Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend treating my children differently

209 replies

Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 17:41

A friend of mine who doesn’t live locally to me treats my children differently and I’m not quite sure how to approach it.

I have two boys and a girl and she seems to favour the girl 👧 as we live a fair distance from each other we always send little gifts to each other now and again and she usually sends something for my little girl but now for the boys.

same with their birthdays, she made the effort to buy my little girl a gift but again not the boys.

I have politely said that whilst my little girl appreciates the gifts the boys feel left out but she’s still doing it. How else can I approach this? I feel like she’s not getting the message. I don’t want to hurt her feelings but I believe all my children should be treated the same

OP posts:
PuzzledWatermelon · 25/05/2023 06:40

Hi Op, I’m glad you have managed to get the situation sorted with your friend, as per your update.

I have a few questions - your sons are older (10 and 12) than your daughter (5), did your friend ever buy your sons presents in the years before your daughter was born? How long have you known your friend? How long have you known your friend’s teenage son who you buy presents for?

Bit strange she only just started buying presents five years ago when your daughter was born. Or did you meet your friend just before you had your daughter, maybe she feels closer to your daughter because she has known her from birth as opposed to your sons (that is if you’ve only know this friend for 5/6/7 years…?)

I’m not saying what friend is doing is “right” (I would buy for all three) but I’m maybe just trying to shed some light as to why your friend does this. However, if your friend has known your sons since THEY were born then this whole situation feels more strange.

Good luck.

PixiePirate · 25/05/2023 06:36

Do you buy for her son? If so, perhaps suggest that you both stop exchanging gifts altogether. It might help to side step the issue without any confrontation.

RG89 · 25/05/2023 06:25

I am shocked how many people seem to find this ok! i have one child, most my friends have multiple, one has 5, if I'm getting for one child of a family, I'm getting for all! It won't always be of equal value as I go to their tastes not costs, but it will always be around the same amount, because it's wrong to show favouritism to a friend's kids. Kids aren't stupid, they notice a lot!

silverfullmoon · 25/05/2023 06:21

I'm glad your friend has listened OP and I think you did absolutely the right thing. I'm actually quite shocked that some people have said its fine to shower one child with gifts and ignore others based solely on their gender. I wonder how they'd feel if it was your sons she was favouring solely because she didnt have a son. My guess is the responses would be very different then. Thats really messed up and the fact your boys have noticed this and asked why she prefers your daughter is evidence that its hurtful to kids and they do notice.

Ignore the people who said you are "ungrateful", you arent, you've explained multiple times that you appreciate the gesture greatly but feel it would be better to give no gifts than favour only one child. Thats perfectly reasonable and understandable.

FFSFF · 25/05/2023 05:27

Yes thankfully she’s understood where I’m coming from 😊

Does she though?

I also can't understand how so many people on here think this is OK. Children come before friendships and their feeling matter - regardless of gender or age.

OP, if your friend ignores your requests and keeps doing this, I would distance myself from her permanently.

smileandwavexx · 25/05/2023 04:09

It's so much easier to buy for a girl then a boy, I have 2 of each and find I can always buy my girls loads of cute nic nacks but never find anything for the lads, same for birthdays!
Me and my best friend find this, il always pick stuff up for her dc if I see it useful for them. Her dd loves Harry Potter so if I see something she will love il get it. Theirs loads of little cute things but Her ds isn't into much other then football so it's limited to what to get him ? So I often buy one without the other
Weve both Never seen it like this

JandalsAlways · 25/05/2023 02:36

Mrsmillshorse · 23/05/2023 18:26

I feel sorry for your friend. She's not trying to single out the boys and make them feel bad.

You have to think of the bigger picture. What's wrong with your girl getting extra gifts? How lovely for her to have a family friend sending her nice things.

I think this too, probably just sees cute girly things and gets them. Maybe she just feels a closer bond with your daughter. I think it's lovely

TheMeaningOfLife · 25/05/2023 02:07

I would tell your sons “x doesn’t have a daughter of her own so she is indulging in her desire to buy girlie things and your sister is getting the benefit”. I don’t think it is worth losing a friendship over nor can you insist your friend buys for three rather than one. Life isn’t always fair, some people have more, maybe this is a chance to teach your boys that. My only aunt blatantly favoured my sister when it came to gifts, money etc. and my parents did not have the money to compensate. I got over it and it became a joke with my sister as we got older.

JustAnotherOpinion123 · 24/05/2023 22:19

Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 22:04

At the end of the day she’s MY friend not theirs. They will have their own friends yes but I’m not going to stand by and accept my children being left out because she sees it fit to just favoritise one of them, it’s not nice.

Definitely with you with this OP. I could understand if you'd met this friend because your dd and her ds were friends, or there was some other connection like that, but that doesn't seem to be the case.
My best friend has 2 boys and I love them both equally, can't imagine turning up at their house with a present for just one of them (unless it was a birthday) nor do I think she'd be happy if I did. I frequently find things I think one of them will like, but I buy them and keep hold of them until I find something for the other child or keep a note for birthdays/Christmas.

misskatamari · 24/05/2023 09:52

I’m so surprised by the answers on here!

How are so many grown adults dismissing this and saying it’s completely fine to treat children differently. It’s not! These are children! They don’t understand the complex reasons why this woman wants to spoil their sister and not them. All they will see if their sibling getting gifts and them not. What does that teach them..? They’re not good enough or as worthy? It’s not like their sister is doing anything to earn the gifts, it’s not a birthday, but she’s getting something they aren’t. Can people really not see how that would feel to a child? I’m so shocked you’re being told you’re unreasonable here.

I don’t care if your friend means well or wishes she had a daughter so wants to buy cute stuff. She’s a grown woman and can deal with her own issues. It’s unfair to make those issues your children’s problem.

and as for you buying gifts for your boys when she does this - wtaf? No! As well meaning as she is, her actions are not in the best interests of your children, and she’s the adult here so needs to adjust her behaviour. Just because she “means well” doesn’t mean her actions aren’t harmful

boobee · 24/05/2023 09:43

It's probably because your friend hasn't got a dd and enjoys buying the things for girls. I have a few friends that do this for my dd as they have ds and want to buy the girls stuff.
I'd not say it's unfair to your friend I'd just say we've decided not to do gifts going forward but thank you for all you've got so far, a card will be fine.

Saucemonkey · 24/05/2023 08:25

Keep the gifts and hide them, donate to charity shop. I wouldn’t let one child get a gift and the others nothing as this is not ok. Rather than lose a friend just intercept the gift, if friend asks about it just say no I didn’t give it to her as her brothers don’t get a gift and I don’t want them feeling inferior to her.

neilyoungismyhero · 24/05/2023 03:02

EmptyBedBlues · 23/05/2023 22:33

This sounds like it all about your feelings, rather than your children’s, OP.

What exactly have the ten and twelve year olds been saying to make you think they’re taking it so much to heart?

The OP has already said her son has mentioned that her friend likes her daughter more than them because of the gift situation.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 24/05/2023 01:34

Glad she's listened.

She has no particular reason to be closer to your DD than to your DSs, that's why her behaviour was off.

A godparent to one child. Understandable. If she had a DD who was best friends with your DD and she bought both girls things because your DD spends a lot of time at her house, again, understandable. But there is no situational reason why she should be closer to your DD than your DSs so she is showing favouritism on the sole basis that she is a girl. And that's not nice.

Stompythedinosaur · 24/05/2023 00:04

It ask her to stop sending gifts for your dd as the inequity is bad for all the dc.

Robinni · 23/05/2023 23:27

Glad you got the issue resolved (hopefully) @Ilovepugs2017

It did strike me that the difference in ages/cost may have played a part…

Generally from age ten from family members I received money bday/Xmas only, and all the little gifts from my Mums friends dried up as I was perceived to be too old and not a little girl anymore being a preteen/teenager.

If you have only contributed singular presents to her son then she may find it irritating to have to dig in for three.

To have your child receive £15.00 worth and then have to fork out £50.00 is irritating and you have to draw the line somewhere.

Anyway, can understand your point of view regardless the older age/number of children. The boys will still be miffed to be differentiated from their sister - particularly when in school/due to puberty there will be a lot to set them out as at a different life stage already.

Shynapple · 23/05/2023 23:06

Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 23:00

Yeah I get what you mean.
The thing is that it isn’t just birthdays for example. It will be randomly throughout the year. Always something for my daughter but never anything for my sons. Then on birthdays she will make the effort to buy my daughter gifts and a card where as when it’s the boys birthdays she will send me a text to say oh wish (name) a happy birthday from me.

Yes thankfully she’s understood where I’m coming from 😊

I see, that does change matters I must say, for one child to get card and gifts versus just a text for your sons. I'm sorry, I hope that she's now reflecting.

Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 23:04

Bivarb · 23/05/2023 22:57

Personally I'd distance myself from this friend.
Inviting you and only 1 out of 3 of your children is just weird. Showering one child with gifts while completely ignoring the other ones is just nasty. I'd be worried about resentment building between the children and their relationship is too important to risk that. Your kids are your priority and more important than your friend. Your boys might grow up and wonder why you didn't put a stop to it.

If you really want to keep the friendship, I'd explain how you feel about the obvious favouritism and tell her not to send gifts for any of them.

Yes and this is exactly why I’ve had to say something because I will not tolerate my children feeling left out by someone who is meant to be a close friend to me. I’ve noticed it’s bothered them hence why I’ve taken action because I won’t allow this to carry on tbh.

I have explained my feelings about this to her now and luckily she has taken it on board and understands where I’m coming from.

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 23:01

ThomasinaLivesHere · 23/05/2023 22:58

I don’t get those disagreeing with you. Even if I enjoyed girly presents and enjoyed the company of a girl better than her brothers I would still try to treat them evenly as children notice such things and it bothers them.

Yes it definitely does. I believe in children being treated fairly.
It’s good that even my daughters school implement this, for example they won’t give out party invites unless the whole class is invited just so that no children are feeling left out. I 100% agree with this

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 23:00

Shynapple · 23/05/2023 22:52

I was in full agreement with you until you mentioned the age of your sons. Is your friend picking up little cute gifts/outfits that she's found when out and about? At age 5 it can often be a couple of pounds for a t shirt/little toy.

For an almost teenage boy (or girl for that matter) it's absolutely not so easy to pick up a 'little something' as a treat. I've taken to giving my god children of similar ages to your sons money so that they can pick what they want. Alternatively I may buy some sort of sports clothing that I feel they may like but make sure I get a gift receipt, kids that age can be super picky.

There is a big difference in little gifts for a 5 year old versus almost teens in my opinion (happy to be wrong)

Your friend sounds lovely in how she has taken your feelings on board.

Yeah I get what you mean.
The thing is that it isn’t just birthdays for example. It will be randomly throughout the year. Always something for my daughter but never anything for my sons. Then on birthdays she will make the effort to buy my daughter gifts and a card where as when it’s the boys birthdays she will send me a text to say oh wish (name) a happy birthday from me.

Yes thankfully she’s understood where I’m coming from 😊

OP posts:
ThomasinaLivesHere · 23/05/2023 22:58

I don’t get those disagreeing with you. Even if I enjoyed girly presents and enjoyed the company of a girl better than her brothers I would still try to treat them evenly as children notice such things and it bothers them.

Bivarb · 23/05/2023 22:57

Personally I'd distance myself from this friend.
Inviting you and only 1 out of 3 of your children is just weird. Showering one child with gifts while completely ignoring the other ones is just nasty. I'd be worried about resentment building between the children and their relationship is too important to risk that. Your kids are your priority and more important than your friend. Your boys might grow up and wonder why you didn't put a stop to it.

If you really want to keep the friendship, I'd explain how you feel about the obvious favouritism and tell her not to send gifts for any of them.

Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 22:55

EmptyBedBlues · 23/05/2023 22:51

This. I mean, surely everyone has the ‘not everyone gets invited to everything/the same amounts of presents/feels equally connected to everyone else’ conversation with their children periodically?

I would worry, OP, that your own obviously strong feelings about this are warping your judgement, and you’re bringing up children who will always be the ones checking to make sure no one else’s slice of cake is a minute bit bigger than theirs, because that’s what they’ve been taught.

You see it a lot on here, people anxiously counting up play date ‘reciprocation’ or how many dinner parties the friends you invited invited you to, and some posters aggressively recommending ‘cutting people off’ if there’s no quid pro quo. It’s a depressingly petty and transactional view of human relationships.

All you’ve achieved here is presumably no more little presents for your daughter.

But this isn’t about play dates, birthday parties or how many gifts each child has. Obviously that all differs. Your missing the point which is the fact that my friend is favouring one of my children over the other two which to me is unacceptable.

Anyway we will have to agree to disagree on this :)

OP posts:
Shynapple · 23/05/2023 22:52

I was in full agreement with you until you mentioned the age of your sons. Is your friend picking up little cute gifts/outfits that she's found when out and about? At age 5 it can often be a couple of pounds for a t shirt/little toy.

For an almost teenage boy (or girl for that matter) it's absolutely not so easy to pick up a 'little something' as a treat. I've taken to giving my god children of similar ages to your sons money so that they can pick what they want. Alternatively I may buy some sort of sports clothing that I feel they may like but make sure I get a gift receipt, kids that age can be super picky.

There is a big difference in little gifts for a 5 year old versus almost teens in my opinion (happy to be wrong)

Your friend sounds lovely in how she has taken your feelings on board.

EmptyBedBlues · 23/05/2023 22:51

CleverLilViper · 23/05/2023 22:38

So? Why didn’t you just tell them that your friend had seen something your daughter would like and sent her it?

why feed into it?

This. I mean, surely everyone has the ‘not everyone gets invited to everything/the same amounts of presents/feels equally connected to everyone else’ conversation with their children periodically?

I would worry, OP, that your own obviously strong feelings about this are warping your judgement, and you’re bringing up children who will always be the ones checking to make sure no one else’s slice of cake is a minute bit bigger than theirs, because that’s what they’ve been taught.

You see it a lot on here, people anxiously counting up play date ‘reciprocation’ or how many dinner parties the friends you invited invited you to, and some posters aggressively recommending ‘cutting people off’ if there’s no quid pro quo. It’s a depressingly petty and transactional view of human relationships.

All you’ve achieved here is presumably no more little presents for your daughter.