Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend treating my children differently

209 replies

Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 17:41

A friend of mine who doesn’t live locally to me treats my children differently and I’m not quite sure how to approach it.

I have two boys and a girl and she seems to favour the girl 👧 as we live a fair distance from each other we always send little gifts to each other now and again and she usually sends something for my little girl but now for the boys.

same with their birthdays, she made the effort to buy my little girl a gift but again not the boys.

I have politely said that whilst my little girl appreciates the gifts the boys feel left out but she’s still doing it. How else can I approach this? I feel like she’s not getting the message. I don’t want to hurt her feelings but I believe all my children should be treated the same

OP posts:
Thighlengthboots · 25/05/2023 08:36

JusthereforXmas · 25/05/2023 08:30

you cant make her buy for the boys but you can intervene with her sending to your daughter, if she posts things just send them back etc...

I can't abide favoritism, its shitty 'mean girls' behavior from an adult and people trying to make out like your friend is for some reason besties with your daughter (as if they are classmates not a child and fully grown woman) and thus its justified are frankly creepy and fucking bizarre. Adults dont act like that and shes YOUR friend not your young child's and should treat all 3 the same.

I completely agree. I also dont get the "life lesson" thing. By that rationale, should we expose kids to all kinds of unpleasant behaviour just to prove to them that life isnt easy? where does this end?

Not all kids are the same- some are sensitive and emotional, others are tougher and more resilient, we all learn in different ways. The idea that we must toughen them up because life will beat the shit out of them when they are older is frankly, utterly bizarre to me. That woudnt have worked for me as a kid at all. I'm glad my kids have a sense of fairness, it will benefit them when they are older.

JusthereforXmas · 25/05/2023 08:30

you cant make her buy for the boys but you can intervene with her sending to your daughter, if she posts things just send them back etc...

I can't abide favoritism, its shitty 'mean girls' behavior from an adult and people trying to make out like your friend is for some reason besties with your daughter (as if they are classmates not a child and fully grown woman) and thus its justified are frankly creepy and fucking bizarre. Adults dont act like that and shes YOUR friend not your young child's and should treat all 3 the same.

Clars10 · 25/05/2023 08:28

Probably the unpopular opinion here… but you know that life is not going to treat all your kids the same right? I think is good opportunity to also teach this to your kids…
ask her why she send gift only for your daughter and give that same answer yo your boys. And talk to them about this piece, could be because she is little and easier to get gifts… if your boys are much older as I understand then also buying gifts is more tricky because then it needs to be taken preferences and so on.. is not the same to buy for 5 years old than for a 10 years old
She is not mistreating your boys, she is just creating a bond with one of them, which I think is normal since in general people may have more affinity with one person than the other
if it is really that uncomfortable for you, just ask her to not send anything, but I don’t think that it is fair to your daughter either

Samlewis96 · 25/05/2023 08:23

Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 18:42

Yes it is nice that she’s doing that but imo still unfair on the boys..

As I said I wouldn’t do the same if she had three children I would get them something each as I’d hate to think of a child feeling left out or less special than another child

I have 3 kids. They have ALWAYS had gifts at different times from different people. For example DDs got gifts from their relatives that DS didn't and DS got gifts from his. Never heard any complain of being left out Will have to check with them now all adults to see if they have any lasting damage due to it.

Luckypom · 25/05/2023 08:16

I’ve now read a bit more - the ages ofgs

Luckypom · 25/05/2023 08:09

@Ilovepugs2017

If you are giving the gifts to charity why do your sons even know 🤷‍♂️

Mountain out of a molehill surely

EmptyBedBlues · 25/05/2023 08:06

SoupDragon · 25/05/2023 07:44

"Oh yes, it's just because X prefers your sister". 😂😂

Yup. Normal life lesson which is highly unlikely to strike any child to the heart unless it’s someone the less-preferred child is very attached to, which it isn’t in this case. This is some kind of insecure adult emotion about ‘exclusion’, of the kind that pops up its head on here a lot, usually from people who wail about ‘cliques’ and struggle with other people making friends and ‘not inviting all the class mums’, nothing to do with the children.

Luckypom · 25/05/2023 08:04

@Paramummy3

This

Maybe living vicariously through you as she has seen cute stuff she likes but can’t use 🤷‍♂️

I don’t think it’s a slight on your sons, can you not just gracefully intercept and pass the presents on without announcing it? I’m not sure how old your children are

BustyLaRoux · 25/05/2023 08:02

My DS honestly wouldn’t notice that his sister got something and he didn’t. And if he did I would tell him he’s not entitled to something just because she has something. Life isn’t equal and fair and I genuinely think it’s a good idea not to try and make things fair all the time so as not to upset them. It isn’t representative of what is to come. Isn’t it better to say “well yes it’s not fair really, but my friend has always wanted a daughter to buy things for. Right or wrong. This is why she’s doing it. It doesn’t mean she doesn’t love you guys too. She’s just enjoying buying little girl things as she doesn’t get to do this for her child”.

Thats an honest answer. And would help them see that he’s life isn’t always exactly equal and fair, and help them learn to accept these small inconsequential incidences. Instead of forcing your friend to buy things for your sons as well (or stop buying gifts for your daughter), just explain this is how it is. It doesn’t really matter. This is the reason why. Don’t teach them entitlement.

My DD has quite a strong sense of fairness (she’s younger than my DS). And sometimes she’ll get in a strop because her brother has something which she hasn’t been given. I absolutely do not make sure she then gets the same. I say “today isn’t your day. Maybe tomorrow will be! Don’t you have enough stuff? Do you actually need [whatever it is he has]? No..? Well then. Quit complaining. Tomorrow you’ll have something (a sweet given out by a birthday child for example) and he won’t. That’s life!”

Lavenderflower · 25/05/2023 08:00

I understand how you are feeling. If you feel uncomfortable - I would distant yourself. That being said it is important to understand that you children will not be treated equally by others particularly as they are different ages.

Beamur · 25/05/2023 07:55

I really don't get all the angst about treating the children equally at all times.
Your friend prefers your DD, that doesn't mean she hates your son's.
I think by saying it's all or nothing, you look a bit grabby and are denying your DD the chance to feel a little bit favoured for once.
Growing up I knew I was the favoured grandchild for one set of my grandparents and very much not for the other! Both of these experiences were actually very good life lessons. Life isn't always fair and denying someone something because you can't have it too is pretty selfish.

Bahhhhhumbug · 25/05/2023 07:53

I think its more to do with her being much younger,than her being a girl, people like to 'treat little ones. I'm 7 and 9 years older respectively than my 2 siblings. I remember as a child getting lots of sweets/little pressies off visitors/relatives but then they tailed off and my two little siblings started getting them and people stopped buying me random treats/toys . Never bothered me as l understood it was because they were now the 'little ones'.

Oldslipperatadisco · 25/05/2023 07:49

It is a bit rough on your boys but it’s not the end of the world. Just tell them that your friend is very fond of your daughter. Not everything can be equal all the time. Your friend just probably loves buying girly stuff. You can’t make her buy stuff for all your children. Just say thank you. I have lots of siblings and some of them were favourites of various friends or relatives. For example my sister is really musical so my uncle gave her his guitar. I wasn’t jealous. Kids have to learn to be happy for each other and learn that some people connect more than others. Don’t obsess about it.

SoupDragon · 25/05/2023 07:44

Moveoverdarlin · 25/05/2023 07:28

This wouldn’t bother me really. So what if she buys your daughter stuff as she has a little soft spot for her? I’d tell the boys exactly that, I have both boys and girls and this wouldn’t bother me.

"Oh yes, it's just because X prefers your sister". 😂😂

SoupDragon · 25/05/2023 07:43

I wouldn't buy something for only one sibling, that's just mean. It would be different if it was a different sibling each time so, whilst they didn't all get a gift at the same time, no one was left out.

I'm amazed people think it's OK, especially given pretty much everyone usually thinks it's mean to leave just a couple of children out of a birthday party.

Moveoverdarlin · 25/05/2023 07:28

This wouldn’t bother me really. So what if she buys your daughter stuff as she has a little soft spot for her? I’d tell the boys exactly that, I have both boys and girls and this wouldn’t bother me.

LacewingOrpington · 25/05/2023 07:28

I had someone do this. Of course the kids notice. I said it was very kind to buy xxx birthday gifts but please stop as it will have an impact on all 3 of the children that someone they see regularly only buys gifts for one of them. They took it well. They buy them an equal small gift for Xmas now instead.

Biscuitsandpizza · 25/05/2023 07:24

But that's your motto @Ilovepugs2017 , it doesn't mean it has to be hers?

I can't imagine asking a friend not to buy one gift if they're not also going to buy 2 more! A family member yes, probably I would, but a friend, absolutely not. To me that's incredibly rude and ungrateful.

GGee123 · 25/05/2023 07:24

Are your boys actually upset by their sister getting presents? Or do they just notice & have a minor grumble?
If they're not upset by it, I'd be inclined to leave it & let your friend carry on. I do totally understand what you're saying & it would annoy me too, but your friend is trying to do a nice thing, albeit unfairly, & doesn't seem worth making a major issue out of.
Obviously if your boys are getting upset over it, that's a different matter & needs to be addressed!

TheLadyofShalott1 · 25/05/2023 07:19

Out of nosiness interest @Ilovepugs2017 how did you meet this friend 2 years ago, and why/how have you become such close friends in such a short time-frame - especially as you say you have only actually met in the flesh "a handful of times"?

I am interested in this aspect because if you weren't such "close friends" it would surely be easier to just let the friendship quietly slip away, rather than either of you giving each other rules on your behaviours within the friendship.

To me, the age difference between your DD and her siblings does make a legitimate reason for the difference in treatment given by your friend. A 5 year old is still very young, and I think it is a natural instinct in many of us, to want to give the "baby" of the family lots of little treats, and cute toys and clothes for 5 year olds will catch our eyes (and imagination much more than the equivalent for
10 + aged children.

If your DD had been a "later in life" addition to the family, and her siblings were 20 and 22, would you still expect your DFriend to buy treats for them as well, and if not, at what age would you consider that it was alright to not include your older children? In other words, what age is your cut-off line?

I think that if I had ever been in your situation, I would have just smiled at my youngest getting little presents, and said to the other two (if they noticed anyway) well that's the perks of being only 5, whereas you two have the perks of staying up later, watching more interesting films, getting to make a lot more choices, not having to be in the same room as us when my friends come to visit, you two can go on sleepovers with your friends (if that is something they do) etc etc etc!

I am a great believer in equality and fairness, but I am also a big believer in children having more independence the older they get, and them learning about some of the "not too harsh" realities of life, and that outside of the family the older they get, the less interested parents friends will have in them - these are just a few examples. They will soon not even be at home when your friend visits OP, and it is human nature for adults to become less interested in teenage children, and then the adult children of their friends and acquaintances, unless we are talking about long-held friendships of the parents, where each child has been known since birth.

In my opinion you are making this a far too serious problem OP, when you should just be teaching your children to laugh it off. I am actually embarrassed for you that you told your friend that every time she gets your 5 year old a present, or a treat, she has to do the same for the (quite a bit) older ones. To me that is very bad manners on your part. However, I do hope that you are right about your friend taking it well, and understanding your slightly ott reasons, and that it wasn't just her initial reaction to you until what you said sinks in.

Please try and relax a little OP, or through bitter experience, I can warn you that it is going to be a long and very tiring life. I wish I hadn't been brought up to expect to give and receive perfection - it is impossible, and again, imo, not even desirable.

Manthide · 25/05/2023 07:08

My great aunty who sadly died this year used to always get me presents - she had a thing for buying me handbags from jumble sales (1970s Liverpool)!! She never used to get my brother anything. I think he way relieved he didn't have to say he was thankful. Later on as an adult she used to send me postal orders. Again she didn't send my brother anything but then by that point I had a good relationship with her and he doesn't bother with anyone. She had 2 sons but no daughters.

SomePosters · 25/05/2023 07:00

Sorry but I just don’t subscribe to this have to treat everyone the same crap.

As their parent you do but other people can develop individual relationships and it’s not healthy to teach your kids they are entitled to something just because a sibling has it.

Unless you’re planning to dish out girlfriends and equally paying jobs for the rest of their lives?

FabFitFifties · 25/05/2023 06:57

Is she your daughter's God Mother?

Kamia · 25/05/2023 06:55

Don't give her the gifts save them for an occasion. Unless it is clothes. It's not about whether it is right or wrong to do something like that, it's the fact you mentioned you are not happy with it and she continues doing this.

Ffion21 · 25/05/2023 06:50

if you’ve spoken to her and it’s gone unnoticed but you also value her friendship…why not simply set aside the gifts? Re-wrap then for Christmas then the boys won’t know tue difference and she’s still getting the gift from Santa in her stocking.