Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my inlaws are being used as flying monkeys?

110 replies

chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 09:28

Long story but am no contact with my narcissistic mother for 4 years no contact with my enabling father for 2 years.

Recently, and I posted about it here, my mother in law, with whom I get on really well, bumped into my mother in the middle of town and told her there was a street fête on their street. She said, "do pop over if you're in the neighbourhood." Lo and behold, my parents arrived.

My mother was crying to my mother in law about how horrible I am and she was berating my husband too, to my mother in law (her own son!!). Once we heard from MIL that she had told my mother to "pop round" for the street fête, both DH and I did not attend the street fête, as we knew my parents would jump at the opportunity to attend.

MIL told DH afterwards how my mother was crying, but then was saying awful things about me and DH. She said she even felt a bit sorry for her!

Now it transpires that my sister in law, who it also turns out was at the street fête that day, was WITH my MIL when my mother launched her tirade against me. I've just found out that my SIL also "felt sorry" for my MIL and decided to invite her to her house for dinner this weekend!

I'm completely gobsmacked. I've only heard this from my MIL, who kind of said it by accident.

I don't know why my SIL would do this. It is none of her business! I've never been overly close to my SIL but at the same time I've never had a disagreement with her.

I feel betrayed, sidelined and very upset.

DH messaged his sister to ask why she's doing this and her reply was "to be a good person to older people who are struggling." SIL does not know the details of the estrangement between me and my parents as I have always ensured I don't wash my dirty linen in public! But suffice to say that she does know we are estranged.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Lovingitallnow · 23/05/2023 14:32

Are they your SIL's neighbours? I remember a thread where she wanted to invite them as her neighbours for Xmas dinner instead of her SIL's alcoholic NC parents. And got her arse handed to her.

LacewingOrpington · 23/05/2023 14:30

My sibling keeps doing this with my in-laws who were very low contact with and I resist the urge to tell them how it’s obvious they can’t resist because “birds of a feather flock together”! They delights in bringing them up and saying “sorry to upset you but…”. I think they misjudge what upsets me. I believe they thinks I find it upsetting that they chooses to be closer to my in-laws than I am, whereas it upsets me as yet another reminder how theu don’t have my back.

My parents have mostly been the opposite, they made different decisions with my grandparents who were just as bad if not worse, so have expressed some struggles with our preferred approach but they’ve always had my DH and my back.

I think this is a situation where when someone shows you who they are, believe them. I would always have my children and their partners and my siblings back even if I would view it differently from them and make different decisions myself. There is no reason for them to have a relationship with your family and the fact they actively choose to do this has likely meant they’ve treated your DH in a similar way all his life and part of the reason you and your DH emotionally understand each other. IMO It is not appropriate to interject yourself into your children’s relationship with their in-laws, your siblings relationship with their in-laws or even your friends’ relationships with their family or in-laws.

SeaPink · 23/05/2023 14:20

People like your mum can be very convincing. My mum's the same. She was an aggressive bully to me and my dad behind closed doors but her public face is sweet and helpless.
I'd just leave your in laws to get on with it. They might live to regret it

MzHz · 23/05/2023 14:15

Timeforchangeithink · 23/05/2023 10:05

Quite honestly your SIL obviously wants to know why you are NC, nothing more,nothing less. No point in saying anything to her, she's shown what she thinks of you and her brother so I guess there's another Christmas present you don't have to buy. Bloody families!

To be fair, mothers like @chicosmommy‘s are VERY good at making people feel sorry for them and using others as flying monkeys, they make up all kinds of shit about us to make themselves look wronged and the victim when the utter reverse is true.

I’ll go further to say that SIL may not be familiar with a toxic dynamic and she can’t possibly imagine that this poor old lady act is anything other than truth.

we…. On the other hand keep our laundry washing private which might feel like the right thing to do, but it creates a space for toxic person to fill. Our Fear, Obligation and Guilt means we can’t go round telling the truth because we’d never be believed anyway

if I were you, I’d get dh to speak to his sister and tell her what’s gone on and why you’re NC and that while she’s welcome to speak to who she likes, it feels a massive betrayal and creates a real threat to the peace and happiness not only in your immediate family but SIL/Mil too and to be VERY wary of what your DM is saying as it’s just not true

tell SIL that there’s very good reason for ALL her kids to have gone NC with her.

Bananarepublic · 23/05/2023 14:12

WheelsUp · 23/05/2023 10:20

People who have good decent parents don't understand why someone would go NC with them. You see it on here. Someone posts about their parents behaving awfully and you can spot the people with normal parents because they'll say something like just explain how it makes you feel in a letter because a reasonable person will consider their behaviour if someone tells them that they are upset. They don't understand that there's years of pain and you know how your parents think because they tell you in detail and assume that you want to know because their feelings are the most important in the world.

I know that I am doing the same thing by saying that they don't mean harm but my experience is that people with normal parents can't and will never understand.

This is so true. It happens on here all the time. Not just with family members but also with DHs - just talk to them! As if abusive people stop being abusive if you have a little chat.

Another thing is that I think there's a bit of ego involved, a bit like when people think your child doesn't sleep because you're not trying hard enough and they would do it better - they think they could do your family relationships better than you do. It's infuriating.

OP in this circumstance I'm not sure if I'd say much. I agree with @takealettermsjones approach, just say it once and don't listen to any follow up conversations.

Batalax · 23/05/2023 13:57

Give your mother enough rope and she’ll hang herself. As pp say, make sure they know it’s your siblings too, then refuse to engage with anything concerning her name.

diddl · 23/05/2023 13:55

Your MIL might be kind but imo she's a bloody idiot!

and she was berating my husband too, to my mother in law (her own son!!).

And yet she still invited them!

So she's either as nosy as SIL or she doesn't car too much for her son & his wife!

billy1966 · 23/05/2023 13:48

You poor woman.

You will need to be strong.
His sister is being deliberately nasty as she doesn't like you.

Have nothing further to do with her.

Your MIL is sneaky and underhand but not the brightest button in the box, as she let the cat out of the bag.

@TheChoiceIsYours message is excellent.

You need to protect yourself from them all, even that husband of yours who is scared of his own shadow.

They have zero loyalty to you, so you will need to be resolute in your boundaries.

Awful people.

RedHelenB · 23/05/2023 13:42

You can't control your ILs invitations. Since you won't tell them why you're nc they're only getting your mums side of things. Other than making it perfectly clear you won't attend social events with them there is nothing else you can do other than ignore.

pickledandpuzzled · 23/05/2023 13:35

I'd message MiL a bit differently-

You're a really kind woman and I know you are trying to help. You think that you can help rebuild the good relationship all families should have, and save my parents feelings.

I know it's hard for you to understand but unfortunately they aren't like you, or most parents. They aren't 'just a bit difficult'. They are very good at hiding what they are really like. All my siblings and I have had to distance ourselves to keep us and our children safe.

Please be very careful what you tell them. They are very manipulative, and don't care who they hurt to get what they want.

I had hoped not to drag you into it- it's embarrassing and upsetting, and I'd have preferred to keep it private. Unfortunately they've started to rope you and SiL in so I thought I'd better warn you to be careful.

Blort · 23/05/2023 13:33

Well, I really hope this comes back to massively bite them in the arse!!

chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 13:27

Sorry I can't reply individually to everyone...I just don't have the time with work. I've read every message, most twice at this stage. So many people in the same boat as me. And such great advice. Thank you all so much. And good luck to you all who are in the same boat - Lord knows we need it. Thank you

OP posts:
Supersimkin2 · 23/05/2023 13:25

Dyou know what, let them
get on with it. It doesn’t have to be a big deal. The less you show you care, the more power you hold.

You could say afterwards: ‘I expect they had a great gossip. Thing is, if I was going to tell on my mother, I’d start with the police. So would her other children. I was a bit hurt at first by SIL marching in where angels fear to tread, but it’s a free country.’

Heatwavenotify · 23/05/2023 13:24

To add I wouldn’t justify your reason for being NC with your mother to them either. It’s frankly none of their business. They know you are NC and that’s enough.

You have to look at two things. Firstly if they love and respect you as a family member they would support you without having to know the ins and outs. They have no relationship with her but they do have with you. You are allowed privacy and your relationship or lack of has no impact on their lives.

Secondly what is the motive. You are not close to your SIL so she isn’t doing it with misguided but loving intentions. Your MIL knew you wouldn’t attend the party and wouldn’t have told you about the SIL plans had she not been caught out. They both know what they are doing and doing it regardless. Your DH needs to put you first here because he knows it is wrong. If he won’t then I wouldn’t be visiting again and he will have to deal with that instead. By treating his wife this way they are in fact treating him with little respect also. He may want to reflect on that.

Escapingafter50years · 23/05/2023 13:23

The simple answer is Yes, your inlaws are being used as flying monkeys. Not just that, but willingly. Their behaviour is so disrespectful to you.

"He doesn't want to "upset" his mother. If he reads his sister the riot act, she'll just go crying to his mother, which will upset his mother."

Sorry OP, but this explains a lot. Your DH has dysfunction in his family as well as you, and it's not confined to his sister. His mother has brought him up to behave exactly as she wants, or she will be upset - and your DH understands that his mother being upset is so awful that it must be avoided at all costs, he has been trained like this from an early age so it is ingrained behaviour.

Your MIL and SIL colluded to keep the invitation extended to your parents a secret from you. They are not your friends and tread very carefully.

You cannot tell your SIL not to see your parents as advised earlier in this thread, that will only make her more determined. It is an awful situation for you and I feel your pain. I do think it is worth giving your MIL more information about your background and what you and your siblings have suffered. It is not washing your dirty laundry in public, you are stating your lived experience. Also, abuse thrives in secrecy and so many people get away with it because their victims cover up for them (been there). Perhaps it would be best for both you and your DH to address this with your MIL so she knows you are together on this? As to his sister, if he talks to her I would think "reading her the riot act" will only make things infinitely worse. He could approach it from a questioning point -
Why did you ask her?
Do you know that chicosmommys siblings are no contact with her mother too?
Do you think chicosmommy & her siblings have no relationship with her for no good reason?
Who do you think is more important in our family, chicosmommy or her mother?
You know I stand beside my wife on this - what do you think will happen if you put her mother ahead of my relationship with my wife?
How can we continue to have a relationship with you if you disrespect my wife in this way?
So he's not accusing her but asking her to reflect. I suspect he would need a lot of patience and given the SILs behaviour and what you have said about her and your MIL, I wouldn't hold out a lot of hope.
He could ask her, if she's determined to have your parents over, to at least have enough respect for you to not discuss you with your parents.

Also try posting on the Stately Homes thread, there are far too many of us there who have experienced narcissistic abuse, but there is great support and advice to be found there.

TwoFluffyDogsOnMyBed · 23/05/2023 13:19

She won’t show her true colours to your SIL though and both parties will enjoy their mutual dislike of you. Your mum wants validation that she’s right and SIL will provide that…she won’t to lose her ‘supply’. She’s gathering her flying monkeys.

I would completely ignore SIL and focus on MIL. Just explain the situation to her and make absolutely sure that she knows that if anything is said regarding you, to take it with a pinch of salt.

My mum isn’t a narcissist as such - she means well but she does a lot of this sort of manipulation between family members. She thinks that she can control the family dynamics and try to make things better but she isn’t socially aware enough to do so. I often have to warn other family members (my sons in particular) to not take anything she says seriously. It’s impossible to speak to my mother because if anyone tries to tell her the truth her brain sort of implodes and she has a weird episode. Your MIL sounds nice so confide in her and tell her that you love her and you’re scared that your mother could ruin your relationship.

Zarataralara · 23/05/2023 13:15

Alcoholics are frequently manipulative. And even without that thrown into the mix your narcissistic mother will look for sympathy and play the victim card anywhere she can. She can’t get to you so she’ll get in wherever she can. My mother never missed an opportunity to slag me off, anywhere, anytime.
You can explain to your mil and SIL that they’re being used but whether they choose to take notice is anyone’s guess.

Iwasafool · 23/05/2023 13:02

I had the same thing but the other way round i.e. my mum feeling sorry for nasty MIL. In the end I just said it's her or me. She was taken aback, tried to justify it and I just repeated it's her or me, up to you. She decided on me.

WalnutWhippy · 23/05/2023 13:01

saraclara · 23/05/2023 12:44

Please ensure that they both know that ALL your siblings are also NC with your mum.
That's far harder for your mum to explain away than if it was just you. And it should make MIL and SIL pause for thought, surely?

Yes, I'd mention that to your MIL and leave it there. You don't want to get into trading stories about your mother the way she will do about you. Hopefully the SIL won't be able to manipulate your MIL into believing your mother's rubbish.

saraclara · 23/05/2023 12:58

Does your MIL know how your mum treated your DH in the past? Because I think his involvement here should be with her, not SIL. He can calmly say to his mum that, while he understands that she wanted to be kind to a distressed person, she really needs to recognise what this woman did and said to him, and that when you and all your siblings have no contact with her, she can surely understand that the problem is with your mum and not you.

He doesn't have to 'upset her' he just needs to have a conversation that makes it clear how inappropriate it is for his family to strike up a friendship with her. Both from your perspective and his own, given that your mum was shitty to him too.

AliceMcK · 23/05/2023 12:56

Let your SIL crack on and if she brings them up grey rock the hell out of her. If she persists I’d tell her to stay out of your personal business or your going to fall out with her.

I’ve no idea if my In-laws are in contact with my mother, they were fb friends before I went NC, I’ve blocked my mother so can’t see if they are still in touch and to be honest I don’t care anymore. My FIL will occasionally ask if I’ve heard from her I either pretend I haven’t heard him or say nup and walk away. I don’t think my DHs siblings couldn’t care less about my family issues. I think FIL may still have my SIL (brothers wife) who I’m also NC with, on fb as in the past he has said things about them like being on holiday.

My in-laws know most of why I’m NC though as they witnessed some of it. FIL & MIL are of a generation where they try and smooth over toxic behaviour but SIL sees it for what it is and I knows DH & I are doing what we need to do to protect my mental health and our children.

I do have a cousin who is now very close to my mother, she’s not stupid, she’s a very smart woman but has a weird loyalty thing towards my mother. I don’t know the full starry but my mother works in mental health (O the irony) and something happened with my cousin and my mother was there for her. That’s between them, I haven’t let it effect my relationship with my cousin, we are not close but do get on, she dosnt talk about my mother to me and I’m fine with that.

One thing I do do is I have my fb completely locked down, only a select few people see my posts and I’ve made sure they are people I trust not to share anything with my mother, especially photos of my children. I never tag anyone in pictures who could potentially be friends with my mother either.

if your in-laws persist in their relationship with your mother and you feel they are too involved I’d phase them out of things and if they ask why they don’t see photos anymore or get invited to things or you stop going to things be clear about them choosing to insert themselves into your family has effected your relationship with them now.

whynotwhatknot · 23/05/2023 12:53

Your dh is a bit of wimp saying he wont do anything to upset his mother

telling her youve been abused by this woman isnt upsetting anyone its a bloody fact

yyour sil doesnt sound very nice just watch your back

Pipsquiggle · 23/05/2023 12:51

You've had some good advice on here. You need to make it clear to SIL & MIL that it's not just you that is NC with your mum but all your siblings as well, so it doesn't turn into a you vs your mum argument.

I personally would tell SIL /MIL as much as you feel comfortable. Your mum has already made part of your life awful, why should you allow her to come into it now?

As for SIL and MIL, although well meaning, you need to tell them that by inviting this woman into their lives they are effectively cutting off your DH & you. Make it clear you will not share any space or time with your mother. They need to make a choice as to who they want in their lives.

NeedToThinkOfOne · 23/05/2023 12:45

As others have said
People who have good decent parents don't understand why someone would go NC with them.

I really feel for you OP, you’re in a v.similar situation to mine and look at all these posts from people who experience the same. You’re not alone, nor are YBU. We all have that stomach churning feeling when something like this happens, makes you appreciate the calmness of NC times.

Here’s hoping your relatives show their true colours at the lunch invite and your SIL might start to see things from your POV.

saraclara · 23/05/2023 12:44

Please ensure that they both know that ALL your siblings are also NC with your mum.
That's far harder for your mum to explain away than if it was just you. And it should make MIL and SIL pause for thought, surely?