Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any Lawyers here? Need a legal Perspective on the world’s most ridiculous scenario

212 replies

Thisisastupidscenario · 23/05/2023 23:14

So in this hypothetical situation… which I’m aware is ridiculous.

If an individual with an axe to grind was to approach the HR department of a company or the company in general (a large international company that has large customers) and make some allegations against an employee (namely that they’ve lied about their qualifications, despite fairly rigorous onboarding). Would or could that company sue that individual with an axe to grind for several million (maybe billion, and this is just an average joe here) for fraud and reputation damage?

to me it sounds like utter dog poo. But I’m not a sharp legal kind.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AnnWallace · 09/06/2023 07:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BittenontheBum · 26/05/2023 18:46

@Thisisastupidscenario if this relative didn't sound so menacing I'd be tempted to aquire a burner phone and send him cryptic M16 type mission messages 🤣🤣
But seriously, in your shoes I'd take a huge step back.
He can't sue you, The Company (can't help but see Kray type geezers) can't sue you either.
If your family are choosing to believe his bullshit sadly nothing you say will make a difference. Until they realise for themselves they've been fleeced....
Good luck, you sound like a very caring person 🌺

Airz · 26/05/2023 14:28

Thisisastupidscenario · 23/05/2023 23:14

So in this hypothetical situation… which I’m aware is ridiculous.

If an individual with an axe to grind was to approach the HR department of a company or the company in general (a large international company that has large customers) and make some allegations against an employee (namely that they’ve lied about their qualifications, despite fairly rigorous onboarding). Would or could that company sue that individual with an axe to grind for several million (maybe billion, and this is just an average joe here) for fraud and reputation damage?

to me it sounds like utter dog poo. But I’m not a sharp legal kind.

UK defamation, libel and slander law states that for a company's defamation claim to be successful, they must prove that the defamatory words or material has caused or is likely to cause significant harm to their business.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 26/05/2023 11:17

WeAreTheHeroes · 24/05/2023 18:39

Is there actually a naval rank of Senior Lieutenant Commander? The RN website shows Lieutenant Commander, but not Senior LC.

Sorry, just catching up op. I was wondering this too.
He’s deluded, his lies will catch him out one day and he’s shitting himself that you know someone who works in the same place he does…it’s getting too close to home now hence the not so subtle threats to you.
He’s not that clever is he…Anyone in an Intelligence type role tells no one.

SchoolTripDrama · 26/05/2023 10:42

This ⬆️

CountessWindyBottom · 25/05/2023 23:08

Walter is dangerous. Not just because he could have any number of personality disorders but for his flagrant indulgence in criminal behaviour. I worked with a compulsive liar years ago and it was funny and outrageous until she started making shit up about me. She was an absolute loon. But this guy has shown himself to be not just a liar but a thief, arch manipulator and an abuser. If you can afford it I would probably go and seek some decent legal advice (his threats to sue are bullshit) on how to go about protecting you and your aging relatives from him reigning further financial or emotional damage on anyone else. I suspect one of his conditions is borderline personality disorder (although I don't believe this to be in isolation) and a hallmark of that is pathological attention seeking. For now, I would minimise contact, seek legal advice and take a longer term view, under expert guidance, as to what you can do to protect elderly relatives etc. I feel sorry for you, it's a horrid situation.

Lemonyfuckit · 25/05/2023 22:57

Banned4life · 24/05/2023 01:41

Absolutely not. Even it there were grounds for a claim (and there isn’t) why would a corporation spend lots of money suing an unknown individual for ‘millions’ that the individual doesn’t have?

Yes this is also an important point in debunking Walter's fantasises- aside from the actual defamation points ie they have to have a cause of action (some sort of loss to the company - which wouldn't be the case if you're just telling Walter 'I don't believe you') and if what you say actually is true, ie Walter's qualifications are indeed fabricated, then no cause - litigation is exceedingly expensive and time consuming and invariably parties don't recover what they actually spend, and the 'deep pockets' concept is real - wherever possible when a party is looking to sue they'll go after a company rather than an individual because there is zero point in suing someone for sums of money they don't possess. So the chance of a company suing you an individual for 'MILLIONS' is utterly incredible, assuming you're not actually a billionaire, because even if they in the exceedingly remote chance won their case, what would they get if you don't have millions to pay out to them? A lot of sunk legal costs.

But anyway they wouldn't have a case, so again why on earth would they bother.

Mamanyt · 25/05/2023 22:57

LOL, "corporations," NOT "corportations!" An edit button, an edit button! My kingdom for an edit button!

Mamanyt · 25/05/2023 22:55

DPotter · 23/05/2023 23:25

The company couldn't sue as it's not their reputation being attacked. And I have a feeling companies, corporations can't sue for defamation / slander anyway.

The only person who could sue for defamation / slander would be the person accused of lying about their qualifications. In reality going to law in this type of situation is incredibly costly, way beyond the pockets of the vast majority of the public. The individual could issue a 'cease & desist' letter, but what anyone would do if the individual didn't cease or desist I don't know.

Whatever - it sounds a distressing situation to be in. Do you / the individual concerned have a union or professional body who could advise / assist / support ?

Here in the USA, corportations/companies certainly can sue, and do, for slander/defamation. Dominion Voting Systems recently won a HUGE settlement from FOX News over FOX's asserting that their voting machines could be, and were, tampered with, and Dominion allowed it. And Smartmatic, another voting machine company, is in the process of suing them now, and they, too, were named on the air. So yes.

However, the person who's reputation was imputed would have to bring suit, not the company who heard it.

JudgeRudy · 25/05/2023 22:37

Yes, I was a bit lazy there....and hungry. Post dinner I've caught up. No I would not have imagined this was the story. There are some very odd people about...
Funnily enough I spoke to someone at work today who claimed to have sold a road kill badger to a Chinese restaurant for £50....which would be harder to disprove.
This person sounds like he has a mental illness.

Thisisastupidscenario · 25/05/2023 21:57

SafeguardingSocialWorker · 25/05/2023 21:42

Also his name, if you havent used an alias for him in your phone, is quite visible on one of the screenshots.

Can understand why googling him may not be helpful with a name like that. Lots of articles about the famous morally dubious person with the same name.

Oops, would be shame for him to be outed… shall report to MN

OP posts:
SafeguardingSocialWorker · 25/05/2023 21:42

Also his name, if you havent used an alias for him in your phone, is quite visible on one of the screenshots.

Can understand why googling him may not be helpful with a name like that. Lots of articles about the famous morally dubious person with the same name.

SafeguardingSocialWorker · 25/05/2023 21:31

If this came across my desk as a social worker in a safeguarding team I would be very very interested.

I know from experience these people walk amongst us.

SecretDoor · 25/05/2023 20:23

If you feel a relative is being conned and financially abused could you refer to the local SS adult safeguarding team?

Thisisastupidscenario · 25/05/2023 19:57

JudgeRudy · 25/05/2023 19:17

Ooh, I wanna know more. Here's my take. If the axegrinder accuses the company of having shit checks in place to ensure the staff they recruit are of a minimum standard (eg qualified)....and it's true...then no, of course they can't sue.
I do wonder if the axegrinder is also the fraudulent employee. They've got 'found out' and are now saying 'well it's your own fault for employing me without due diligence'. Did the employee mislead or lie?

not in an arsey way, but click see all from the OP. I can guarantee you this thread hasn’t gone the way you imagined

OP posts:
LookingforMaryPoppins · 25/05/2023 19:56

Walter sounds deluded and anyone believing him gullible.

Assuming you are in the UK, senior leadership roles in large companies pay far more than 70k. They also don't get flown around in private Jets - the vast majority of CEO's don't travel by private jet.

As for a claim against you for millions..... the company have no cause of action, there is no claim. Walter would be the only person with a cause of action but only if the information being provided about his is untrue. As you haven't provided any information there is no claim without even considering whether the information (not) provided is true.

For arguments sake let's say that Walter could prove you maliciously provided untrue information to his employer, what is his loss? He hasn't lost his job (and wouldn't unless the employer found he did lie), no reputational damage or financial loss as far as what you have said.

JudgeRudy · 25/05/2023 19:17

Ooh, I wanna know more. Here's my take. If the axegrinder accuses the company of having shit checks in place to ensure the staff they recruit are of a minimum standard (eg qualified)....and it's true...then no, of course they can't sue.
I do wonder if the axegrinder is also the fraudulent employee. They've got 'found out' and are now saying 'well it's your own fault for employing me without due diligence'. Did the employee mislead or lie?

Thisisastupidscenario · 25/05/2023 18:51

And by that I mean, running up lines of credit and then getting others to pay it off ^

OP posts:
Thisisastupidscenario · 25/05/2023 18:50

QuintanaRoo · 25/05/2023 18:29

I’m assuming his lifestyle doesn’t match his salary if he’s actually on a lower salary? Does nobody else find that odd. Also senior company personnel tend to be searchable on a company’s website…..if he isn’t then that’s also another red flag. Is it a sibling?

We don’t actually know his lifestyle, plus there’s the sums of money he’s liberated from other people. He was very financially irresponsible when he lived with his parents, he’d got into debt over several unpaid phone contracts and subscriptions, it had gone up into the thousands. I don’t know but I imagine he lives like Anna Delvey

OP posts:
QuintanaRoo · 25/05/2023 18:29

I’m assuming his lifestyle doesn’t match his salary if he’s actually on a lower salary? Does nobody else find that odd. Also senior company personnel tend to be searchable on a company’s website…..if he isn’t then that’s also another red flag. Is it a sibling?

Nothingisblackandwhite · 25/05/2023 18:19

They could try but I doubt they would succeed and any solicitor would tell them that .

Thisisastupidscenario · 25/05/2023 18:09

GeorgesMarvelousCalpol · 25/05/2023 17:30

I know this whole scenario is not really funny, but I did spend way too long trying to figure out what d'amour wizard wands are - I thought "oooh, they sound cool" 😆🤣

On a serious note, you've been through this for years and you're getting nowhere. I really think you need to go NC, and if your family members (parents?) aren't willing to see the truth that's their issue. Not only at they unwilling to see the truth, they're actually threatening you in the process (if you tell the police we'll deny everything, and say it could easily have been you) - that cannot be good for your MH.
I too remember your previous thread, there's nothing to be done here but go full NC.

Amour wizard wands… it sounds like something ann summers or love honey might sell… 😂😂😂😂

OP posts:
GeorgesMarvelousCalpol · 25/05/2023 17:30

Thisisastupidscenario · 25/05/2023 11:32

Why the hell did my phone correct famous you d’amour fgs 😂😂😂

I know this whole scenario is not really funny, but I did spend way too long trying to figure out what d'amour wizard wands are - I thought "oooh, they sound cool" 😆🤣

On a serious note, you've been through this for years and you're getting nowhere. I really think you need to go NC, and if your family members (parents?) aren't willing to see the truth that's their issue. Not only at they unwilling to see the truth, they're actually threatening you in the process (if you tell the police we'll deny everything, and say it could easily have been you) - that cannot be good for your MH.
I too remember your previous thread, there's nothing to be done here but go full NC.

AcrossthePond55 · 25/05/2023 15:17

GnomeDePlume · 25/05/2023 12:44

Sadly people do hide frauds carried out on them by family members. FOG writ large. Nobody wants to be the first one to break rank and say that X is a liar and a cheat.

You see the same where families stand by relatives who have committed heinous crimes. It is the victims who are blamed and cast out.

This is so true. FOG and a misbegotten sense of shame that someone from their family could behave so heinously. Better to hide it and cover it than shine a light on it. After all, what would the neighbours say?

^^

GnomeDePlume · 25/05/2023 12:44

Sadly people do hide frauds carried out on them by family members. FOG writ large. Nobody wants to be the first one to break rank and say that X is a liar and a cheat.

You see the same where families stand by relatives who have committed heinous crimes. It is the victims who are blamed and cast out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread