Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I have kept my big mouth shut at work?

218 replies

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 17:38

I work for a large tech company and manage a very small, specialist team. My LM was sharing a ppt that he is planning on presenting to the wider team in a all hands call next week. It's a ppt concerning systemic racism and has come directly from People. We had a flurry of similar talks following George Floyd's death but not so much recently.

At the end when my manager was asking for input/feedback I (as a half Indian/English woman) said some may feel uncomfortable with being labelled "a victim" of racism. I as the only POC (white passing but that's beside the point) thought it was a fairly innocuous point to make and was just wanting my LM to strike the right tone. But after we got off the call one of my colleagues sent an IM to the effect of "what was that all about them?" and some other slightly disapproving/patronising comments. Tbg it seemed like it was said in advisory way from him - I've only recently been promoted.

Really scared I've messed up.

OP posts:
Perlosa · 23/05/2023 20:17

I can see trying to support my sentiment using the house ownership stat was weak/tenuous.

OP posts:
Perlosa · 23/05/2023 20:14

^appreciate the effort!

Hmm I didn't really explore why the term may be offensive. But you've put it very well @darjeelingrose. Thanks.

OP posts:
darjeelingrose · 23/05/2023 20:07

It wasn't massively clear. My problem was not with the abbreviations at all. I read it, read the thread and read it again. It was much clearer on a second reading. You have an issue with the word "victim" because within the context of the presentation, you feel like it reduces individuals to a reductive category, which could be prejudicial to them and the perception of them. But you didn't write that in your OP, you just put "the victim". It just needed a bit more explaining.

LuckyAmy1986 · 23/05/2023 20:05

I don't get how the two are linked. The house owning and the being subjected to racism thing.

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 19:59

Haha am I that incoherent? I really don't see how my OP is THAY difficult to understand. I assumed most people on mumsnet are probably professionals and would know lm, ppt etc

OP posts:
GoodChat · 23/05/2023 19:15

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 19:02

Agh I guess I don't know what I wanted, just giving my input as you do in situations like this.

If you don't know what you wanted you shouldn't have made comment. In situations like this you need to be able to portray what you're saying clearly and without emotion. You're trying to communicate to a room of people with different experiences.

1offnamechange · 23/05/2023 19:12

there's no nice way of saying this so I'm sorry for sounding bitchy - but given this thread as an example is it possible that what you said wasn't particularly coherent?

In which case you were definitely not unreasonable to make the point you did (as per calmdown's explanation of what you intended) but perhaps your colleague was right in that it didn't come across very well? You are interpreting their comments as disapproving/patronising but perhaps he's interpreting yours in a different way than you intended too. Sounds like nobody is really 'in the wrong' - perhaps just something to reflect on in future - have a think about exactly what you want to say, even if this means feeding back ten minutes later in writing rather than at the time, or getting someone you trust to read over it, rather than saying it straightaway.

It's good of you to provide feedback, lots of people just ignore and want to get back to work, and it sounds like you've got really valid points that would be valuable contribution - but if you're going to the effort of doing so you want to make sure people get what you're trying to say.

ClareBlue · 23/05/2023 19:10

I'm surprised two white people are making an issue with what the only POC attending says about being labelled a victim. It's not you that should keep their mouth shut. What you said is valid and don't let others make you doubt yourself. You are literally the only person there that actually experiences what they are talking about.
More worrying is that you are posting saying you should not have made the point and kept your big mouth shut. I think they should listen to what you have to say.

Quitelikeit · 23/05/2023 19:10

hmm I don’t know - perhaps your employer should consult an external agency in the future as surely expertise in this area would lie in that direction

I would say he/she did not intend to offend but really when you have no real life experience of that scenario then you are going to leave yourself vulnerable to different interpretations

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 19:03

Just because they own a home it does not mean they have not been a victim of something

I agree!

OP posts:
Perlosa · 23/05/2023 19:02

Agh I guess I don't know what I wanted, just giving my input as you do in situations like this.

OP posts:
Perlosa · 23/05/2023 19:00

Did you want the power point to say many POC have experienced racism rather than have been a victim of it?

Because what is the difference?

Hmm interesting, I personally do think there is a distinction between the two. And I believe my BI family members would agree (not 100% sure)

OP posts:
GoodChat · 23/05/2023 18:59

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 18:44

So you don't want them to call people of colour victims but you do want them to talk about how people of colour overcome adversity, is that right? No! Just that it's wrong to assume every single non-white person in the UK is going to identify with the term

Got you - so you don't want them to go with the approach that every non-white person is a victim?

Quitelikeit · 23/05/2023 18:56

Did you want the power point to say many POC have experienced racism rather than have been a victim of it?

Because what is the difference? I don’t think the language is offensive as if you are a victim of something then how is it offensive if someone points that out?

Also is it not ok to talk about home ownership in poc? Just because they own a home it does not mean they have not been a victim of something

Maybe next time if you are going to suggest something like amendments I would do it in private

Iiquidsnake · 23/05/2023 18:52

I can't stand management speak bollocks

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 18:49

There are a few British-Indians in the wider team so was just trying to avoid patronising them to be honest!

OP posts:
Perlosa · 23/05/2023 18:48

@ThatFraggle Oh thanks for the correction, per say did look wrong.

I hate paying lip service, guess I need to get used to it.

OP posts:
ThatFraggle · 23/05/2023 18:46

*per se

Not 'per say'

Carrotv · 23/05/2023 18:45

In case of doubt I understand you to be saying only that that 'victim' might be an unfortunate choice of word and that you were trying to make the training more nuanced. No one could reasonably have a problem with that ... but yet like another poster said there are no go areas these days especially when it comes to diversity training or similar and it's less stressful to just nod and smile.

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 18:45

Line manager is white. And so is the colleague that pulled me up.

OP posts:
Perlosa · 23/05/2023 18:44

So you don't want them to call people of colour victims but you do want them to talk about how people of colour overcome adversity, is that right? No! Just that it's wrong to assume every single non-white person in the UK is going to identify with the term

OP posts:
Perlosa · 23/05/2023 18:42

You may not have a job soon so dont worry

How reassuring haha!

OP posts:
GoodChat · 23/05/2023 18:41

So you don't want them to call people of colour victims but you do want them to talk about how people of colour overcome adversity, is that right?

Catchasingmewithspiders · 23/05/2023 18:41

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 18:39

No, so I said not all people will like the characterisation of being a victim of racism.

So when the slide showing crime, education and home ownership by ethnic group came up I said "this is what I'm talking about, in my experience some like to frame their accomplishments in terms of overcoming adversity". Or something like that.

The point is weak.

But I'm alarmed a colleague felt the need to nudge/correct me.

Is your colleague white or Indian?

Because if your colleague is white and you are giving your experience/feedback as a POC and they are feeling the need to correct you then that's on them not you.

Sounds a bit white saviourish swooping in to correct the POC that they are actually a victim after all even if they don't want to be called on.

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 18:41

@Calmdown14 YES! Thank you! This is why I read maths at university.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread