Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ParkRun and Transgender record breaker

532 replies

PennysLane · 23/05/2023 23:09

Trans runner (M to F) has smashed a woman’s record. Turns out he’s an attempted murderer too.

He attempted to murder the HR Manager of U.K. Athletics after he investigated his eligibility to compete as a woman. (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lauren_Jeska )

I have enjoyed Parkrun on several occasions with my children, I’ll not be doing it again until they get this sorted. If at all.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/22/parkrun-self-id-male-runners-smash-womens-records/

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/23/transgender-murder-parkrun/

Parkrun women's record held by transgender attempted murderer

Feminist activists outraged as it is revealed the fun run record is held by Lauren Jeska, who was given an 18-year sentence in 2017

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/23/transgender-murder-parkrun/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Chersfrozenface · 24/05/2023 09:23

Hearti · 24/05/2023 06:35

If it’s just a run in the park then don’t bother publishing times!!

the reality is that lots of people use parkruns published timings to motivate their running speed, wether they be newbies starting out or club sprinters. Those age and sex ranks are religiously referenced with keen eyes every Saturday afternoon, often on the back of weeks, years or months of invested training. Park run results matter to the average jo bloggs competing in the race. The results are not diminished just because jo Bloggs isn’t a professional runner.

i suspect male heavy parkrun management, dismissing the fairest option of a third trans category. Sadly inclusion for people with penis means exclusion for women.

Or publish the times, with a caveat that they are meaningless.

The woman's time a female participant is comparing herself against could easily have been accomplished by a male.

RichardBarrister · 24/05/2023 09:22

firef1y · 24/05/2023 08:56

I don't remember having to prove who I am to register for parkrun. I don't remember having to prove my name or my gender or even my age (pretty sure that the only times I've had to prove who I was for a race even was Brighton and London marathons). 99.9999% of people doing parkrun are not even thinking about beating anyone other than themselves, yes there always is "that" person who has to come first, but they're usually entitled twats no matter what gender they identify as.

Therefore I can't be too arsed at the idea that a transgender female holds a record. It's not like parkrun is a qualifier for the Olympics or anything, it makes absolutely no difference to any other parkrunner, we're only there to compete with ourselves (and run in a social manner)

So because you don’t run very fast and just do it for the participation (which is absolutely fine), you support a situation that could prevent the fastest woman from getting the women’s record?

Tinkerbyebye · 24/05/2023 09:22

I haven’t read the full thread but the issue is that on the website it still states the they won and are a record holder, and that’s what needs to be removed

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/05/2023 09:20

So for me it is not really about whether the course "record" is fair but is the data produced, that many runners use, accurate and fair?

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/05/2023 09:18

People can lie about their age for Parkrun as well, doesn't make it fair or right.

Parkrun is both inclusive and competitive. For those who just want a Saturday morning run, there is no requirement to register their sex and age or get a result. People that do register, want the result becuase it matters to them. Some will be doing it to compare their own results and some will to compare where they are in their age and sex cohort.

Mr Monkey is a keen Parkrunner and in the last year he has been aiming to get a good for age marathon time. He has been using his Parkrun results as part of his overall training schedule to track how he is doing within his age and sex class - as that is how good for age times work. If someone younger had self ID'd in to his age class, his results and tracking would be off.

If Parkrun wants to offer this service to people it has to be true and useful. If it is just an inclusive fun run in the park then stop the time tracking by age and sex. However they know if they do that many regulars would stop attending.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 24/05/2023 09:15

I’d say I’m pretty GC. I definitely am pretty vocal about men in women’s sport. I also do Parkrun. Someone up thread said that everyone at Parkrun self identifies, and I think that’s the point. If you do Parkrun, you’ll know that there are different categories for age and sex. Older women, younger women, girls over 11, girls under 11, and so on. Each of these categories, in the results each week, has rankings. So it’s possible for someone to be first woman in their age category for example. Nobody is going to check their ID to check they are the age they are, just as they aren’t going to check whether they were actually born a woman. The record doesn’t mean anything outside of Parkrun. It can’t be used in the competitive athletics world, because, apart from anything else, the timing mechanism is inaccurate. I’d say pretty much every other week at our Parkrun something goes wrong with the results. Someone jumps the funnel, doesn’t hand their token in, the scanners have an issue, and so on. You could argue that this person should have their ‘record’ stripped. But you could also argue that someone else might also need to have their ‘record’ stripped because they cut a corner on the path, or the timing went wrong that week, or they aren’t the age they say they are….and so on. Parkrun isn’t competitive athletics, and if they strip this ‘record’ it opens a can of worms for other past results.

Personally, I think that the focus in the Parkrun world on ‘ records’ is wrong, given its ethos. But that’s a different debate.

KohlaParasaurus · 24/05/2023 09:06

Eleganz · 24/05/2023 08:45

But there are others ways to participate in competitive running rather than parkrun. I had always understood that parkrun was about encouraging as many people as possible to run, not give elite runners another opportunity to test their mettle.

I agree to a large extent, and I'd still go even if my only "result" was my personal time, but the competitive features are already embedded in the system and it would be a backward step to remove them as a reaction to a small number of males interfering with the validity of some women's placings and records. Parkrun may be focused on participation, but the sharp end of the field matters too.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/05/2023 09:04

Damnspot · 24/05/2023 08:57

Lauren Jeska last recorded a park run time in 2015.

And it's only now that we can really talk about this freely, especially on AIBU. There have been threads on this before in FWR.

Thanks to women like Maya Forstater.

Previously we were told 'trans women are women' and that there could be no debate.

The irony of those men trying to shut women up, larping as women to steal our prizes and then get into women's single sex spaces including prisons claiming to be 'the most oppressed' is not lost on me.

The TRAs really have done a number on women. They want us to only exist as a subset of our own sex (cis) and to only exist on their terms.

BogRollBOGOF · 24/05/2023 09:03

cakeorwine · 24/05/2023 08:32

I'd love it if some elite women decided to go touristing and smash known false records though... alas I am very far from that league

Wouldn't that affect local people who would then never be able to beat the local record because someone from outside the area has taken it?

So what would be the point in competing if you knew you could never win?

I can handle the fact that one of my regular parkruns has a record held by one of the current elite women. She was bloody amazing, and well done to her.

It is disconcerting being lapped when you're not expecting it by someone flying past and making it look easy though.

I will never win. Not even my age category. I'm happy to be mediocre. But the records should be fairly won.

Far better that the record is held by an elite woman who's earned it than a man in prison for violent crime.

Touristing is a popular trait of parkrun. Some parkruns exist largely because of tourists in areas of low population. Some parkruns gain a "cult" status because of their history or characteristics.

It's not local parkrun for local people.

Damnspot · 24/05/2023 08:57

Lauren Jeska last recorded a park run time in 2015.

firef1y · 24/05/2023 08:56

I don't remember having to prove who I am to register for parkrun. I don't remember having to prove my name or my gender or even my age (pretty sure that the only times I've had to prove who I was for a race even was Brighton and London marathons). 99.9999% of people doing parkrun are not even thinking about beating anyone other than themselves, yes there always is "that" person who has to come first, but they're usually entitled twats no matter what gender they identify as.

Therefore I can't be too arsed at the idea that a transgender female holds a record. It's not like parkrun is a qualifier for the Olympics or anything, it makes absolutely no difference to any other parkrunner, we're only there to compete with ourselves (and run in a social manner)

Doagooddeed · 24/05/2023 08:52

@randomsabreuse You mean thats how you view Park runs, many others do not.

You could make your argument for almost all grass roots competitions, the vast majority of competitors aren't going to win, prizes are minimal or non existent and no matter how well you do, it wont lead to a contract from Adidas or Nike.

So lets not safe guard women from men competing against them, after all women don't matter and on a sunday morning, they d be better off at home, making sure there is a hot brekkie and clean house for when the man returns home from from his sporting endeavours.

AuContraire · 24/05/2023 08:49

EdgeOfACoin · 24/05/2023 08:47

If ParkRun is 'just' for fun, why are the results on the website?

Because it simultaneously matters a lot, and doesn't matter at all, depending on whether it's men or women were talking about.

AuContraire · 24/05/2023 08:48

saraclara · 24/05/2023 08:45

I'd have thought that attempting to murder one of its staff would be enough reason for Parkrun to strike a runner's result from the records, personally.

I don't think the threshold for should be this low for scrubbing cheaters records, tbh

EdgeOfACoin · 24/05/2023 08:47

If ParkRun is 'just' for fun, why are the results on the website?

EdgeOfACoin · 24/05/2023 08:46

cakeorwine · 24/05/2023 08:11

If positions matter, then does it matter if more women or men take part next week - so you could be 30th 1 week or 1st next week and yet do better when you came 30th compared to when you came 1sr - as it's the time that matters.

Would you prefer to be the 1st female but with a slower time or 2nd female with a faster time?

Another question - how do you know if a runner is trans or not? Sometimes it's obvious, Sometimes it isn't.

What about transmen - should they run under their biological sex? All that testosterone could really help.

Maybe each person should have to show their birth certificate and take a hormone test before running?

Female-bodied people who have artificially increased their testosterone levels are cheating. No, they should not be in the women's race, regardless of how they self-identity. Perhaps there could be a separate race for ftm transitioners, which would be much fairer.

Male-bodied people who have artificially reduced their testosterone levels should also not be competing against women. Firstly, because a reduction of testosterone from typical male levels comes nowhere near the level of testosterone found in females. Secondly, because a male body confers additional advantages over a female body when it comes to almost all sports.

Eleganz · 24/05/2023 08:45

KohlaParasaurus · 24/05/2023 08:38

I was going over this in my head in response to another thread about a transwoman taking a parkrun course record (I had no idea that Lauren Jeska held one too) and came to a similar conclusion. Parkrun can't realistically police the sex of entrants. But if they remove all the trappings of competition, the course records and the results organised by time and stating age grades, and list the results alphabetically, we genuinely will be just "taking part" or "competing with ourselves" and it won't matter, and all the bingo and alphabet and tourist "challenges" won't be affected.

But lots of us, including many who, like me, are never going to be in contention for records, enjoy having the trappings of competition and it would become an(other) example of women losing a nice thing because a tiny number of males can't be trusted not to push their way into it.

I'd like to see a policy of at least <i>asking</i> male participants not to register as female, irrespective of how they identify. I won't be boycotting parkrun in the meantime, but I'm not buying their merchandise.

But there are others ways to participate in competitive running rather than parkrun. I had always understood that parkrun was about encouraging as many people as possible to run, not give elite runners another opportunity to test their mettle.

saraclara · 24/05/2023 08:45

I'd have thought that attempting to murder one of its staff would be enough reason for Parkrun to strike a runner's result from the records, personally.

randomsabreuse · 24/05/2023 08:41

I really don't care about parkrun results/records because no one really loses or wins anything at parkrun. It's a "run not a race" after all. The nearest I get to racing is the final sprint with my child (or running buddy) which is entirely irrelevant other than in the moment - we "race" at the end of most of our runs because it is fun for us! I guess at the front of some parkruns there might be an actual "race" but it's still only about bragging rights and no funding, qualifications or prizes of any sort are at stake.

The whole point of parkrun is participation with a record of times that compare with your own previous times. I could easily choose to change my DoB a few years and no one would know (or care, I'm floating in the mid 30s for time!). There are no ID checks on sign up because it doesn't matter.

I'm much more bothered about directly competitive sports (tennis, squash) where there is a 1v1 table and contact sports are the most important to regulate. Parkrun is basically a regular fun run, not a competition!

BenCoopersSupportWren · 24/05/2023 08:39

When anyone says “it’s only Parkrun, it doesn’t matter” what you’re really saying is “it’s only women, they don’t matter”.

When anyone says “but how are you going to know they’re trans, gonna demand to see their genitals?” what you’re really saying is that you don’t think transwomen are capable of acting honourably enough to not lie about their sex and not cheat women out of their rightful sporting achievements when categories are segregated by sex.

Why do you think so badly of women AND transwomen?

Doagooddeed · 24/05/2023 08:38

cakeorwine · 24/05/2023 08:32

I'd love it if some elite women decided to go touristing and smash known false records though... alas I am very far from that league

Wouldn't that affect local people who would then never be able to beat the local record because someone from outside the area has taken it?

So what would be the point in competing if you knew you could never win?

It happens, one of our park run records was set by an elite runner on holiday but that doesn't mean a local female runner cannot be first female finisher on a particular day.

I'm not really sure why you are defending men running in female events.

KohlaParasaurus · 24/05/2023 08:38

CantSell · 24/05/2023 07:43

I’m a GC parkrunning woman. Parkrun is a run, not a race, and organised by kind hearted volunteers. I suspect most of those objecting have no idea what parkrun is actually like. If a transwoman finished ahead of me, and was listed as female, I’d just roll my eyes at their self deception. All I care about is my PB.

I think parkrun should probably scrap course records and maybe do away with places, just listing finishers alphabetically. That way people (mainly non-parkrunners) would stop obsessing about records and the rest of us could just enjoy parkrun as it was intended: a non-competitive, run in the park with a friendly bunch of people.

I was going over this in my head in response to another thread about a transwoman taking a parkrun course record (I had no idea that Lauren Jeska held one too) and came to a similar conclusion. Parkrun can't realistically police the sex of entrants. But if they remove all the trappings of competition, the course records and the results organised by time and stating age grades, and list the results alphabetically, we genuinely will be just "taking part" or "competing with ourselves" and it won't matter, and all the bingo and alphabet and tourist "challenges" won't be affected.

But lots of us, including many who, like me, are never going to be in contention for records, enjoy having the trappings of competition and it would become an(other) example of women losing a nice thing because a tiny number of males can't be trusted not to push their way into it.

I'd like to see a policy of at least <i>asking</i> male participants not to register as female, irrespective of how they identify. I won't be boycotting parkrun in the meantime, but I'm not buying their merchandise.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 24/05/2023 08:37

If I did Park Run it would be Park Waddle - but I'd still boycott it.

And it is beyond disgusting that Jeska is held in Foston Hall - a women's prison.

AuContraire · 24/05/2023 08:36

cakeorwine · 24/05/2023 08:32

I'd love it if some elite women decided to go touristing and smash known false records though... alas I am very far from that league

Wouldn't that affect local people who would then never be able to beat the local record because someone from outside the area has taken it?

So what would be the point in competing if you knew you could never win?

Because it's one thing getting beaten by a very fast woman.

Entirely different getting beaten by a mediocre man pretending to be a woman.

Eleganz · 24/05/2023 08:35

Whilst I have no problem with parkrun running runs in prisons or indeed people believing what they want about themselves (as long as it doesn't harm others) the organisation clearly does need to look at how it deals with records for runs. Obviously there is the issue of m to f post-puberty transgender athletes posting records in the female category but also there is the issue of people convicted of serious crimes and currently serving sentences in prison being able to post records for parkruns that will clearly generate media attention.

The organisation needs a policy about records that includes both how transgender athletes should be treated and how prison park runs should be treated. My advice for the former is that they should follow the policies of UK Athletics. My advice for the latter is that no prison park runs should be eligible for records.

An alternative is to stop publishing and promoting records given that is not what they claim parkrun is about (i.e. not competitive).

Swipe left for the next trending thread