Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL wanted grandson not granddaughter

191 replies

cornflakebrownie · 24/05/2023 13:44

Name changed for this but am a long-time user. DH and I have two gorgeous DDs and to our surprise and delight are now expecting (in our 40s) our third child. Everything is going well with the pregnancy and yesterday at 20-week scan we found out all being well we’ve got another healthy girl on the way.

MIL has told my husband a couple of times earlier in the pregnancy that it would be nice if it was a boy. She says FIL also wants a grandson. This disappointed me but a few people had said similar given we have two girls already, so I just shrugged it off.

Then today DH called MIL to tell her our news and she told him “it would have been nice if it was a boy”. I can’t believe she’s still saying this now we actually know it’s a healthy girl.

I feel really sad and angry. DH says I’m overreacting. So as not to drip feed, we’ve had a few issues generally with MIL and FIL over the last few years, with them rarely coming to see the girls, we always have to go to them. There’s also been some financial troubles in their family, which have impacted us, but DH is very loyal and wants to keep up our weekly video chats with his mum.

Am I wrong to feel so pissed off?

OP posts:
CriticalAlert · 25/05/2023 18:38

Congratulations on your healthy girl. Don't get upset about your mil comment. She's a moron.

aSofaNearYou · 25/05/2023 18:37

I think this really depends on context. On the surface of it, "it would have been nice if it was a boy" is not the absolute nicest thing she could have said, but I also don't think it's as rude as something like "what a shame". The latter is inherently negative, whereas the former COULD be said in a relatively chirpy way that precedes general positivity about the baby regardless. Different if it was said reproachfully and didn't come across like it came with an implied "but we're all very excited anyway" I'm guessing that since you say you have issues with them anyway, it didn't come across generally positive. But I do think that makes a difference to how offensive this is.

EbonyRaven · 25/05/2023 18:35

You're not allowed to voice out loud (on here) what you said in your first sentence ^ @NoPaintedPony but you are 100% correct.

NoPaintedPony · 25/05/2023 18:31

There’s something about pregnancy and having children that makes people, especially older ladies feel they’re allowed to say and do whatever they please.
If u had been blessed with a boy mil or someone would say, that u can stop now as u have both - yeap happened to me 🙄
At the end of the day, if the baby and you are healthy, that’s all matters

Itsonlywater · 25/05/2023 18:17

Congratulations! One of my close friends has 3 beautiful girls and they are the best of friends. Our son is the only grandson on both sides after many years of girls. After hearing for what seemed like an eternity from FIl how nice it would be to have a boy in the family, he hasn't made any effort with our son (or daughter for that matter). Just no pleasing some people unfortunately. Enjoy these precious times with those that matter

Nothingisblackandwhite · 25/05/2023 18:16

I would reply , well it’s a shame that after 2 granddaughters you still haven’t learned to be a proper grandmother! That’s will shut her up

anon666 · 25/05/2023 18:02

This happened with MIL and FIL.

Just ignore it. Their loss for being so weird about it. It's annoying but not a deal breaker.

VerasRaincoat · 24/05/2023 22:38

My MIL was exactly the same, she said she’d only be interested and buy the baby gifts if we had a boy. We ended up having the sex she wanted, but knowing that her love was dependent on the ‘right’ sex, I put zero effort into ensuring she has any relationship with him. My husband now doesn’t bother so I’m not going to remind him to call or to invite them over. She’s also an awful person in other ways which I’m sure most mils who are nasty enough to voice gender preferences are.

Can’t believe posters are saying gender disappointment should extend to grandparents 🙄🙄🙄 Can only deduce they are rude mils too.

My mother wouldn’t dream of voicing a preference, just that that he or she were happy and healthy.

roobyro · 24/05/2023 21:51

Father in law reacted exactly the same.
To be honest, it just went over my head. Gender disappoint is real. Perhaps it shouldn't be shared, but it's family and I'm sure she will love her grandchild when she is born.

As I have got older I have learnt to not let the small things bother me. Depends on how she is as a grandparent to be honest. If she doesn't bother, then it's going to make no difference- and at least she won't have favourites. If she does bother, then don't take it to heart.

girlfriend44 · 24/05/2023 21:44

Ignore the tactless creature.

Anyone with a brain knows whether a child is born well and healthy is all that matters.

cornflakebrownie · 24/05/2023 21:33

Congratulations @FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb and @MissLC on your fabulous girls.

@sodabreadjam I wish you were my MIL!

Thank you to everyone who has responded, it’s been a massive help sorting this all out in my mind.

OP posts:
FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 24/05/2023 19:42

We had some of that when we had our 3rd daughter, also early 40s. We didn't find out til she was born.
After shoulder dysocia, a million stitches, PPH and ending up in HDU, I felt fairly justified in telling people how truly grateful we were that we were both alive. That shut them up.

MissLC · 24/05/2023 19:39

I was pregnant at the same time as my SIL. MIL would constantly comment that boys are better... turns out SIL was having a 2nd boy and, of course, I was having a girl.
The boys are hugely favoured by her still but I absolutely adore our little girl. She is bright, sassy and such a joy to be around (most of the time) and she is doted on by me, her dad and maternal grandparents.
I'm sure your little one will be just as adored when she arrives. All you can do is ignore MIL comments and enjoy your little one.

GuitarsUnderTheStars · 24/05/2023 18:54

She’s an idiot. No loving parent or grandparent would say it.

I’d distance myself a bit, she’s not going to bring positive things to your life with such an unhealthy attitude. You don’t have to put up with her inappropriate comments, you can choose an alternative.

sodabreadjam · 24/05/2023 18:54

I am a grandmother. Your job as a grandparent is to say "that's lovely" to any news about grandchildren - the first or the tenth, all boys or all girls, whatever names are chosen. You don't give opinions unless you are asked.

The only thing that would have disappointed me would be having no grandchildren - even then I hope I wouldn't have made my disappointment too obvious.

ladydimitrescu · 24/05/2023 18:39

Mine said "oh, never mind" when I announced the sex, first baby and first grandchild. Had the opposite sex the next time and she doesn't care about that one either.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 24/05/2023 18:34

Katypp · 24/05/2023 16:10

Seriously how do people get through life if they are so offended and react so ridiculously to one comment? The art of relationship building seems to be a dying art and is being replaced by constant jostling over who has the upper hand. it must be exhausting

But it’s not one comment. How do people get through life being unable to comprehend written words?

I cannot be bothered with less-than-satisfactory relationships, so I don’t. I’m sorry you do.

TeaYarn · 24/05/2023 18:09

EbonyRaven · 24/05/2023 15:49

I have found this too, especially in women who are - I would say 65+... For some reason, they seem to prefer boys, and favour their grandsons over any grand-daughters, AND they favour their sons over any daughters. They let the 'boys' have their own way, and they never lift a finger to help, and the women get the bunting out when the sons/grandsons visit once a month, (and sit down being waited on hand and foot.)

When the females visit, it must be once or twice a week, (once a month and she'd be disowned,) she must help her parents and parents-in-law and grandparents, when they demand it, and she must be a good little girl and do the domestic shit and chores. Boys/men get away with murder from women born pre-1960 IME and IMO.

But yeah, I have heard many a woman born before 1960 blather on about how much better boys/sons are, and show disappointment and disdain when their daughters, and daughter-in-laws have girls/daughters.

Disgusting way to behave. As a few posters have said, why do some people find it so easy to be so rude and so cruel? My friend's grandmother told her mother (back in the late 1960s,) that she had massively let her and her father down by producing 3 girls. Who the fuck SAYS that?

And when my friend's mum's brother got married (and his wife produced a son,) the 3 girls were forgotten and ignored. Literally no birthday cards or gifts, and nothing for Christmas, nothing. My friend's mum went no contact with her parents when my friend and her 2 sisters were in their teens. How - and why - can people be so nasty?

Judging by this thread, nasty people still exist. Moaning and carping because a young woman isn't giving them a bloody grandson! (As has been said, it's the man's sperm that determines it anyway!)

You ok hun?

pigsDOfly · 24/05/2023 17:24

EbonyRaven · 24/05/2023 15:49

I have found this too, especially in women who are - I would say 65+... For some reason, they seem to prefer boys, and favour their grandsons over any grand-daughters, AND they favour their sons over any daughters. They let the 'boys' have their own way, and they never lift a finger to help, and the women get the bunting out when the sons/grandsons visit once a month, (and sit down being waited on hand and foot.)

When the females visit, it must be once or twice a week, (once a month and she'd be disowned,) she must help her parents and parents-in-law and grandparents, when they demand it, and she must be a good little girl and do the domestic shit and chores. Boys/men get away with murder from women born pre-1960 IME and IMO.

But yeah, I have heard many a woman born before 1960 blather on about how much better boys/sons are, and show disappointment and disdain when their daughters, and daughter-in-laws have girls/daughters.

Disgusting way to behave. As a few posters have said, why do some people find it so easy to be so rude and so cruel? My friend's grandmother told her mother (back in the late 1960s,) that she had massively let her and her father down by producing 3 girls. Who the fuck SAYS that?

And when my friend's mum's brother got married (and his wife produced a son,) the 3 girls were forgotten and ignored. Literally no birthday cards or gifts, and nothing for Christmas, nothing. My friend's mum went no contact with her parents when my friend and her 2 sisters were in their teens. How - and why - can people be so nasty?

Judging by this thread, nasty people still exist. Moaning and carping because a young woman isn't giving them a bloody grandson! (As has been said, it's the man's sperm that determines it anyway!)

That's a very ageist and sweeping statement regarding 65+ women.

Have you actually any proof of this, as in how much research have you done to back it up, or is it just the odd 65+ women or two that you know.

Over the years that I've been on MN I have seen quite a number of thread started by young women who are disappointed by the sex of the babies they were expecting or who wanted a particular sex if they did become pregnant. I assume none of them was over 65 years of age.

I'm 74 and have never felt that way. When my grandchildren were born I was just happy that they were healthy babies.

They are small people, not robots ordered to some preconceived notion of 'boy' or 'girl'.

I have three adult children, when they were born I had absolutely no preference regarding sex, again I just wanted healthy babies.

GettingStuffed · 24/05/2023 17:17

My FiL was the same when I had DS2, however they bonded well once he was actually here. I did have a girl later but that didn't affect his relationship.

CatherinedeBourgh · 24/05/2023 17:14

gannett · 24/05/2023 17:03

Say "there's always a chance she'll be trans"

please please do this.

HarrysTiles · 24/05/2023 17:13

My sympathies, OP - but don’t let the buggers dim your happiness.

My ex-MIL and SIL were OBSESSED with little girls - SIL had three boys, I had two with third on the way and the things they said to me along the lines of ‘let’s hope it’s not another boy’ we’re horrendous, (particularly as me eldest was going through cancer treatment at the time)

As it was, I did have a daughter. They couldn’t have been less interested, except to appear every now and again with another ridiculously flouncy, impractical dress, tell me I was doing everything wrong and then bugger off.

Enjoy your family, your way - best of luck x

gannett · 24/05/2023 17:03

Say "there's always a chance she'll be trans"

SallyWD · 24/05/2023 17:03

I'm so tired of all this - people being disappointed by a certain gender. All babies are unique human beings and special regardless of their genitals. Your MIL already has a son, why obsess about having a grandson too? Some people are never satisfied with what they have. She's lucky to have (at least one) child and now three granddaughters. Count your blessings!
I had similar from my MIL who was obsessed with me having 3 children. It's all she banged on about - that I must give her 3 grandchildren. Well we stopped at 2 after I had prolapses and a cancer diagnosis and she still pressurised me to have more in my 40s! I'm not at all assertive but I said very strongly that I'd given her a healthy granddaughter and a healthy grandson and she really needed to learn to be thankful for what she had in life. After that she never mentioned it again.

mathanxiety · 24/05/2023 16:56

YANBU.

I had a MIL like this. It was very much a reflection of her misogyny.

Point out the misogyny to your DH and tell him his daughters and his wife are being completely disrespected by MIL amd FIL.