Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this BBC response to complaints about the ADHD exposed programme on Panorama is inadequate

58 replies

waronadhd · 23/05/2023 11:45

disclaimer: I am one of the people who has complained.

BBC recently responded to complaints made about the episode of Panorama called ADHD Private Clinics Exposed, where a journalist got diagnosed with ADHD by three private clinics, but not by an NHS assessment done by a consultant.

Their response:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact/complaint/panoramaprivateadhdclinicsexposed

AIBU to think this is not good enough? They sent a generic response to a much-complained about programme, and did not address my main gripes with it, which is about factually misrepresenting the NHS.

As mentioned by others, NHS Tees, NHS Esk, and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation all say that an adult ADHD assessment can take between 1-2 hours. Meanwhile North West London NHS Foundation Trust says an assessment can up to 90 minutes. This is not 3 hours, as the programme claims is what is necessary for a good assessment, implying that private clinics fall short of a target that is standard in the NHS.

The BBC also love to mention high rates of diagnosis in the private sector, but there are NHS clinics with much higher rates of positive diagnoses (95% at one clinic for example). Panorama is claiming that this programme has not resulted in any additional stigma for ADHD sufferers, but I don't think this is true at all. There have already been stories online of shared care being withdrawn.

In some parts of the country (Yorkshire for example) you cannot even get assessed for ADHD as an adult at the moment, unless you are acutely in danger of self-harm or harming others. This includes scenarios involving children with ADHD ageing out of childhood services and suddenly losing access to the medication they rely on when reaching 18.

This programme had the potential to highlight all the issues and failures in care that are happening in the UK regarding adult ADHD, in both the private sector and the NHS. Instead it presented a biased report of shoddy private clinics and an exemplary NHS service that is simply a bit overstretched, giving rise to even more stigma and negative attention to a disorder which is under diagnosed in women as is. I think it's depressing that the response to the complaint talks about people not enjoying the programme, completely ignoring the questions about factual accuracy and potential damage caused.

Panorama: Private ADHD Clinics Exposed, approach to the programme, BBC One, 15 May 2023 | Contact the BBC

We received complaints from some viewers who questioned Panorama’s approach and were concerned the programme might stigmatise people with ADHD.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact/complaint/panoramaprivateadhdclinicsexposed

OP posts:
Yesterda123 · 23/05/2023 15:20

Spacestace · 23/05/2023 14:30

In some parts of the country (Yorkshire for example) you cannot even get assessed for ADHD as an adult at the moment, unless you are acutely in danger of self-harm or harming others

And this is why NHS diagnoses rates appear to be so high, because the threshold to get anywhere near an assessment is high- it's self selecting really. Compared with someone logging onto a website, paying some £ and then having a sub optimal video chat. Sure some private clinics are not out solely to make money, but the issue is some are and rely on people keen to find for answers and willing to spend £££s on doing so combined with people being desperate because they can't access NHS services; it's a very lucrative business.

I watched the documentary and didn't feel it minimised ADHD, but was critical of businesses diagnosing people on what is usually an assessment that falls far short of clinical guidelines. It's important vulnerable people aren't taken advantage of.

I agree.

Spacestace · 23/05/2023 14:30

In some parts of the country (Yorkshire for example) you cannot even get assessed for ADHD as an adult at the moment, unless you are acutely in danger of self-harm or harming others

And this is why NHS diagnoses rates appear to be so high, because the threshold to get anywhere near an assessment is high- it's self selecting really. Compared with someone logging onto a website, paying some £ and then having a sub optimal video chat. Sure some private clinics are not out solely to make money, but the issue is some are and rely on people keen to find for answers and willing to spend £££s on doing so combined with people being desperate because they can't access NHS services; it's a very lucrative business.

I watched the documentary and didn't feel it minimised ADHD, but was critical of businesses diagnosing people on what is usually an assessment that falls far short of clinical guidelines. It's important vulnerable people aren't taken advantage of.

waronadhd · 23/05/2023 14:28

Yesterda123 · 23/05/2023 13:45

My local NHS Adult ADHD clinic does 3 hr assessments.

I never said that none of the NHS clinics do 3 hour assessments, just that many don't, and that the BBC has falsely claimed that NHS assessments are 3 hours long across the board, regardless of trust.

OP posts:
waronadhd · 23/05/2023 14:25

Colourfingers2 · 23/05/2023 13:47

Hasn’t anyone ever wondered why there was no such thing as ADHD or ADD before Ritalin was invented? In fact there are an awful lot more disorders and the like being diagnosed to fuel an ever burgeoning prescription drug market. For instance Personality Disorders were only invented in either 1981 or 1986 and guess which drug to treat it miraculously appeared then.

Except that is not true at all. The first descriptions of children exhibiting ADHD-type symptoms date from about 1798, though back then it was referred to as a defect of moral control, possibly resulting from brain damage.

Also, how long it has been since something became officially named and recognised as a disorder is not linked to its validity. Autism as it is known today only became an official diagnosis in 1943 (around the same time Ritalin was invented), is that fake too? More and more people are being diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease and at a younger age due to advances in medical knowledge. Is this problematic to you?

OP posts:
Colourfingers2 · 23/05/2023 13:47

Hasn’t anyone ever wondered why there was no such thing as ADHD or ADD before Ritalin was invented? In fact there are an awful lot more disorders and the like being diagnosed to fuel an ever burgeoning prescription drug market. For instance Personality Disorders were only invented in either 1981 or 1986 and guess which drug to treat it miraculously appeared then.

Yesterda123 · 23/05/2023 13:45

My local NHS Adult ADHD clinic does 3 hr assessments.

FergalforPM · 23/05/2023 13:42

The BBC always responds in a patronising defensive manner to any criticism.

Wintry57 · 23/05/2023 11:49

think it’s a real shame that we’ve had several good documentaries on autism (Christine McGuiness, Chris Packham) really trying to increase understanding and all I’ve seen on ADHD is stuff minimising and rubbishing it.

I haven’t seen the show but I read an article about it and it’s not helpful, not insightful and not what adults or kids struggling with ADHD need - it’s a free pass to sneer.