Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you really get your five a day?

218 replies

chessica · 23/05/2023 21:13

YABU - yes
YANBU - no

I aim to eat healthily where I can but realistically I probably only have 3 portions of fruit or veg most days. Some days more and some days I only have one.
In a normal day, I’ll have an apple, a bowl of berries/some grapes and then possibly a chickpea curry. Sometimes I add spinach to this and sometimes I don’t. Obviously that’s only 3 a day really as I’m not having that many berries or chickpeas.

OP posts:
Ossoduro2 · 23/05/2023 22:27

I aim for more than 30 different plants a week and I safely get 7-10 portions a day. I don’t eat a huge amount of fruit, mainly vegetables. I don’t eat much meat and I’m always trying to lose baby weight that won’t budge so I’m motivated to fill my plate with vegetables for that reason.

mondaytosunday · 23/05/2023 22:27

Yes and usually more. I eat tomatoes for breakfast and a big salad and protein for lunch. Dinner I double or triple up any veggies. If I eat fruit it's a banana, but not every day.

CindersAgain · 23/05/2023 22:25

febrezeme · 23/05/2023 21:21

It's been well documented that the whole "5 a day" thing was a huge - and very successful - ad marketing campaign which doesn't actually have any scientific backing so eat whatever going feel comfortable

It’s only made up because people weren’t likely to attempt the true recommendation of 8-10. It’s well documented that high fruit and veg intake has a positive effect on health, so it’s not helpful to say people should eat the amount they want and that will be the most healthy thing for them.

curtainsfringe · 23/05/2023 22:25

How are peoples teeth coping with all the fruit?! 😆

Pestispeeved · 23/05/2023 22:24

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 23/05/2023 22:20

Usually yes. Normally 2 portions fruit & 4 or 5 portions veg.
When I'm pregnant do I fuck 😂I sadly live off toast

When I was pregnant with DC3 it was a case of, yeah you can drink coffee in the garden, whilst I eat TOAST. A certain amount of going with the flow , is just fine.

Badbudgeter · 23/05/2023 22:24

Most days it's not really hard. Soup for lunch, some sort of fruit snack, raspberries were reduced so had those today, bag of salad with some artichoke hearts (from a jar) cherry tomatoes and fish for dinner. An apple and some more raspberries in the evening. . Very fruit heavy today but often have lots of veg days.

I think I'm quite lucky that I get free food at work of the soup/ saladtype stuff. I had an amazing salad at work on Monday hot oak smoked salmon and prawns. It was massive, I struggled to finish it and thought of Mumsnet!

Jeezuswept · 23/05/2023 22:23

I try to aim for 10+ a day, but only a max of 3 fruits.

I find it fairly easy:

Breakfast: porridge with blueberries, almonds and walnuts

Lunch: cous cous salad (lettuce, cucumber, tomatoes, red onion, peppers, beetroot, grated aubergine, chickpeas, sauerkraut, fresh basil) with side of sweet potato wedges

Dinner: veggie chilli or curry (with carrots, broccoli, cauliflower, red kidney beans, spinach, peas) lots of herbs and spices too.

Snack: apple or mango with Greek yoghurt

That's a typical day, I also try and eat lots of fermented foods for good gut bacteria.

I don't know if it's diet related but I'm very healthy, I run marathons and rarely ever get poorly.

curtainsfringe · 23/05/2023 22:22

@CindersAgain no I didn't. I know they count in the "30 a week recommendations or whatever it is" but didn't think they did in the 5 a day?

edwinbear · 23/05/2023 22:22

I only ever manage 1-2 a day. Today I had:

Breakfast - nothing, never eat it (so zero)

Lunch - Coronation chicken sandwich & a packet of crisps. (Bit of lettuce in it, nowhere near a portion so, zero)

Dinner - grilled chicken, potato salad, spinach & Parmesan salad (so one in the spinach)

That’s a pretty typical day for me. Which obviously isn’t ideal but I’m a healthy weight, fit and active, no health issues. If I added a banana, apple, dried fruit etc as snacks, I’d pile weight on.

merryhouse · 23/05/2023 22:21

Yes, it's very easy.

Dried fruit with breakfast. Fruit juice with dinner. Piece of fruit mid-afternoon. Piece of fruit in the evening.

Salad for lunch (between 2 and 3 portions). Vegetables at dinner - either 2 or 3 separate on a plate or cooked up in some sort of dish, probably 2 or 3 mixed portions. Maybe even 4 if we have lentils and chickpeas.

I don't find it a problem at all. Of course, it's entirely possible I have less meat and less carbohydrate than some people.

CindersAgain · 23/05/2023 22:21

curtainsfringe · 23/05/2023 22:18

Those people who are only eating 3 a day, can I ask what you are acting eating? I’m struggling to imagine what you eat.

Breakfast: granola with yoghurt & pomegranate & berries (but not 1 portion of each).

Lunch: chicken curry - had onion & cauliflower in but again not 2 portions

Dinner: beans on toast

snacks: chocolate & some nuts.

Beans count, did you include them?

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 23/05/2023 22:20

Usually yes. Normally 2 portions fruit & 4 or 5 portions veg.
When I'm pregnant do I fuck 😂I sadly live off toast

phoenixrosehere · 23/05/2023 22:19

Thesunnymood · 23/05/2023 21:47

Some of us just eat like that. I grew up outside of UK, not sure if that makes a difference

Same here.

I love fruit and veg. Always have. There’s usually a big shop on Friday and needed top-ups on Tuesday. Oldest we have to ration with fruit because he’ll eat his weight if allowed and eats his veg mainly at school. Youngest likes his broccoli, peas, watermelon, strawberries, and raspberries. DH prefers veg over fruit but eats bananas.

There is still junk food (DH is a massive snacker) but fruit and veg is what probably 3/4 of our shopping bill goes to.

curtainsfringe · 23/05/2023 22:18

Those people who are only eating 3 a day, can I ask what you are acting eating? I’m struggling to imagine what you eat.

Breakfast: granola with yoghurt & pomegranate & berries (but not 1 portion of each).

Lunch: chicken curry - had onion & cauliflower in but again not 2 portions

Dinner: beans on toast

snacks: chocolate & some nuts.

Purplecatshopaholic · 23/05/2023 22:17

Nope, not even close (and I don’t particularly care)

Spinnakerser · 23/05/2023 22:16

Yep today I’ve had mushrooms spinach swede onions garlic leeks carrots plus houmous so 8 different items, not all large ones though!

Pestispeeved · 23/05/2023 22:15

Howtokeepbreathing · 23/05/2023 22:02

This whole post seems quite sneery.

I don't really understand the jibe you're making at your client at the dietician? How does 5 portions a month tie in with the 800 calories a day?

Disagree with "some people don't want to be healthy and nourish their bodies" it is far more complex than that. Nobody really WANTS to be unhealthy. I'm fortunate to be confident with cooking and meal planning and like basically all vegetables, so I can lazily chuck together a bunch of veggies with certain herbs and spices and make something we enjoy eating without really thinking about it. That's privilege.

Not everyone has had the circumstances, time, money and capacity to learn how to do this.

It does seems sneery, but the reality is that my clients (not in the normal range) needed 18 months intervention at about 7 hours a week to start to comply with what the NHS had asked them to do.

Getting someone to do enough physio so that they could wash their own hair. Getting someone to eat twice as many cals as they'd admit to the dietician, and watching their weight fall. Mental and physical health are intertwined, each clients needs are unique. The largest obstacle is denial.

I'd love to say there was a simple solution, there isn't. People are different, many are in denial. Intervention needs to be intensive and personalised.

Bayleaf25 · 23/05/2023 22:14

I’ve had about 9 today (which is a pretty standard day for me).

Howtokeepbreathing · 23/05/2023 22:12

Those people who are only eating 3 a day, can I ask what you are acting eating? I’m struggling to imagine what you eat.

Eggs on toast with half an avocado for brunch.

Homemade pizza for dinner, with onion, pepper and mushroom topping - but the quantities are definitely not 80g of each per person!

There may be a small glass of orange juice in there, which would count, but not sure if enough.

Snacks during the day would include maybe a couple of biscuits with a cup of tea, and crisps in the evening.

That would be quite usual for me on a Saturday or Sunday.

anon067 · 23/05/2023 22:06

Some days I probably don't because my portion hasn't been big enough.

I like making smoothies though which I find a good way to get several of the 5 in.

Lemonademoney · 23/05/2023 22:05

Usually but not always for myself but my children always get at least the recommended if not more as they will have fruit with their breakfast and veg with their lunch as well as veg with their evening meal and fruit for snacks etc. My children definitely eat better than I do which I’m conscious of and trying to shift my own eating accordingly

SirenSays · 23/05/2023 22:05

I eat 5+ a day most days but not in the right quantities.

DilkushaKitchen · 23/05/2023 22:03

We eat a fair amount of vegetarian recipes, so today I've had loads, I had blueberries on my breakfast, salad and leftover roast veg (tomatoes, onion, pepper, aubergine, courgette) as part of my lunch, a pear, and then kohlrabi, carrot and more pepper in a stir fry for tea. But even if we're having a meat and potatoes tea I'll usually do three veg with it (two fresh, one frozen) and have a piece of fruit and some salad or veggies with my lunch.

Howtokeepbreathing · 23/05/2023 22:02

Pestispeeved · 23/05/2023 21:56

I worked as a compliance carer for 5 years. Most of my clients struggled to do 5 portions an month. Once face to face with a dietician there would be tears and a statement "I've never eaten more than 800 cals a day". But that is mean.

Eat what ever you want, blame whoever you want. Life expectancy is going down, embrace it. Make a living will and sort your own life.

I'm not sure how to express it nicely, some people don't want to be healthy and nourish their bodies, they don't want to eat a healthy diet, they just want.

This whole post seems quite sneery.

I don't really understand the jibe you're making at your client at the dietician? How does 5 portions a month tie in with the 800 calories a day?

Disagree with "some people don't want to be healthy and nourish their bodies" it is far more complex than that. Nobody really WANTS to be unhealthy. I'm fortunate to be confident with cooking and meal planning and like basically all vegetables, so I can lazily chuck together a bunch of veggies with certain herbs and spices and make something we enjoy eating without really thinking about it. That's privilege.

Not everyone has had the circumstances, time, money and capacity to learn how to do this.

curtainsfringe · 23/05/2023 22:02

See I think 2 handfuls of raspberries is pretty huge. That's at least half a punnet if not more and would definitely upset my belly!

I agree, it's also a lot of shopping if you & partner & dc are all eating 10 portions a day!