Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend treating my children differently

209 replies

Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 17:41

A friend of mine who doesn’t live locally to me treats my children differently and I’m not quite sure how to approach it.

I have two boys and a girl and she seems to favour the girl 👧 as we live a fair distance from each other we always send little gifts to each other now and again and she usually sends something for my little girl but now for the boys.

same with their birthdays, she made the effort to buy my little girl a gift but again not the boys.

I have politely said that whilst my little girl appreciates the gifts the boys feel left out but she’s still doing it. How else can I approach this? I feel like she’s not getting the message. I don’t want to hurt her feelings but I believe all my children should be treated the same

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:17

TheMeaningOfLife · 25/05/2023 02:07

I would tell your sons “x doesn’t have a daughter of her own so she is indulging in her desire to buy girlie things and your sister is getting the benefit”. I don’t think it is worth losing a friendship over nor can you insist your friend buys for three rather than one. Life isn’t always fair, some people have more, maybe this is a chance to teach your boys that. My only aunt blatantly favoured my sister when it came to gifts, money etc. and my parents did not have the money to compensate. I got over it and it became a joke with my sister as we got older.

I wouldn’t ever insist she buys for all 3 but I definitely think it would be fairer to not buy for any of them rather than just one.

I don’t want to lose the friendship really hence why I’ve asked for advice here on how is best to approach it in a direct but not horrible way because the last thing I wanted to do was upset/offend her

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:15

JustAnotherOpinion123 · 24/05/2023 22:19

Definitely with you with this OP. I could understand if you'd met this friend because your dd and her ds were friends, or there was some other connection like that, but that doesn't seem to be the case.
My best friend has 2 boys and I love them both equally, can't imagine turning up at their house with a present for just one of them (unless it was a birthday) nor do I think she'd be happy if I did. I frequently find things I think one of them will like, but I buy them and keep hold of them until I find something for the other child or keep a note for birthdays/Christmas.

Yes exactly. They have no connection other than me and her being friends. As I said before I don’t want to seem ungrateful but my children come first and I believe her actions in terms of favouring one child over the other two isn’t nice

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:13

misskatamari · 24/05/2023 09:52

I’m so surprised by the answers on here!

How are so many grown adults dismissing this and saying it’s completely fine to treat children differently. It’s not! These are children! They don’t understand the complex reasons why this woman wants to spoil their sister and not them. All they will see if their sibling getting gifts and them not. What does that teach them..? They’re not good enough or as worthy? It’s not like their sister is doing anything to earn the gifts, it’s not a birthday, but she’s getting something they aren’t. Can people really not see how that would feel to a child? I’m so shocked you’re being told you’re unreasonable here.

I don’t care if your friend means well or wishes she had a daughter so wants to buy cute stuff. She’s a grown woman and can deal with her own issues. It’s unfair to make those issues your children’s problem.

and as for you buying gifts for your boys when she does this - wtaf? No! As well meaning as she is, her actions are not in the best interests of your children, and she’s the adult here so needs to adjust her behaviour. Just because she “means well” doesn’t mean her actions aren’t harmful

I honestly couldn’t agree more with this post!

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:11

Saucemonkey · 24/05/2023 08:25

Keep the gifts and hide them, donate to charity shop. I wouldn’t let one child get a gift and the others nothing as this is not ok. Rather than lose a friend just intercept the gift, if friend asks about it just say no I didn’t give it to her as her brothers don’t get a gift and I don’t want them feeling inferior to her.

I had mentioned it to her previously but she didn’t seem to get the point and just kinda changed the subject so I’ve had to be a bit more direct this time, seems to have worked though as she says she understands where I’m coming from. She has now send if she sends gifts in the future she will send a joint gift that they can share like a box of chocolates

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:10

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 24/05/2023 01:34

Glad she's listened.

She has no particular reason to be closer to your DD than to your DSs, that's why her behaviour was off.

A godparent to one child. Understandable. If she had a DD who was best friends with your DD and she bought both girls things because your DD spends a lot of time at her house, again, understandable. But there is no situational reason why she should be closer to your DD than your DSs so she is showing favouritism on the sole basis that she is a girl. And that's not nice.

Exactly this.

All the time we’ve spent together my 3 children have been there alongside her son so there’s no reason why she should be favouring one over the other two

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:08

Ontheperiphery79 · 23/05/2023 22:47

I'd be very direct, personally, but that's not necessarily the best way to maintain a friendship one values.

Maybe you can stop buying presents for her son and you (diplomatically) reinforce your boundaries, requesting that she not send your daughter presents.

I don't think I could pursue a friendship with a friend who so overtly favoured one child.

I have been a bit more direct in how I’ve addressed it this time and luckily I think she’s got the point. It hasn’t affected our friendship because I do think she understands now that I’ve explained

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:06

momonpurpose · 23/05/2023 22:46

I agree OP. If she can't or won't send to all then no gifts. My best friend was desperate for a girl and has boys. I have a girl. She loves to send her girl things. But if I had boys she'd send gifts for them. This is really wrong of her and I cannot understand why she thinks it's OK to leave your boys out

I don’t understand why she’s done it either. I know she only has one child which is a boy but if it came to birthdays etc I would always try and make the effort to spend a bit more on her and her son as I know it would be expensive buying for all three of my children. Tbh I honestly don’t expect her to get anything for any of them and I’m sure a happy birthday message would suffice for all three of them, I just don’t understand why she is sending gifts for one and not the other two. As I said previously it is just birthdays it’s randomly throughout the year aswell

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:04

Terrribletwos · 23/05/2023 22:44

I don't understand why she is doing this. It's wrong to favour or send gifts to one child excluding others and really just rather odd. I would feel troubled and confused as to why she is doing this. If it was me I would definitely have to ask why.

I don’t understand why either tbh. I’ve just politely asked that she doesn’t do it from now forward as it’s unfair on my other two children

OP posts:
EmptyBedBlues · 25/05/2023 14:10

Feelinadequate23 · 25/05/2023 13:39

OP I think you’ve been really rude to your poor friend! She was doing something nice! Having 3 kids means people aren’t going to volunteer to treat them all or take them all out as 3 is just too many - it’s expensive and time consuming. Obviously you have to treat them all the same as they’re your kids and you chose to have them! Grandparents also as they are close family.

But others absolutely not! Didn’t you ever have a relative or family friend you were closer to? One of my uncles much preferred my brother to me as they were both interested in football. I was fine with that! Equally another uncle preferred me as we are both quite calm and quiet whereas my brother is very boisterous. Didn’t scar my brother one bit! Our godparents also differed a lot in approach - my bro got lots of little presents throughout childhood whereas I just got one big one at 18. It did us good to learn to accept life isn’t perfect but we were still ok.

IMO you’ve missed a chance to teach your sons a useful skill here - to understand people don’t always get the same things and life works out differently for everyone. You should be modelling to them how to calmly accept this and move on, not validating some imaginary hurt. Obviously it would be different if friend was being actively horrible to sons, saying mean things to them etc. but she’s not! She’s just doing something nice for your daughter.

I think this is a perfectly sensible approach.

Feelinadequate23 · 25/05/2023 13:39

OP I think you’ve been really rude to your poor friend! She was doing something nice! Having 3 kids means people aren’t going to volunteer to treat them all or take them all out as 3 is just too many - it’s expensive and time consuming. Obviously you have to treat them all the same as they’re your kids and you chose to have them! Grandparents also as they are close family.

But others absolutely not! Didn’t you ever have a relative or family friend you were closer to? One of my uncles much preferred my brother to me as they were both interested in football. I was fine with that! Equally another uncle preferred me as we are both quite calm and quiet whereas my brother is very boisterous. Didn’t scar my brother one bit! Our godparents also differed a lot in approach - my bro got lots of little presents throughout childhood whereas I just got one big one at 18. It did us good to learn to accept life isn’t perfect but we were still ok.

IMO you’ve missed a chance to teach your sons a useful skill here - to understand people don’t always get the same things and life works out differently for everyone. You should be modelling to them how to calmly accept this and move on, not validating some imaginary hurt. Obviously it would be different if friend was being actively horrible to sons, saying mean things to them etc. but she’s not! She’s just doing something nice for your daughter.

Northernparent68 · 25/05/2023 13:10

Anonymouseposter · 23/05/2023 19:13

I wouldn't like this. If you had said that your MIL or DM was doing it I think the responses would have expressed outrage. I also wonder what responses you would have got if she was buying only for your son and not your daughter.

I thought this as well

YerArseInParsley · 25/05/2023 13:06

Why do u have such a big problem with the op not wanting one child to be favoured? She's asked for the gifts to be discontinued for the sake of her other children, what's your problem with that? The friend clearly has an issue with the boys.

YerArseInParsley · 25/05/2023 12:58

If that was my dad I would be having it out with him and sending him on his was with both gifts. That's a sh!tty thing to do.

weaseleyes · 25/05/2023 12:35

I suspect that from your earlier attempts to address it, when you said you'd have to buy something for your boys to stop them feeling left out, she may have thought you were hinting she should get something for all three. That's a significantly bigger obligation and cost than sending a little something for a much smaller child. Now you've explained your reasoning about the fairness, she seems to have accepted it straight away

YerArseInParsley · 25/05/2023 12:15

You've already told her but she continues to send a gift for your daughter. Don't give your daughter the present, bin it or send it back. It's not nice sending one child birthday gifts but not the others. I could be wrong but I suspect she only buys for one of your kids because she only has one for you to buy for, some people can be funny like that.

What did your friend say when you told her not to send your daughter gifts?

pinkyredrose · 25/05/2023 11:30

Has your 9yr old suddenly become 10?

Manthide · 25/05/2023 11:30

@SoupDragon amazed people think it's OK, especially given pretty much everyone usually thinks it's mean to leave just a couple of children out of a birthday party.

The boys are 10 and 12 so have probably been left out of birthday parties / left people out themselves by that age. My elder dds ( age 31 and 30) don't get Easter eggs from my aunty - and haven't for a long time - but their younger siblings ( age 20 and 15 do). I do think it could have been laughed off instead of becoming a thing especially if the gifts are very girlie and not high value.
It really irritates me when dh divides a cake, for example, in equal portions and dd3 doesn't want any as she's had a large school dinner. (That bit is fine) This happens over a couple of days until she is basically forced to eat the cake so it doesn't go stale as it's her cake! I was brought up that generally if cake is not wanted it goes back into the general mix - it's not imprinted with a person's name.

Achwheesht · 25/05/2023 10:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DryIce · 25/05/2023 10:18

Sounds like you sorted it out, OP - I'm glad your friend saw your point.

I've found the responses a bit odd also, mumsnet usually seems against unfair treatment - e.g. leaving a few kids out of parties etc. In this case I think it's because it's about a little girl, I find there is always an undercurrent on here about how baby girls are just better.

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 25/05/2023 09:22

Samlewis96 · 25/05/2023 08:23

I have 3 kids. They have ALWAYS had gifts at different times from different people. For example DDs got gifts from their relatives that DS didn't and DS got gifts from his. Never heard any complain of being left out Will have to check with them now all adults to see if they have any lasting damage due to it.

That sounds like your dc have different relatives in which case it is different. Yes if a child has an independent relationship with an adult then its ok but this adult doesn't have a separate relationship with the daughter.

I'm another who can't believe how many think this is ok

silverfullmoon · 25/05/2023 08:48

people trying to make out like your friend is for some reason besties with your daughter (as if they are classmates not a child and fully grown woman) and thus its justified are frankly creepy and fucking bizarre

I found this bizarre too. They dont have a "bond" because OP said this:

We have only spent time together a handful of times in the time we have known each other because of the distance so it’s not like she has a closer bond with one child over the other two

This woman barely knows OP's daughter and has barely interacted with her so its nonsense that they are "friends" or have an "emotional connection" as some people keep insisting. She's doing it solely because she's female. Thats it!

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 25/05/2023 08:46

EmptyBedBlues · 23/05/2023 17:59

Don’t see the issue. It’s not as though only one child isn’t getting presents. She just prefers one child to the other two., or feels closer to her, or sees more things she thinks she would like because she’s more attuned to her? You have to treat your children equally as a parent, but I don’t see that a geographically-distant family friend needs to take a ‘presents for all or for none’ approach. I buy presents for my godchildren, but not their siblings, for instance.

I’m with the OP, it’d have to be all of them or none of them for me. I have a god-daughter and I treat her brother in exactly the same way as I treat her. I think it’s really mean to leave children out.

Bringonthesunforthewashing · 25/05/2023 08:44

LaMaG · 23/05/2023 18:53

I have boy / girl twins and if you can believe this my father, their grandfather will arrive with something for my daughter and not for my son. Or a thoughtful gift for her and a rubbish one for him. For example he got a cool set of girly colouring markers when on hols and handed over a pack of HB pencils for my boy, clearly bought on the way. He doesn't try to hide his favouritism and I get very upset but DS doesn't seem to mind yet, they are only 9. He never showed any interest at all in older DS either.

Same here! My dad favoured girl twin, would even ask if she wanted to go for tea and play. She was and still is quite quiet and shy but boy twin is confident and chatty.

Dd would go shy, ds would say, ‘I will I will grandad’. My dad would say, ‘not you, just girl twin’!!!

barmycatmum · 25/05/2023 08:42

Wow, I find her behaviour more than a but bizarre. To so blatantly leave out your boys, even to treating them differently on their birthdays… that’s awful in my book.
glad it’s been handled, and I hope she honors her word.

PoePoePoePoePoe · 25/05/2023 08:36

@Ilovepugs2017 other posters don’t see a problem because girls are hugely favoured on Mumsnet so they’d sympathise with your friend.

If, on the other hand, she was favouring a son and leaving out the daughters there’d be predictable uproar 🙄🤷‍♀️.