Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my inlaws are being used as flying monkeys?

110 replies

chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 09:28

Long story but am no contact with my narcissistic mother for 4 years no contact with my enabling father for 2 years.

Recently, and I posted about it here, my mother in law, with whom I get on really well, bumped into my mother in the middle of town and told her there was a street fête on their street. She said, "do pop over if you're in the neighbourhood." Lo and behold, my parents arrived.

My mother was crying to my mother in law about how horrible I am and she was berating my husband too, to my mother in law (her own son!!). Once we heard from MIL that she had told my mother to "pop round" for the street fête, both DH and I did not attend the street fête, as we knew my parents would jump at the opportunity to attend.

MIL told DH afterwards how my mother was crying, but then was saying awful things about me and DH. She said she even felt a bit sorry for her!

Now it transpires that my sister in law, who it also turns out was at the street fête that day, was WITH my MIL when my mother launched her tirade against me. I've just found out that my SIL also "felt sorry" for my MIL and decided to invite her to her house for dinner this weekend!

I'm completely gobsmacked. I've only heard this from my MIL, who kind of said it by accident.

I don't know why my SIL would do this. It is none of her business! I've never been overly close to my SIL but at the same time I've never had a disagreement with her.

I feel betrayed, sidelined and very upset.

DH messaged his sister to ask why she's doing this and her reply was "to be a good person to older people who are struggling." SIL does not know the details of the estrangement between me and my parents as I have always ensured I don't wash my dirty linen in public! But suffice to say that she does know we are estranged.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WomanStanleyWoman2 · 23/05/2023 19:42

@chicosmommy - to add to what @Gymnopediesaid, if (when) your SIL reports anything you say back to your parents, they will take it as a form of engagement with them. It won’t matter to them that it’s a negative form of engagement; all they will see is that you are still talking and thinking about them, and above all, that they can get under your skin. They will wax lyrical to your SIL about how none of it is true and it’s so unfair, knowing full well it could get back to you - and their hope and expectation will be that you then defend yourself and essentially begin a dialogue of sorts.

They will love the idea that they can still wind you up even when you refuse to see them. Don’t give them the oxygen.

chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 19:18

Gymnopedie · 23/05/2023 18:31

I'm going to ask him to visit them this weekend and tell them the dirty laundry about how bad DM is.

Please don't. They will take great delight in telling your mum what's been said. You're just feeding the fire and giving them exactly what they want, which is gossip. 'Oooh, do you know what chicosmommy and [DH] have been saying about you?' They sound like the sort of people who love to be the first to share some gossip, even if no-one else knows. But then again you don't know who else they'd tell.

Please stick to dignified silence. And try not to let it upset you. You know that they - especially SIL - are taking pleasure in your upset, so don't let them see that you are. You don't need to see them at all, DH can if he wants, but don't let him guilt you into doing so no matter what tactics he tries to use.

Thanks and in hindsight I agree. I printed off all the replies here and handed them to DH to read.

OP posts:
saraclara · 23/05/2023 18:35

Gymnopedie · 23/05/2023 18:31

I'm going to ask him to visit them this weekend and tell them the dirty laundry about how bad DM is.

Please don't. They will take great delight in telling your mum what's been said. You're just feeding the fire and giving them exactly what they want, which is gossip. 'Oooh, do you know what chicosmommy and [DH] have been saying about you?' They sound like the sort of people who love to be the first to share some gossip, even if no-one else knows. But then again you don't know who else they'd tell.

Please stick to dignified silence. And try not to let it upset you. You know that they - especially SIL - are taking pleasure in your upset, so don't let them see that you are. You don't need to see them at all, DH can if he wants, but don't let him guilt you into doing so no matter what tactics he tries to use.

I don't think there's any point in him telling duplicitous SIL. But MIL seems to be an allly, and was basically just trying to be nice (she did, after all, defend OP to her mother). Why she supported SIL in seeing OP's mum by babysitting in order for it to happen, goodness knows. But I reckon that if OP's DH explains things to her (and reiterates how badly his MIL treated him too) she might not be in a hurry to do that again, and likely to avoid OP's mum in the future.

Gymnopedie · 23/05/2023 18:31

I'm going to ask him to visit them this weekend and tell them the dirty laundry about how bad DM is.

Please don't. They will take great delight in telling your mum what's been said. You're just feeding the fire and giving them exactly what they want, which is gossip. 'Oooh, do you know what chicosmommy and [DH] have been saying about you?' They sound like the sort of people who love to be the first to share some gossip, even if no-one else knows. But then again you don't know who else they'd tell.

Please stick to dignified silence. And try not to let it upset you. You know that they - especially SIL - are taking pleasure in your upset, so don't let them see that you are. You don't need to see them at all, DH can if he wants, but don't let him guilt you into doing so no matter what tactics he tries to use.

LacewingOrpington · 23/05/2023 18:25

saraclara · 23/05/2023 17:48

Your MIL is not actually a loving, kind mother if she’s brought her son up to fear her being upset.

Who says he's scared of her, @LacewingOrpington ? My MIL was quite the most lovely person I've been lucky eough to have in my life. I would have hated to have upset her. But it doesn't mean I was scared of her. Fearing upsetting someone doesn't mean being scared OF them. Simply of being scared that you might hurt them.

I agree what you describe is not the same. However, I think not feeling able to challenging your Mother on her getting deliberately involved with the in-laws you and your wife have consciously and deliberately chosen to No Contact with is.

diddl · 23/05/2023 18:02

I wouldn't bother telling them anything.

They sound as if they would just go ahead to make up their own minds anyway.

If your husband doesn't really have your back on this I wouldn't trust him on knowing when to stop whilst trying to convince his mum of your side.

saraclara · 23/05/2023 17:48

Your MIL is not actually a loving, kind mother if she’s brought her son up to fear her being upset.

Who says he's scared of her, @LacewingOrpington ? My MIL was quite the most lovely person I've been lucky eough to have in my life. I would have hated to have upset her. But it doesn't mean I was scared of her. Fearing upsetting someone doesn't mean being scared OF them. Simply of being scared that you might hurt them.

billy1966 · 23/05/2023 17:28

chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 14:56

Yes him not standing up for me is the only source of any argument between us tbh. I'm going to ask him to visit them this weekend and tell them the dirty laundry about how bad DM is.

I agree with the others.

Keep your linen to yourself.

I do not think you should share your business with such disloyal untrustworthy people.

However, your husband could tell his mother that HE thinks she is an awful woman AND that ALL her children having gone NC for years tells its own tale.

I think HE should say how disappointed HE is, that HIS family would cause HIS wife pain, by THEIR behaviour.

Your SIL is a thundering nosy witch and I wouldn't look at her again.

The truth is your husbands family have let themselves down very badly in this.

You have zero need to make any further effort with them.

I really am sorry.

I cannot stand nosy people.

Peachy2005 · 23/05/2023 17:17
  • get past, sorry
Peachy2005 · 23/05/2023 17:16

I really like the@pickledandpuzzled message to MIL suggestion, although these things may be better communicated by your DH directly to his mum for a while. If he’s going round this weekend, it’s a really good chance to warn his family that firstly, you and he don’t want to hear anything relayed back about your parents and secondly, they can expect no help or sympathy when it all eventually goes tits-up! If your DH is planning to supply a lot of details about your past with your parents, I’d be inclined to say just give the broad strokes. If he gives a lot of details, your MIL may tell all of it to your SIL and SIL may repeat it all to your parents who will then give their version (all a pack of lies) and SIL feeds it back to MIL, who will probably have trouble resisting feeding that all back to DH/you etc…and on and on… Don’t give them too much ammunition, is what I’m trying to say! Good luck…it’ll be hard to past this much obliteration of boundaries by your ILs 😢

weekendworry · 23/05/2023 17:10

weightymatters73 · 23/05/2023 16:29

I think unfortunately you do need to air your dirty linen in public, then your MIL and SIL know what they are dealing with.

I disagree - very much so.

Grey rock only works if you stay out, all the way out of drama. A Narc has a way of inveigling things out of the unsuspecting confidants and then piles on top of that, twisting and changing the narrative. It is how they get flying monkeys onside in the first place!

Silence is golden. You cant change a persons mind for them but when the mask slips because the narc shows themselves - it is an absolute revelation and suddenly people go from 'poor them, how could you do that to your lovely Mum' to 'holy fuck what a narc' faster than a bullet.

weightymatters73 · 23/05/2023 16:29

chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 09:53

I should also add, none of my siblings speak to our parents. The reason for estrangement is my mother's alcoholism, verbal abuse of her kids, attempted control of her kids, continually bashing us to anyone who will listen, calling us names etc. etc.

I think unfortunately you do need to air your dirty linen in public, then your MIL and SIL know what they are dealing with.

LacewingOrpington · 23/05/2023 16:05

Your MIL is not actually a loving, kind mother if she’s brought her son up to fear her being upset. If I tell my parents something they’re doing/not doing is upsetting me or my DH then they respect and listen to that even if it doesn’t make sense to them. I expect your DH suffers FOG when tackling his family. We’ve just drawn up the drawbridge and medium chill the lot of them. Worked well for us. We explain nothing now (after years of over explaining) and focus on what we can control which is our boundaries and our own well-being. It’s been interesting as it’s really shown overtime the similar dynamics that play out in both our family even though they present differently on the surface.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 23/05/2023 15:28

Zhougzhoug · 23/05/2023 10:56

Obviously it's up to you what you tell people about your life, but if you hadn't told MIL & SIL that you were no contact with your mum for a good reason, you can see how the confusion occurred. I'm sure you're coming from a good place not wanting to wash your dirty linen in public but they're not mind readers. They might have just thought you'd been too busy to see your mum lately or something! I'd say something like "I wasn't sure whether to tell you in case it made it awkward for you, but I think you'd better know that I've deliberately limited contact with my mum for some time now because of her alcoholism and abusive behaviour."

OP’s SIL doesn’t need to know why the OP cut off her parents. She WANTS to know why - she’s probably drooling like a starving dog to find out why - but she doesn’t need to know. All she needs to know is that this has happened, and therefore she should keep her beak out.

OP - ignore the advice saying “You need to explain why you’re NC and that all your other siblings are NC too”. You absolutely do NOT need to do this. It’s just feeding their appetite for gossip - and the likelihood is that, rather than giving them food for thought, it will just fuel their interest. Just disengage and, if they complain, point out that it was their decision to insert themselves in your family issues.

My BIL has no problems with his parents, as far as I’m aware. I’ve still never invited them to dinner without him, because frankly, why would I? Who would? Literally our only connection is that their son’s wife and my sister happen to be the same woman. If I (and most people) don’t feel the need to develop a social relationship with a sibling’s in-laws when they do get along, why would anyone do it with in-laws who don’t get along?

Mygrandadwasmywingman · 23/05/2023 14:59

I had exactly the same happen but with my sd

My while family are narcs-or flying monkeys and I went nc with them and moved well over 100 miles away

My family know I moved but not my address,work place,phone number etc

Any sd (then 17) moved in with us in 2019 as her mother chucked her out and caused so much shit for us,I made it clear it was her or me-one of us had to move out (she was off to uni at this point anyway)

My dp chose me so sd went skidding off to my family-stirring the pot on how evil i was (asking for a token rent asking her to clean up after herself,as I'm not hear to pick up her dirty knickers and do her washing up and please dont go shit stirring to her own mother or my family-she refused) and giving them my address,work place,phone number-the lot

Of course that stirred them up again-I had to get the police involved to get them to back off and it means I can't speak openly to my darling mil (sd's granny) in case she let's slip (innocently) to sd and up it all comes again

Of course she's very happy with herself and is in touch with them via sm to this day-stirring the pot even though ive only seen her once since the first lockdown-what they don't know,they make up

it'll come back and bite her arse one day

Until you've lived it you can't imagine it

chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 14:56

billy1966 · 23/05/2023 13:48

You poor woman.

You will need to be strong.
His sister is being deliberately nasty as she doesn't like you.

Have nothing further to do with her.

Your MIL is sneaky and underhand but not the brightest button in the box, as she let the cat out of the bag.

@TheChoiceIsYours message is excellent.

You need to protect yourself from them all, even that husband of yours who is scared of his own shadow.

They have zero loyalty to you, so you will need to be resolute in your boundaries.

Awful people.

Yes him not standing up for me is the only source of any argument between us tbh. I'm going to ask him to visit them this weekend and tell them the dirty laundry about how bad DM is.

OP posts:
justasking111 · 23/05/2023 14:55

Neither I nor my siblings are in contact with mother her narcissm is off the scale. She has in the past inveigled herself into our circle of other family and friends. It never lasted the mask slipped.

None of us have ever bad mouthed her we stay resolutely silent. @chicosmommy your SIL will have to learn the hard way because your mother will cause upsets in her life. Just stand back.

chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 14:55

LacewingOrpington · 23/05/2023 14:30

My sibling keeps doing this with my in-laws who were very low contact with and I resist the urge to tell them how it’s obvious they can’t resist because “birds of a feather flock together”! They delights in bringing them up and saying “sorry to upset you but…”. I think they misjudge what upsets me. I believe they thinks I find it upsetting that they chooses to be closer to my in-laws than I am, whereas it upsets me as yet another reminder how theu don’t have my back.

My parents have mostly been the opposite, they made different decisions with my grandparents who were just as bad if not worse, so have expressed some struggles with our preferred approach but they’ve always had my DH and my back.

I think this is a situation where when someone shows you who they are, believe them. I would always have my children and their partners and my siblings back even if I would view it differently from them and make different decisions myself. There is no reason for them to have a relationship with your family and the fact they actively choose to do this has likely meant they’ve treated your DH in a similar way all his life and part of the reason you and your DH emotionally understand each other. IMO It is not appropriate to interject yourself into your children’s relationship with their in-laws, your siblings relationship with their in-laws or even your friends’ relationships with their family or in-laws.

So true

OP posts:
chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 14:54

CantGetDecentNickname · 23/05/2023 14:33

Some really good posts on here OP. I think the one above is very good as it may open DH's eyes to the fact that his DM has done this to you both despite knowing how her own DS was treated by your DM and that maybe he doesn't have to worry about "upsetting her" any longer since she thinks nothing of upsetting him. The other thing here is to "Please ensure that they both know that ALL your siblings are also NC with your mum." as PPs have said.

I would stick to occasionally seeing MIL with your DCs, but not trusting her an inch in future so not telling her anything or giving her anything she can pass on to your DM. SIL I would completely cut out. It is clear from your posts that she has never liked you much and has jumped at the chance to try to make trouble. I hope she gets what she deserves from your DM. If you ever do bump into SIL in future you can just laugh and say "I wonder what delightful things DM is saying about you now. I've been hearing all sorts of things via the gossip networks." and leave her to stew.

It is sad you've had to go through this and you are sensible to protect yourself and your DC from it. Ignore the others as they'll figure it out in time. Your DM won't be able to keep up the good act for ever.

Love that about the leaving SIL stew bit. That's v good! I'll try that!

OP posts:
chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 14:53

Howtotalksoyourparentslisten · 23/05/2023 14:43

I’d strongly suspect that your lovely MIL and SIL have been secretly bitching about you and your mum for a long time. You’re not as close as you think you are.

My SIL, yes, but i don't think my MIL would. My MIL actually told my DM that I am a "great mother" when my DM started bashing me. My DM also asked my MIL if DH and me are still together and then got huffy when MIL said that we are happy and "like two peas in a pod." My MIL told my DH this.

OP posts:
chicosmommy · 23/05/2023 14:52

Lovingitallnow · 23/05/2023 14:32

Are they your SIL's neighbours? I remember a thread where she wanted to invite them as her neighbours for Xmas dinner instead of her SIL's alcoholic NC parents. And got her arse handed to her.

No. But they're from the same town, maybe like 5 or 6 miles away from one another.

OP posts:
Runaway1 · 23/05/2023 14:44

Sadly, I agree with pp that grey rock with MIL and SIL is now the only way forward to avoid anything being passed on to your mother. I’m really sorry they’ve done this to you and know how exhausting maintaining grey rock can be.

Howtotalksoyourparentslisten · 23/05/2023 14:43

I’d strongly suspect that your lovely MIL and SIL have been secretly bitching about you and your mum for a long time. You’re not as close as you think you are.

Howtotalksoyourparentslisten · 23/05/2023 14:39

Ignore it completely, otherwise SIL will feed back to
your parents that you’re upset, and then your parents will be delighted that they’ve affected you. Grey rock all the way - ‘you’re having my parents over for dinner? Oh how lovely have a nice time’ ‘you met my mum in town? Oh that’s nice isn’t the weather great today’ etc etc.

CantGetDecentNickname · 23/05/2023 14:33

saraclara · 23/05/2023 12:58

Does your MIL know how your mum treated your DH in the past? Because I think his involvement here should be with her, not SIL. He can calmly say to his mum that, while he understands that she wanted to be kind to a distressed person, she really needs to recognise what this woman did and said to him, and that when you and all your siblings have no contact with her, she can surely understand that the problem is with your mum and not you.

He doesn't have to 'upset her' he just needs to have a conversation that makes it clear how inappropriate it is for his family to strike up a friendship with her. Both from your perspective and his own, given that your mum was shitty to him too.

Some really good posts on here OP. I think the one above is very good as it may open DH's eyes to the fact that his DM has done this to you both despite knowing how her own DS was treated by your DM and that maybe he doesn't have to worry about "upsetting her" any longer since she thinks nothing of upsetting him. The other thing here is to "Please ensure that they both know that ALL your siblings are also NC with your mum." as PPs have said.

I would stick to occasionally seeing MIL with your DCs, but not trusting her an inch in future so not telling her anything or giving her anything she can pass on to your DM. SIL I would completely cut out. It is clear from your posts that she has never liked you much and has jumped at the chance to try to make trouble. I hope she gets what she deserves from your DM. If you ever do bump into SIL in future you can just laugh and say "I wonder what delightful things DM is saying about you now. I've been hearing all sorts of things via the gossip networks." and leave her to stew.

It is sad you've had to go through this and you are sensible to protect yourself and your DC from it. Ignore the others as they'll figure it out in time. Your DM won't be able to keep up the good act for ever.

Swipe left for the next trending thread