Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to read really shit books to my baby?

234 replies

CooCooCaChu · 22/05/2023 20:25

I've got an eight month old baby. We've got lots of really basic baby books. You know the kind, red circle on one page, blue triangle on the next. Or the endless 'that's not my ...'.

I find it incredibly boring to keep going 'oh look, this is a cow. Moooo.'

If I don't read these basic books, will she miss out on something important developmentally? Or can I skip straight to things with more of a narrative so I don't feel the need to stab myself in the eye just to create a bit of excitement?

Yabu you need to spend hours reading 'here is a car, brum brum'
Yanbu read something more fun, your baby will probably enjoy it more anyway

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 23/05/2023 11:32

@bussteward oh yes "accidents" 😂. The whole book is just awesome.
The Ahlberg's created the book when they realised their daughter was just as happy "reading" things like the Argos catalogue.

MargotBamborough · 23/05/2023 11:24

bussteward · 23/05/2023 10:58

@Needmorelego @MargotBamborough I love it too. It’s the book 4yo DD most wants to read to her new baby (technically my baby!): “Once there was a little boy. His name was Peepo. One two three. Look, he doesn’t have a blackout blind Mummy. What’s a bucketful of coal?”

Love it!

I also love the fact that they all pitch in and it isn't just mummy doing chores while daddy sits on his bum.

Qazwsxefv · 23/05/2023 11:18

Like other posters we had loads of the touchy feely “that’s not my” type books but they were mainly for dd to touch/try to eat - I didn’t read them to her as such just gave her one to feel the different textures.

for actual stories we loved (and still love) any Julia Donaldson, the Alfie books (pictures are dated but Alfie’s toddler like understanding of the world and toddler issues (lost toy, falling out with friends etc) are just so well done), each peach pear plum (can recite this one from memory) 10 little monsters/princesses/trucks, giraffes can’t dance, llama llama red pyjama, we’re going on a bear hunt, where the wild things are for a few

also loved “go the fuck to sleep” but only when she was very pre verbal - 8 months may be to late!

bussteward · 23/05/2023 11:09

@Needmorelego Yes! My favourite page is “accidents”

FourTeaFallOut · 23/05/2023 11:05

FourTeaFallOut · 23/05/2023 10:56

You can't really undervalue the role of repetition in language acquisition, boring as it is. Keep reading the books the dc is familiar with but add new ones that you find enjoyable too.

Undervalue = under estimate/ over-value.

Back to the baby books for me.

Saschka · 23/05/2023 11:05

bussteward · 23/05/2023 10:47

Eh? So we shouldn’t read Peepo! with its gas mask and blackout warden? Let’s rule out Not Now Bernard because he’s got an old-fashioned TV not a flat screen. Farewell, Tiger Who Came to Tea because no one has a boy from the grocer anymore.

We changed that to “the supermarket delivery”. It was the milkman that threw DS Grin

Needmorelego · 23/05/2023 11:03

@bussteward The Babies Catalogue is another favourite of mine.
Even has a Stay At Home Dad - which was unusual for the early 80s when it was published.

Saschka · 23/05/2023 11:01

Aged 8 months, read them whatever you like. Something with rhythm, surprises or actions will generally get their interest, but they just like hearing your voice. Something longer like Each Peach Pear Plum will be better because it will last longer. Board books and rag books are good for them to get used to turning pages, but you don’t need to read those out loud.

Aged 2-4, they are going to like “where’s Mr Dog?” etc, and will insist on you reading them again and again. Luckily by that age, your toddler’s excited little face will be cute enough to make it worthwhile.

bussteward · 23/05/2023 10:58

@Needmorelego @MargotBamborough I love it too. It’s the book 4yo DD most wants to read to her new baby (technically my baby!): “Once there was a little boy. His name was Peepo. One two three. Look, he doesn’t have a blackout blind Mummy. What’s a bucketful of coal?”

WaltzingWaters · 23/05/2023 10:57

I read both. I leave the board books out so my DS can look at them whenever without breaking them. So we read them a lot and they’re great for basic vocabulary. But also have more children’s books with a story that I’ll read to stop myself going crazy.

FourTeaFallOut · 23/05/2023 10:56

You can't really undervalue the role of repetition in language acquisition, boring as it is. Keep reading the books the dc is familiar with but add new ones that you find enjoyable too.

MargotBamborough · 23/05/2023 10:53

bussteward · 23/05/2023 10:47

Eh? So we shouldn’t read Peepo! with its gas mask and blackout warden? Let’s rule out Not Now Bernard because he’s got an old-fashioned TV not a flat screen. Farewell, Tiger Who Came to Tea because no one has a boy from the grocer anymore.

My two year old is obsessed with Peepo and has to have it read to him every night before bed. He's learning English as his second language and a lot of his first vocabulary in English was from Peepo.

Needmorelego · 23/05/2023 10:52

Peepo not Peppo 🙂

Needmorelego · 23/05/2023 10:51

@bussteward I love Peppo so much. It shows that the daily life of a baby is pretty much the same whether it's 2023 or 1943.

bussteward · 23/05/2023 10:47

Sugarfree23 · 23/05/2023 09:37

@ShinyShite
No point in looking at baby picture books with cabled phones, big box tellys, record players, etc
Book date more than you think.

I also came across a Biff & Chip book with the moral of the story being don't vandalise phone boxes - where would you even go to find a phone box??

I have also came across Enid Blyton books even the updated language versions just seem dated and a world away from what todays kids can relate to.

Eh? So we shouldn’t read Peepo! with its gas mask and blackout warden? Let’s rule out Not Now Bernard because he’s got an old-fashioned TV not a flat screen. Farewell, Tiger Who Came to Tea because no one has a boy from the grocer anymore.

cyncope · 23/05/2023 10:34

You don't have to read at all to an 8 month old.
Introduce books at 12 months or 18 months or 2. It's up to you. Nothing bad will happen, they're not going to fail their GCSEs.

Sugarfree23 · 23/05/2023 10:32

As a child I loved Enid Blyton the stories pulled you in made you want to keep reading - very like JKR. But many children today find them dated and unrelateable.

roofracker · 23/05/2023 10:32

OP stop worrying, honestly so much of this apparently essential stuff doesn't matter AT ALL! I never read to mine as it bored me shitless, they are now in 20s and very successful.

MargotBamborough · 23/05/2023 10:31

I loved Enid Blyton as a child and the books were almost as out of date then as they are now. I was a bit of a weird, socially awkward kid and I remember saying things like, "I say!" and "golly!" which of course were lifted straight from Enid Blyton and made me even weirder and ripe for piss taking by other children. I imagine it would be worse now with all the extra words we don't use these days.

That said, I do credit Enid Blyton with getting me into reading. I think it's because she wrote so many books, including so many series with characters I grew to know and love. Once I'd read one book from a series I wanted to read them all, which turned me into a really voracious reader and did wonders for my literacy.

I think the key is to find an author your child loves who has written a lot of books. But how many children's authors are as prolific as Enid Blyton?

AtomicBlondeRose · 23/05/2023 10:22

Won’t someone spare a thought for all those adults wandering around at a total loss
because their parents never read one-words-a-page baby books to them, given that they’re apparently essential.

Those kids who never took up football because they couldn’t recognise a ball, or who flunked a job interview because they were told “just go through that green door” and their negligent, selfish mother never read the book that said “green” in it. It’s a scandal.

Needmorelego · 23/05/2023 10:05

About "old fashioned" books - something I used to do when my daughter was about 4 or 5 was look at when the book was written and try to figure out how old the child in the story would be now.
I think Alfie (from the Shirley Hughes books) is about my age (if he was an actual person) so I would say it's a story about a boy who was my age when I was a little girl. So something in the illustrations I could point out and say "ooh I had one like that" or "look the chair it's like the one at Granny's house".
Fascinating fact....My Naughty Little Sister is 'set' pretty much 100 years ago now !!
Fun way to introduce history.

Tessisme · 23/05/2023 10:03

My eldest absolutely lapped up 'That's Not My Puppy', 'That's Not My Truck', 'That's Not Your Parking Space' (ok, I made that one up) etc. His face recognising the pictures, his wee hand brushing across the different textures, and his bemused reaction to my ridiculous sing-songy inflection were all so enjoyable for me. DS2, however, was not on board with these books AT ALL. He stared at me as if I was some weird clown storyteller who had wandered in off the street to torture him. He had the same reaction when I tried to sing to him🤣 Each to their own ...

Anyway, many of the baby books were skipped as a result and he's still bright as a button. So no harm done.

SmileyClare · 23/05/2023 09:48

Maybe I’m romanticising Enid Blyton books too much, but I still think she was one of the greatest children’s story tellers.

Some of her books have aged better than others I suppose, and just aren’t relatable to children.

My dc all loved “The Magic Faraway Tree” although I must admit I probably loved reading it to them more 😂

Sugarfree23 · 23/05/2023 09:37

@ShinyShite
No point in looking at baby picture books with cabled phones, big box tellys, record players, etc
Book date more than you think.

I also came across a Biff & Chip book with the moral of the story being don't vandalise phone boxes - where would you even go to find a phone box??

I have also came across Enid Blyton books even the updated language versions just seem dated and a world away from what todays kids can relate to.

GoodChat · 23/05/2023 09:15

@ShinyShite there are some words we just don't use and that a pre-schooler is too young to fully grasp an explanation of

Swipe left for the next trending thread