Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any Lawyers here? Need a legal Perspective on the world’s most ridiculous scenario

212 replies

Thisisastupidscenario · 23/05/2023 23:14

So in this hypothetical situation… which I’m aware is ridiculous.

If an individual with an axe to grind was to approach the HR department of a company or the company in general (a large international company that has large customers) and make some allegations against an employee (namely that they’ve lied about their qualifications, despite fairly rigorous onboarding). Would or could that company sue that individual with an axe to grind for several million (maybe billion, and this is just an average joe here) for fraud and reputation damage?

to me it sounds like utter dog poo. But I’m not a sharp legal kind.

OP posts:
ArdeteiMasazxu · 24/05/2023 07:27

I am not a lawyer but an employer.

If I heard from a random source that there was an allegation that one of my employees had falsified their qualifications I would first check the credibility of the source

If credible I would also, before taking action, consider whether the employee was actually extremely good at their job or not. If someone is on a £70k salary they should be performing at a level that most ordinary Joes can't sustain. If they are doing it successfully then I would be 80% inclined to not care. These days we tend to specify "bachelor degree OR equivalent professional workplace experience" because some people get to where they are going by unconventional routes - but there's the issue of honesty too and obviously lying is bad. So IF they were good at their job and having a non-graduate in the role wouldn't leave us uninsured or something would talk to the employee 1:1 and let them know I rate their work highly and appreciate them, that an allegation of this kind has been made and that I don't care that they are unqualified but I do care if I am being lied to so if this allegation is true they can come clean now and there will be no consequences.

Of course if they aren't great at their job then this would be a useful bit of information for showing them the door.

There is absolutely no chance the company would sue the would-be whistleblower. If the allegation is true then they have done nothing wrong. If it is false then it's not the company who is being harmed but the individual, but it's a weird thing to make a false allegation of because all university qualifications are matters of public record, universities publish their lists of graduates. I can claim I got a BSc in Biochemistry from the University of Nottingham in 2005 but if my name isn't on the list of people who got that degree in that year then no I didn't.

However I think it's more likely that your relative is actually on a £35k salary and is lying to you about their income and seniority.

crumpet · 24/05/2023 07:27

(Oh I give up. Bloody phone)

crumpet · 24/05/2023 07:27

Ther would be o grounds to Sue!

crumpet · 24/05/2023 07:25

If he’s lied to the company about his qualifications and the company finds out, there would be grounds for dismissal.

but as others have said, there would be be grounds for the company to sue the complainer.

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 07:23

AWhaleSwamBy · 24/05/2023 05:48

Yeah, I remember that one

Don’t we all, I don’t want to link them because I name changed but if you remember what he was doing on the threads, it’s the same concerning behaviour

OP posts:
Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 07:22

Speedweed · 24/05/2023 07:11

Companies normally check everyone's qualifications etc before they start through third party agencies, so if that's been done they'd just ignore the claims. They might run the checks again if the allegations were so detailed as to seem credible, or if they alleged the individual had been able to mislead the third party verifiers somehow (unlikely).

Other than that, nothing would happen. Companies really don't give a shit about lunatics writing all cap emails because they get so many of them.

It’s a big company so they would have, so what I think has happened here is that he does work there but in a much more junior, probably entry level role.

but to new friends/ partners he’s claiming to have these high level quals and then to family and friends and anyone outside the company he is claiming that he’s in a a senior leadership role, that type that morally requires 20+ years of industry experience

so he’s been checked and his legit quals have but for the job he’s got but he’s claiming to have a much more senior position due to his qualifications but this is now self protection to ensure he doesn’t get rumbled

OP posts:
WeAreTheHeroes · 24/05/2023 07:22

You're clearly onto something OP because if he really were all the things he claims to be he'd be secure in the knowledge you were wrong, shrug and leave you to get on with it.

Speedweed · 24/05/2023 07:11

Companies normally check everyone's qualifications etc before they start through third party agencies, so if that's been done they'd just ignore the claims. They might run the checks again if the allegations were so detailed as to seem credible, or if they alleged the individual had been able to mislead the third party verifiers somehow (unlikely).

Other than that, nothing would happen. Companies really don't give a shit about lunatics writing all cap emails because they get so many of them.

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 07:05

TimesRwo · 24/05/2023 00:27

Are you the one who got in touch with the company?

No no one has, it’s all invented

OP posts:
EnjoyingTheSilence · 24/05/2023 05:56

Damn, need to ask dh where his employer is stashing his private jet!

I know you can’t @Thisisastupidscenario but I’d love to hear the bugger story about this. Must be incredibly infuriating for you.

AWhaleSwamBy · 24/05/2023 05:48

CombatBarbie · 24/05/2023 05:43

Have you written about this guy before, there was a thread before about a relative claiming to be something big.... May have been gov security.

Yeah, I remember that one

GoodChat · 24/05/2023 05:46

Luckingfovely · 24/05/2023 04:44

I think the OP is saying that the company provides the employee with private jets for business travel, not that he can afford them on a £70k salary.

But yeah, it's a load of old puff, there is no legal case here at all.

Even so, a company isn't going to charter private jets for someone on £70k.

CombatBarbie · 24/05/2023 05:43

Have you written about this guy before, there was a thread before about a relative claiming to be something big.... May have been gov security.

Redebs · 24/05/2023 04:56

I wonder if you might be protected under whistleblowing policies if Walter's nonexistent qualifications and incompetence might be a risk

Luckingfovely · 24/05/2023 04:44

I think the OP is saying that the company provides the employee with private jets for business travel, not that he can afford them on a £70k salary.

But yeah, it's a load of old puff, there is no legal case here at all.

Loverofoxbowlakes · 24/05/2023 04:27

My company actually did discover an employee lied on their application about degree level/professional qualifications without which they shouldn't have been working in that position.

After terminating their contract there is (incredibly) no legal recourse against the former employee, so I'm fairly sure you're safe op.

And I wouldn't he able to help myself from dobbing Walter in to his employer...

Twistyripple · 24/05/2023 01:46

This is absolutely fabulous.......what a load of twaddle. No chance that a company would do that to a random individual

Banned4life · 24/05/2023 01:41

Absolutely not. Even it there were grounds for a claim (and there isn’t) why would a corporation spend lots of money suing an unknown individual for ‘millions’ that the individual doesn’t have?

AcrossthePond55 · 24/05/2023 01:07

Bollocks. Walter is just trying to scare you/others from 'turning him in' to his employer. Because he knows it's going to get him sacked if they know he lied on his CV.

I'm in the US, but during the course of my career I saw three people sacked on the grounds of 'falsifying qualifications'. And this wasn't even lying about a professional/licensing degree (ie nursing degree or legal degree), it was just lying about having a 4 year university degree.

ChopperC110P · 24/05/2023 00:54

Notimeforaname · 24/05/2023 00:48

Private jet with 70k a year 🤣🤣🤣

I know, that salary is missing three zeros….

ChocChipHandbag · 24/05/2023 00:53

On a very basic level, defamation is about tarnishing the reputation of person A in other people's eyes.

So I can say "Fred, you're a thief" to Fred in private and no claim is possible.

But if I say "Fred is a thief" in front of John then Fred has a theoretical claim against me as it lowers his reputation in the eyes of John (provided, of course, that Fred is not actually a thief).

If you tell a company "you've hired a fantasist" then it only harms the company if you publish this comment more widely.

Notimeforaname · 24/05/2023 00:48

Private jet with 70k a year 🤣🤣🤣

ChopperC110P · 24/05/2023 00:41

Thisisastupidscenario · 23/05/2023 23:14

So in this hypothetical situation… which I’m aware is ridiculous.

If an individual with an axe to grind was to approach the HR department of a company or the company in general (a large international company that has large customers) and make some allegations against an employee (namely that they’ve lied about their qualifications, despite fairly rigorous onboarding). Would or could that company sue that individual with an axe to grind for several million (maybe billion, and this is just an average joe here) for fraud and reputation damage?

to me it sounds like utter dog poo. But I’m not a sharp legal kind.

No.

Hawkins0001 · 24/05/2023 00:41

Intelligence services asset and ones been bragging ? @Thisisastupidscenario

XelaM · 24/05/2023 00:37

£70K even

Swipe left for the next trending thread