Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any Lawyers here? Need a legal Perspective on the world’s most ridiculous scenario

212 replies

Thisisastupidscenario · 23/05/2023 23:14

So in this hypothetical situation… which I’m aware is ridiculous.

If an individual with an axe to grind was to approach the HR department of a company or the company in general (a large international company that has large customers) and make some allegations against an employee (namely that they’ve lied about their qualifications, despite fairly rigorous onboarding). Would or could that company sue that individual with an axe to grind for several million (maybe billion, and this is just an average joe here) for fraud and reputation damage?

to me it sounds like utter dog poo. But I’m not a sharp legal kind.

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 24/05/2023 10:45

He sounds dangerous. Having built that much fantasy into his life how far would he go to protect the fantasy?

sheldonia · 24/05/2023 10:38

Getabloominmoveon · 24/05/2023 07:33

But why do you care? If he’s shit at his job, he’ll be found out and sacked. Or maybe he’s in a role where the ability to tell massive porkies is an asset. Having worked in a number of big corporates I can assure you he won’t be the only psycho with an inflated sense of self-importance.

Well, most people care about being constantly lied to, and then threatened.

Call them strange

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 10:35

PuffinsRocks · 24/05/2023 10:07

OMG it's this guy again! He really has no shame does he OP? And sadly it sounds like it could be him doing the break-ins, especially if he's done stuff like that before.

It does seem likely doesn’t it. I would tell the police but the relative in insistent that it’s lies and they’ll tell the police I’m lying- so I don’t really need wasting police time being held over my head.

im at a point where I do think… you made your bed relative, you’re going to have to lie in it… but that does seem cruel because Walter has manipulated and abused them for years

OP posts:
Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 10:33

AlligatorPsychopath · 24/05/2023 10:24

You can have contact with and support your elderly relative without having contact with Walter, though. He'll always fuck with your head; you'll think more clearly if you're not opening yourself up to him.

This was after one incident of cameras being smashed and police not able to go around, Walter was the closest relative, I live 6 hrs away. Desperate times, as really needed cameras back up that day as it seemed crimes maybe escalating.

larger picture is any contact with him leads to an elaborate and exhausting story so you are correct here, problem is, he spreads his lies very well and for whatever reason he’s believable, and no one seems to stop and question what he’s saying… just that now I’m going to be dragged to court for repetitional damage and my children will lose their house. This has resulted in a few panicked phone calls from other relatives and quite a nasty one from his partner

OP posts:
AlligatorPsychopath · 24/05/2023 10:24

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 10:07

this legal threat is new, and previously after all the lies before I didn’t.

ive explained upthread. Elderly relative in close proximity is being targeted, worried and as he is geographically close (and not thinking he’d sink that low because it’s outright breaking and entering) to check on the elderly relative enter ludicrous private jet story and flying to or back from all expense paid trip to vegas, so can’t and it’s really got me questioning now if it’s actually him targeting the relative and creating an alibi

You can have contact with and support your elderly relative without having contact with Walter, though. He'll always fuck with your head; you'll think more clearly if you're not opening yourself up to him.

PuffinsRocks · 24/05/2023 10:07

OMG it's this guy again! He really has no shame does he OP? And sadly it sounds like it could be him doing the break-ins, especially if he's done stuff like that before.

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 10:07

AlligatorPsychopath · 24/05/2023 10:00

I think the question is, why do you still have any contact with Walter if he's issued threats against you? You can't save the rest of the world from him, even if it were your job, which it isn't.

this legal threat is new, and previously after all the lies before I didn’t.

ive explained upthread. Elderly relative in close proximity is being targeted, worried and as he is geographically close (and not thinking he’d sink that low because it’s outright breaking and entering) to check on the elderly relative enter ludicrous private jet story and flying to or back from all expense paid trip to vegas, so can’t and it’s really got me questioning now if it’s actually him targeting the relative and creating an alibi

OP posts:
Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 10:03

Iyiyiiii · 24/05/2023 09:57

What was invented - the relative? or the whole scenario

Surely if the information is truthful, then you cannot be sued?
as @ChocChipHandbag says

So I can say "Fred, you're a thief" to Fred in private and no claim is possible.

But if I say "Fred is a thief" in front of John then Fred has a theoretical claim against me as it lowers his reputation in the eyes of John (provided, of course, that Fred is not actually a thief).

If Fred is a thief and its provable, then no lie or falsehood has occured?

I’ve posted this up thread but see below for a more detailed overview of scenario.

but basically, no one has approached his company, he’s claiming an anonymous person has and the company has taken it very seriously and will ‘take down’ anyone who’s said this and he wanted to check if it was me as I previously case aspersions on his role because he was worried for my children’s welfare. This is obviously shite as a multi National company wouldn’t take on an individual, especially because according to him it’s true and he has this snr position and all of these qualifications. So this anonymous person is lying (according to him)

backstory below

walter is a huge huge liar and it’s not the innocuous lies that don’t really hurt anyone else but yourself. The lies are used to con people or deride others or to carry out affairs (on his ex partner). The level of lie isn’t just oh I got a promotion at work or inflating a salary a bit for the brag factor, they are outlandish to the very limits of possibility. But sadly someone always seem to believe him and it ends up costing them, big time. But he is very manipulative. Others have recognised him from some other posts (I can’t really talk to anyone about this in real life because it’s so embarrassing to be related to someone like this) and it’s always something just outside of my frame of reference. These scenarios are not just for cheating people they are always an excuse to be a dick too, so not returning his elderly GM or M calls for months and then panicking and then it would turn out he’s on a secret spy mission and wasn’t permitted contact to the outside world (this legit happened) and one must go along with this bullshit

i have known Walt, his entire life, so I know his qualifications and he mine. Such as close family do. And now some, really hard ones to get have magicked up. now off the back of several fictional intelligence jobs, Walter has a snr leadership role (the type that normally doesn’t necessarily need a degree but 20+ years of experience and work place qualifications) just off the back of his fictional PhD. Now that would be one thing but it’s the same conning story starting all over again but it’s also the derision of my qualifications and my job because I’m inferior to Walter in his fantasy. Coincidentally I actually know (through a Friend of a friend) someone who works where he is claiming to be a high flier and I mentioned this to his mother and gm and then literally 3 days later this lawsuit has happened of someone ‘anonymously’ calling his company and saying he’s lied. I’ve never done that as frankly I doubt he’s lying to them, he probably does work there but in an entry level role, the lies are to people outside work and he’s worried about getting outed. Hence the ridiculous scenario

OP posts:
AlligatorPsychopath · 24/05/2023 10:00

I think the question is, why do you still have any contact with Walter if he's issued threats against you? You can't save the rest of the world from him, even if it were your job, which it isn't.

Iyiyiiii · 24/05/2023 09:57

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 07:05

No no one has, it’s all invented

What was invented - the relative? or the whole scenario

Surely if the information is truthful, then you cannot be sued?
as @ChocChipHandbag says

So I can say "Fred, you're a thief" to Fred in private and no claim is possible.

But if I say "Fred is a thief" in front of John then Fred has a theoretical claim against me as it lowers his reputation in the eyes of John (provided, of course, that Fred is not actually a thief).

If Fred is a thief and its provable, then no lie or falsehood has occured?

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 09:52

Motnight · 24/05/2023 09:50

He is certainly a multi tasker.

That’s a very nice way of putting it

OP posts:
Motnight · 24/05/2023 09:50

He is certainly a multi tasker.

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 09:50

Motnight · 24/05/2023 09:45

I recognise you from a previous thread Op!

probably, there’s not too many of these guys out there, don’t link them though please, I just don’t need the abuse from him if he or his new partner stumble across my mn vents

OP posts:
Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 09:49

DollyParkin · 24/05/2023 09:44

A very unambitious Walter Mitty to think that £70k is a “high flying” salary!

And if you really want to trip him up as a fake Dr Mitty, go to the online catalogue of the library of the university he claims has awarded him a PhD. When you earn a PhD you are required to deposit a copy - paper or digital - in that university’s library. It won’t be in the catalogue if it doesn’t exist.

(Although I do know that this is not a watertight proof as it’s hard to prove a negative. But still …)

For me 70k would be highflying, I’d feel well chuffed if I got there in the next 5 years.

he’s also not even 30 so to have crammed ba, msc with an international placement, PhD, 12 years in the civil service, time in the navy and then m16 and now this snr leadership role before 30 is quite something, especially for someone who failed their a levels and the btec, so didn’t even leave higher education until 21.

OP posts:
Motnight · 24/05/2023 09:45

I recognise you from a previous thread Op!

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 09:45

Fancylike · 24/05/2023 09:36

Hahaha, this dodgy character does not deserve sympathy or kindness.
It sounds like his lies are calculated to get people to do what he wants, to get money and sex, and to abuse them. But no, he’s just insecure :(

Exactly and then the threats him and his new partner have made against me now and my kids, granted they aren’t grounded in reality but it’s done to create fear and intimidate. No surprise he used to be physically violent.

concern is now that he’s the person harassing or stealing from this elderly relative due to how he reacted to my request to check in on them… it’s too suspicious

OP posts:
DollyParkin · 24/05/2023 09:44

A very unambitious Walter Mitty to think that £70k is a “high flying” salary!

And if you really want to trip him up as a fake Dr Mitty, go to the online catalogue of the library of the university he claims has awarded him a PhD. When you earn a PhD you are required to deposit a copy - paper or digital - in that university’s library. It won’t be in the catalogue if it doesn’t exist.

(Although I do know that this is not a watertight proof as it’s hard to prove a negative. But still …)

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 09:39

chipswitheveryting · 24/05/2023 09:33

He sounds like he has to lie to be the person he wants to be, then lie again when people start seeing through the lies, the tangled webs we weave.

Really the guy needs sympathy and understanding, he feels low and insecure in a tough world and this is his way of surviving. Big up his positive qualities in the hope that he pursues them more as a way of feeling secure. Don't tear him down or turn your back on him, there's only evidence of low self esteem here and that doesn't deserve the punishment of judgement or ridicule.

He’s stolen and embezzled thousands, and some of it from a dying man, but yeah shouldn’t pass judgment on that. Degrades others but yeah no judgment on that..,

OP posts:
Fancylike · 24/05/2023 09:36

chipswitheveryting · 24/05/2023 09:33

He sounds like he has to lie to be the person he wants to be, then lie again when people start seeing through the lies, the tangled webs we weave.

Really the guy needs sympathy and understanding, he feels low and insecure in a tough world and this is his way of surviving. Big up his positive qualities in the hope that he pursues them more as a way of feeling secure. Don't tear him down or turn your back on him, there's only evidence of low self esteem here and that doesn't deserve the punishment of judgement or ridicule.

Hahaha, this dodgy character does not deserve sympathy or kindness.
It sounds like his lies are calculated to get people to do what he wants, to get money and sex, and to abuse them. But no, he’s just insecure :(

chipswitheveryting · 24/05/2023 09:33

He sounds like he has to lie to be the person he wants to be, then lie again when people start seeing through the lies, the tangled webs we weave.

Really the guy needs sympathy and understanding, he feels low and insecure in a tough world and this is his way of surviving. Big up his positive qualities in the hope that he pursues them more as a way of feeling secure. Don't tear him down or turn your back on him, there's only evidence of low self esteem here and that doesn't deserve the punishment of judgement or ridicule.

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 09:26

Pipsquiggle · 24/05/2023 09:18

I still can't believe your family are falling for his BS.

You've done what you can. Keep reiterating to your family how it doesn't add up. Stand back and let him implode.

I mean FFS, the fact that he's put 'Senior Intelligence Officer' on LinkedIn FGS - he's ridiculous

There was also m16 and snr lieutant commander in the Royal Navy! I really want to know if there is someone on here who works for the company but can’t becuase it’s outing and then it’s the fact he’s used those previous roles to cheat money from vulnerable people and now that an elderly relative is being harassed and things are going missing, they are finding windows open, cameras smashed, seeing someone in the shadows

OP posts:
DemonicCaveMaggot · 24/05/2023 09:25

It is possible to be hired with fake qualifications.

The principal of my DC's elementary school claimed to be have a PhD. It turned out to not be the case at all. That together with faking annual reviews, favoritism, and 'borrowing' school computers all lead to her being fired.

She got through all the pre-employment checks which should have been thorough for an elementary school principal.

She got found out and she was fired because that turned out to be the tip of an iceberg in terms of her conduct. Nobody got sued either.

Pipsquiggle · 24/05/2023 09:18

I still can't believe your family are falling for his BS.

You've done what you can. Keep reiterating to your family how it doesn't add up. Stand back and let him implode.

I mean FFS, the fact that he's put 'Senior Intelligence Officer' on LinkedIn FGS - he's ridiculous

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 09:02

catsnhats11 · 24/05/2023 09:00

70k is a good salary but not that good, I mean certainly not private jet territory!!

Most people with doctorates don't earn massive salaries, a doctorate isn't a golden ticket to big money (quite the opposite really)

I'd just ignore him

Sadly I know this too well as I actually have one 😫😫😫 if anything outside of the industry you’re working in it can be a blocker

OP posts:
Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 09:02

Pipsquiggle · 24/05/2023 08:46

OK so obviously red flags all over the place there.

The thing is, it sounds like he is lying to you, which tbh isn't a big deal from a corporate perspective. Obviously awful from a trust and faaaaamily perspective

If he has lied to his company to get his current position or is lying to clients about his role and what he does he will probably get found out eventually, particularly if it is a big company with any kind of due diligence.

I applied for mid-management positions at several big companies a few years ago and they all wanted to see my degree certificate even though I am in my 40s. I thought it was overkill but it was probably to avoid scenarios like this.

I think he actually works there but at an entry level role as there’s no way he’d get through clearing and screening. I work for a big company and they wanted my certificates and still called the university I went to so I know it’s bs. He’s just creating a facade that this is his job. Prior to this fictional one his LinkedIn said he was a snr intelligence officer at the civil service and had been for 12 years

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread