Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you really get your five a day?

218 replies

chessica · 23/05/2023 21:13

YABU - yes
YANBU - no

I aim to eat healthily where I can but realistically I probably only have 3 portions of fruit or veg most days. Some days more and some days I only have one.
In a normal day, I’ll have an apple, a bowl of berries/some grapes and then possibly a chickpea curry. Sometimes I add spinach to this and sometimes I don’t. Obviously that’s only 3 a day really as I’m not having that many berries or chickpeas.

OP posts:
thismeansnothing · 24/05/2023 13:50

Yup. Usually have a couple of portions of fruit with breakfast. Again as a mid morning snack. A couple of portions of veg at dinner and again at tea.

YukoandHiro · 24/05/2023 13:48

Not every day but if you plan some veggie days you naturally get a lot more that day to balance it out

Createausername1970 · 24/05/2023 13:47

maddiemookins16mum · 24/05/2023 13:19

some on here eating 10-15 different fruits and veg each day must have a healthy wallet along with a healthy body. If a family or couple have a tight weekly budget, their priority will be good, solid food that goes a long way, they won’t be buying expensive punnets of soft fruit or ‘posh’ salads. There’s a certain degree of snobbery with this ‘we eat at least 10 portions each a day’ compared to someone who might only be able to afford a bunch of bananas, a packet of 6 apples and a tin of pears each week for their family.

This is very true. If I had just added more fruit and veg to my existing habits, it would have definitely cost much more.

I am trying to include far more healthy things in my diet, but it does come at a cost. Overall, I am probably not spending much more than I was before - but there is nothing left over for "treats". All the yummy snacky things are gone. And I buy more things in bulk to keep the costs down, and will travel to a much cheaper supermarket monthly to do so, which is further than I would go on a weekly basis. Although I eat berries everyday, I only buy one punnet of fresh a week, once that has gone (after about 3 days) I use frozen berries.

But yes, it is true, a "good" diet can be expensive. Previously a loaf of white bread and a pot of jam that would do me for breakfast and lunch for most of the week cost £2 max. My greek yoghurt costs me about £5 a week, plus the berries and nuts etc., that probably brings it us to £10 a week for my lunches. So my healthy lunch costs me about £8 a week more. But, I would have spent that on biscuits, crisps, snacks etc. and if I went into the office I would often pick up a meal deal from a supermarket, but that can be £3 - £5 each time. Now I take my yoghurt concoction and put it in the fridge. I

I am very aware that if we were on a very tight food budget we wouldn't be eating as we do now.

Scarlettpixie · 24/05/2023 13:22

What else are you eating? You only mention fruit and then the chick pea curry. Easy way to uo it would be to chuck in more veg when you make that sort of thing. Presumably there was tomatoes and onions in there so they also count.

i easily get five a day in but I do eat a plant based diet. Today i had fruit with breakfast, a big salad with lunch and will be doing a stir fry for tea. With more fruit as a snack that is about 8 today.

Snoken · 24/05/2023 13:22

I'm vegetarian and I hate fake meat so all my protein comes from vegetables, so yes, I would imagine I go over the 5 a day. My food varies but on an average day I have blueberry porridge with mango pieces and nuts for breakfast/lunch (I only eat two meals a day), afternoon snack is a glass of green juice and a boiled egg, evening meal is usually some kind of vegetable stew/curry/patties with bulgur or vegetable pasta. I think that would take me to 6-7 a day.

maddiemookins16mum · 24/05/2023 13:19

some on here eating 10-15 different fruits and veg each day must have a healthy wallet along with a healthy body. If a family or couple have a tight weekly budget, their priority will be good, solid food that goes a long way, they won’t be buying expensive punnets of soft fruit or ‘posh’ salads. There’s a certain degree of snobbery with this ‘we eat at least 10 portions each a day’ compared to someone who might only be able to afford a bunch of bananas, a packet of 6 apples and a tin of pears each week for their family.

Wakeywake · 24/05/2023 13:15

There might be the odd day when I don't, but generally yes, I have at least 5 portions. Today I had melon, strawberries and a salad with tomatoes, cucumbers, radish and rocket. I'll have a couple of veg types with dinner and at least a satsuma as a snack.

Robyn847 · 24/05/2023 13:13

Do Terry's Chocolate Oranges count?

If they don't, then no.

Ponoka7 · 24/05/2023 13:09

Always. If I do a chickpea curry, it has onions, peppers, mushrooms and spinach. Bolagnaise has tomatoes onions, peppers, mushrooms, courgette and occasionally aubergine. I always use salad and put veg in a omelette. Once you get in the habit it's easy to hit the target.

ItWasntMyFault · 24/05/2023 13:08

I often have 5 different types of fruit and veg but as a portion is 80g there is no way I eat 400g worth unless it's winter when I make big pots of veggie soup.

JaneJeffer · 24/05/2023 13:02

No I hardly ever have fruit. I did eat 3 strawberries yesterday though Grin

newusern1 · 24/05/2023 12:49

Egghead68 · 24/05/2023 07:27

Those people who are only eating 3 a day, can I ask what you are acting eating? I’m struggling to imagine what you eat.

Breakfast: Muesli & berries (1 portion)
Lunch: Cheese & tomato sandwich, yoghurt, apple (1 portion)
Dinner: Lasagne & broccoli (1 portion)

It’s not that strange.

Lasagna contained tomatoes. If you make it yourself you can also add onions, mushrooms, garlic, peppers maybe carrots, lentils and use chopped tomatoes instead of a blended sauce.

Createausername1970 · 24/05/2023 12:42

I never used to. We had a terrible diet and I knew it, but neither hubby or son liked veg or salads. But a couple of years ago I went on the Fast 800 diet and lost lots of weight and my constant indigestion and IBS symptoms pretty much disappeared.. Hubby was impressed and joined me on it. and lost over 3 stone.

Previously my diet consisted of toast for breakfast and lunch, then something out of a packet from the freezer, with chips or pasta or rice.

Now I don't recognise myself... I have Chia seed water for breakfast. Berries and greek yoghurt for lunch with walnuts, almonds, pumpkin seeds, flax seeds and sunflowerr seeds and a bit of cinnamon and honey. Then for dinner we usually have leafy greens with a randomly created stir fry concoction which tends to includes mushrooms, onions, peppers, baby corn, pak choy. I often marinate some meat in the morning (chicken mainly, but we do eat pork and beef too) using the marinades from the Fast 800 diet, really easy marinades and very very tasty.

I am not sure if I actually eat a "portion" of everything, but I am happy I am getting a good all-round selection of healthy things most days.

Having said that, we were in the West Country on holiday recently and we had takeaways, chips, cream teas, ice creams, cooked breakfasts etc., and thorough enjoyed every morsel. But it was good to get back to "normal" as I was getting bad indigestion by the end of the holiday.

Turfwars · 24/05/2023 12:27

SkyandSurf · 24/05/2023 05:41

I started having a green smoothie every morning - celery, cucumber, pear, lettuce, lemon, spinach and coconut water with ice.

That way I at least get some veggies out of the way before the day starts.

Then I just do the best I can from there!

In the winter I do a lot of veggie soups which helps a lot as well.

Your smoothie sounds nice - I must try it!

I don't think I always hit 5 a day, but I'm pretty sure I typically manage 30 a week plant based things or more, if I were to count the nuts and seeds, spices and herbs that I use in my meals.

Generally my dinner plate is 50% veg, 25% each of potato and meat. We usually have fish at least once a week if we can, and I've been introducing a veggie once a week as well.

My lunch is usually a tuna salad sandwich and some sort of veggie soup, or a substantial salad - I add mango and butternut squash to that along with pumpkin seeds. So I think that most days I come close to my 5 a day.

For snacking I'm more likely to get out the crackers and cheese with chutney than a bar of chocolate. Crisps though are my downfall.

Neekoh · 24/05/2023 12:15

Vegetables form the basis of both my lunch and dinner, so hitting portions target is fairly straightforward. But if it's a choice between eating loads of one thing to get an official portion or eating smaller amounts of greater variety I'd choose the latter - the wider the range the better your nutrient intake (generally).

ButteryNuts · 24/05/2023 11:59

No, not every day. But you can see from this thread most people overestimate whether they're hitting it. A portion is 80g - a handful of raw spinach or a tablespoon of blueberries don't fully count.

Blip · 24/05/2023 11:22

I usually eat 10-15 different fruit and veg a day but definitely not 10-15 "portions".

I'm think variety is supposed to be good for the biome although truthfully that doesn't motivate me, I just enjoy most foods and like variety.

Neekoh · 24/05/2023 11:19

Yes. More, in fact - I aim for at least 8 portions, 10 on a good day; most of that being veg as I don't eat much fruit for blood glucose reasons.

KnittedCardi · 24/05/2023 11:16

Egghead68 · 24/05/2023 07:27

Those people who are only eating 3 a day, can I ask what you are acting eating? I’m struggling to imagine what you eat.

Breakfast: Muesli & berries (1 portion)
Lunch: Cheese & tomato sandwich, yoghurt, apple (1 portion)
Dinner: Lasagne & broccoli (1 portion)

It’s not that strange.

So, yeah, similar:
Yoghurt with blueberries, 2x coffee
Toast with an apple
2x Ginger tea
Spag with tomato and garlic
Tiramisu

zingally · 24/05/2023 10:11

Rarely tbh. I usually make it to 4, but not often 5. I know I need to do a bit better, as my weight has crept up in the last couple of years, but it is what it is.

Cornfurnno · 24/05/2023 10:09

On holiday yes most definitely.
At home it’s a big effort and most days no.

toastofthetown · 24/05/2023 09:50

Partytastic · 23/05/2023 21:51

I’ve started skipping breakfast as I’m fasting so I’m having less so some days I only just hit 5 but usually a far amount more.

Those people who are only eating 3 a day, can I ask what you are acting eating? I’m struggling to imagine what you eat.

I also fast, I usually aim for one meal a day, sometimes two and very rarely snack. I’m a vegetarian and enjoy vegetables so base meals around them. I think I generally eat a healthy and varied diet, but the very large portions required by the NHS to ‘count’ make getting above three impossible for me. I also eat nuts and seeds as a core part of my diet, which are incredibly nutritious. I always almost effortlessly hit the thirty plants per week target. The plant count is what I’ve had from these meals, as well as some additional granola, tea and coffee and I’m at 28 from Monday to Friday, and didn’t count any of the spices either, which also count to target. I’ll easily be higher after the weekend.

This week for example I had:

  • sag dal (only one full portion from the beans), halloumi salad and masala omelette, (split dinner so two portions from pepper in the omelette, and spinach in the salad) vegetable egg fried rice (with peas, carrots, peppers, sweetcorn but not enough of any one to be full portion of any veg) *potato and egg salad with tandoori broccoli (one portion from broccoli, depends if they could from potatoes) *Indian beans and eggs (two, one from beans, one from sweet potatoes, maybe a third from tomatoes)
Do you really get your five a day?
Minikievs · 24/05/2023 09:39

I'm about the same as you OP. Some days I get loads, very occasionally I get none, but mostly it's around 3. I think the portion sizes for making it "count" are what I struggle with.
As an example, yesterday, I had blueberries and raspberries in my breakfast but it was probably not even a full handful.
Some cucumber with lunch.
A couple of raw carrots. A couple of broccoli florets and a handful of sweetcorn with dinner.
Other days I might have a salad for lunch, or a stir fry for dinner and it would be much more on those days obviously.

CornishGem1975 · 24/05/2023 08:58

Nope! Some days I might eat 7 or 8, some days I might eat 1 or 2. I don't monitor it, it's just balance. Fruit doesn't really agree with me and I don't enjoy it but I love vegetables, just not all day every day.

Enoughisenouff · 24/05/2023 08:57

Yes I normally do get 5 a day - on a good day about 8 .. what I am unsure of though is just how much of something you need to eat for it to count