Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I mad to want to have a second child on my own?

268 replies

Ostryga · 23/05/2023 19:42

For context I have a 6yr old that I’ve raised as a single parent since she was born so raising children on my own is very much the norm for me.

I am secure financially, own my home, can afford childcare/take maternity leave.

I’m also 35 so I worry it’s just my hormones telling me I’m running out of time for another baby!

OP posts:
Leo227 · 25/05/2023 11:34

@CleverLilViper reading the links you've just posted, but it literally just points towards having positive male role models. I don't read anything in there that wouldn't be achievable from a strong relationship with OPs brother for example

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 11:25

How's about this? No doubt it'll be rejected by the brigade that think fathers and mothers play exactly the same role in the household and as such, their roles can be adopted by either (they can't)

And also this: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/1068316X.2020.1774589

https://www.pediatricsoffranklin.com/resources-and-education/pediatric-care/the-importance-of-a-father-in-a-childs-life/

We have a very dismissive outlook of the role of fathers in society. We don't value men in the household and instead, reinforce the belief that men are useless and scratch our heads when they act as such.

So many women on this thread seem to really not understand that being forced to raise a child without a father due to bereavement or the father not being optimal (to put it mildly) and having to do your best to work around those circumstances is not remotely the same as purposely choosing the less than stellar circumstance and pretending it's perfect.

Why would anyone knowingly choose that for a child knowing that it could have a lasting and damaging impact on the child further down the line and then have the nerve to claim their decision is anything but selfish?

There's a bloody good reason why, when you see teenagers (typically boys) acting in criminal and anti-social fashion there's a trend to guess that they're fatherless. Because most of the time, they are.

The Importance of a Father in a Child’s Life - Pediatric Associates of Franklin

Fathers play a role in every child’s life that cannot be filled by others. This role can have a large impact on a child and help shape him or her into the person they become.

https://www.pediatricsoffranklin.com/resources-and-education/pediatric-care/the-importance-of-a-father-in-a-childs-life

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 11:20

I always - theoretically - felt this is what I would do had DH and split up between DC1 and DC2 (which we didnt' so remained theoretical). I think it's probably quite tough witout a support network though, one kid is one thing, but two is a different ball game and it can be tricky to manage with only one parent.

catchthedog · 25/05/2023 11:13

@Opine and if I'm missing something, which i totally might be, please do share anything you can pinpoint that your father has brought to your life specifically and only because he is your father/male.

tigger2022 · 25/05/2023 11:13

Of course she can healthily raise a son. He wouldn’t be learning all of the same patterns of behaviour. Many women experience men that through their own free will choose to be horrible or abusive or just generally useless - it’s their choice to behave that way - but the idea that it’s the women who survive that, and through surviving it learn that we really don’t need men to survive or raise children - that we’re the problem o_O. Nope, the fact sons can be raised into good men much easier without the current batch of men’s influence says a lot about them, not us.

catchthedog · 25/05/2023 11:11

@Opine I think you're misunderstanding the male / only a penis thing. It's that "men " literally are only that - aside from the penis they are just regular humans with qualities/interests/skills that are as accessible to women as they are men. therefore having a specific MALE father presence in a child's life is not the important factor. it's being surrounded by family members / friends who are going to being the rest of those qualities.

Opine · 25/05/2023 10:54

The imaginary man is the one whom is best not included in your Childs life because he MAY and toxic. He is problematic just by default. I’m not getting into abuse tit for tat. Don’t assume anything about me because I don’t despise men.

OP has said several times that men are essentially defunct. No male child can benefit from hearing that. We’re talking about OP not you in any case. She doesn’t like men so she couldn’t healthily raise one. Do you dispute that?

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 10:54

tigger2022 · 24/05/2023 13:45

A sperm donor exists

Do you even hear yourself?

tigger2022 · 25/05/2023 10:21

Opine · 25/05/2023 10:03

@tigger2022 what abusive man? No such person exists and that’s another conversation. I’ve seen the absolute worst of men as a child. I could tell you some toe curling stories about real men not fantasy ones that you pluck out of your mind for the sake of an argument.

Id NEVER dream on commenting on your family set up unless of course you ASKED a forum.

As I posted before - I’m a survivor of CSA and SA. I was in an abusive relationship for 4 years of my life. I was then SA by another man shortly after. My father and brother are abusive. How dare you call my trauma imaginary, while you so casually diagnose random children with it? For many people a male presence, a male influence, is not always a good one. In many cases it is a net negative. You also believe single mothers should opt for sex selection because you think mothers shouldn’t raise sons alone??? All this is so regressive. My son is not being taught how to hit, control, belittle, r__e, mock, or be served by women. He is being raised to look up to women, to admire us, to love us, to respect us.

Alsobeyondshit · 25/05/2023 10:19

RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 09:52

@Opine Why is the Country where the sperm is sought relevant?

Sex selection is illegal in the UK for good reason

Opine · 25/05/2023 10:03

*on a forum

Opine · 25/05/2023 10:03

@tigger2022 what abusive man? No such person exists and that’s another conversation. I’ve seen the absolute worst of men as a child. I could tell you some toe curling stories about real men not fantasy ones that you pluck out of your mind for the sake of an argument.

Id NEVER dream on commenting on your family set up unless of course you ASKED a forum.

Opine · 25/05/2023 09:59

@RedRosette2023 gender selection of embryos is permitted in some places.

tigger2022 · 25/05/2023 09:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What would be much better is if she stayed with a horrible man for his “male presence”, his special man essence that just by proximity (or just by the mother knowing his name and address at the moment of conception) stops babies from becoming juvenile delinquents, teach her daughters that a person can never ever survive without a man, and go around diagnosing random categories children she hasn’t met (some of whom haven’t even been conceived yet) with irreparable complex trauma. That’s better, right?

FYI if my DCC ever does feel bad about his upbringing it won’t be because of the loving supportive home he grows up in, it will be because of judgemental people who can’t keep their noses and opinions to themselves.

RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 09:52

@Opine Why is the Country where the sperm is sought relevant?

Opine · 25/05/2023 09:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RedRosette2023 · 25/05/2023 08:48

OP doesn’t say about her relationship with her own family.

Her brothers, cousins, close friends, Dad. She might have a whole host of incredible male role models for a potential son.

FWIW I’m happily married and think my DH is a good Dad, but we have pretty set roles and he’s mostly a provider. We’ve set our lives up accordingly. That in itself is a role model. But if he dropped dead my DS’ have a great relationship with their Uncles, Grandfather and I know my brother especially would take them both under his wing. Yes it would be a loss to them, but not insurmountable IMO.

Alsobeyondshit · 25/05/2023 08:35

A quick Google of 'importance of a father figure' might give you some interesting reading op.

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 08:34

Ostryga · 23/05/2023 22:06

How is it not? I’m not bringing a child into the world to beat it, I already have a home that includes a child and even if I say so myself we are very good at what we do.

Why would it be so horrific that I bring a baby into out happy home?

Why do you want a second child?

There are studies out there that show that children need good fathers. Of course, they don’t need shit dads but decent fathers they do need. Depriving them of this by choice is selfish.

You can do what you want and I suspect that you will because you don’t seem all that open to considering the ways this could result in trauma for the potential child and seems to be more about what YOU want.

tigger2022 · 25/05/2023 07:01

Also the whole “reverse sexism” BS, goodness me 🙄

tigger2022 · 25/05/2023 07:01

Honestly so much nonsense on this thread. Of course a “male role model” isn’t a universal good. Often it’s bad. My creepy incel brother learned to hate women from our dad. My abusive ex who bullied me, assaulted me, controlled me, treated me like staff, is now bullying his daughter and teaching his own son how to treat women. I was assaulted by another man a few years later who now has sons who he will be imparting all his wisdom on. All of those people by the way had their own “male role models” growing up, supposedly stable heterosexual mummies and daddies living together, so your methods are pretty consistently flawed tbh. Boys learn that they are superior and mummy is staff from their dads.

My ds (who is not “deprived” of a father 🙄) is in a happy, loving home. Everyone comments on how happy he always is. Any men he encounters have to be polite to him, because I tell them to. He’s not getting any homophobic or sexist messages. He can play with whatever toys he wants without being mocked. (His amazing “male role model” grandfather did say he looked like a p* when he saw a photo of him in a salmon shirt 🙄). Nobody has ever shouted at him, nobody has ever hurt him, nobody has ever belittled him. The idea any old male influence will do when male influences are often bad (the fact that you have learned a person can’t exist without a man supporting them - what does that tell you?)

The idea that “yes your daddy is called Steve and he’s a plumber but he’s not here because he’s lazy and he just doesn’t like you” would be a nicer story to tell my son than “I like my independence and I didn’t want to have a husband, but I desperately wanted to be your mummy, so a nice man and some doctors helped me have a baby” - I mean, really, which one is leaving you with trauma there

Women can do it all, most women are doing it all without even realising. OP is a brilliant mother to her dd and would be an amazing mother to baby number 2.

Coyoacan · 25/05/2023 03:38

Why? Most men are shite

Are you also going to choose the sex of your child? Or are you going to tell a little boy what a low opinion you have of men?

HamBone · 24/05/2023 23:33

You‘re thinking this over carefully, OP, and if it’s what you want, I’m sure you’ll make a success of it.

I do suspect that you’re under-estimating how stretched time-wise you’ll be when they both have activities, but you’ll manage because you want to.

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/05/2023 23:32

Ostryga · 24/05/2023 23:19

It’s you’re.

And also I think I don’t care anymore! Maybe I’ll have women that will endlessly tell me I’m ruining my children’s lives because having a man to be a part of it is so important to them. You cannot deprive your child of their dad!

When actually it’s not deprivation it’s just a different way of having a family, no idea why everyone’s so dang scared of it.

If you can’t raise a family on your own just say that. It’s not down to men.

There are no different ways of having a family. To have a child requires one man and one woman. The resulting child belongs 50% to each parent. Any situation where they don't have a relationship with their parents has got to be sub optimal. Of course things go wrong, people die, some parents are bad and people manage. That doesn't make it a desirable choice though.

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/05/2023 23:29

Ostryga · 24/05/2023 22:41

Why? Most men are shite. And I know that will offend people married to men who insist they are incredible, except they don’t do a single thing for their family except work. How many husbands or fathers of children organise birthday parties, cards, family presents, the cooking, school calendars, play dates, sleepovers, pick their kids up from nursery or school?

I’m going to hazard a guess none of you getting SO upset with me having a baby without a father is because you only have a man that supports YOU, not your children and their lives.

I think you need some counselling to work through your issues before you even consider another child.

In my opinion having a child and purposely depriving them of a father is far worse and far more selfish than a parent who is deficient in organising birthday parties. You seem to have very weird priorities. Anyway lots of fathers do cook, clean, organise things, take a 50 50 role.

Swipe left for the next trending thread