Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any Lawyers here? Need a legal Perspective on the world’s most ridiculous scenario

212 replies

Thisisastupidscenario · 23/05/2023 23:14

So in this hypothetical situation… which I’m aware is ridiculous.

If an individual with an axe to grind was to approach the HR department of a company or the company in general (a large international company that has large customers) and make some allegations against an employee (namely that they’ve lied about their qualifications, despite fairly rigorous onboarding). Would or could that company sue that individual with an axe to grind for several million (maybe billion, and this is just an average joe here) for fraud and reputation damage?

to me it sounds like utter dog poo. But I’m not a sharp legal kind.

OP posts:
Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 12:54

W0tnow · 24/05/2023 12:49

He kind of sounds like he has the same psychological profile as Donald Trump.

It must have been a trip, being his parent or sibling, as he was growing up. And not in a good way.

Growing up around him was living in fear, he was extremely physically aggressive, he would get his friends to pelt me with rubbish as I walked home from school. He’d regularly attack me, sonne from our town once saw and dragged him off and called the police, it was swept under the rug. You couldn’t have any money on you it would be stolen, no jewellery, no car keys nothing, cards had to be hidden

OP posts:
Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 12:51

WeAreTheHeroes · 24/05/2023 12:43

He sounds like a sociopath, not just a fantasist. If someone has lied about their qualifications and experience to get a job they can be prosecuted for fraud, not just lose their job.

Obviously you're concerned because he's knows you and your family well. I'm guessing either brother or cousin. If you truly suspect him of stealing and/or extorting money from relatives go to the police.

That aside, can the person you know who works there not look him up and find out what his job title is? They may be able to see who his manager is and that will give an indication as to the level of his job.

I think he’s got a job there but a lower level one and just like any company it will have pretty serious onboarding checks so I doubt he’s lied to them, he’s probably bullshitted an interview, but don’t we all to an extent. It’s just outside of work he’s created this persona.

i know he’s stolen and embezzled upwards of £50k at least, but it’s the proof I don’t have any hard evidence and the family would support him in this not me.:

i think that’s what he’s afraid of, that I’ll contact his colleague and rumble him..and he’s invented this whole scenario about a stranger contacting to see if I a) already have and b) to scare me. He’s so manipulative he’s told people that me and his ex are no in cahoots to discredit him. Apparently that is more plausible than him lying about the position he holds there

OP posts:
W0tnow · 24/05/2023 12:49

He kind of sounds like he has the same psychological profile as Donald Trump.

It must have been a trip, being his parent or sibling, as he was growing up. And not in a good way.

WeAreTheHeroes · 24/05/2023 12:43

He sounds like a sociopath, not just a fantasist. If someone has lied about their qualifications and experience to get a job they can be prosecuted for fraud, not just lose their job.

Obviously you're concerned because he's knows you and your family well. I'm guessing either brother or cousin. If you truly suspect him of stealing and/or extorting money from relatives go to the police.

That aside, can the person you know who works there not look him up and find out what his job title is? They may be able to see who his manager is and that will give an indication as to the level of his job.

CuriouslyDifferent · 24/05/2023 12:35

There is a scenario where if an individual lies about their qualifications, I did hear of a large company who got rid of said of employee, then at the very least attempted to pursue damages via the court system, as the individual had worked for them for about 5 years and taken a huge salary and in their eyes defrauded them.

in your scenario, can’t see anything like it happening. It’s all so employee favored that even if there’s theft of customer lists, supplier contracts, IP walking to the competitor it’s very expensive and low chance of success for recovery, and always ends up as bad publicity.

I had to sign 27 pages of confidentiality clauses in a settlement agreement once, but my lawyer thought it laughable and unenforceable, as it related to criminal activity where I had the option of being whistleblower and best they could do was regain the amount. In reality I’d already whistleblown with the authorities by that point (the company knew) so wheels were in motion anyway.

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 12:27

Delphigirl · 24/05/2023 12:13

I’m laughing at this condensed chronology. Think you need to add “invented time travel” to his CV.

but seriously people like this can be rather dangerous so be careful.

But this is the level of lunacy we are dealing with. I despair.

semi recently he’d helped with a clear out before and was caught rifling through paper work and then several attempts were made to withdraw funds from a deceased persons bank account and he’d been asking for key personal info on that person too out of ‘curiosity’… just under the threshold for suspicious activity and just at the time he announces a fully funded by his company all American road trip that now has suddenly been cancelled. Now he’s planning on helping with another clear out… if at first you don’t succeed and all that

OP posts:
Delphigirl · 24/05/2023 12:13

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 09:49

For me 70k would be highflying, I’d feel well chuffed if I got there in the next 5 years.

he’s also not even 30 so to have crammed ba, msc with an international placement, PhD, 12 years in the civil service, time in the navy and then m16 and now this snr leadership role before 30 is quite something, especially for someone who failed their a levels and the btec, so didn’t even leave higher education until 21.

I’m laughing at this condensed chronology. Think you need to add “invented time travel” to his CV.

but seriously people like this can be rather dangerous so be careful.

BetterFuture1985 · 24/05/2023 12:11

I'm not a solicitor (yet) but I can tell you a legal professional would need more information to understand what - if any - legal issues there are. However, even as a law student I can see that the company has no case (being told an employee doesn't have the qualifications they say they do is a quick matter of HR checking said qualifications and then sacking the individual for gross misconduct if they lied).

DogInATent · 24/05/2023 12:05

Walt sounds like a next-level Mitty.

Unfortunately Linked-In lets you post what you want about yourself, and allows you to claim to be working anywhere you like in any role you like. It's a major flaw and they seem reluctant to fix it.

I don't see an easy, non-confrontational way of tackling this when the fraud is within the family. Mittys are usually very plausible to the type of person they target, and they can deflect attempts to reveal the truth into them being the victim of a slur.

You could try calling his bluff. Appear to take the threat seriously, let him know you've taken legal advice (you asked here...), tell him you're instructing a solicitor and will need details of the company's legal representation in order that the matter can be rapidly resolved. Due to the serious nature of the allegations you've been advised (I've just told you) that you cannot discuss the details with him and it must now only be dealt with through legal representatives.

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 11:52

GnomeDePlume · 24/05/2023 11:46

The ex who is being blackmailed could go to a solicitor. Put their cards on the table and see what advice they can give. The solicitor isn't going to tell their employer.

she may already have, I don’t know. She was a softie, a nice person but we don’t speak, ive been instructed to not engage with her. He was abusing her (shock horror I know) and they are already in a bitter legal dispute. He wants money he’s claiming is his, he could ruin her life with it, it’s along the lines of concrete proof of leaking confidential info and potentially stealing but all done under duress but of course the duress now can’t be proved because it’s years later but the actual ‘crime’ which is a criminal offence can

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 24/05/2023 11:46

The ex who is being blackmailed could go to a solicitor. Put their cards on the table and see what advice they can give. The solicitor isn't going to tell their employer.

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 11:34

Pipsquiggle · 24/05/2023 11:25

The thing is OP, just because of the other threads you have written, you need to get to a point of knowing you have done your best to protect people but you can't control them.

You can't control your dickhead relative. He will keep being a bastard.
You can't control your relatives who allow themselves to believe him, even when there is absolutely NO evidence to support his claims.

All you can do is not support his narrative and call out to your relatives that they are being conned, keep telling them, the drip, drip effect might eventually work. That's all you can do, unless you have proof he has stolen something / blackmailed someone and then call the police.

You’re right of course!

it is just so exceptionally difficult to sit back and watch someone just ruin countless peoples lives and steal from them etc. It’s just awful. MN is some sense is my safe space because I’m too ashamed to talk in real life to anyone and I actually even wonder if they’d believe me. Family don’t. Thank you all for being my support network!

i wish he’d slip up and I could get some proof, I mean his stories are so ludicrous that common sense should prevail, but it’s not.

OP posts:
Pipsquiggle · 24/05/2023 11:25

The thing is OP, just because of the other threads you have written, you need to get to a point of knowing you have done your best to protect people but you can't control them.

You can't control your dickhead relative. He will keep being a bastard.
You can't control your relatives who allow themselves to believe him, even when there is absolutely NO evidence to support his claims.

All you can do is not support his narrative and call out to your relatives that they are being conned, keep telling them, the drip, drip effect might eventually work. That's all you can do, unless you have proof he has stolen something / blackmailed someone and then call the police.

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 11:22

Pipsquiggle · 24/05/2023 11:10

There is absolutely no way his employers would take you to court.

Maybe even say, 'I look forward to the court summons from the Royal Navy. And if I am proven wrong I will gladly apologise publicly and pay costs'

That’s made me giggle a bit thank you, much needed!

he’s moved on from the navy now though… he was at m16 for a while and now it’s big industry

OP posts:
Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 11:15

NoSquirrels · 24/05/2023 11:07

Ah, this is awful.

It would be extremely unlucky if your elderly relative had one shady close relative who’s crooked, and then was also randomly targeted by other criminals on a regular-ish basis who know where to look for things of value etc.

If I were you I think I’d have a word with police anyway, explain the situation- that you suspect it is a relative but there is no proof, that this will be strenuously denied by all parties as there’s a history of ongoing low-level abuse, but that please could they do a welfare check type call out via community policing to talk to elderly relative generally about security etc. Might be just enough to put the wind up Walter without ruffling feathers too obviously?

They’ve already done this but without referring to Walter and wondering if this is another thing that’s ruffled him I’m pushing for an funding cameras to be put up but it can’t be done til next month and Walter has a date with the relative to help them have a clear out before then, who knows what will go missing then. They just need to see through the FOG and lies but it’s not working and then his poor ex, I desperately want to warn her but I’ve been commanded not to by family

OP posts:
Pipsquiggle · 24/05/2023 11:10

There is absolutely no way his employers would take you to court.

Maybe even say, 'I look forward to the court summons from the Royal Navy. And if I am proven wrong I will gladly apologise publicly and pay costs'

NoSquirrels · 24/05/2023 11:07

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 10:35

It does seem likely doesn’t it. I would tell the police but the relative in insistent that it’s lies and they’ll tell the police I’m lying- so I don’t really need wasting police time being held over my head.

im at a point where I do think… you made your bed relative, you’re going to have to lie in it… but that does seem cruel because Walter has manipulated and abused them for years

Ah, this is awful.

It would be extremely unlucky if your elderly relative had one shady close relative who’s crooked, and then was also randomly targeted by other criminals on a regular-ish basis who know where to look for things of value etc.

If I were you I think I’d have a word with police anyway, explain the situation- that you suspect it is a relative but there is no proof, that this will be strenuously denied by all parties as there’s a history of ongoing low-level abuse, but that please could they do a welfare check type call out via community policing to talk to elderly relative generally about security etc. Might be just enough to put the wind up Walter without ruffling feathers too obviously?

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 11:05

ClawedButler · 24/05/2023 10:57

For me, the question here is whether he believes his own lies or not.

If yes, he's clearly unwell. These are delusions, signs of psychosis (losing touch with reality).

If no, he's just a complete bastard. I see what you're saying that he really shouldn't be allowed to get away with what he's done and is doing to other people, but also see what PPs have said that you can't save everyone from him on your own, and it's not your responsibility to do so.

What you have said about him reminds me of someone I know who's quite similar wrt telling appalling lies that have very real and damaging consequences for those around them. Whilst I have some shred of sympathy for this person (because I believe them to be unwell, and also know that they will never experience true happiness), ultimately I look at them like a burning building: you can either get out, or stay and get burned. You can't reason with it, make it see sense, or stop it being destructive.

It's a tough situation, no wonder you're pulling your hair out.

I don’t think he does… he just sells them to people to get what he wants.

my heart breaks for these relatives, he took 50k from one under false pretences, I guess luckily from him they died later (natural causes). He’s abused, physically and emotionally, controlled, manipulated them to such an extent they are all terrified of him and go along with whatever he says. But it’s getting them to see it, it’s almost like the people that fall for romance scams they are so committed to the idea that they love this person that they are willing to go to war for it but deep down they are incredibly vulnerable and are being exploited but would deny it under torture

OP posts:
Highdaysandholidays1 · 24/05/2023 11:05

All doctorates are publically available, if gained in the UK, it's a condition of the award. So they can never be hidden (they can be embargoed for a year sometimes, not beyond that).

tenbob · 24/05/2023 10:58

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 10:53

That’s fab! You summed it up so well, the David and Goliath nature of this fictional lawsuit would actually cause reputational damage

Not to mention that if a company was this trigger happy to sue anyone and everyone who approached them, they wouldn't have time to get any actual work done.

Plus the amount you mention is more than you would see in a US class action lawsuit. It would never ever happen in the UK.

The only thing I can think of that comes even slightly close to what he is claiming is that I've seen people sign settlement agreements to leave the company, where they are gagged from talking about why they've left (usually the company wanting to cover up some form of discrimination) and including a clause that if the ex employee bad mouths the company, they company can seek damages to cover repairing the damage to their reputation (ie hiring a PR firm to defend the company)
But I have never, ever heard of this actually being enforced. It is just a line to make people think twice about going to the press with their story of discrimination

ClawedButler · 24/05/2023 10:57

For me, the question here is whether he believes his own lies or not.

If yes, he's clearly unwell. These are delusions, signs of psychosis (losing touch with reality).

If no, he's just a complete bastard. I see what you're saying that he really shouldn't be allowed to get away with what he's done and is doing to other people, but also see what PPs have said that you can't save everyone from him on your own, and it's not your responsibility to do so.

What you have said about him reminds me of someone I know who's quite similar wrt telling appalling lies that have very real and damaging consequences for those around them. Whilst I have some shred of sympathy for this person (because I believe them to be unwell, and also know that they will never experience true happiness), ultimately I look at them like a burning building: you can either get out, or stay and get burned. You can't reason with it, make it see sense, or stop it being destructive.

It's a tough situation, no wonder you're pulling your hair out.

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 10:53

tenbob · 24/05/2023 10:47

I'm not a lawyer, but my job includes looking after the corporate reputation for a big FTSE company, and have spent 20-odd years doing similar roles for FTSE companies, most of them household names.

Over the years, we've had various people claiming mad conspiracies, setting up websites claiming we do awful things etc, scammers using the company name for 'lotteries' and fake employment etc.

We have never sued or even attempted to sue any of these people, and they are deliberately trying to damage the company reputation.

I can't see any mechanism by which the company could sue, let alone the PR nightmare that would be any sort of 'David v Goliath' lawsuit.

So from the perspective of my role in a company, it would never happen.

To give you some examples of the sort of things we deal with in a typical year... we've had investors who have lost money buying our shares set up blogs claiming all sorts of weird financial mismanagement, and we usually ignore them on the basis they will have very few visitors. We don't even bother engaging with the individual

In one company I worked for, we had someone set up a website called 'CompanyXkillspeople.com' which was making all sorts of lurid claims, and we sent the host a legal letter to get it taken down, but I don't think we even properly investigated who was making the claims.

We fairly often get disgruntled people threatening to 'go to the press' unless we resolve their issue, give them compensation for a past issue, and occasionally, it will be something like sack their cheating ex husband.
99% of them don't know how to contact 'the press', and the very few that do usually result in a journo we know quite well telling us over lunch that they've had a weird email from a very angry person.

This would be pretty standard across any sort of large company, especially if they are 'customer facing' in any way - a retailer, utility company, etc

Happy to DM you more context or insight into how a company would typically handle a reputational issue, if it would be helpful

That’s fab! You summed it up so well, the David and Goliath nature of this fictional lawsuit would actually cause reputational damage

OP posts:
Ourladycheesusedatum · 24/05/2023 10:48

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 08:01

Yes this has happened before and been used to con people but I also care because I’m at any opportunity put down due to my mid tier role, due to walter’s more successful role. The quals are entirely fictional and only a recent development in the delusion. But yes I get dragged in, and being warned to not speak to anyone at the company about him with thinly veiled threats at my house and my kids that I’ll be ‘taken down’ in a multi million £ law suit. It started because I know someone, who knows someone who works at the company in question and mentioned this and the bam what do you know lawsuit

I would just not see Walter any more. Or at least very little.

Walter cant put you down if you dont see him.

Also give no shits what Walter says to anyone else about you.

If say a friend tells you that Walter says your never going to go beyond mid tier, then you laugh and say so what? Hows is it Walter's business what I do with my life?

If other people you care about are enmeshed with Walter, you just (if you want to) tell them you will always be there for them and that's it.
No more Walter and you will one day find out if Walter's lies bite him back.

tenbob · 24/05/2023 10:47

I'm not a lawyer, but my job includes looking after the corporate reputation for a big FTSE company, and have spent 20-odd years doing similar roles for FTSE companies, most of them household names.

Over the years, we've had various people claiming mad conspiracies, setting up websites claiming we do awful things etc, scammers using the company name for 'lotteries' and fake employment etc.

We have never sued or even attempted to sue any of these people, and they are deliberately trying to damage the company reputation.

I can't see any mechanism by which the company could sue, let alone the PR nightmare that would be any sort of 'David v Goliath' lawsuit.

So from the perspective of my role in a company, it would never happen.

To give you some examples of the sort of things we deal with in a typical year... we've had investors who have lost money buying our shares set up blogs claiming all sorts of weird financial mismanagement, and we usually ignore them on the basis they will have very few visitors. We don't even bother engaging with the individual

In one company I worked for, we had someone set up a website called 'CompanyXkillspeople.com' which was making all sorts of lurid claims, and we sent the host a legal letter to get it taken down, but I don't think we even properly investigated who was making the claims.

We fairly often get disgruntled people threatening to 'go to the press' unless we resolve their issue, give them compensation for a past issue, and occasionally, it will be something like sack their cheating ex husband.
99% of them don't know how to contact 'the press', and the very few that do usually result in a journo we know quite well telling us over lunch that they've had a weird email from a very angry person.

This would be pretty standard across any sort of large company, especially if they are 'customer facing' in any way - a retailer, utility company, etc

Happy to DM you more context or insight into how a company would typically handle a reputational issue, if it would be helpful

Thisisastupidscenario · 24/05/2023 10:47

GnomeDePlume · 24/05/2023 10:45

He sounds dangerous. Having built that much fantasy into his life how far would he go to protect the fantasy?

Exactly and his poor ex partner who he’s blackmailing to give him money

OP posts: