) froze her eggs recently, if I haven’t had kids by 33 I’ll do the same, x is so relieved to press pause and take the pressure off’ another friend has also mentioned egg freezing recently for the same reason, both have just said they don’t want the responsibility of kids yet but are in a ‘good’ position to do so ... each to their own but all I could think was that it’s all well and good but it doesn’t guarantee anything! Sadly the demon biology also makes it harder to carry as you age too, it’s not all about eggs!

I just think so many in my generation have the attitude that it will just happen later regardless thanks to science but everyone I know who has had kids or tried to have kids later has struggled (not a guarantee ofc but a statistical probability nonetheless)... interested to hear other people’s thoughts on this. Perhaps this is more of a ‘my circle of friends’ issue than a wider one.

YANBU - it’s a concern, many may end up disappointed in the future, not to mention already falling birth rates etc
YABU - mind your own!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Robinni · 24/05/2023 19:27

usererror99 · 24/05/2023 18:45

I agree OP

Unless you freeze dozens of eggs in your twenties may as well not bother doing it in your mid to late thirties onwards but women love to delude themselves especially when it comes to fertility

As someone who was infertile by age 35 I'll be drumming into my kids the importance of fertility and not to be naive - science can only do so much and isn't the magic cure it's made out to be

@usererror99

I’ll be drumming into my kids that they should do what makes them happy, enjoy their lives and not feel pressured into doing things they are not ready for as ultimately this is not in their best interests.

Having a baby is a huge commitment and should ideally only be undertaken when a person can cope with it, is in a secure relationship and actually wants it.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 19:26

GeraltsBathtub · 24/05/2023 19:11

Maybe not at 29 but in my circle it has been more common than not to be in your mid-20s by the time you finished education/training (doctors, lawyers, vets, PhDs) and then you want time to get settled into the career.

Hmm on that. I know 2 female consultants who wanted to "get settled" in their careers. Both got their consultant posts in their 30's ( one was 34, one was 36 or 37) they both had fertility struggles and underwent IVF one of them has one child, several IVF attempts and at least one miscarriage. The other has had multiple IVF attempts and a miscarriage, so far no baby she is 43 this year...

RedRosette2023 · 24/05/2023 19:23

When I was 25 I thought IVF was implanting a guaranteed baby in your belly. I was so shocked when a colleague told me she miscarried via IVF and had an unsuccessful attempt. I think there’s so much focus on not getting pregnant when you’re young that you’re ignorant to the trails and tribulations of getting pregnant, if you’re unfortunate enough to find out about those it’s likely already too late.

orangemagnolia · 24/05/2023 19:22

SleepingStandingUp · 24/05/2023 16:13

Op you're coming across rather as "now I'm a mother, I understand the world and my poor friends, they're so immature and ignorant compared to me because they haven't got children yet. One day they'll be childless and I'll be right and it will so tragic they didn't know everything I do"

All of which is perfectly true. She's right to feel that way.

Robinni · 24/05/2023 19:21

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 18:45

Also I'd rather ris not being fit enough to interail than risk not being able to care for teenagers properly (and yes teens need a lot of parenting).

Not arguing either way.

Just saying it is unreasonable for OP, or anyone to “worry” or chastise others choices.

There is no ideal, pros/cons either way depending on what your priorities are.

MsCactus · 24/05/2023 19:20

I remember the Kardashians froze their eggs and then every single egg perished when they tried to defreeze (word?) them.

Presumably the Kardashians had the best procedures, doctors etc - so that shocked me. It almost seemed like a pointless thing to do unless you freeze a massive number of eggs, or freeze an embryo (which seems to be less prone to perishing)

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 19:17

GeraltsBathtub · 24/05/2023 19:11

Maybe not at 29 but in my circle it has been more common than not to be in your mid-20s by the time you finished education/training (doctors, lawyers, vets, PhDs) and then you want time to get settled into the career.

There is nothing financially stopping anyone having kids then later going to uni in the uk in terms of entitlement to student finance (yes kids are expensive though). If you don’t already hold a degree you could have kids and work and wait until 35+ to get one provided you have the entry requirements. I am NOT saying this is necessarily a preferable/the most ideal option before my words are twisted. But it is possible. You’re no less entitled to higher education at 45 than 18.

OP posts:
Mistymist · 24/05/2023 19:14

Such a heartbreaking post! 💐

GeraltsBathtub · 24/05/2023 19:11

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 18:28

Jesus OP is 29 not 19 ! Who is still in FT education at 29 ? Very, very few people .

Maybe not at 29 but in my circle it has been more common than not to be in your mid-20s by the time you finished education/training (doctors, lawyers, vets, PhDs) and then you want time to get settled into the career.

TeaParty4Me · 24/05/2023 18:59

I have voted YABU.

Their options are to TTC now when they’re in their fertility prime.
Or wait until they’re older and ready for kids.

They do not want kids now and TTC now would be the wrong decision.

So their only other option is to wait until they’re older.
So they either do nothing and wait or try and increase the chances of having a child when the time comes.

Of course it’s still hard to have a child over a certain age but you’ve got more chance of doing so if you freeze your eggs/embryos than doing nothing.

TakeMeDancingNakedInTheRain · 24/05/2023 18:55

I think it's the women who think they have forever to have a baby and see women having kids way beyond 40 and think it's the norm now so they'll be fine and dont even bother with egg freezing that are more at risk of missing the boat. I have a close friend who is 40 and acts like she's got all the time in the world, she's been busy travelling, planning/having a wedding, career stuff, buying a new house, then doing up the new house. To add to the complication she's also in a same sex marriage (she was married to a man for over a decade before this but never tried for children). She does really want kids and at least 1 to be biologically hers yet here she is 40 and she's still not even started the process. She's going to do ivf and I think in her head that buys her lots of time. I had a chat with her about it with a few other friends when we were out for a meal about 4 years ago now and she got mad that I pointed out her age and how she is running out of time. It wasn't coming from a place of smugness I promise more just "have you really looked into it and sooner is better than later". The women who freeze eggs do have some level of understanding that freezing eggs doesn't = guaranteed baby in x years, I think it's more the people like my friend who would rather just pretend that age isn't an issue here and that she needs to get on with it before the ship sails. I generally don't care what other women do but I know my friend wants kids, I'll be sad if she doesn't have her own child, she can of course still be a mum through her wife who is over a decade younger but she actually wants a biological child. I think by the time she gets around to it she'll be too old.

usererror99 · 24/05/2023 18:45

I agree OP

Unless you freeze dozens of eggs in your twenties may as well not bother doing it in your mid to late thirties onwards but women love to delude themselves especially when it comes to fertility

As someone who was infertile by age 35 I'll be drumming into my kids the importance of fertility and not to be naive - science can only do so much and isn't the magic cure it's made out to be

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 18:45

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 18:43

But that is the logical outcome to deliberately delaying childbearing to your 40's.

Also I'd rather ris not being fit enough to interail than risk not being able to care for teenagers properly (and yes teens need a lot of parenting).

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 18:43

Robinni · 24/05/2023 18:34

That’s a separate issue @Neurodiversitydoctor and a valid reason for having kids earlier, but not the point of the thread.

Thread relates to OP’s friends choosing to postpone family and focus on career/travel in late 20s/early 30s.

OP had some deluded idea that people in their 50s have the ability/inclination to party in Ibiza and go inter-railing…

Which I pointed out is not likely in terms of their physical capabilities/financial circumstances.

But that is the logical outcome to deliberately delaying childbearing to your 40's.

Lorisa · 24/05/2023 18:38

I tend to agree OP. Anecdotally, I had my first at 20, and now pregnant with my second at 28. I conceived both times in the first month of trying. No miscarriages. Healthy, straightforward pregnancies.

My sister conceived two in her 20s, same story as me. Then, she tried to conceive a third in her mid-30s. It took her almost a year, with 2 miscarriages. My mum had a miscarriage between me and my sister, again, she was in her 20s with my sister and 30s with me. I have lots of friends in their 30s & 40s, and all share similar stories of TTC for a good few months and having miscarriages.

Anecdotal, but my experience.

macj1 · 24/05/2023 18:38

As a survivor of the fertility go-round, (daughter born at 42 after 2x IVF) here's a share of my experiences:

  1. The fertility clinics pre-screen women's day 3 FSH and anyone over 16 is told not to proceed (this means you are peri-menopausal) - because it's a waste of your money and it ruins their success stats. Thus only a minority get to have IVF aged over 40.
  2. Even after pre-screening and only allowing women with a chance of success to proceed to IVF, the success rates over 40 are still about 12% per woman. That means for every 100 women spending £10K per cycle 88 will have no baby.
  3. The clinics selling egg freezing to younger women are selling a myth: frozen eggs only have about a 10% chance of success for any given cycle.
  4. Many women drop out of IVF due to the gruelling injection regime, the effect of the drugs etc. I was told it was as stressful as cancer treatment and only succeeded with the help of a support group. Look up intra-muscular progesterone injections for clear idea. It's a horse needle.
  5. Those lovely px of movie stars with their twins born after the age of 45? They are all using egg donors. Of course they can't say publicly, this is private information for their children when grown - but my Californian IVF fertility practice let me know that they did not use women's own eggs on anyone undergoing IVF over aged 45 because the chances of success were so poor.

To sum up: for me, there's no trade-off - enjoyment of 30's and 'freedom' for then undergoing a procedure with a 12% chance of succeeding using incredibly expensive, painful, gruelling IVF ...

That's if it's a choice. Many are waiting, as I was, to meet the right person, to settle down, for the time to be right.

The right time, as I learned, was in my late 20's/early 30's.

When my daughter asked me why I had her so late (she worked out I'll be 82 when she's 40) I told her that I was busy travelling the world, climbing Ayres Rock, going overland across Africa...

She said 'I would have come with you' (she was 8 years old at the time).

Heartbreaking. I would have traded all those experiences to have more time with her - or to have had the chance to have a few more children.

Robinni · 24/05/2023 18:37

strawberryjeans · 24/05/2023 18:10

I asked earlier but not sure if it was seen or lost in the sea of other comments. We want to have our babies (either one or two, will play by ear) before DH is 30 which gives us another 5 years. I’m a couple years younger than him. We haven’t begun trying yet but will later this year. Aside from that… I thought there was no real obvious difference for women bearing children in their early 30s versus your mid or late twenties? Surely the risks only increase post 35, slightly, then more and more with each year. I didn’t know there were any lesser biological chances at 32, say.

https://www.britishfertilitysociety.org.uk/fei/at-what-age-does-fertility-begin-to-decrease/

At what age does fertility begin to decrease? - British Fertility Society | BFS

Girls are born with a fixed number of immature eggs in their ovaries. The number of eggs decreases as women get older. At birth, most girls have about 2 million eggs, at adolescence that number has gone down to about 400, 000, at age 37 there remain ab...

https://www.britishfertilitysociety.org.uk/fei/at-what-age-does-fertility-begin-to-decrease/

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 18:37

But you can’t quit your job and backpack on a shoestring for months at a time with your kids

Er we did actually ( well travelled through Europe with a campervan)
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**

Robinni · 24/05/2023 18:34

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 18:28

So instead condemn teenagers to deal with this as well as everything else they are dealing with and grandparents in their 80/90's ? No thanks

That’s a separate issue @Neurodiversitydoctor and a valid reason for having kids earlier, but not the point of the thread.

Thread relates to OP’s friends choosing to postpone family and focus on career/travel in late 20s/early 30s.

OP had some deluded idea that people in their 50s have the ability/inclination to party in Ibiza and go inter-railing…

Which I pointed out is not likely in terms of their physical capabilities/financial circumstances.

Medstudent12 · 24/05/2023 18:33

I’m 30, no kids yet. I would never be able to buy a house where I live if I’d had kids at 25/26, I’d have settled for a much less desirable area and never break into the nicer bit as house prices rise. You can travel after kids, maybe 2-3 weeks a year long haul maximum if still working. But you can’t quit your job and backpack on a shoestring for months at a time with your kids.

A carefree twenties is very different to being 45+ and trying to have that same crazy social life, you can’t pretend it’s the same. As a doctor I’m very very aware that not everyone makes it to 50 and not everyone is healthy enough to enjoy their retirement. I’m not banking on being able to tick off most of my bucket list in later middle age, I want to do some of it now. Plus very few female doctors have kids in their 20s, majority become GPs instead of hospital doctors if they have kids and I don’t want to be a GP!

I’ll start trying in a couple of years. Not because I want to yet (my life is great now) but because my biological clock is ticking. If the NHS didn’t move hospital registrars potentially 2 hours away from their home for a 6 month rotation at a different hospital with 3 months notice then maybe we’d consider kids earlier 🤷🏻‍♀️.

I would never trade in my experiences of uni, backpacking, living abroad, holidays, dating and meeting my partner to have kids at 25 odd. Yes I might be less fertile in my 30s. But I had a great time waiting! You have to decide what’s more important to you. I wanted the travel etc some people are more family orientated - both are very valid choices.

Robinni · 24/05/2023 18:30

LeftASituation · 24/05/2023 17:56

I have a friend who ‘worries’ about others. It’s fake and patronising as hell and actually just means she feels superior to them. Her teen daughter has started doing it about her peers and it’s irritating for all their friends.

^ This 100% @LeftASituation

Patronising and superior.

She is probably acting so defensive and using this “concern” to validate her own choice because no doubt the friends are going on about fabulous holidays and how free they are to enjoy and have babies later.

(which by the way is not cool either - they should be more supportive of her as a new mum but clearly are oblivious)

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 18:28

Blimeor · 24/05/2023 18:28

@knitpicky @strawberryjeans

Part of the problem is education is easier to access (and free!) when you're young. There should be more money made available for people to train later in life. So if you want to have kids earlier you won't lose out on those opportunities.

Jesus OP is 29 not 19 ! Who is still in FT education at 29 ? Very, very few people .

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 18:28

Robinni · 24/05/2023 18:25

Yes you care about them.

But it isn’t your business to be judgemental over their choices to prioritise other things because it isn’t your personal choice.

Let me tell you what starts to happen in your 50s very commonly.

Menopause. Osteoporosis. Arthritis. Heart disease. COPD. High blood pressure. Diabetes. Cancer. Etc etc

https://www.webmd.com/healthy-aging/ss/slideshow-what-to-expect-in-your-50s

I buried my mother at just over 60. Just attended a friends mothers funeral who was 67. DH mother went mid 50s along with other friends parents….

Someone in their 50s is not going to be inclined to make the most out of experiences such as inter-railing or whatever else… they may travel but for many it will be at a slower pace than a person in 20s/30s. Or focus on different activities.

Besides which - if you have children in your late 20s, by 50s you are paying for them to go to Uni, for their driving lessons/cars, house deposit, wedding etc… how when all this is added up is it even possible to afford all the travelling.

Sorry, but I have friends having their babies now late 30s/early 40s - no issues. They have had a fabulous decade of career progression, lovely house, car, life experiences. And they can now afford for kids to have the best.

It’s not a bad choice and worrying after your friends and trying to throw cold water over them choosing to prioritise having fun, is as bad as it would be for them to say you choosing to have a baby right now is a bit crap and you’re missing out etc etc.

Different choices, both should be respected without fretting.

So instead condemn teenagers to deal with this as well as everything else they are dealing with and grandparents in their 80/90's ? No thanks

Blimeor · 24/05/2023 18:28

@knitpicky @strawberryjeans

Part of the problem is education is easier to access (and free!) when you're young. There should be more money made available for people to train later in life. So if you want to have kids earlier you won't lose out on those opportunities.

Robinni · 24/05/2023 18:25

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 17:29

I worry because they are people I care about and I hope fertility doesn’t end up being an issue for them both. Sorry you felt pushed into it by your doctors and that you didn’t have more options. A little ageist to think you can’t enjoy life/holidays etc at 50 no? I consider 50 quite young nowadays. Unless this specifically relates to you and the illness that means it will be harder for you?

Yes you care about them.

But it isn’t your business to be judgemental over their choices to prioritise other things because it isn’t your personal choice.

Let me tell you what starts to happen in your 50s very commonly.

Menopause. Osteoporosis. Arthritis. Heart disease. COPD. High blood pressure. Diabetes. Cancer. Etc etc

https://www.webmd.com/healthy-aging/ss/slideshow-what-to-expect-in-your-50s

I buried my mother at just over 60. Just attended a friends mothers funeral who was 67. DH mother went mid 50s along with other friends parents….

Someone in their 50s is not going to be inclined to make the most out of experiences such as inter-railing or whatever else… they may travel but for many it will be at a slower pace than a person in 20s/30s. Or focus on different activities.

Besides which - if you have children in your late 20s, by 50s you are paying for them to go to Uni, for their driving lessons/cars, house deposit, wedding etc… how when all this is added up is it even possible to afford all the travelling.

Sorry, but I have friends having their babies now late 30s/early 40s - no issues. They have had a fabulous decade of career progression, lovely house, car, life experiences. And they can now afford for kids to have the best.

It’s not a bad choice and worrying after your friends and trying to throw cold water over them choosing to prioritise having fun, is as bad as it would be for them to say you choosing to have a baby right now is a bit crap and you’re missing out etc etc.

Different choices, both should be respected without fretting.

photo of couple walking dog outside

What to Expect in Your 50s

Learn more about how your body changes in your 50s -- not all of it is necessarily unwelcome.

https://www.webmd.com/healthy-aging/ss/slideshow-what-to-expect-in-your-50s