Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ParkRun and Transgender record breaker

532 replies

PennysLane · 23/05/2023 23:09

Trans runner (M to F) has smashed a woman’s record. Turns out he’s an attempted murderer too.

He attempted to murder the HR Manager of U.K. Athletics after he investigated his eligibility to compete as a woman. (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lauren_Jeska )

I have enjoyed Parkrun on several occasions with my children, I’ll not be doing it again until they get this sorted. If at all.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/22/parkrun-self-id-male-runners-smash-womens-records/

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/23/transgender-murder-parkrun/

Parkrun women's record held by transgender attempted murderer

Feminist activists outraged as it is revealed the fun run record is held by Lauren Jeska, who was given an 18-year sentence in 2017

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/23/transgender-murder-parkrun/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Bovrilla · 24/05/2023 10:06

I think the fact he tried to kill a UK athletics official is a huge issue. That should mean a lifetime ban.

The gender issues, agree that it would be helpful to have male, female, gendered male and female categories for lots of sports.

Iyiyiiii · 24/05/2023 10:05

EnthENd · 24/05/2023 00:15

Even if they weren't trans they should be excluded for having literally tried to murder an official in their sport! WTAF @ ParkRun organisation.

Wow - from Wiki

In March 2016 she attacked Ralph Knibbs, a former professional rugby player and UK Athletics HR manager, with a knife, at Alexander Stadium, in Birmingham. Jeska stabbed Knibbs in the head and neck, resulting in a 2 cm hole with blood pumping out. She claimed she feared UK Athletics would strip her of her records and her eligibility to compete against female athletes.[2][7] Jeska also attacked Tim Begley and Kevan Taylor, employees of UKA who came to Knibbs's aid.[7]

Ralph Knibbs - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ralph_Knibbs

Iyiyiiii · 24/05/2023 10:04

user1471517900 · 23/05/2023 23:19

It's running in a park. You'd stop you and your kids doing something healthy because someone you don't like holds a record in it?! Wow.

I'm going to say you're missing the point there love

Fizbosshoes · 24/05/2023 10:03

I think the difficulty is that parkrun (all one word, small p btw) as a free , inclusive run means it can have multiple uses.
Technically it's a timed run, not a race....but actually a lot of people are racing - even if only against their own time from last month etc. The "first finisher " and table of results and recording of individual pbs suggests that can be (if you want it to be) competitive. But the fact that lots of people do it as a social activity, can take young children or, push buggies, take dogs etc or, or to improve general fitness makes it different from actual races.
If the categories are gender rather than biological sex then as a poster on the feminism board* pointed out, this will skew the age graded results for women as there will be some men's results in there too. And if sex doesn't matter, then should age matter,... what if a fast 18 year old identified as an under 10 and won junior parkrun, would we ask all the under 10s to get a grip because it isn't really a competition?

*@PennysLane there is a very similar debate on the feminism board where you might find some different views to here.

TheOrigRights · 24/05/2023 10:02

takes into account different beliefs

Since when did my DNA determining that I am a woman become a belief?

Drfosters · 24/05/2023 10:00

Surely the only solution at this point is 4 catergories. Biological woman, gendered woman, biological man, gendered man. People can choose the category that they prefer. If men and women only wish to run against someone of their own biology then they enter than class but if they prefer a more inclusive experience then they enter as per their gender. At this point that is the only way I genuinely think everyone can be kept happy. It is all inclusive, takes into account different beliefs. If park run is supposed to be fun then I can’t see why this would be a problem

AmazonAmazine · 24/05/2023 09:59

(I’m agreeing and adding to the post I quoted)

TheOrigRights · 24/05/2023 09:58

Except she doesn’t hold the parkrun record. Not even close. Her fastest time is 17:18, which whilst very swift, is nearly two minutes slower than the women’s parkrun record. What a load of nonsense that’s easily fact checked.

parkrun records are held for each course.

AmazonAmazine · 24/05/2023 09:58

EsmaCannonball · 24/05/2023 09:48

Whenever people try to argue that both sides are as bad as each other in this debate I do think they need to be reminded that a man who sees himself as a man's conception of a woman tried to murder a sporting official who questioned the fairness of trans ideology. Other men who identify as a man's conception of a woman have committed murders and violent crimes (many of them motivated by sex or hatred of women) but this is the one clear case where the attempted murder was ideological.

They tried to murder a sports official, it’s unusual because it’s directly related to the sport. Most crimes are not attempting to kill someone because you disagree with an athletics decision, I reckon it’s very very rare. It’s quite reasonable that a sport may additionally sanction someone who has a proven risk towards officials or volunteers in the sport. I’m sure if a rugby player attacked a referee or something they’d be barred from rugby, in addition to the prison sentence.

Chersfrozenface · 24/05/2023 09:52

Astralitzia · 24/05/2023 09:46

Parkrun is a fun run and it's not a competition, nor is it designed to be. It's not even particularly accurate. It's organised by volunteers of varying skill.

I've found my local parkrun invaluable and I prefer to time myself. It doesn't matter to me where I place in what category or who is in front of me - no parkrun runner is competing for anything, there is no first prize or trophy - and to be quite honest I have no idea who the "best" runners are because I'm only paying attention to myself. I won't be boycotting mine.

If it's not a competition and not designed to be, what point is there, or was there ever, in publishing participants' times, and in age and sex categories at that, rather than just in order of arrival or alphabetically?

Anyway, since the results are meaningless, either stop publishing them or say so clearly, on the website and wherever they are published.

Astralitzia · 24/05/2023 09:50

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

If you treat a non-competitive volunteer-run fun run as a serious competition then that's on you. You need to take it as it comes, not complain that it's not organised like a different kind of event.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/05/2023 09:48

Therefore I can't be too arsed at the idea that a transgender female holds a record.

Jeska is male. This isn't about "trans men".

EsmaCannonball · 24/05/2023 09:48

Whenever people try to argue that both sides are as bad as each other in this debate I do think they need to be reminded that a man who sees himself as a man's conception of a woman tried to murder a sporting official who questioned the fairness of trans ideology. Other men who identify as a man's conception of a woman have committed murders and violent crimes (many of them motivated by sex or hatred of women) but this is the one clear case where the attempted murder was ideological.

Astralitzia · 24/05/2023 09:46

Parkrun is a fun run and it's not a competition, nor is it designed to be. It's not even particularly accurate. It's organised by volunteers of varying skill.

I've found my local parkrun invaluable and I prefer to time myself. It doesn't matter to me where I place in what category or who is in front of me - no parkrun runner is competing for anything, there is no first prize or trophy - and to be quite honest I have no idea who the "best" runners are because I'm only paying attention to myself. I won't be boycotting mine.

AmazonAmazine · 24/05/2023 09:45

AmazonAmazine · 24/05/2023 09:41

From what I understand it isn’t recently achieved, it was prior to prison and actually contributed to the attack- that they were facing losing running records.
They were facing the removal of their titles in British Athletics due to failure to provide testosterone levels through blood tests. They choose to, instead of getting blood tests, to attempt to kill someone as a premeditated attack. The person has partially lost their sight and been disabled in the attempted killing.
Let’s ask another question. Ignore the trans bit:
Should someone who tries to kill a sports official, a convicted attempted murderer, be stripped of their titles because they are a risk to the sport? If the crime was linked to attempting to go against sporting rules or circumvent them as a sole motive.
I don’t think there would be an outcry if for example a footballer stabbed a referee who gave them a red card in a final and then was stripped of sporting titles.
If this person runs to running in any capacity they are a significant potential risk to others, I do think they should be barred from ParkRun and stripped of titles because of the nature of the offence. It’s an extreme case, and a reasonable outcome to ensure safety of volunteers

Found it. She ran the record in 2012
https://www.parkrun.org.uk/aberystwyth/

home | Aberystwyth parkrun

https://www.parkrun.org.uk/aberystwyth/

Olios · 24/05/2023 09:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

AmazonAmazine · 24/05/2023 09:41

From what I understand it isn’t recently achieved, it was prior to prison and actually contributed to the attack- that they were facing losing running records.
They were facing the removal of their titles in British Athletics due to failure to provide testosterone levels through blood tests. They choose to, instead of getting blood tests, to attempt to kill someone as a premeditated attack. The person has partially lost their sight and been disabled in the attempted killing.
Let’s ask another question. Ignore the trans bit:
Should someone who tries to kill a sports official, a convicted attempted murderer, be stripped of their titles because they are a risk to the sport? If the crime was linked to attempting to go against sporting rules or circumvent them as a sole motive.
I don’t think there would be an outcry if for example a footballer stabbed a referee who gave them a red card in a final and then was stripped of sporting titles.
If this person runs to running in any capacity they are a significant potential risk to others, I do think they should be barred from ParkRun and stripped of titles because of the nature of the offence. It’s an extreme case, and a reasonable outcome to ensure safety of volunteers

firef1y · 24/05/2023 09:41

RichardBarrister · 24/05/2023 09:22

So because you don’t run very fast and just do it for the participation (which is absolutely fine), you support a situation that could prevent the fastest woman from getting the women’s record?

Oh I can run quite fast when I really want to. I've been first in age group a couple of times, on the harder trail courses granted, but still it's amazing the difference 1 day can make when you're changing age group. And yes it's nice to be able to say you were 1st in something, but I didn't get any prizes for it, because there are no prizes. And if I remember rightly the week after when I didn't get 1st in age group, I was actually quicker.

It's just not a race (except against yourself), I enter plenty of races and can categorically tell you parkrun is not a race, your time is never accurate. I press the button on my garmin as I cross the start and again on finish and my "official" time never matches my watch. I don't think that many parkrun courses are exactly 5k either, I've been to ones that have been anything from 2.97 to 3.45miles (that was an epic misplacement of the turn point). The one I do most often is usually around 3.17miles, not a huge amount more than 5k, but still more). It usually takes time to filter through the start, that adds a few seconds, then you're relying on the reaction time of the time keeper at the finish. Plus there's all the other little things that can go wrong.

I run parkrun as a way of seeing my own progress (or lack of), but I don't rely on their timings. I also run parkrun because I like to be able to pick a person in front of me and see if I can catch them up, I don't care if that person is male female or trans.

If I want to actually race then I do an official race, one that has a timing chip on my bib (or shoe), that gives me an accurate time (usually to the millisecond). Parkrun falls more in to the "fun run" category, which BTW I treat the same way that I treat official races because that's how I enjoy running.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/05/2023 09:38

Of course. As it is for any mass event. But most people know it is not ok to lie and are aware there will be consequences if they do and get found out.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 24/05/2023 09:34

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/05/2023 09:30

I know that. But as people have said if a 25 year old man self id'd in to the over 50s group of men there would be an uproar.

Why does it only matter when women have to budge over?

It matters equally. But there is no mechanism for Parkrun to verify any result - whether that’s whether someone is really a woman, or whether someone is really over 50. It’s equally unverified for all categories.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/05/2023 09:32

Also there is a bige difference between some timing inaccuracies within your own sex and age cohort and someone being included in that cohort who has significant advantages and will probably post an outlier time.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/05/2023 09:30

I know that. But as people have said if a 25 year old man self id'd in to the over 50s group of men there would be an uproar.

Why does it only matter when women have to budge over?

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 24/05/2023 09:28

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/05/2023 09:20

So for me it is not really about whether the course "record" is fair but is the data produced, that many runners use, accurate and fair?

Depends how accurate you want it. But no, I’d say it’s not accurate. It’s not chip timed. There’s no start line. Your time will depend on where you start in amongst the crowd at the start. There’s nobody checking to stop people cutting corners, or what sex they were born as, or what their real age is.

I understand the argument that people use the results data for their own means, like your dh, and that’s fine. But they need to take it in the context of what it is - not particularly accurate or verified data from a volunteer run event in the local park.

AuContraire · 24/05/2023 09:25

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/05/2023 09:20

So for me it is not really about whether the course "record" is fair but is the data produced, that many runners use, accurate and fair?

Exactly.

And if someone who is 20 emailed ParkRun HQ and said "Is it OK to self-ID my age? I'm not eligible for Junior ParkRun but I think I would be more competitive in that event and I would find it very invalidating to have to race with my peers in the adult ParkRun events", do you think ParkRun would reply "No problem! ParkRun is an inclusive event just for fun. We welcome everyone into the Junior ParkRun events."?

Because this very much seems to be a concession they are willing to sanction so long as it's only messing things up for women and girls.

justteanbiscuits · 24/05/2023 09:25

I could only read the start of the Telegraph article due to paywall. I don't understand entirely as those in prison run under pseudonyms, and this person has been in prison since 2017. It states "a local parkrun" but is that a prison one?

All very confusing

Swipe left for the next trending thread