Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend treating my children differently

209 replies

Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 17:41

A friend of mine who doesn’t live locally to me treats my children differently and I’m not quite sure how to approach it.

I have two boys and a girl and she seems to favour the girl 👧 as we live a fair distance from each other we always send little gifts to each other now and again and she usually sends something for my little girl but now for the boys.

same with their birthdays, she made the effort to buy my little girl a gift but again not the boys.

I have politely said that whilst my little girl appreciates the gifts the boys feel left out but she’s still doing it. How else can I approach this? I feel like she’s not getting the message. I don’t want to hurt her feelings but I believe all my children should be treated the same

OP posts:
Guiltridden12345 · 25/05/2023 23:38

I’m with you op. The problem with the generosity towards your daughter is the message it sends to your sons - i don’t like you as much. Pretty horrible. My kids would certainly notice. I’d send a message saying pls stop, it’s upsetting for the other kids to see you favouring one. And then give any gifts she sends to charity/someone else. Don’t rubber stamp this conduct - your gut is telling you it’s wrong, so it’s wrong. Your kids, your rules.

Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 23:32

Tandora · 25/05/2023 23:24

why am I shocked?
this is my perspective :

  1. Your friends aren’t obliged to buy gifts for your sons. (Someone suggested you could buy them a little treat and you said you didn’t fancy spending the money 🤣)
  2. If someone buys a gift for your daughter ( or any of your children) the appropriate response is gratitude. Not to tell them off or ask for more gifts for your other children.

regarding your analysis that you “need to put your children first”- You are being massively precious. Your children are different people and will have different experiences in life. Not everything they receive will be exactly the same. This is not a problem and it isn’t harmful to them. If your friend was a significant person in their life- eg their grandparent/ a caregiver, then this different treatment might be problematic as it might impact their self esteem/
self worth. However, Given that your friend has no meaningful relationship with any of your children it’s not something that can be reasonably be expected to have that effect.
having said that, if you are adamant in protecting your boys from any minor disappointment then there are
very basic practical measures that you could take- give your dd present when boys aren’t around, give your dd present at times when boys are receiving a different treat , regift present.
instead you chose to treaT your friend with rudeness , and throw her generosity back in her face.
im shocked that you value your friends so little and consider them so disposable.

I haven’t ‘told her off’ or expected her to buy gifts for all my children. I have asked that she doesn’t just buy for one because it’s not very fair, simple as.

OP posts:
Tandora · 25/05/2023 23:24

Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 22:37

*several gifts whilst ignoring the boys essentially. Why should they be treated differently?

why am I shocked?
this is my perspective :

  1. Your friends aren’t obliged to buy gifts for your sons. (Someone suggested you could buy them a little treat and you said you didn’t fancy spending the money 🤣)
  2. If someone buys a gift for your daughter ( or any of your children) the appropriate response is gratitude. Not to tell them off or ask for more gifts for your other children.

regarding your analysis that you “need to put your children first”- You are being massively precious. Your children are different people and will have different experiences in life. Not everything they receive will be exactly the same. This is not a problem and it isn’t harmful to them. If your friend was a significant person in their life- eg their grandparent/ a caregiver, then this different treatment might be problematic as it might impact their self esteem/
self worth. However, Given that your friend has no meaningful relationship with any of your children it’s not something that can be reasonably be expected to have that effect.
having said that, if you are adamant in protecting your boys from any minor disappointment then there are
very basic practical measures that you could take- give your dd present when boys aren’t around, give your dd present at times when boys are receiving a different treat , regift present.
instead you chose to treaT your friend with rudeness , and throw her generosity back in her face.
im shocked that you value your friends so little and consider them so disposable.

Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 22:37

Feelinadequate23 · 25/05/2023 22:26

This thread shows me why so many MNers struggle to make/keep friends. Imagine telling a friend off for buying your kid a gift!

*several gifts whilst ignoring the boys essentially. Why should they be treated differently?

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 22:35

Tandora · 25/05/2023 22:21

And if she can’t see that she’s being unfair just gifting one child then that’s not someone I want in mine or my childrens lives tbh

😮😮😳

Sorry but what is so shocking about putting my children as my priority?🤨

OP posts:
Feelinadequate23 · 25/05/2023 22:26

This thread shows me why so many MNers struggle to make/keep friends. Imagine telling a friend off for buying your kid a gift!

Tandora · 25/05/2023 22:21

Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 21:57

I’m not being rude or ungrateful. My children feelings are more important than a friend sorry! And if she can’t see that she’s being unfair just gifting one child then that’s not someone I want in mine or my childrens lives tbh. Luckily she can see my point and is fine with it & has said she’s sorry and will not do this going forward!

And if she can’t see that she’s being unfair just gifting one child then that’s not someone I want in mine or my childrens lives tbh

😮😮😳

Elaina87 · 25/05/2023 22:19

How old are the boys? I have a cousin with 2 boys and girl. The boys are now late teens so I don't buy for them. The girl is younger and is my God daughter so I buy for her.

Maybe just don't tell the boys your daughter has received a present so they don't feel left out? If they don't see her very often and aren't close to her, I can't imagine it would bother them too much.

Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 21:57

Tandora · 25/05/2023 21:39

This . YABVU. Anything she gives any of your children is a kindness, she’s not obliged to buy for all three. Just give it to her without making a big deal, buy the boys an extra treat, or if it really has to be such a drama then regift. You would be incredibly rude and ungrateful to complain,

I’m not being rude or ungrateful. My children feelings are more important than a friend sorry! And if she can’t see that she’s being unfair just gifting one child then that’s not someone I want in mine or my childrens lives tbh. Luckily she can see my point and is fine with it & has said she’s sorry and will not do this going forward!

OP posts:
Tandora · 25/05/2023 21:39

baloosbaloos · 23/05/2023 18:24

@Paramummy3 I expect that’s the explanation. SO much cute girl stuff around, she probably just relishes the chance to buy it. Seems a bit churlish to make such a big deal of it. She’s not a family member, she doesn’t have to treat them exactly equal, anything she gets for any of your kids is a bonus. You could always buy your sons an extra treat to make up for it when it happens.

This . YABVU. Anything she gives any of your children is a kindness, she’s not obliged to buy for all three. Just give it to her without making a big deal, buy the boys an extra treat, or if it really has to be such a drama then regift. You would be incredibly rude and ungrateful to complain,

YerArseInParsley · 25/05/2023 21:35

@Ilovepugs2017

Some comments make the mind boggle. I can't believe anyone would be OK with this situation.

YerArseInParsley · 25/05/2023 21:33

@Feelinadequate23

No, she should be doing what she wants. If OP doesn't want her kids treated differently then that's her choice. I think it's pretty sh!t someone would constantly send 1 kid something and leave the others out. The friend could send a gift for the daughter then next time one of the sons then the other son has a turn or none at all.

CM1897 · 25/05/2023 20:48

Ilovepugs2017 · 23/05/2023 18:02

I just would rather her not bother at all than favour one child over the other two because it’s not nice. They have noticed and said how come your friend always sends things for -daughters name-.

It could be the fact she only has a son, and doesn’t get to enjoy shopping for a girl herself. Maybe deep down she wants a daughter, and likes buying girlie things. It’s no excuse, but it may explain it a bit

Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 19:43

SnackQueen · 25/05/2023 17:57

Meanwhile, I do think you need to take a chill pill with this whole "what about my other children!!!!" wail-fest mindset. It's exhausting and a sure fire way to create neurotic kids with persecution complexes.

So because I care about my kids feelings and actually listen to their feelings it’s going to make them neurotic? Ok then 🤔😂

OP posts:
silverfullmoon · 25/05/2023 18:53

NoThanksymm · 25/05/2023 16:12

You’re being unreasonable.

your kids are loved and your little girl has a special relationship with an ‘auntie’ type. This little girl gets to feel special. Aunts are very very important for little girls (research supported, Google it).

the boys might need a special person too. Manage that. Not your friend.

a potential perspective from your friend. She’s shopping, sees something cute and girly she loves and thinks of your child (yay love!). Not so much for the boys, maybe as you mentioned as she has a boy.

and you are selfish enough to be trying to shut down this simple joy. OR to demand MORE presents.

YTA.

Did you even read the thread? She doesn’t have a “special aunty relationship” fgs. OP has only met this woman a “handful of times”. This woman has barely interacted with OPs daughter!

SnackQueen · 25/05/2023 17:57

Meanwhile, I do think you need to take a chill pill with this whole "what about my other children!!!!" wail-fest mindset. It's exhausting and a sure fire way to create neurotic kids with persecution complexes.

Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 17:25

JenJuni · 25/05/2023 16:10

I think it can be tricky when you can only afford one proper child’s gift, maybe give her ideas of low cost gifts that she could afford three of?

The issue is that it’s several times throughout the year and on my DD’s birthday but my sons are always excluded. Now I have spoken to her about this, she has said in future she will buy a joint gift like some chocolate they can share

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 17:24

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 25/05/2023 17:13

But the ops dd doesn't have a special relationship with this woman, she is only her mum's friend, nothing more than that, exactly the same relationship as the ops 2 ds have

Exactly this. She isn’t an aunt or anyone even remotely close to her. She has the same relationship with all 3 children. As I have said previously I’ve never expected her to get any gifts in the first place. She’s made the choice to just give things to one of my children on several occasions randomly throughout the year and on birthdays

OP posts:
BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 25/05/2023 17:13

NoThanksymm · 25/05/2023 16:12

You’re being unreasonable.

your kids are loved and your little girl has a special relationship with an ‘auntie’ type. This little girl gets to feel special. Aunts are very very important for little girls (research supported, Google it).

the boys might need a special person too. Manage that. Not your friend.

a potential perspective from your friend. She’s shopping, sees something cute and girly she loves and thinks of your child (yay love!). Not so much for the boys, maybe as you mentioned as she has a boy.

and you are selfish enough to be trying to shut down this simple joy. OR to demand MORE presents.

YTA.

But the ops dd doesn't have a special relationship with this woman, she is only her mum's friend, nothing more than that, exactly the same relationship as the ops 2 ds have

NoThanksymm · 25/05/2023 16:12

You’re being unreasonable.

your kids are loved and your little girl has a special relationship with an ‘auntie’ type. This little girl gets to feel special. Aunts are very very important for little girls (research supported, Google it).

the boys might need a special person too. Manage that. Not your friend.

a potential perspective from your friend. She’s shopping, sees something cute and girly she loves and thinks of your child (yay love!). Not so much for the boys, maybe as you mentioned as she has a boy.

and you are selfish enough to be trying to shut down this simple joy. OR to demand MORE presents.

YTA.

JenJuni · 25/05/2023 16:10

I think it can be tricky when you can only afford one proper child’s gift, maybe give her ideas of low cost gifts that she could afford three of?

Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:27

RG89 · 25/05/2023 06:25

I am shocked how many people seem to find this ok! i have one child, most my friends have multiple, one has 5, if I'm getting for one child of a family, I'm getting for all! It won't always be of equal value as I go to their tastes not costs, but it will always be around the same amount, because it's wrong to show favouritism to a friend's kids. Kids aren't stupid, they notice a lot!

Exactly and I’m the exact same as you with other peoples kids. Children are quite sensitive and they notice more than people often realise

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:22

FabFitFifties · 25/05/2023 06:57

Is she your daughter's God Mother?

No she isn’t. She’s nothing to do with my daughter really. Just a friend of mine

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:22

silverfullmoon · 25/05/2023 06:21

I'm glad your friend has listened OP and I think you did absolutely the right thing. I'm actually quite shocked that some people have said its fine to shower one child with gifts and ignore others based solely on their gender. I wonder how they'd feel if it was your sons she was favouring solely because she didnt have a son. My guess is the responses would be very different then. Thats really messed up and the fact your boys have noticed this and asked why she prefers your daughter is evidence that its hurtful to kids and they do notice.

Ignore the people who said you are "ungrateful", you arent, you've explained multiple times that you appreciate the gesture greatly but feel it would be better to give no gifts than favour only one child. Thats perfectly reasonable and understandable.

Thank you 😊
I do believe I’ve done the right thing as it has been bugging me and I needed to say exactly how my boys are feeling about it and how it’s unfair to treat them differently.
Im just hoping things change from here forward as she has said she understands

OP posts:
Ilovepugs2017 · 25/05/2023 15:20

FFSFF · 25/05/2023 05:27

Yes thankfully she’s understood where I’m coming from 😊

Does she though?

I also can't understand how so many people on here think this is OK. Children come before friendships and their feeling matter - regardless of gender or age.

OP, if your friend ignores your requests and keeps doing this, I would distance myself from her permanently.

Well she says she understands so we will see how things go from here I guess. My little girls birthday is coming up soon and she was asking me what she is into at the moment etc! So I wanted to get it out in the open before she ends up getting something. My sons birthday is 8 days after and as I said previously I’d end up just having a text to say ‘oh wish x an happy birthday from me’.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread