Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to read really shit books to my baby?

234 replies

CooCooCaChu · 22/05/2023 20:25

I've got an eight month old baby. We've got lots of really basic baby books. You know the kind, red circle on one page, blue triangle on the next. Or the endless 'that's not my ...'.

I find it incredibly boring to keep going 'oh look, this is a cow. Moooo.'

If I don't read these basic books, will she miss out on something important developmentally? Or can I skip straight to things with more of a narrative so I don't feel the need to stab myself in the eye just to create a bit of excitement?

Yabu you need to spend hours reading 'here is a car, brum brum'
Yanbu read something more fun, your baby will probably enjoy it more anyway

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1493379562 · 31/05/2023 10:26

The only books (or on TV) that I can't abide are Pepper Pig ones. The pictures are awful. Who has all their features on one side of their face! My little granddaughter adores the 'That's not my' books and loves to feel the textures. She loves lift the flap books in fact anything where she can interact. I started off buying all new but now buy some decent books from ebay. Her daddy has enrolled her at the local library too. I have bought all the 'Ten minutes to bed' books. There are extra characters in each book and the author has written books about them too so they all sort of go together

CelestiaNoctis · 29/05/2023 04:09

Read whatever you like. It's just about baby hearing general language. I would make sure to mix in basic stuff like alphabet, shapes and counting but besides that you can read whatever most of the time. Little tip, if you really can't spare the energy and are sick of it, basically every book is on YouTube with someone reading it and turning the pages for you. I discovered this after reading rainbow fish and hungry caterpillar 6 times a day.

Angelil · 29/05/2023 03:21

Justalittlebitduckling · 22/05/2023 21:42

From pretty young they’ll hand you the books they want you to read! I bought some of those babylit ones because I’m pretentious and my toddler never had any interest in them at all. He likes Julia Donaldson board books. And the classics like Dear Zoo, Owl Babies and the Very Hungry Caterpillar. It gets boring after three repeats in the same setting but generally I find I just like hanging out with him and enjoying seeing the world through his eyes, so you might surprise yourself.

If you want to save your sanity, three ideas:

  1. buy some baby board books in other languages and learn together.

  2. tell stories. Telling stories is a lost art in much of Western culture and it’s actually really important

  3. pick different baby books each week from the library. At least then there’s some variety!

Great ideas generally but speaking from the standpoint of a multilingual family I REALLY wouldn’t do 1. unless you have experience of the language as otherwise the kid will pick up your pronunciation errors.

as for the original OP, we have a 4yo and a baby and have done both from an early age (basic board books for concepts plus narratives intended for slightly older children aged 2-5). I would also quote Maria Montessori at this point: “Follow the child.” My 4yo cannot read but we have been reading Roald Dahl to him lately, specifically George’s Marvellous Medicine, as he is obsessed with potions and mixing at the moment and so I knew he would love this story. He loves the concept of chapter books generally as he sees this as being quite grown-up compared to books for younger children that you read all in one shot (though he still enjoys plenty of books of this nature too) - so we have read Flat Stanley recently too. Mix it up! Your kid will be fine.

CKMc2b · 28/05/2023 12:51

Fooshufflewickjbannanapants · 22/05/2023 21:20

My kids favourites were the bastard hairy mcclary from donaldsons fucking dairy series, oh how I longed for the that's not my ..... shite

Awww really, I actually love those books! Hehe

MeandT · 28/05/2023 11:46

My kids were like cocaine addled ravers when it came to bedtimes. My Mum bought them (me) a copy of 'The Rabbit Who Couldn't Sleep' for Christmas one year.

It has different typefaces for what you're supposed to read slowly, faster, in a sleepy voice, etc. so the power of suggestion basically hypnotises them to sleep.

I feel asleep every bloody time & they would keep poking me to wake up & finish the story 🙄

Once they got to about 7 they finally became good at bedtimes - if anyone needs a light at the end of the tunnel?

TheEternalForever · 28/05/2023 10:57

I read almost 300 pages of The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo to a friend's almost 1 year old when I was babysitting and it happened to be the one I was reading at the time. Every time I thought he'd gone to sleep so I could stop reading aloud he started fussing again so I had to pick back up. I think he quite enjoyed it in the end. I've also read him many a lesbian romance from my kindle and he's never complained about them either. And sometimes I read him excerpts of the novel I'm currently writing so I can pretend it's published and I'm doing a book reading at Waterstones. If it ever does get published I think I'll have to dedicate it to him at this rate

immergeradeaus · 28/05/2023 08:23

I loved these books. Read endless ‘that’s not my..’ loved hamming up the ‘blue square’ abstract stuff. There were a few twee stories with less interesting pictures or words but we had hundreds of pre-school books and they were a major part of my children’s lives.

I also liked Biff and Chip and the Magic Key. Oh Floppy! No, Floppy!

But I hated Beast Quest. Listened to dc1 read the first four aloud and declared that they would be reserved for silent reading. We didn’t get past the front cover of Rainbow Fairies.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 28/05/2023 08:21

We had loads and they drove me insane, too. So mind numbing. I’d read my kid whatever I was reading. I never did the inane ‘kids’ music’ either, I played what I liked.

He’s smart as a whip, so I think as long as you engage with them, that’s enough.

Sugarfree23 · 28/05/2023 08:19

@CooCooCaChu
Op I've concluded most people don't know the type of book you're talking about, or if they do know they treat them as toys for baby to pick up and turn pages themselves, never actually read them to the child.

In the passing I looked in a couple of supermarkets neither of them had them. Which means you need to go to a proper book shop or order from Amazon.

A well meaning relative bought one of my kids something like the one pictured. Dull boring, and almost like people never point out every day objects to their kids.

To not want to read really shit books to my baby?
Wildspace · 28/05/2023 07:54

They are mostly going to learn from you about books from your attitude and enjoyment of them. If you can’t get enthusiastic about the board books then by all means have them around for DC to explore themselves but use the ones you like to share that enjoyment with them.

BestBeforeddmmyy · 28/05/2023 07:46

We would all probably agree that the repetition can be tedious. However your baby will not be a baby for long and s/he can learn a lot from hearing the stories many times. I think it’s only a tiny thing to do, to read the stories. As your baby gets older, you will hopefully start to enjoy the routine snuggles and bonding over the stories.

PopcorningLikeAHappyGuineaPig · 24/05/2023 21:21

Sugarfree23 · 24/05/2023 19:14

I think baby's just like people talking hearing voices.
I have recollections of parking mine in front of the TV News so I could eat my dinner in peace.

Love that bit in a Call The Midwife episode where we see Dr Turner reading The Lancet to the baby (can't remember if baby was Alison or Teddy) and the baby seemed enraptured.

MadCatLady27 · 24/05/2023 20:55

I also remember funny bones

On a dark dark night...

Everything was dark dark, I'm not sure my mum was a fan 😂

MadCatLady27 · 24/05/2023 20:43

I don't yet have children so not able to offer any advice as such but I have fond memories of my mum reading to me every night - she had a voice for every character, so I'd say part of it is how you're reading too - lots of expression is probably worth a lot

I recently brought someone a gift for their 2 year old as she'd recently had a new baby and I didn't want the 2 year old to feel left out so I got her a board type book about where is the gruffalo - it had different gruffalo characters behind each of the felt lift the flaps - may be a nice one as baby can feel the different material and in time recognise the characters?

When asking my mum for suggestions for what to get as the gift she said (number??) Zoo lane is good - again not sure if at baby's age

Again I don't have children so no expert, but the gruffalo book looked like it could offer various modes of interaction at different stages, not too hideous to read etc.

Could you mix it up a bit, so one night do one of the baby books then the other a book that's a bit more interesting, but nicely illustrated for them to look at the pictures?

Sugarfree23 · 24/05/2023 19:14

logoutsettings · 24/05/2023 16:49

What about some good kids ones, like the secret garden or Tom sawyer?

I think baby's just like people talking hearing voices.
I have recollections of parking mine in front of the TV News so I could eat my dinner in peace.

logoutsettings · 24/05/2023 16:49

WestOfWestminster · 22/05/2023 20:28

I dunno Op. I mean, what kind of book are you thinking of? A grown up one or still a childs one? I would find it odd sitting there reading an adult book to a baby, but perhaps thats just me?

What about some good kids ones, like the secret garden or Tom sawyer?

Lucyh999 · 24/05/2023 16:43

So true! And really it’s not about what the OP finds fun or not, those books have a place in learning, as you say.

Lucyh999 · 24/05/2023 16:39

Well, reading them whatever you want at 8 months might be fine when they’re still a captive audience but when they get a little bit older 12-18 months, you’ll probably find they don’t want to sit on your knee whilst you recite books that you like. In my own personal experience, they want colour, stimulation, sounds, sensory experiences and my very alert and quick little one will not sit through anything with lots of words but nothing to touch or feel. They’re all different but I’ll wager you find the same as they develop.

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 24/05/2023 05:36

Your toddler sits for reading books? 😂 I managed to keep mines attention all for 3 seconds usually 😂😂

Sugarfree23 · 24/05/2023 01:25

Peepo at least has a story even if I didn't like it.

The sort of book Op and I are both talking about are the books with ☎️ 'phone' next to it. ⚽️ ball 🚗 car 🐄 cow.
I had one full of ancient tech that I ditched I also found it an incredibly dull book to read. I'm sure my kids learn what every day objects were by seeing 👀 them in the flesh rather than a picture in a book.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 23/05/2023 20:55

your child will pick up on your feelings towards reading. Read what you want within reason. My boys love hearing poetry.

bussteward · 23/05/2023 20:52

Julia Donaldson is awful! Half her stuff doesn’t even rhyme, I’m amazed by the love she’s getting on this thread. I still have PTSD flashbacks from someone giving Stick Man to DD before I strategically hid it.

Anderson2018 · 23/05/2023 19:37

the gruffalo/ gruffalos child and all the other Julia Donaldson books are good because they are rhymes so their a lot more interesting to read and baby will listen to you. Also there’s a great book called hippobottymus that mines loved and it’s a fun one to read, my kid ripped it to shreds one day and I’m still upset as it was great lol

RoseGoldEagle · 23/05/2023 18:25

I’m with you OP, but there are loads of amazing books that will still work! For example I adore reading Goodnight Tractor (the pictures make me feel all warm and cosy and almost nostalgic), and my kids point out the animals and make animal noises and get the benefits of the repetition; whereas so many similar-ish books about farms are just rubbish and don’t rhyme or scan properly, and I avoid those! Millions of examples, definitely read what you enjoy, we always have and my 6 year old is flying with reading now and reads all sorts.

CooCooCaChu · 23/05/2023 17:03

AtomicBlondeRose · 23/05/2023 10:22

Won’t someone spare a thought for all those adults wandering around at a total loss
because their parents never read one-words-a-page baby books to them, given that they’re apparently essential.

Those kids who never took up football because they couldn’t recognise a ball, or who flunked a job interview because they were told “just go through that green door” and their negligent, selfish mother never read the book that said “green” in it. It’s a scandal.

😂

OP posts: