Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ParkRun and Transgender record breaker

532 replies

PennysLane · 23/05/2023 23:09

Trans runner (M to F) has smashed a woman’s record. Turns out he’s an attempted murderer too.

He attempted to murder the HR Manager of U.K. Athletics after he investigated his eligibility to compete as a woman. (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lauren_Jeska )

I have enjoyed Parkrun on several occasions with my children, I’ll not be doing it again until they get this sorted. If at all.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/22/parkrun-self-id-male-runners-smash-womens-records/

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/23/transgender-murder-parkrun/

Parkrun women's record held by transgender attempted murderer

Feminist activists outraged as it is revealed the fun run record is held by Lauren Jeska, who was given an 18-year sentence in 2017

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/23/transgender-murder-parkrun/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
MrsJamin · 26/06/2023 14:40

That's exactly what I mean @OvaHere . I remember seeing the news about the female record too but it just reeks of "we care about achievement when it suits us and about community engagement when it suits us." They're trying to be all things to all people and this is an untenable position.
I still haven't had a single response to my many emails about this. Pathetic they can't even try and put into words what their position is as they know it doesn't make sense.

OvaHere · 26/06/2023 14:37

AuntieStella · 26/06/2023 13:57

You must have missed the announcements when the female parkrun record was broken (I mean the international fastest - like Andy's was the fastest men's internationally)

It was even covered by the BBC

Samantha Harrison: Athlete breaks female Parkrun record - BBC News

Fastest at one individual event doesn't get that level of shout-out (esp as the one at the start of the thread was over 2 minutes slower) though some other exceptional achievements do get them eg Alex Yee attracted a lot of attention when he ran the (then) second fastest men's time internationally when he was barely out of his teens. Ditto oldest ever parkrunner (at all, or to a milestone)

If you look at what parkrun blogs and tweets about, fast running is a tiny fraction of it. But the national/international record times would feature whenever a new one is set.

I think you misunderstood the point that MrsJamin was making. When women complain about males taking female records we get told Parkrun is only about inclusion and being the best in class or fastest doesn't matter.

Clearly it does to both sexes (and Parkrun when it suits them) but only one sex has fair competition thanks to Parkrun rules.

AuntieStella · 26/06/2023 13:57

You must have missed the announcements when the female parkrun record was broken (I mean the international fastest - like Andy's was the fastest men's internationally)

It was even covered by the BBC

Samantha Harrison: Athlete breaks female Parkrun record - BBC News

Fastest at one individual event doesn't get that level of shout-out (esp as the one at the start of the thread was over 2 minutes slower) though some other exceptional achievements do get them eg Alex Yee attracted a lot of attention when he ran the (then) second fastest men's time internationally when he was barely out of his teens. Ditto oldest ever parkrunner (at all, or to a milestone)

If you look at what parkrun blogs and tweets about, fast running is a tiny fraction of it. But the national/international record times would feature whenever a new one is set.

Samantha Harrison at Parkrun in Long Eaton

Samantha Harrison: Athlete breaks female Parkrun record

Samantha Harrison set a new record time as part of her training for the London Marathon.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-derbyshire-63862898

hollyblueivy · 26/06/2023 12:09

MrsJamin · 26/06/2023 11:17

The male record for parkrun has been broken in Edinburgh this weekend. Twitter account parkrunuk retweets someone announcing it and they remark "Brilliant achievement Andy 😍👏👏🧡". Tell me again that parkrun do not see it as a race and that records are important and valid... But only for men.

Fair point

OvaHere · 26/06/2023 11:24

MrsJamin · 26/06/2023 11:17

The male record for parkrun has been broken in Edinburgh this weekend. Twitter account parkrunuk retweets someone announcing it and they remark "Brilliant achievement Andy 😍👏👏🧡". Tell me again that parkrun do not see it as a race and that records are important and valid... But only for men.

So true. Bloody awful hypocrites they are.

MrsJamin · 26/06/2023 11:17

The male record for parkrun has been broken in Edinburgh this weekend. Twitter account parkrunuk retweets someone announcing it and they remark "Brilliant achievement Andy 😍👏👏🧡". Tell me again that parkrun do not see it as a race and that records are important and valid... But only for men.

megletthesecond · 30/05/2023 10:56

I'm not volunteering this weekend. DS is but I'm on strike until they start treating women better.

AuntieStella · 29/05/2023 21:05

greenacrylicpaint · 29/05/2023 13:26

those who say 'it doesn't matter' - of course it does! researchers, including those researching sex differences in sports, use this freely available data for studies.
allowing males to be recorded as female makes the data less meaningful.

If they are using it, then I hope they are already caveating it to cover both the timing being by amateur volunteers, and that category of runner is not verified.

They would be much better off using published results tables from affiliated events

lljkk · 29/05/2023 20:09

Nellodee · 29/05/2023 09:59

No genital inspections would be needed. Make a rule, no males in female race. A complaint goes in : this person is male. A short search is done, a letter sent. “We have suspended you from the female race as we have had a report that this category is incorrect. You may appeal by x y z.” Total time, about 5 mins. The more people knew it would happen, the less 5 mins would need to be spent. I’d imagine someone in a male prison would not pass the appeal. There might be a couple of India Willoughbys that mess up the system, but it’s going to take sports being firm a few times and it will soon be apparent that stubbornness in the face of reality is pointless. I wouldn’t expect park runs to deal with complex cases like Caster Semenya, but I think that’s likely to only be a problem in certain countries. In almost all cases, I’d imagine a brief phone call would be enough to establish the truth.

And let’s be clear - any difficulties arising from this would absolutely be from male people breaking the rules, not the rules themselves.

Park run organisers sending out letters, who the F has time for that. Our local PkRn struggles to get volunteer marshalls each & every week, they don't have time to police course records like that.

The things about statistics is that one or 2 'bad' data points (outliers) don't change the results if you're dealing with a huge dataset. Whatever PkRun has in public domain is potentially beyond vast dataset. A tiny number of TWs or TMs can't change the overall between-sex comparisons.

greenacrylicpaint · 29/05/2023 13:26

those who say 'it doesn't matter' - of course it does! researchers, including those researching sex differences in sports, use this freely available data for studies.
allowing males to be recorded as female makes the data less meaningful.

Fiftyisthenewsixty · 29/05/2023 10:39

Chersfrozenface · 29/05/2023 09:43

What would "feeling feminine" look like?

Caring? Weeping more readily? Fond of sewing, home decorating, flower arranging?

Anyway, definitions of "femininity" vary by culture and background. In Japan, for instance, samurai were heavily into flower arranging.

Exactly that. You can identify with whatever stereotypes your current location and culture regard as "feminine". It doesn't make you female.

megletthesecond · 29/05/2023 10:28

No one needs to be inspected as they're pretty blatant about it and you can tell the difference when someone is running.

Nellodee · 29/05/2023 09:59

No genital inspections would be needed. Make a rule, no males in female race. A complaint goes in : this person is male. A short search is done, a letter sent. “We have suspended you from the female race as we have had a report that this category is incorrect. You may appeal by x y z.” Total time, about 5 mins. The more people knew it would happen, the less 5 mins would need to be spent. I’d imagine someone in a male prison would not pass the appeal. There might be a couple of India Willoughbys that mess up the system, but it’s going to take sports being firm a few times and it will soon be apparent that stubbornness in the face of reality is pointless. I wouldn’t expect park runs to deal with complex cases like Caster Semenya, but I think that’s likely to only be a problem in certain countries. In almost all cases, I’d imagine a brief phone call would be enough to establish the truth.

And let’s be clear - any difficulties arising from this would absolutely be from male people breaking the rules, not the rules themselves.

Chersfrozenface · 29/05/2023 09:43

Fiftyisthenewsixty · 29/05/2023 09:36

I think you can have a strong sense of feeling feminine. But yes, this has nothing to do with sport. Sport doesn't care about your inner feelings. You might as well have categories based on star signs.

What would "feeling feminine" look like?

Caring? Weeping more readily? Fond of sewing, home decorating, flower arranging?

Anyway, definitions of "femininity" vary by culture and background. In Japan, for instance, samurai were heavily into flower arranging.

Fiftyisthenewsixty · 29/05/2023 09:36

I think you can have a strong sense of feeling feminine. But yes, this has nothing to do with sport. Sport doesn't care about your inner feelings. You might as well have categories based on star signs.

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 28/05/2023 22:59

And that's nothing to do with Park Run and the actual thread anyway so was a bit of a derail engaging with it, sorry

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 28/05/2023 22:58

MirandaWest · 28/05/2023 19:16

What are male and female brains? How do I find out which sort I have?

I’m female and so my brain is female.

Same, but I as someone who is not trans have a strong sense of identifying as a woman too so can see where people who are trans are coming from, whether they're trans women or trans men.
It's nothing to do with having a "male or female " brain.

SirVixofVixHall · 28/05/2023 21:58

So are non binary brains purple ?

BluebellBlueballs · 28/05/2023 21:46

MirandaWest · 28/05/2023 19:16

What are male and female brains? How do I find out which sort I have?

I’m female and so my brain is female.

Well, if you can ever get anyone to look inside it's easy. If it's pink it's a girl brain, boys are blue.

MirandaWest · 28/05/2023 19:16

What are male and female brains? How do I find out which sort I have?

I’m female and so my brain is female.

AuntieStella · 27/05/2023 18:12

B) won't fly. They hold parkruns in prisons and YOIs

Also, given the announcement this week about triathlons, I don't think parkrun HQ will do anything. The new rules for that apply only to certain higher levels of competition, and others - such as "entry level" ones - do not have to follow. Parkrun sees itself as a run not a race, and so it does not have to follow the rules for affiliated athletics. And I think it will stay that way

literalviolence · 27/05/2023 14:54

Clymene · 27/05/2023 08:34

Current anatomy uses five different markers to assign a sex to a person at birth: 1) Genitalia 2) reproductive organs 3) gonads 4) sex chromosomes 5) sex hormones and how they affect the cells of the body; especially the brain as there are male and female brain types.

Sex is noted at birth, not assigned. By using 1) in your list, that's it.

Or pre birth using scans and looking at 1).

literalviolence · 27/05/2023 14:52

For me it's just A). The process would be wiping records of people proven to be male. It's not perfect but it's a message that saying you're female when you're male ia cheating.

lljkk · 27/05/2023 14:31

DM article is not behind a paywall.

So what is the logic here, should remove LJ from the Aberwystwyth course women's record because...
A) Y chromosome bearer (and sensitive to testosterone)
B) convicted of a very violent offence
C) probably excess testosterone levels (why LJ's formal records were stripped)
D) some combo of above
E) PP "just don't like him"

Does local Abba PkRn group get to decide, or is it for PkRun Uk to decide, or PkRun international to decide?

How violent does an offence have to be if (B) is the reason? Is suspicion about testosterone levels good enough for criteria (C) ? Who gets to decide how much someone is disliked and criteria E should apply?

What would due process be (including adjudication & appeals available) for any of applying criteria A-E? Who is responsible for making sure (A) to (E) get applied at other PkRuns?

Fiftyisthenewsixty · 27/05/2023 13:57

You do know men can also sit down to pee and hold their willy pointing down into the loo?
Of course. If you know how to make them do it in public toilets let me know. Something tells me that if they can't be arsed to put the toilet seat up and aim, they probably won't respond well to you telling them to sit down. What a weird response. 😆

Swipe left for the next trending thread