Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I have kept my big mouth shut at work?

218 replies

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 17:38

I work for a large tech company and manage a very small, specialist team. My LM was sharing a ppt that he is planning on presenting to the wider team in a all hands call next week. It's a ppt concerning systemic racism and has come directly from People. We had a flurry of similar talks following George Floyd's death but not so much recently.

At the end when my manager was asking for input/feedback I (as a half Indian/English woman) said some may feel uncomfortable with being labelled "a victim" of racism. I as the only POC (white passing but that's beside the point) thought it was a fairly innocuous point to make and was just wanting my LM to strike the right tone. But after we got off the call one of my colleagues sent an IM to the effect of "what was that all about them?" and some other slightly disapproving/patronising comments. Tbg it seemed like it was said in advisory way from him - I've only recently been promoted.

Really scared I've messed up.

OP posts:
Perlosa · 24/05/2023 01:25

@TooBigForMyBoots I have been subject to racist behaviour personally despite being white passing. I'm entitled to an opinion ghag deviates from the narrative that was being articulated.

Last year I went to get my car serviced, I clearly said to the mechanic please call me before adding/fixing parts (I like to shop around). Came back and the mechanic has made a change without my permission and demanded £300. Anyway, we got into a disagreement (I'm naturally polite/a people pleaser) and one point I felt the need to physically step back and the man rudely said "don't worry, I'm not going hit you" and then whispered "p*" under his breath. Yes I experienced racism but I'm no victim. I'm allowed to say that. I wanted to acknowledge "POC" are not a monolith and our experiences/views reflect that.

OP posts:
Catchasingmewithspiders · 24/05/2023 01:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You think the phrase people of colour is complete garbage and utter bollocks because one poster finds it uncomfortable to be blanket referred to as a victim when she doesn't feel like one?

That's an interesting thought process there

Aerin1999 · 24/05/2023 00:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

😂😂😂

TooBigForMyBoots · 24/05/2023 00:47

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 18:44

So you don't want them to call people of colour victims but you do want them to talk about how people of colour overcome adversity, is that right? No! Just that it's wrong to assume every single non-white person in the UK is going to identify with the term

Many UK citizens have been, and are, the victims of racism. They have no more problem with the term than victims of rape, bullying, muggings, burglaries, DV etc.

You may not identify with it @Perlosa but that is your own, 1 single person's, experience. I'm not surprised it has raised eyebrows among your colleagues and management.

I'm not sure what your point is wrt to your grandfather being a successful businessman.Confused His success does not mean that he and others like him, weren't victims of racism.

DojaPhat · 24/05/2023 00:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

bluegreygreen · 24/05/2023 00:19

@Perlosa Perhaps it would be useful to spell it out more simply for your colleagues, rather than use the topic of home owning, which requires a couple of additional steps in the thought process?

Hence - 'some people find the term 'victim' derogatory, and would prefer (x term) to be used instead'

What term would seem more reasonable?

Northe · 23/05/2023 22:59

I think it's much more likely that your colleague had got distracted and so when they hears your input, got in touch to find out what was going on. I doubt anyone is bothered by your comment and even if they are, I doubt they would do much about it

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 22:38

@Catchasingmewithspiders It sounds like you have a family OP who are doing well for themselves despite systemic racism, despite any hardships they have faced and by being called a victim it might feel (it would to me) like all of that hard work and effort has been wiped out and instead of being qualified, successful, hardworking people you are merely victims.

Very eloquently put, thank you! This is the exact argument my cousin made. That the term "victim" somehow reduces agency, minimising or discounting the hard work that goes into carving out success.

OP posts:
Perlosa · 23/05/2023 22:27

Apologies for making the assumption re mumsnetters being professionals. Just the impression I got from being on AIBU. Pretty sure i have seen LM used on previous threads and POC is everywhwere right now it seems. Did not mean to make you irrationally frustrated. It honestly didn't come from a negative place, my husband and I plan for me being a SAHM when the time comes.

OP posts:
Climbles · 23/05/2023 21:41

I think it was one of those situations where people say ‘I’d really like your input on this’ and what they mean is ‘say something good about my thing’. They didn’t want constructive feedback, so they shouldn’t have asked for it.

Irridescantshimmmer · 23/05/2023 21:37

I think your colleagues' reply to your very valid question, showed a glaring lack of sensitivity.

It is only natural that people of colour would prefer to be and seen as survivors as opposed to victims but not everyone has been on the recieving end of prejudice, so they have limited insight and understanding, hence their innapropriate reply to you.

MMAMPWGHAP · 23/05/2023 21:17

I 100% understood what you meant in your OP and in the following one re house ownership. I think the 2 white guys should have paid attention to what you were saying.

andweallsingalong · 23/05/2023 21:16

I think it was a good point, not sure if they understood in the moment so maybe clarify with a follow up email to your manager.

Agree with others that a white colleague correcting a POC isn't a good look and doesn't say much for the effectiveness of the training!

Grumpy67i8 · 23/05/2023 21:13

The person may have just been very confused, I couldn't understand any of your posts until a few of the replies here explained what you probably meant.

spidereggs · 23/05/2023 21:13

Agree with @1offnamechange entirely. But your subsequent post?

I assume that most people on Mumsnet are professional's?

Why?

Strange assumption to make which has irrationally annoyed me greatly. As an ex professional senior level twenty plus years, now sahm, who couldn't follow the abbreviations without Google

SparklyLeprechaun · 23/05/2023 20:59

Tbh I think your colleague just didn't understand the point you were trying to make. A bit like saying all women are victims of sexism - yes, sexism is pervasive, but I don't like being seen as a victim of sexism.

I wouldn't dwell on it, it's no big deal.

Iknowthis1 · 23/05/2023 20:55

I'm very familiar with tech company jargon and I can picture exactly the type of powerpoint.

I don't think you said anything wrong.

Augend23 · 23/05/2023 20:53

sadsack78 · 23/05/2023 20:22

I think you were just trying to be honest and have a more nuanced discussion around the issue.

Talking about racism is an area that makes people VERY nervous in schools, workplaces etc-- especially white people, especially companies where there is inadequate representation and most of the employees are white- where complaints might be filed and someone could be reprimanded. Everyone trips over themselves in a hysterical fit to be seen as not racist.

Which means viewpoints such as yours are met with confusion and shut down quickly, instead of being seen as an opportunity for everyone to develop empathy and understanding. You were trying to be heard, and were instead made to feel embarrassed and like you shouldn't have said anything. Even though you're the only POC there and your opinion needed to be heard.

This.

There's nothing wrong with what you said and you should have been listened to.

Redebs · 23/05/2023 20:50

I'm still confused by your objection. Is it the word victim that you don't like? What point was being made about home ownership?

Atethehalloweenchocs · 23/05/2023 20:46

I think victim is a very loaded word and can be quite stigmatizing - I work with people who have been subject to abuse and criminal activities and a lot of them dont want the word to be used in relation to them either. I can see your point that it would seem patronizing or belittling to some people - I guess the difficulty is knowing who may feel like this, and who welcome or prefer it?

Charley50 · 23/05/2023 20:43

I agree that 'victim' is a disempowering word, that encourages, well, a feeling of victimhood. 'Experience of' is more abstract and detached.

Bit cheeky your colleagues dismissed what you said. I've come to hate the whole EDI industry. We're importing so much of it from the US, and it seems to create division. Plus don't get me started on how much of the EDI budget tends to go on promoting trans ideology, which is actively harmful to women.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 23/05/2023 20:41

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 19:59

Haha am I that incoherent? I really don't see how my OP is THAY difficult to understand. I assumed most people on mumsnet are probably professionals and would know lm, ppt etc

It made sense to me but I do wonder if that's where the confusion from your colleague lies

I'm mixed race and I do not want to be seen or talked about as a victim. Have I experienced racism, yes. Have I experienced sexism, yes. Do all POC want to be referred to as a victim as a result, probably not. Do all women want to be referred to as a victim, probably not.

One of the impacts of systemic racism is the othering of a particular group of people due to their differences. Labeling all POC a victim just because they are POC feels othering to me. And passive and ineffectual as if POC are just drifting around being all victimy.

It sounds like you have a family OP who are doing well for themselves despite systemic racism, despite any hardships they have faced and by being called a victim it might feel (it would to me) like all of that hard work and effort has been wiped out and instead of being qualified, successful, hardworking people you are merely victims.

And quite frankly if a white person takes it upon themselves to tone police, or take issue with a POCs input into a presentation on systemic racism they need to take a long hard look at where they fit into the conversation.

And yes, an all hands presentation at work that presented me as a victim automatically from a senior white manager would rankle with me as well.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 23/05/2023 20:35

PerfectYear321 · 23/05/2023 20:29

I'm confused. You said you were the only POC there but also said every British Indian person at the table agreed

She's talking about the last time she had lunch with her family and something her cousin said that resonated with the point she was trying to make in the meeting

PerfectYear321 · 23/05/2023 20:29

I'm confused. You said you were the only POC there but also said every British Indian person at the table agreed

sadsack78 · 23/05/2023 20:22

I think you were just trying to be honest and have a more nuanced discussion around the issue.

Talking about racism is an area that makes people VERY nervous in schools, workplaces etc-- especially white people, especially companies where there is inadequate representation and most of the employees are white- where complaints might be filed and someone could be reprimanded. Everyone trips over themselves in a hysterical fit to be seen as not racist.

Which means viewpoints such as yours are met with confusion and shut down quickly, instead of being seen as an opportunity for everyone to develop empathy and understanding. You were trying to be heard, and were instead made to feel embarrassed and like you shouldn't have said anything. Even though you're the only POC there and your opinion needed to be heard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread