Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I mad to want to have a second child on my own?

268 replies

Ostryga · 23/05/2023 19:42

For context I have a 6yr old that I’ve raised as a single parent since she was born so raising children on my own is very much the norm for me.

I am secure financially, own my home, can afford childcare/take maternity leave.

I’m also 35 so I worry it’s just my hormones telling me I’m running out of time for another baby!

OP posts:
tigger2022 · 24/05/2023 12:13

The fertility clinic I used had loads of things free of charge to help make a decision- open days, consultations, etc. That could help you get a few more facts about it all too.

LysHastighed · 24/05/2023 12:10

Namechange and post as a single parent pregnant by someone not in the picture. You’re getting too much advice from the crazy people brought out of the woodwork by the word donor.
It’s a really tough choice to balance this huge potential benefit to your family with the potential costs. It sounds like your gut instinct is to go ahead, so I’d do some budgeting and then do that. There is no ‘right’ answer so you will never find it.

Northernlurker · 24/05/2023 12:05

Pregnancy is inherently risk laden.what's your plan for your child if you end up dead or disabled? It's unlikely but a pregnancy would increase your chances of this happening.
Or the child has a life long disability? You could be removing financial security and your well-being from the equation.
Personally I wouldn't rock your boat.

tigger2022 · 24/05/2023 12:01

Also I have to say OP as a SMBC - the joy more than makes up for all the judgey people. And even some of the judgey people even change their minds when they see the joy!

Often I think people who pass very judgemental views must be in very horrible circumstances themselves, and resent anyone who has the audacity not to put up with that.

tigger2022 · 24/05/2023 11:56

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 10:58

It's not traumatic at all, for anyone?

I can't deal with you guys honestly.

No issues, no trauma, just happy happy happy.

honestly...

I’m sorry that you don’t want to hear kids can be happy without Mother, Father, 2.4 siblings, a golden retriever and a little picket fence… but in fact some of us can be even happier! In real life, kids come into the world in all sorts of circumstances. There is no one way that guarantees happiness or misery. DCC will always have the benefit of knowing how wanted they are.

sticklaydeelove · 24/05/2023 11:31

Go for it. You know what hard work it is, it's not your first time at the rodeo.

You're financially secure and if it's what you want then do it. I'd start pronto as you are 35, fertility starts to decline quickly for some people although not all.

Good luck.

Darkstar4855 · 24/05/2023 11:28

Just wanted to say that sperm/egg donors are not necessarily contactable when the child turns 18. I donated eggs and the HFEA would make available only my name and last known address i.e. the address I was living at when I donated. There is no legal requirement for me to keep my contact details up to date, nor is there any requirement for me to respond to attempts to contact me.

I’m not saying I wouldn’t, by the way. Just that it’s not a given.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/05/2023 11:27

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 11:20

There is a difference between shit happening in life and PURPOSELY choosing it.

But she choose to procreate with him, if we follow febrezes logic that this is due to OPs poor choices. And not having a parent of both sexes is worse than most other things. So why should her child not be placed within a nuclear family unit?

The children are in innocent. If its abhorrent to consider a baby growing up without knowing their father, surely it's abhorrent to consider DD to do the same, so the state should intervene or op should be pushed to meet a new man and move him in immediately.

OR there are shades of grey and nuance and not every experience will be as catastrophic emotionally as yours was

Ostryga · 24/05/2023 11:27

And even if I did meet a man I a) wouldn’t move him in with Dd and I and any potential new baby. and b)would never get married as I want to protect my home, pension and savings for mine and my children’s future.

OP posts:
TheMooney · 24/05/2023 11:24

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 11:18

I'm not posting anymore after this but I think it's quite gross for you to say that. 'Things that actually aren't traumatic' who are you to decide that? I'm gobsmacked.

I'm not deciding. People did the research on this question provided actual evidence on this that OP can use to inform her choices.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/05/2023 11:23

febrezeme · 24/05/2023 11:13

*No she doesn’t. I don’t understand what a man can bring to our lives that I would be missing?

A dick? We don’t need those day to day. Honestly not sure what we’re missing out on here.*

But that was presumably your poor choice in choice of father for your child - presumably not a stable relationship not married and so on. Your choice has/will have had lasting repercussions. But it happens that relationships break down. But you want to do it again a deliberately raise a child without a father - whose to say the next child won't be a boy and have totally different needs to your daughter

What a fucking victim blaming post.

OP picked a man who nay have presented zero red flags. Some men are great until the kid comes along and then shit when their "ooh I really want a baby with you" baby finally arrives. Some cheat and run off. Some just hate being beholden to a kid. Some have poor MH and disappear. They didn't all walk around with a sign saying I'm a dick head, let me impregnate you. And you never know how stable a relationship is, even with marriage. You think husbands don't just walk away and abandon their kids?? We're married, three kids, stable but I'm not psychic. He could be hiding torrid affair. He could have a breakdown next week. He could just decide life is bloody hard and there's an easier way. I'd stake my chips on that never happening, but not my kids life because you can never ever know someone inside out for now and into the future.

HIS choices have long rescuing effects on his child. That isn't ops fault but it's her who will have to fix it

jeaux90 · 24/05/2023 11:22

@febrezeme JFC OPs poor choice? Do you also blame women who are customs of DV for their poor choice.

How about congratulations to all us lone parents out here that do a great job on our own despite the ex arseholes we had the misfortune to be gaslighted or abused by.

OP I posted earlier on thread about my situation, very similar to yours but just a few years ahead and I can't believe the idiotic replies on here.

You sound like a clear minded, conscientious parent. I am sure you will consider all options and associated risks carefully before deciding.

TheMooney · 24/05/2023 11:21

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 11:10

Yes I am actually finding it quite distressing tbh so I am going to leave the thread. It's just very frustrating with everyone just saying go for it, I find it shocking. Maybe that's why I am coming across so intense.

I think that you are coming down very hard OP's (possible) life choices but are really not providing any congruent reason for these views.

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 11:20

SleepingStandingUp · 24/05/2023 11:18

So if DH runs off with the milkman tomorrow or god forbid something worse.... would you have my kids removed from me to be adopted by a heterosexual couple? I mean I have three lads, two still pre schoolers. How could it be fair to raise them without a father figure? Or do I get a 12 month gap to get myself in Tinder and find some bloke to shack up with so I can say I satisfied the father reqs?

Should OP herself be looking at giving up her child or moving in any bloke that'll come just so she can give her child what you deem to be a good life vs the inferior one you think she has?

There is a difference between shit happening in life and PURPOSELY choosing it.

Ostryga · 24/05/2023 11:19

febrezeme · 24/05/2023 11:13

*No she doesn’t. I don’t understand what a man can bring to our lives that I would be missing?

A dick? We don’t need those day to day. Honestly not sure what we’re missing out on here.*

But that was presumably your poor choice in choice of father for your child - presumably not a stable relationship not married and so on. Your choice has/will have had lasting repercussions. But it happens that relationships break down. But you want to do it again a deliberately raise a child without a father - whose to say the next child won't be a boy and have totally different needs to your daughter

Any child is going to have completely different needs to my daughter? They’re different people!

And I’m not being blamed for my daughter’s father being shit so you can stop that immediately. I didn’t make him be a vile father.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 24/05/2023 11:18

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 10:25

I also disagree with that. it's also not fair on the child

So if DH runs off with the milkman tomorrow or god forbid something worse.... would you have my kids removed from me to be adopted by a heterosexual couple? I mean I have three lads, two still pre schoolers. How could it be fair to raise them without a father figure? Or do I get a 12 month gap to get myself in Tinder and find some bloke to shack up with so I can say I satisfied the father reqs?

Should OP herself be looking at giving up her child or moving in any bloke that'll come just so she can give her child what you deem to be a good life vs the inferior one you think she has?

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 11:18

TheMooney · 24/05/2023 11:15

No, actually. There's enough pain and trauma in the world, no need to go around seeing trauma in things that aren't actually traumatic.

I'm not posting anymore after this but I think it's quite gross for you to say that. 'Things that actually aren't traumatic' who are you to decide that? I'm gobsmacked.

TheMooney · 24/05/2023 11:15

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 10:58

It's not traumatic at all, for anyone?

I can't deal with you guys honestly.

No issues, no trauma, just happy happy happy.

honestly...

No, actually. There's enough pain and trauma in the world, no need to go around seeing trauma in things that aren't actually traumatic.

febrezeme · 24/05/2023 11:13

*No she doesn’t. I don’t understand what a man can bring to our lives that I would be missing?

A dick? We don’t need those day to day. Honestly not sure what we’re missing out on here.*

But that was presumably your poor choice in choice of father for your child - presumably not a stable relationship not married and so on. Your choice has/will have had lasting repercussions. But it happens that relationships break down. But you want to do it again a deliberately raise a child without a father - whose to say the next child won't be a boy and have totally different needs to your daughter

Ostryga · 24/05/2023 11:12

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 10:58

It's not traumatic at all, for anyone?

I can't deal with you guys honestly.

No issues, no trauma, just happy happy happy.

honestly...

What is your massive issue? I’ve replied honestly to you and now you are hounding.

I know I can provide a happy, warm, safe and thriving environment to any child. And the outcomes of me having a decent career, intelligence both academically and emotionally will far outweigh any negatives that being conceived by donor spent will apparently cause.

The reason I’m not rushing ahead is because I have a child already here to think about.

And don’t be so rude to someone who has experienced something absolutely terrible in life just to prove your point. It doesn’t make you come across well.

OP posts:
LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 11:10

Myonecent · 24/05/2023 11:04

Why is this affecting you so much? You’re being really over the top and intense. Yes Op asked a question on an open forum, you’ve answered, others have answered but you seem so determined to passionately argue against the thought of a donor?

I’m sorry if I’ve missed but do you have lived experience that’s making you feel this way?

Yes I am actually finding it quite distressing tbh so I am going to leave the thread. It's just very frustrating with everyone just saying go for it, I find it shocking. Maybe that's why I am coming across so intense.

Trixiedrum · 24/05/2023 11:07

I don’t take issue with the donor thing, or raising a kid without a dad.

Logistics are what I’d worry about. If baby cries all night there is no second adult to take them so you can have an extra hour of sleep. No second adult to stay home with either child if they’re poorly on a working day. If baby gets bronchiolitis or croup, big sister will have to come to the hospital too, even at 3am. You’ll have to give up the meals out, or work them around naptime, nappy changes etc. Big sister’s Lego and anything precious can’t be in the living room anymore, and you’ll struggle to play with her like you did before.

If you have a supportive and flexible family or friend network around you that would mitigate some of the logistical issues.

If it were me I hope I wouldn’t go ahead, because it would probably be very hard, and I don’t think I would cope well. But you know yourself best, and maybe it’s the right thing for you. I hope it work out, whatever you do. You sound like a happy little family.

TheMooney · 24/05/2023 11:07

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 10:53

Please do answer that. I would love to see if you would feel the same in this scenario. Do children need mothers?

I think that children need loving, attentive, consistent adults. However, bringing up that scenario immediately brings into surrogacy the equation, which is always a huge thread derail, and really not relevant to the original question.

Myonecent · 24/05/2023 11:04

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 10:58

It's not traumatic at all, for anyone?

I can't deal with you guys honestly.

No issues, no trauma, just happy happy happy.

honestly...

Why is this affecting you so much? You’re being really over the top and intense. Yes Op asked a question on an open forum, you’ve answered, others have answered but you seem so determined to passionately argue against the thought of a donor?

I’m sorry if I’ve missed but do you have lived experience that’s making you feel this way?

LuckyAmy1986 · 24/05/2023 10:58

tigger2022 · 24/05/2023 10:54

7 years is not a massive age gap, having much younger siblings is also nice. Being donor conceived is not traumatic, only the feeling of being lied to - that’s why the donor conception network advise talking to DCC about it from a young age, so they grow up never remembering a time they didn’t know where they came from.

10 years ago I was in an abusive relationship, where I was controlled, bullied, and physically and sexually assaulted. Now he has a wife and 2 children, and I have my son by DC. The idea that his wife selflessly brought 2 kids into the world to be bullied and abused by a monster, but me bringing my happy little boy into an environment where has never been shouted at or insulted or hurt is the worst, most selfish thing ever… something doesn’t add up to me.

It's not traumatic at all, for anyone?

I can't deal with you guys honestly.

No issues, no trauma, just happy happy happy.

honestly...