Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I mad to want to have a second child on my own?

268 replies

Ostryga · 23/05/2023 19:42

For context I have a 6yr old that I’ve raised as a single parent since she was born so raising children on my own is very much the norm for me.

I am secure financially, own my home, can afford childcare/take maternity leave.

I’m also 35 so I worry it’s just my hormones telling me I’m running out of time for another baby!

OP posts:
Bogggle · 24/05/2023 08:59

Canthave2manycats · 23/05/2023 21:44

So, let's get this straight.

Adopting (where there is no father) is ok.

Using donor sperm (also no father) is not ok.

What about children with two mothers, or two fathers, then?

Didn't @TakemedowntoPotatoCity mean bingo as in on one of these threads someone will always come along soon enough and mention adoption as if it's some really easy option that everyone can do, and that there's a load of babies just lining up waiting to be adopted?

Teder · 24/05/2023 08:57

tigger2022 · 24/05/2023 08:30

@RedRosette2023 yeah if it was determined you couldn’t get pregnant unless you live as the socially accepted “perfect” family, there’d be no babies. I’m constantly baffled by the accusation I had my son selfishly… who ever gets pregnant selflessly?! A couple wanted to be parents, so they had a baby. Same as me.

There are extreme scenarios though. Nobody has to be the “perfect socially acceptable family”. Equally, choosing to use a donor when you have an older child who has a known biological father is quite a big step in the opposite direction. The friends I have do acknowledge the difficulties their donor conceived children may have. I think it’s important because they can support their children, if any issues do arise.

Knightsrest · 24/05/2023 08:54

How easy a child is your DD because I had 2 and one was a very easy baby and the other one absolutely broke me.

I have known two women who were abandoned when their children were very small babies and both those children are now adults. The way their lives have panned out is very different as have the lives of their children. The one thing that made a huge difference is one had a huge amount of family support, that one is my niece

You can have plenty of money and that can buy in cleaners and childcare but as well as practical help she has always had emotional support from her Mum, her Dad, myself and her two brothers.

The other one didn’t have support, she always criticised her Mum and sister for various reasons. She came across as very bitter overall.

Do you have a good pension/insurances? This isn’t about pension in retirement. I became disabled aged 48, I had great health before this. I was retired early through ill health after a year on very good sick pay, my youngest child was only 12 at the time.

I would also ask how secure your job is and have you done the maths regarding childcare and maternity leave costs.

Conkersinautumn · 24/05/2023 08:34

Ultimately I think anyone thinking about kids has to be ready and have thought through going it alone as so many partners turn out to be uninterested and unreliable. You're prepared, you're capable I am fairly sure you've got this.

tigger2022 · 24/05/2023 08:30

@RedRosette2023 yeah if it was determined you couldn’t get pregnant unless you live as the socially accepted “perfect” family, there’d be no babies. I’m constantly baffled by the accusation I had my son selfishly… who ever gets pregnant selflessly?! A couple wanted to be parents, so they had a baby. Same as me.

RedRosette2023 · 24/05/2023 08:27

Ideals in life are so uncertain. Better to plan for reality than hold out for perfection IMO.

By contrast to those here and of course it’s purely anecdotal, one of my best friends never knew her father and is at peace with that. She’s very matter of fact and objective as a person and accepts her Mum got pregnant by a fling. Not exactly the same but it’s really not held her back.

Honestly there are so many women who start it out alone or end up alone who do a fantastic job, I don’t see what’s so unusual about this. I get that in an ideal world OP would have a loving father on board who would be earning £100k and allowing her to SAHM, but gotta work with what you got.

catchthedog · 24/05/2023 07:50

@LuckyAmy1986 have you read the studies you tell op to read ? they don't actually match up with what you're saying.

SparklyBlackKitten · 24/05/2023 07:39

DD is asking for a sibling but by the time the sibling comes along she will be a least 7. They wont grow up as sibling. Thell both grow up as onlys.

And also you saying it less harmful or hurtful to have an unknown dad than a dad that isnt involved in their lives... you can't know that. Not knowing where half your dna comes from is really hard ! understatement

What happens if a special needs baby make it appearance in your life as you are a bit older to have a child. Then what? Would you still cope. Would you want to do that to yourself or dd?
Etc etc

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 07:39

Would people be saying go for it if this was a single dad who wanted another baby on his own?

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 07:36

IAmTheWalrus85 · 24/05/2023 07:34

But isn’t OP’s point that her daughter has a father and he doesn’t bring anything to their lives - in fact he’s caused a lot of trauma and heartache - so why not skip the trauma and heartache?

I don’t want to put words in OP’s mouth but I doubt she’d dispute that a loving, committed father is a great thing to have if you can get it. But she doesn’t have the luxury of time to find a loving, committed one. And a shit, absent one is actively harmful to a child, plus she needs to consider the issues associated with bringing a new man into her daughter’s life at this point.

Better no man than a crap one.

@IAmTheWalrus85 you know she doesn't HAVE to have a baby right? Better no man than a crap one is not a reason to do this, unless you are looking at it from a purely selfish point of view!

Wombastic · 24/05/2023 07:36

Go for it op

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 07:35

@Ostryga Yes but you are only comparing it with 'worse' scenarios! Like I said just because something could be worse, doesn't mean you should do the thing that actually might be really harmful.

I didn't say you were selfish, I said IT is selfish. I'm just giving my opinion. (I am surprised you took it so well tbh! It's good you are open to seeing both sides.)

IAmTheWalrus85 · 24/05/2023 07:35

Sorry that was a reply to a post upthread 🤦🏼‍♀️

IAmTheWalrus85 · 24/05/2023 07:34

But isn’t OP’s point that her daughter has a father and he doesn’t bring anything to their lives - in fact he’s caused a lot of trauma and heartache - so why not skip the trauma and heartache?

I don’t want to put words in OP’s mouth but I doubt she’d dispute that a loving, committed father is a great thing to have if you can get it. But she doesn’t have the luxury of time to find a loving, committed one. And a shit, absent one is actively harmful to a child, plus she needs to consider the issues associated with bringing a new man into her daughter’s life at this point.

Better no man than a crap one.

Ostryga · 24/05/2023 07:29

@LuckyAmy1986 totally get what you’re saying. But the most recent study I can find shows much worse outcomes for children of divorce rather than single mother by choice. Parental conflict is much worse than not having a father apparently.

I don’t think I’m being selfish - I’m not currently pregnant! Just asking for opinions.

@jeaux90 yes this is a massive factor for me. 1 child is expensive but we’re comfortable, I don’t want to detract from DD’s life to have another baby.

OP posts:
ChildcarePanic · 24/05/2023 07:28

I looked into this and after joining a few Facebook sites that had donor conceived people commenting about the effect it has had on them, and the rejections they had from their donors, I wouldn't. I've accepted I may never have another child, which is so hard but I'm too morally torn to use a donor.

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 07:22

jeaux90 · 24/05/2023 06:43

Lone parent to DD14 since she was 1. She's had no contact with her father since then and is absolutely fine. (For the other readers on this thread)

OP I can imagine this is a really tough decision. DD really wanted a sibling for a few years but it was a phase. Now she is a teen she'd be completely fed up with having a younger kid around although she adores her cousins.

The other factor in my personal experience is cost. My DD was diagnosed with ADHD and ASD when she was 10, girls often have a later diagnosis. I put her in an all girls private school for secondary, as this was the best decision for her and she is now thriving after struggling the last couple of years in primary with the massive class

The point is there is no way I could give my DD the opportunity and lifestyle we have if I had two. We take nice holidays and she goes to a lovely school. I am financially independent, I have a great career luckily but I definitely couldn't offer two kids the same opportunity my DD currently has. Like you we have a great life, eat out, go away etc

Just sharing my experience. Whatever decision you make you Will continue to be an amazing mum I'm sure.

@jeaux90 You wouldn't have chosen that for your DD though I am guessing, ideally? That's the point. This would be an active choice from the outset.

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 07:20

I think you would be mad and I think it's really selfish.

I would also be saying the same to a single dad on here debating whether to have another on his own via surrogate/donor eggs. It's just so selfish. Concentrate on the child you have.

I don't know where people are getting it from that it won't cause the child any issues. How do you know? Do some research!

Of course people will just do what they want because 'go for it!' 'if it's what YOU want'! etc

Just because something would be less harmful than this, doesn't mean you should actively go out of your way to do it. It's still harmful.

There are also plenty of children with dads who are very happy, and plenty without who are not happy (just to balance the ridiculous argument upthread)

jeaux90 · 24/05/2023 06:43

Lone parent to DD14 since she was 1. She's had no contact with her father since then and is absolutely fine. (For the other readers on this thread)

OP I can imagine this is a really tough decision. DD really wanted a sibling for a few years but it was a phase. Now she is a teen she'd be completely fed up with having a younger kid around although she adores her cousins.

The other factor in my personal experience is cost. My DD was diagnosed with ADHD and ASD when she was 10, girls often have a later diagnosis. I put her in an all girls private school for secondary, as this was the best decision for her and she is now thriving after struggling the last couple of years in primary with the massive class

The point is there is no way I could give my DD the opportunity and lifestyle we have if I had two. We take nice holidays and she goes to a lovely school. I am financially independent, I have a great career luckily but I definitely couldn't offer two kids the same opportunity my DD currently has. Like you we have a great life, eat out, go away etc

Just sharing my experience. Whatever decision you make you Will continue to be an amazing mum I'm sure.

CardiffMam · 24/05/2023 06:07

Go for it! There are 7 years between my eldest and youngest and they are best friends. Both your children will have stability and love from you and love and friendship from a sibling.

tigger2022 · 24/05/2023 05:58

Opine · 23/05/2023 23:12

My father was absent throughout my childhood as were lots of my friends. It was very much the norm to be raised by a single mother. Most of us went out of our way to ensure we had two parent households for our own children and ALL of us agree that fathers are very very relevant despite what we were told or forced ourselves to feel.

There is quite a distance between shit dad/penis in the house to loving father.
Being without a father is of course survivable but my mother didn’t actively choose that for me and I’d think she was a self righteous dick of she had.
later on, from teen hood, he was around and massively enriched my life.

Having a dad but not seeing him and resenting that or using an absent father as an explanation for all unhappiness is not the same as (and is definitely not better than!!) growing up in a happy household where there really is no ‘dad’ out there just a biological donor and having your needs met by one person. It’s not any more selfish for single people or lesbians to have children. There are plenty of miserable kids with dads and plenty of happy kids without them.

TheTaylorNation · 23/05/2023 23:15

A surrogate is not a mum ! Often nit even related to that child biologically

My point is, a guy having a child by a surrogate is depriving that child of their mother. You can't bring a child into the world without one.

Opine · 23/05/2023 23:12

My father was absent throughout my childhood as were lots of my friends. It was very much the norm to be raised by a single mother. Most of us went out of our way to ensure we had two parent households for our own children and ALL of us agree that fathers are very very relevant despite what we were told or forced ourselves to feel.

There is quite a distance between shit dad/penis in the house to loving father.
Being without a father is of course survivable but my mother didn’t actively choose that for me and I’d think she was a self righteous dick of she had.
later on, from teen hood, he was around and massively enriched my life.

SunnyFrost · 23/05/2023 23:03

It sounds like your daughter has been through a lot. You sound like a great mum to her and like you two have a very strong bond. I can’t help thinking that given the rejection she is suffering from her dad, it might not be the best thing for her for you to have a baby that will inevitably take a lot of your focus away from her. She may perceive it as another rejection, of you needing more than just her. I know that’s not logical but often small children aren’t.

Being honest, I think you should focus on her. There’s no way that having a baby with such a large gap and only one parent to go around won’t detract from her life and limit what you can do with her, at least to some extent. She may of course gain lots of other things from having a sibling but also they may not be close at all due to the large age gap and she would just be losing out on a chunk of her mum’s time and attention after already being abandoned by her dad.

I would leave it, for her sake.

RooftopParty · 23/05/2023 23:01

I think it’s unethical. My friend was conceived by donor and it’s caused a lot of issues for him, questioning who he is, family stuff and impacted his relationships. He’s in touch with other donor conceived people and many have similar experiences.

I think that some people being useless/absent parents, isn’t a reason to deliberate create children with the intention of not being brought up by their biological parent from day one.