Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ParkRun and Transgender record breaker

532 replies

PennysLane · 23/05/2023 23:09

Trans runner (M to F) has smashed a woman’s record. Turns out he’s an attempted murderer too.

He attempted to murder the HR Manager of U.K. Athletics after he investigated his eligibility to compete as a woman. (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lauren_Jeska )

I have enjoyed Parkrun on several occasions with my children, I’ll not be doing it again until they get this sorted. If at all.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/22/parkrun-self-id-male-runners-smash-womens-records/

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/23/transgender-murder-parkrun/

Parkrun women's record held by transgender attempted murderer

Feminist activists outraged as it is revealed the fun run record is held by Lauren Jeska, who was given an 18-year sentence in 2017

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/23/transgender-murder-parkrun/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Chersfrozenface · 27/05/2023 13:34

"intersex is an outdated and offensive term"

Indeed.

Which, astonishingly, didn't stop a health survey, funded by UK Research and Innovation (the UK Government-funded body that invests in science and research) amongst others, from using 'Intersex' as one of the options in the first question, about "sex assigned at birth".

See screenshot in the first post on this thread
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4814227-our-future-health-asks-for-sex-assigned-at-birth?page=1

A supposedly scientific health survey, FFS

Our Future Health asks for sex assigned at birth | Mumsnet

Going through the process to register for Our Future Health, a huge UKRI funded health research programme. First question:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4814227-our-future-health-asks-for-sex-assigned-at-birth?page=1

SunnyEgg · 27/05/2023 13:25

Please stop exploiting the experiences of people with rare DSDs in the service of males who think their special feelings should outrank anyone else's. People with DSDs (intersex is an outdated and offensive term) have repeatedly asked not to be dragged into this

Good point

BluebellBlueballs · 27/05/2023 13:10

Fiftyisthenewsixty · 26/05/2023 22:02

Gender is an ancient term; predating biological sex by many millenia. (It literally means "presumed sex"). Not true.
Nobody is worried about aeroplane toilets or disabled cubicles.
I'm sure if you actually thought about it for a second, you could figure out why but I just wanted to add I actually do hate unisex cubicles. The best way to separate facilities would be to have one for people who stand up to pee and one for people who sit down. That way the people who sit down wouldn't have to clean the seat and stand the piss of the stand-uppers. Hmm, I wonder what we could call them?

You do know men can also sit down to pee and hold their willy pointing down into the loo?

nothingcomestonothing · 27/05/2023 11:43

Sladurche · 26/05/2023 15:44

I'd like to see the vagina on a British ship or a French table which tells you how they've been gendered.
Of course gender predates our understanding of biological sex. Gender was based on what people (and objects) were presumed to be depending on their appearance.
Of course any languages have no gender pronoun at all. That's not what we're talking about.
And the 5 indicator scale is a well-documented standard, not cod science.
XY people can be born with vaginas and female internal sex organs as their cells don't react to androgen. XX people can be born with a lot of testosterone which makes them bigger and stronger.
Some intersex people don't know they are intersex until puberty.
Currently they can be excluded from competing in sports because of their biology.
This is why it's daft.

Please stop exploiting the experiences of people with rare DSDs in the service of males who think their special feelings should outrank anyone else's. People with DSDs (intersex is an outdated and offensive term) have repeatedly asked not to be dragged into this, it's nothing to do with them.

No one is excluded from competing in sports. Some people aren't able to compete in the categories they'd like, because they are not the Main Character in the world and other people have needs and wishes too.

ArcticSkewer · 27/05/2023 11:33

Brain types indeed! What nonsense

Clymene · 27/05/2023 08:34

Current anatomy uses five different markers to assign a sex to a person at birth: 1) Genitalia 2) reproductive organs 3) gonads 4) sex chromosomes 5) sex hormones and how they affect the cells of the body; especially the brain as there are male and female brain types.

Sex is noted at birth, not assigned. By using 1) in your list, that's it.

Fiftyisthenewsixty · 26/05/2023 22:02

Gender is an ancient term; predating biological sex by many millenia. (It literally means "presumed sex"). Not true.
Nobody is worried about aeroplane toilets or disabled cubicles.
I'm sure if you actually thought about it for a second, you could figure out why but I just wanted to add I actually do hate unisex cubicles. The best way to separate facilities would be to have one for people who stand up to pee and one for people who sit down. That way the people who sit down wouldn't have to clean the seat and stand the piss of the stand-uppers. Hmm, I wonder what we could call them?

literalviolence · 26/05/2023 20:32

Sladurche · 26/05/2023 14:56

Gender is an ancient term; predating biological sex by many millenia. (It literally means "presumed sex").
In fact our understanding of what makes people "biologically" male or female is constantly developing.
Current anatomy uses five different markers to assign a sex to a person at birth: 1) Genitalia 2) reproductive organs 3) gonads 4) sex chromosomes 5) sex hormones and how they affect the cells of the body; especially the brain as there are male and female brain types.
The fifth one is by far the most important, as I think we'd all agree that what's between the ears is more important that what's between the legs.
Most people tick all 5 boxes male or female; around 2% don't. They are usually brought up by their parents as the gender they most externally resemble.
Transgender people; by and large, are peaceful people who feel that what's between their ears doesn't match what's between their legs. They are very much hated, by and large and many feel like they are treated like monsters. As is amply evidenced here. By changing the age-old definition of gender to be exactly equal to sex, you will be taking rights away from all those people by exclusion -transgender, and intersex of all varieties.
Not only that, but you will impose the dangerous precedent which all feminists have been trying to avoid of defining and limiting cis women purely based on what's between their legs. We've been fighting to have that association removed for over 100 years.
As for sport, there are always outliers to the "women" and "men" definitions, even in cis competitions. Some men are weaker, some women ate stronger. That's why basing competition shoukd be off of performance categories; rather than sex. Bit like boxing has featherweight and bantamweight. Bit like the paralympics categorises people into similar disability categories.
As for "female only" spaces like toilets and changing rooms, nobody I know is frightened to send their boys into the male bathroom. There are far more gay men than there are transwomen. Nobody is worried about aeroplane toilets or disabled cubicles.
The one place I would absolutely agree to exclude transwomen with penises from are refuges, prisons and healthcare. But we have to offer alternative safe spaces for trans men and women, too.
Finally, for this particular article, this person is vile. This person is a murderer. Their sport record as well as any other records should be expunged. This should be the same for any woman, man or non-binary person who commits crimes.

Just to pick up on a few points. It's regressive old-fashioned and quite frankly offensive nonsense to suggest there are lady brains and men brains. Loads of people are afraid to send their boys into the men's. Their are threads on MN dealing explicitly and solely with that. Don't call women cis unless they self identify as such. I am not cis because I don't identify as a woman and neither do loads of others. There are alternative spaces for TW in terms of prisons - the prison for male bodied people. Most sports do not have cross over between elite men and elite women. A top class women cannot compete with a top class women because of all the physical differences which advantage women. There are a lot of made up pseudofacts in your post.

Bellevu · 26/05/2023 20:21

andifeelfine · 24/05/2023 13:52

It's a charity with a small number of paid staff, mostly based in West London.

Things like t-shirts and branding are dealt with by HQ. Sales of parkrun merchandise and grants from sponsorship are used for purposes such as subsidising new events and funding the limited paid staff.

The actual events themselves, the events in the park, are run by unpaid volunteers. On any given Saturday, all of the volunteers could be volunteering for the very first time. We're not talking highly trained professionals here.

The volunteers generally aim for accurate times, but when that doesn't happen, for any one of a million plausible and valid reasons, no one cares. Because, as has been said so many times on this thread, the times don't count for anything.

Times from official races are taken seriously. Times from parkruns are not.

In terms of organisation, you basically have HQ and then a little group of local volunteers at every location. They are basically doing the day-to-day stuff themselves (including getting those results up on the website) but adhering to rules set by HQ centrally.

Times from official races are taken seriously. Times from parkruns are not.

Tell that to the teenage girls on our local county team whose teams use their parkrun times as set of their time trial qualifiers.Hmm

Chersfrozenface · 26/05/2023 20:20

Also where do you het your figure of 2% of people not being male or female from? Are you referring to intersex? The figure is much lower.

Indeed. The percentage of the human population with DSDs is 0.018%.

And all those with a DSD are either male or female.

Fiftyisthenewsixty · 26/05/2023 20:15

We've been fighting to have that association removed for over 100 years
No we haven't @Sladurche You seem to have fallen for the misconception that feminism wants to ignore the physical differences between the sexes which is absolutely not true. Also where do you het your figure of 2% of people not being male or female from? Are you referring to intersex? The figure is much lower. And that has nothing to do with being trans anyway.

Fizbosshoes · 26/05/2023 20:06

We've been fighting to have that association removed for over 100 years

Yes for years womens sport has been less accessible, less well paid, fewer athletes sponsored, and generally "behind" men's sport.

See women only being able to compete in marathons at the Olympics since the 1980s, womens boxing only included in 2012. Womens football (or netball) rarely getting any TV coverage etc. So why on earth would women give up the (immensely slow but important) progress that has been made and allow men to compete in their category?

As for sport, there are always outliers to the "women" and "men" definitions, even in cis competitions. Some men are weaker, some women ate stronger. That's why basing competition shoukd be off of performance categories; rather than sex. Bit like boxing has featherweight and bantamweight. Bit like the paralympics categorises people into similar disability categories.

...but the outliers in women's competition wouldn't win or challenge the top men because men have a biological physical advantage in almost every sport Serena Williams dominated women's tennis for probably a decade, and is arguably the greatest female player of all time. Would she have won a match against any of the top men's players? No. Does this take away from any of her achievements on the women's circuit? Also no.

And in case it escaped your notice the paralympics like almost every other sports competition categorises people by sex as well as those with similar disabilities.

Marchintospring · 26/05/2023 19:42

@Sladurche Transgender people; by and large, are peaceful people who feel that what's between their ears doesn't match what's between their legs. They are very much hated, by and large and many feel like they are treated like monsters.

Most people are, by and large peaceful.
People that act imitate the opposite sex are not treated like monsters at ALL. They have had successful films, are represented in theatre, TV and have been celebrated. It’s when men actually want to be considered women in law that there’s an issue.
We don’t tell people that have body dysmorphia that yes they are ugly or fat.We work with them to see the truth.

And I for one still worry about my son around other men. In toilets, on a night out just in general.

OvaHere · 26/05/2023 18:37

As for "female only" spaces like toilets and changing rooms, nobody I know is frightened to send their boys into the male bathroom.

This is simply not true.

I have 3 sons and when they were young (but too old for going in to the female bathroom) I would hover by the door like a hawk watching who entered after them. If they were taking even a few seconds longer than expected I would shout through into the toilet to get a response from them. Luckily most of the time I could send them in a pair or in triplicate - safety in numbers!

I sent them into the male bathrooms because they are male and above the age of about 7 it's not reasonable to have them in the female spaces. I found they stopped wanting to anyway because it made them uncomfortable as by that age they are very aware of their sex.

That doesn't mean I wasn't acutely aware of the risk male spaces pose to young boys. I very much was and made attempts to mitigate that risk where possible.

Unlike some people though I've never thought my concerns over male bathrooms for my male children should mean that the space belonging to women and girls can be encroached on.

EdgeOfACoin · 26/05/2023 16:58

Not only that, but you will impose the dangerous precedent which all feminists have been trying to avoid of defining and limiting cis women purely based on what's between their legs. We've been fighting to have that association removed for over 100 years.

Actually, feminists have been fighting to avoid defining and limiting women to outdated, restrictive stereotypes.

The TRAs are the ones trying to re-classify 'women' as people who conform to sex stereotypes and have pink brains instead of blue brains.

The TRAs have labelled me a 'birthing parent', a 'menstruator', a 'uterus haver'. I've never been more reduced to bits and pieces of my genitalia since the TRAs came on the scene.

Beowulfa · 26/05/2023 16:36

Millennia ago our ancestors didn't give a fuck about gender identities, but they did know about biologial sex when they started farming. Shame all that carefully curated knowledge got diluted through the generations to result in people talking bollocks to justify bollock-owners cheating.

Chersfrozenface · 26/05/2023 16:07

I'd like to see the vagina on a British ship or a French table which tells you how they've been gendered.

Well, they wouldn't have one, would they? Because they are of a grammatical gender, not a biological sex.

Of course gender predates our understanding of biological sex. Gender was based on what people (and objects) were presumed to be depending on their appearance.

So a Latin table looks female? How does it do that, then? In German Tisch is masculine while Tafel is feminine, yet they mean the same thing. The French word for vagina, vagin, is grammatically masculine.

And in the ancestor of the overwhelming majority of European languages, and those of the Iranian plateau and northern Indian subcontinent, the two grammatical genders were animate and inanimate. No connection with biological sex or appearance thereof at all. The words that developed from this ancestor language developed grammatical genders arbitrarily.

Sladurche · 26/05/2023 15:44

I'd like to see the vagina on a British ship or a French table which tells you how they've been gendered.
Of course gender predates our understanding of biological sex. Gender was based on what people (and objects) were presumed to be depending on their appearance.
Of course any languages have no gender pronoun at all. That's not what we're talking about.
And the 5 indicator scale is a well-documented standard, not cod science.
XY people can be born with vaginas and female internal sex organs as their cells don't react to androgen. XX people can be born with a lot of testosterone which makes them bigger and stronger.
Some intersex people don't know they are intersex until puberty.
Currently they can be excluded from competing in sports because of their biology.
This is why it's daft.

fellrunner85 · 26/05/2023 15:30

That's why basing competition shoukd be off of performance categories; rather than sex. Bit like boxing has featherweight and bantamweight

Erm... but they're still divided by sex as well. You don't get male featherweight boxers fighting female featherweights, for very good reason - ie that a 125lb man has significantly more strength and power than a 125lb woman.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 26/05/2023 15:23

Oh no, not the fake science fuckery again with a great dollop of pink and blue brain.

Chersfrozenface · 26/05/2023 15:22

Gender is an ancient term; predating biological sex by many millenia. (It literally means "presumed sex").

This is nonsense.

First of all, gender' is a word in English. There are many other languages, and many have only one word for the quality of being male of female.

It has never meant "presumed sex". It's from the Anglo-Norman and Middle French gendre (Anglo-Norman and Middle French, French genre ) kind, sort (c1125 in Old French), sex, quality of being male or female (second half of the 12th cent),

It was expanded to mean the grammatical class of words in some languages - masculine, feminine and neuter (e.g. Latin, German, Old English), masculine and feminine in many families of languages (Celtic languages, Latin-based languages).

In fact our understanding of what makes people "biologically" male or female is constantly developing.

This too is nonsense. There are only two sexes in mammalian species, of which Homo sapiens, humans, is one.

Sladurche · 26/05/2023 14:56

Gender is an ancient term; predating biological sex by many millenia. (It literally means "presumed sex").
In fact our understanding of what makes people "biologically" male or female is constantly developing.
Current anatomy uses five different markers to assign a sex to a person at birth: 1) Genitalia 2) reproductive organs 3) gonads 4) sex chromosomes 5) sex hormones and how they affect the cells of the body; especially the brain as there are male and female brain types.
The fifth one is by far the most important, as I think we'd all agree that what's between the ears is more important that what's between the legs.
Most people tick all 5 boxes male or female; around 2% don't. They are usually brought up by their parents as the gender they most externally resemble.
Transgender people; by and large, are peaceful people who feel that what's between their ears doesn't match what's between their legs. They are very much hated, by and large and many feel like they are treated like monsters. As is amply evidenced here. By changing the age-old definition of gender to be exactly equal to sex, you will be taking rights away from all those people by exclusion -transgender, and intersex of all varieties.
Not only that, but you will impose the dangerous precedent which all feminists have been trying to avoid of defining and limiting cis women purely based on what's between their legs. We've been fighting to have that association removed for over 100 years.
As for sport, there are always outliers to the "women" and "men" definitions, even in cis competitions. Some men are weaker, some women ate stronger. That's why basing competition shoukd be off of performance categories; rather than sex. Bit like boxing has featherweight and bantamweight. Bit like the paralympics categorises people into similar disability categories.
As for "female only" spaces like toilets and changing rooms, nobody I know is frightened to send their boys into the male bathroom. There are far more gay men than there are transwomen. Nobody is worried about aeroplane toilets or disabled cubicles.
The one place I would absolutely agree to exclude transwomen with penises from are refuges, prisons and healthcare. But we have to offer alternative safe spaces for trans men and women, too.
Finally, for this particular article, this person is vile. This person is a murderer. Their sport record as well as any other records should be expunged. This should be the same for any woman, man or non-binary person who commits crimes.

Fiftyisthenewsixty · 26/05/2023 13:54

Some of the comments here really illustrate why we're in this mess. So many women rushing to prove how kind they are by claiming that equality for women is not important. Sickening.

fellrunner85 · 26/05/2023 11:48

Cheers @AuntieStella , you're always the font of knowledge on running lore!

AuntieStella · 26/05/2023 11:18

Can definitely do what?

Age gradings are calculated against the world record times, and so get recalibrated - for every user, not just parkrun - when there is a new record

It doesn't matter how many parkrunners run whatever time they run - it does not affect the age grading. Your personal percentage is how you performed against the record holders.

It lets you compare by category - and you can sort the results table by age grading if you wish