Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I mad to want to have a second child on my own?

268 replies

Ostryga · 23/05/2023 19:42

For context I have a 6yr old that I’ve raised as a single parent since she was born so raising children on my own is very much the norm for me.

I am secure financially, own my home, can afford childcare/take maternity leave.

I’m also 35 so I worry it’s just my hormones telling me I’m running out of time for another baby!

OP posts:
CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 12:46

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 12:44

@CleverLilViper the question has been asked a couple of times now but not answered by anyone.. could you list anything that is a father specific input ? that only he could provide ?

I have already presented a link to that.

You're determined to dismiss it with "Oh but the uncle can provide that!" Or some other nameless man in the OP's life-who, by the way, the OP labels most men as shite-so how many male role models do you think the child will have?

If you can't be arsed to read the link and understand that those things cannot simply be provided by some other nameless man who is there every now and then, I'm not doing it for you.

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 12:44

@CleverLilViper the question has been asked a couple of times now but not answered by anyone.. could you list anything that is a father specific input ? that only he could provide ?

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 12:42

fuckmyuteruslining · 25/05/2023 12:35

There is a difference with what we make the best of cos there's no realistic choice otherwise and what we choose to do. The op doesn't need to do this. She wants to because her hormones are driving her. Most women experience the desire for more than one child. But the head doesn't always agree and this is a case in point. The op is going to hugely disrupt her life and that of her child's and if it's harder than she thinks she has no back up in the parenting. So sure, crack on but it's a bigger risk than most women are taking.

I agree with this completely.

Correct me if I'm wrong-but I've not heard (or indeed, read) the OP give one single reason that will benefit either her DD or this potential child in doing this. This seems to be entirely about what SHE wants with no thought to how this is going to impact either her DD or her potential child.

Sure, it may all go smoothly. Her DD could be the most excited big sister ever and they all live happily ever after, but what if it doesn't? What if that great support system falls through and having two children alone becomes a lot harder than first thought?

What if the potential child grows up and is impacted by how they were conceived? For all the people who are saying go for it-there doesn't seem to be any real consideration on how the impacts the child. It seems to be very much "do what you want!" "You do you!"

Rather than thinking if it is something that you SHOULD do. Just because you can doesn't mean you should.

I would understand more if time was pressing and a woman didn't have a partner or a child already, but this isn't the case here. She has a child that could be poorly impacted by this choice.

Coyoacan · 25/05/2023 12:38

but the OP said she had a good support system so why are you assuming her male role models aren't going to be ever present and substantially in the child's life?

The OP has said a lot of things. She also said that most men are shite, which does not sound like a comment from someone who is surrounded by a good male support system.

Anyway, OP, good luck with your decision. As a single mother of one I can understand your desire. Children are adorable and so much fun.

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 12:35

tigger2022 · 25/05/2023 12:34

So you think even in a two parent family, one of those parents must have magic man juice or the child will grow up traumatised? How come the outcomes of same-sex parents on children are good then?

So you think the only difference between men and women is some magical man juice?

It's like playing chess with a pigeon.

fuckmyuteruslining · 25/05/2023 12:35

There is a difference with what we make the best of cos there's no realistic choice otherwise and what we choose to do. The op doesn't need to do this. She wants to because her hormones are driving her. Most women experience the desire for more than one child. But the head doesn't always agree and this is a case in point. The op is going to hugely disrupt her life and that of her child's and if it's harder than she thinks she has no back up in the parenting. So sure, crack on but it's a bigger risk than most women are taking.

tigger2022 · 25/05/2023 12:34

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 12:29

I am not remotely flip-flopping.

I have been very clear in my argument that children need fathers. In optimal circumstances, children will have both parents present in their lives.

So you think even in a two parent family, one of those parents must have magic man juice or the child will grow up traumatised? How come the outcomes of same-sex parents on children are good then?

shivawn · 25/05/2023 12:34

Well you sound as prepared as anyone can be, good job, financial security, plenty experience as a single parent and good family support.

It's not something that I would choose for myself or my family but I've been very lucky in love and not everyone gets that good fortune. I'd say that going it alone is better than settling for any man that you can find to have a child with you, particularly given that you have some very complex negative feelings towards men.

Just curious but would it trouble you if you had a son?

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 12:33

I have never once mentioned lesbian or gay couples.

Do I think they can raise perfectly happy and healthy children? Absolutely.

As we're on a thread about where the OP is a woman who has, I think it's safe to say, has been with men in the past and as such has the possibility to be with a man again-it's completely irrelevant to bring up same-sex couples as some kind of gotcha.

In OP's circumstances, would it really not be a more optimal circumstance for a father to be present either as a resident parent or a co-parent?

tigger2022 · 25/05/2023 12:33

What really annoys me btw is a) the word “presence” - literally just their magic presence! and b) that you’re not willing to consider the overlap between the outcomes of children growing up in single parent homes (mostly not people who chose to be single parents btw) and children growing up in single income homes. Those things are also outcomes of poverty or low income homes, it’s not magic man essence that prevents poor outcomes but their salary. That is not the case in women who become single mothers on purpose, because the price tag itself is a barrier.

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 12:29

tigger2022 · 25/05/2023 12:24

You’re flip flopping between children must have a positive male influence, children must have any male influence, or they need specifically a father. So in other words, you think lesbian couples shouldn’t raise children either?

I am not remotely flip-flopping.

I have been very clear in my argument that children need fathers. In optimal circumstances, children will have both parents present in their lives.

tigger2022 · 25/05/2023 12:24

You’re flip flopping between children must have a positive male influence, children must have any male influence, or they need specifically a father. So in other words, you think lesbian couples shouldn’t raise children either?

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 12:16

@CleverLilViper what do you mean making them have to step in as a substitute father though? no one is asking anything of them other than they are positive male people to be around. what father specific tasks do you think I'd expect them to perform?

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 12:09

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 12:06

@CleverLilViper not sure what type of family you come from, but mine and most people I can think of are super thrilled to have a new baby in the family, and actively want to spend time with them. My brother and dad certainly don't feel imposed. they are constantly in my house to see the children and take them out etc

And that is great, but either way, expecting your male family members to step in and act as substitute fathers is a massive expectation and imposition on their lives.

If you want those male role models to act as a replacement sufficiently for their dads they will need to be in the child's life for a meaningful amount of time.

That's a big time ask and expectation, is it not? Especially as most people have their own damn lives to lead and their own damn responsibilities.

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 12:06

@CleverLilViper not sure what type of family you come from, but mine and most people I can think of are super thrilled to have a new baby in the family, and actively want to spend time with them. My brother and dad certainly don't feel imposed. they are constantly in my house to see the children and take them out etc

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 12:02

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 11:58

@CleverLilViper but the OP said she had a good support system so why are you assuming her male role models aren't going to be ever present and substantially in the child's life?

The role of the mother may or may not be important again depending on the situation of the child born. for example, I have 2 gay friends who adopted a baby who is now a teenager. The child was too young to recall losing his mother and so doesn't miss her and doesn't display any signs of trauma or issue over the way he has been brought up. He is very close to his grandmas who provide a mothering type figure to his life so ultimately he is receiving his needs.

if men could have children without a woman having to give her body for 9 months and the baby making that connection for 9 months (so more like sperm donation) then the lack of a mother in a planned way could be less of an issue. But it can't happen so isn't comparable.

Is it fair for the OP to impose on her "support system" like that when she doesn't have to?

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 11:58

@CleverLilViper but the OP said she had a good support system so why are you assuming her male role models aren't going to be ever present and substantially in the child's life?

The role of the mother may or may not be important again depending on the situation of the child born. for example, I have 2 gay friends who adopted a baby who is now a teenager. The child was too young to recall losing his mother and so doesn't miss her and doesn't display any signs of trauma or issue over the way he has been brought up. He is very close to his grandmas who provide a mothering type figure to his life so ultimately he is receiving his needs.

if men could have children without a woman having to give her body for 9 months and the baby making that connection for 9 months (so more like sperm donation) then the lack of a mother in a planned way could be less of an issue. But it can't happen so isn't comparable.

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 11:53

Also, the expectation that other men in OP's life should step in and act as substitute dad's because of HER choice to KNOWINGLY bring a child into the world without a father is utterly selfish.

So, OP and other women like OP can just burden the people in her life with her choices because it's what she wanted to do and other people just have to go along with it.

Lovesacake · 25/05/2023 11:50

I’d be concerned about the possibility of your daughter developing a relationship with her dad in the future. Even ten years or more from now it could cause issues with the child who has no dad.
but more than that it’s about the gamble you’re taking with your daughters current life. She currently has the absolute best of you. You’re not a sleep deprived exhausted single mum dealing with a younger child who for many reasons could demand so much more of your time, effort and money than she does. But that’s what you may become.
of course you could have a completely easy, healthy, happy second child who slots right in but there’s no escaping the fact that it’s a gamble.

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 11:47

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 11:41

@CleverLilViper the word Father is used yes and then read what it says he provides.. and the word becomes irrelevant. its the delivery of the function/role/support that is the benefit.

@LuckyAmy1986 I don't believe for a second you see sperm donation in exactly the same way as surrogacy

Firstly, the role of an uncle/grandfather/older brother or other male role model is not the same as the role of a father. They are separate and distinct roles.

Secondly, unless they live in the household (which is doubtful) or are around sufficiently, they're not going to provide those things in meaningful amounts.

Thirdly, would you say the same about the role of a mother? That the role of a mother can simply be substituted by other female figures in the child's life?

If not, why not?

Do we really hold such little value on the role of a father and then want to act surprised when men dip out and act less than stellar?

LuckyAmy1986 · 25/05/2023 11:45

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 11:41

@CleverLilViper the word Father is used yes and then read what it says he provides.. and the word becomes irrelevant. its the delivery of the function/role/support that is the benefit.

@LuckyAmy1986 I don't believe for a second you see sperm donation in exactly the same way as surrogacy

Well I don't think you should reduce the person who will be literally half your child's DNA FFS to just some 'sperm for sale' do you?

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 11:41

@CleverLilViper the word Father is used yes and then read what it says he provides.. and the word becomes irrelevant. its the delivery of the function/role/support that is the benefit.

@LuckyAmy1986 I don't believe for a second you see sperm donation in exactly the same way as surrogacy

LuckyAmy1986 · 25/05/2023 11:38

Ostryga · 24/05/2023 23:16

The entire point of this thread is that I don’t need one. Yes, sperm for sale, but not an actual man.

Like gay couples who use surrogates on here (which most people are against 🤔). You don't NEED an actual woman to have a baby, you just hire the womb and an egg. Everyone agrees right? Babies don't need a mother? Just some female influences around them?

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 11:38

It doesn't point towards having positive male role models. Did you miss the numerous times it said "father."

Is OP's brother, i.e. the uncle going to reside or be present regularly enough in the child's life to actually provide all of that in a meaningful amount?

CleverLilViper · 25/05/2023 11:35

Leo227 · 25/05/2023 11:34

@CleverLilViper reading the links you've just posted, but it literally just points towards having positive male role models. I don't read anything in there that wouldn't be achievable from a strong relationship with OPs brother for example

There the dismissal begins.