Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I have kept my big mouth shut at work?

218 replies

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 17:38

I work for a large tech company and manage a very small, specialist team. My LM was sharing a ppt that he is planning on presenting to the wider team in a all hands call next week. It's a ppt concerning systemic racism and has come directly from People. We had a flurry of similar talks following George Floyd's death but not so much recently.

At the end when my manager was asking for input/feedback I (as a half Indian/English woman) said some may feel uncomfortable with being labelled "a victim" of racism. I as the only POC (white passing but that's beside the point) thought it was a fairly innocuous point to make and was just wanting my LM to strike the right tone. But after we got off the call one of my colleagues sent an IM to the effect of "what was that all about them?" and some other slightly disapproving/patronising comments. Tbg it seemed like it was said in advisory way from him - I've only recently been promoted.

Really scared I've messed up.

OP posts:
Perlosa · 24/05/2023 06:13

@WalkaroundPointing out how successful the British Indian community have been as a group by pointing to house ownership as a sign of their success and non-victimhood, despite “experiencing racism,” could be seen by some as believing in a hierarchy of races, or notions of superiority, which sounds pretty racist in itself.

Okay, so put like that I can see how someone may interpret what I said as offensive.

Absolutely not my view just to be clear.

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 24/05/2023 06:09

From what you’re saying, the “what was that all about” was criticism rather than confusion. Have you answered him?

Walkaround · 24/05/2023 06:05

I can see what you are getting at, but another POC might interpret your viewpoint as victim blaming, as though you think it’s their choice to see themselves as a victim and that’s all that is holding them back. Pointing out how successful the British Indian community have been as a group by pointing to house ownership as a sign of their success and non-victimhood, despite “experiencing racism,” could be seen by some as believing in a hierarchy of races, or notions of superiority, which sounds pretty racist in itself. So, basically, you can’t win! Stereotypical views of different races do affect experiences of racism - racists don’t actually lump all ethnic minority groups together as one homogenous mass, they may view them all as inferior, but assign different negative characteristics to different groups, meaning there may be different experiences and effects of racism for different groups. Racism certainly has an unwelcome effect on all minority groups, though.

ferntwist · 24/05/2023 06:05

Your colleague was quite wrong to message you criticising your comments. What was his objection?

peachicecream · 24/05/2023 05:59

Mamaneedsadrink · 24/05/2023 05:56

Honestly OP, don't bother and leave them to it. Let these people make fools of themselves and then congratulate themselves for being such great ambassadors against racism like many posters on here, because you know they know best. Smh.

How is that helpful?

I get that it's infuriating, frustrating, and very easy to get to a point where you want to throw your arms up and go "fuck it" when it feels like people do not understand.

But surely trying to communicate, discuss and explain these things is the way forward for everyone.

Mamaneedsadrink · 24/05/2023 05:56

Honestly OP, don't bother and leave them to it. Let these people make fools of themselves and then congratulate themselves for being such great ambassadors against racism like many posters on here, because you know they know best. Smh.

peachicecream · 24/05/2023 05:53

OP, I don't think I understand the full thread and haven't followed everything that's being said, but I do see where you are coming from about the us of the phrase 'victims' of racism.

Maybe you should just focus on that specific phraseology with your manager and try to articulate to him exactly why it's problematic?

Are there any other colleagues or people you know who are people of colour or from global majority ethniciites who you could speak to and help you find a way to articulate this?

I would talk it through with some friends (ideally who are not white British), get some outside opinions and then write an email to your boss and maybe copy in HR just clarifying why you feel that the use of 'victims' wasn't appropriate. It doesn't have to be aggressive but just explaining.

Mamaneedsadrink · 24/05/2023 05:48

orangegato · 24/05/2023 05:16

White people pulling you up because of your valid opinions, as clearly they know more about racism. Wow

I was thinking the exact same thing. Sad and depressing. Unbelievable really 😒

Perlosa · 24/05/2023 05:47

Also who are the 'People' it has come directly from?

Sorry that should have read 'People team'

OP posts:
Perlosa · 24/05/2023 05:43

@CabbagePatchDole And there is also a small but growing number of black people who are becoming very successful and wealthy, but that does not make them immune from racism.

And I have made that exact point in this discussion.

OP posts:
Perlosa · 24/05/2023 05:39

@CabbagePatchDole the implication of your statement is that Asians should not be lumped in with other ethnicities who you perceive as not doing so well.

colleagues are right. The OP comes from a place of condescension: Asians are better off than blacks (for instance)

But how is that the implication? I think you are being incredibly unfair and divisive.

OP posts:
orangegato · 24/05/2023 05:16

White people pulling you up because of your valid opinions, as clearly they know more about racism. Wow

Redebs · 24/05/2023 04:41

CabbagePatchDole · 24/05/2023 02:46

OP, with all due respect, you don’t seem to understand systemic racism. Not every Asian in this country is lucky enough to own businesses and property by the way. And there is also a small but growing number of black people who are becoming very successful and wealthy, but that does not make them immune from racism. Racism is not necessarily about personal wealth, although it can be a component of it as many black people are often denied the opportunity to make good money.

the implication of your statement is that Asians should not be lumped in with other ethnicities who you perceive as not doing so well. This is very insulting. I have come across this sort of thing before and if there were black colleagues in the room some
of them may well have been disgusted by what you said. Well done to your colleague for calling it out.

Yes, very well put

MysteryBelle · 24/05/2023 04:39

Calmdown14 · 23/05/2023 18:39

I think that you are trying to say that while many people may be impacted by racism, continuous use of the word 'victim' almost feels like another form of micro aggression.

If as a person of colour, you are automatically put into the category of 'victim' it can contribute to the perceptions others have of you and undermine the way you are viewed in terms of social standing, career or educational achievements etc.

Perhaps just send a conciliatory email to say you appreciated the presentation and can see a lot of work has gone into it but that a couple of minor tweaks to the wording would help to make it more inclusive for those, like your family members, who do not identify with the word victim.

Well said

AliceOlive · 24/05/2023 04:24

You have a right to share your views and feelings. I doubt you’ll have any major blowback but also doubt it will make any difference to the people pushing these presentations.

quice · 24/05/2023 04:13

Being able to write clearly and concisely is a skill you lack, OP.

Ultimately you need to understand that group meetings are not the place to raise sensitive issues about race. If someone publicly asks for PowerPoint feedback, they are just looking for token comments of support. They probably spent time & effort creating it and just wanted to show it off. They’re not trying to be blindsided about the tone they used concerning race, you likely embarrassed them. They’re not wanting to hear someone talking for the sake of it…like you were during the slide about home ownership. You essentially challenged them unintentionally. Welcome to office politics.

conversations about race in the workplace do tend to be token gestures, but in their defence it can take years for the culture to meaningfully change and this presentation might be a step in the right direction. ultimately when challenging people, you need to tread carefully as to not create an awkward atmosphere in a meeting and make your point succinctly & clearly. Sometimes it’s better to say nothing especially if your point isn’t tangible

barmycatmum · 24/05/2023 04:03

I don’t think you should have kept your mouth shut, no.
as women (let alone a minority woman!) it’s so Ingrained in us not to make waves, isn’t it. F*ck that.
they can learn from your insight. And for what it’s worth, I do agree. The victims word being overused puts the emphasis in the wrong place.

perpetrators of racism are the ones who need to do the work to change their behavior. To call people “victims” is reductive.

your colleague is the one who is out of line, I think. Wtf, unless you’re close, messaging you that was wildly inappropriate; you said nothing wrong.

Valeriekat · 24/05/2023 04:01

Not pocket POC ffs

Valeriekat · 24/05/2023 04:01

TooBigForMyBoots · 24/05/2023 00:47

Many UK citizens have been, and are, the victims of racism. They have no more problem with the term than victims of rape, bullying, muggings, burglaries, DV etc.

You may not identify with it @Perlosa but that is your own, 1 single person's, experience. I'm not surprised it has raised eyebrows among your colleagues and management.

I'm not sure what your point is wrt to your grandfather being a successful businessman.Confused His success does not mean that he and others like him, weren't victims of racism.

I certainly hope that you are a pocket otherwise you are "whitesplaining"!

Valeriekat · 24/05/2023 03:57

ClareBlue · 23/05/2023 19:10

I'm surprised two white people are making an issue with what the only POC attending says about being labelled a victim. It's not you that should keep their mouth shut. What you said is valid and don't let others make you doubt yourself. You are literally the only person there that actually experiences what they are talking about.
More worrying is that you are posting saying you should not have made the point and kept your big mouth shut. I think they should listen to what you have to say.

Well put.

Valeriekat · 24/05/2023 03:54

Perlosa · 23/05/2023 18:45

Line manager is white. And so is the colleague that pulled me up.

How dare you go off message! How dare you go against their feeling that they understand "racism" better than a person of colour. They are patronising and I think you should refer to their internalised racism.

Minime88888888 · 24/05/2023 03:53

Your manager asked for feedback and you gave it. How very generous of you. If your colleague wants to further understand 'what that was all about?' you may feel like elaborating but I don't think I'd waste my breath. Try not to worry too much about this.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 24/05/2023 03:45

I don't fully understand. I would like to know what the colleague said. I would also like to know where material came from for the PPT. Also, will any other ethnic groups be able to give insight before it is delivered. The whole thing seems a bit slap dash. Structural racism is too important for that.

Thesheerrelief · 24/05/2023 03:37

You have a very valid point. You didn't explain it clearly in your posts - nothing to do with abbreviations - just that the link between the usage of the word victim and your example of house ownership didn't seem to have a connection until it was explained properly a few posts in.

Assuming your colleague got the point you were making it seems inappropriate that he's querying it in a condescending manner or implying he somehow has more insight or perspective than you.

Violasaremyfavourite · 24/05/2023 03:32

I think it was relevant that the the OP spoke about this in the context of being half Indian. It doesn't mean she thinks black people should be labelled as victims and not Indian or that Indians were in some way superior to black people.

You were asked for input/feedback and you gave it.

The thing is that a lot of Mumsnet users (and other people online too tbf) only have to see a word and they leap on it like a hyena and create a whole narrative based on their views. It avoids the necessity of thinking which can be difficult and uncomfortable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread