Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think free wifi on trains is not a low priority for passengers?

204 replies

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 22/05/2023 17:56

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-65673622

Being reported that the government thinks free wifi is a low priority for passengers so could be cut to save money. Maybe I am out of step, but I really appreciate it, especially on long journeys. I don't watch TV or films, just browse the net on and off and use Whatsapp. Is it really impossible to have a properly staffed train service running more or less to time and also offering free wifi?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DdraigGoch · 25/05/2023 20:27

@tommika I see, it wasn't very clear.

That said, anyone who had seen Yes, Minister can tell you how you can get a survey to reflect the outcome you want.

For example, we keep being told that passengers prefer a trolley service to a buffet. What question are they asking though? Probably something along the lines of:

"Do you prefer having refreshments served at your seat, or walking down the train to a buffet car?"

Whereas if they ask:

"Do you want to be able to buy hot food, or will a lukewarm tea and a chocolate bar be good enough for a long journey?"

You would get a very different result.

tommika · 25/05/2023 16:03

DdraigGoch · 25/05/2023 09:30

No they didn't what?

DfT civil servants are micromanaging the English train operators. That's a fact. During industrial action Shapps was claiming that it was nothing to do with him, even though the words "the Secretary of State" appeared several thousand times in the contracts.

The ‘no they didn’t’ Was directed at @Swrigh1234

Swrigh1234 · Yesterday 07:41
Someone in government came up with this. Civil service isn’t known for being filled with the brightest.

It’s not a civil servants idea that WiFi is not a priority.
The responses from rail travellers in the survey has WiFI (and phone signal) as a much lower priority then the many other issues

BigFatLiar · 25/05/2023 10:01

readbooksdrinktea · 25/05/2023 09:45

This.

As PP, actual staff on the platform is a priority.

I don't think the operators see having people at stations as a priority. Wasn't retaining manned stations and guards on trains part of the railway strike goal.

readbooksdrinktea · 25/05/2023 09:45

GoodChat · 22/05/2023 20:03

Free wifi isn't very secure at all. It's a hackers paradise.

This.

As PP, actual staff on the platform is a priority.

Thinkwhat · 25/05/2023 09:38

I think this depends who they asked. If you look at daily commuters who do trips of 20mins to an hour then I would guess it is really low. If you look at those of us who do long but infrequent journeys for work then it is probably more of a priority. I do a 6 hour there and 6 hour back once a month and I really value it (when it’s working)

DdraigGoch · 25/05/2023 09:30

No they didn't what?

DfT civil servants are micromanaging the English train operators. That's a fact. During industrial action Shapps was claiming that it was nothing to do with him, even though the words "the Secretary of State" appeared several thousand times in the contracts.

DdraigGoch · 24/05/2023 23:50

BigFatLiar · 24/05/2023 23:35

As the services are provided by different companies does their contract require provision of WiFi?

When franchises were a thing, it was often specified. When batflu broke out the franchises were replaced by National Rail Contracts and the DfT just tells the companies how it wants the railway run (no surprise that it's falling apart as a result).

DdraigGoch · 24/05/2023 23:48

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 24/05/2023 21:36

I imagine the Department for Transport folk might have a rethink if they weren't all working permanently from home

They might also have a rethink if they had to use some of the provincial services where there's little in the way of a signal.

This would save peanuts, and just reinforce the feeling that everything is spiralling into decline.

Wonderingifitstimetogo · 24/05/2023 23:38

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 24/05/2023 21:36

I imagine the Department for Transport folk might have a rethink if they weren't all working permanently from home

Its not like the train services were running amazingly a few years ago before wfh became more of a thing

BigFatLiar · 24/05/2023 23:35

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 24/05/2023 21:36

I imagine the Department for Transport folk might have a rethink if they weren't all working permanently from home

As the services are provided by different companies does their contract require provision of WiFi?

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 24/05/2023 21:36

I imagine the Department for Transport folk might have a rethink if they weren't all working permanently from home

DdraigGoch · 24/05/2023 17:37

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 24/05/2023 16:58

If it gets to Euston. Imagine what that money could have done on the existing lines?

Sod all. Trying to get work done around an open railway is costly and time consuming. It also results in something far inferior becuase the WCML was diverted around the lands of inflential land owners who had shares in the canals.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 24/05/2023 16:58

DdraigGoch · 23/05/2023 17:20

An Anytime Return from Manchester to London is £369.40

Why has it reached such an extortionate level? Because there was absolutely no capacity on peak trains, even after Virgin added three coaches to the units and and increased the frequency to the maximum the infrastructure could cope with. Demand had to be priced off to stop peak trains from being swamped.

HS2 will treble the capacity out of Euston, benefitting everyone from long-distance passengers to those using London Overground. More capacity means that fares can be cut, which will encourage people out of their cars (a gain for the planet). Reduced journey times and lower fares between London and the Scottish Central Belt will also provide an attractive alternative to flying (another gain for the planet).

If it gets to Euston. Imagine what that money could have done on the existing lines?

DdraigGoch · 24/05/2023 15:53

musixa · 24/05/2023 12:07

And the EMUs on the east coast may be quiet but the DMUs on Cross Country certainly aren't!

None of which has anything to do with Pendolinos on the West Coast.

Talking of the benefits of onboard WiFi though, Voyagers have very poor mobile reception because of their design. WiFi gives you a better signal.

musixa · 24/05/2023 12:07

And the EMUs on the east coast may be quiet but the DMUs on Cross Country certainly aren't!

musixa · 24/05/2023 12:06

DdraigGoch · 24/05/2023 11:15

In terms of top speed, you are aware of the other advantage of a Pendolino? It can run at 125mph on certain sections of 110mph track.

There's little noise in an EMU.

Who is going to couple and uncouple all of these locomotives? Shunters cost money.

At the moment those sections of track are few and far between.

Shunters cost money - exactly, so spend the money on something that would improve the basics of the service; i.e. more seating, rather than on extras such as wi-fi.

DdraigGoch · 24/05/2023 11:15

musixa · 24/05/2023 06:11

The second locomotive wouldn't need to sit at the platform (if we are considering platform length as a barrier to longer trains) so there would be nothing to prevent more carriages being added.

I agree they accelerate more quickly - as do all DMUs - the downside to this is a much noisier ride and more vibration - and they don't go any faster than a loco hauled train once its acceleration is complete. In most places, speed restrictions due to track configuration mean that trains can't use their top speeds anyway.

In terms of top speed, you are aware of the other advantage of a Pendolino? It can run at 125mph on certain sections of 110mph track.

There's little noise in an EMU.

Who is going to couple and uncouple all of these locomotives? Shunters cost money.

musixa · 24/05/2023 07:54

They would be better off having perhaps two automatic toilets that are designated accessible toilets only, to reduce traffic and the chances of malfunction, and go back to having multiple smaller non-automated toilets. Yes, you'd get some CF non-disabled people using the accessible loos as happens in public toilets, but it would reduce traffic as there'd be no particular incentive for people who didn't need them to use those toilets rather than the smaller ones. And that model would increase seating capacity in other coaches.

The Pendalinos and Voyagers are not fit for purposes as Cross Country trains - they were designed and used as short-to-mid distance commuter trains in Italy. Hence they had to get rid of the food shop to create a luggage storage area.

It's fine to say you can couple two units together, but then you need two train crews because there's no walk through, doubling the staffing cost and creating potential resourcing issues.

Swrigh1234 · 24/05/2023 07:41

Someone in government came up with this. Civil service isn’t known for being filled with the brightest.

musixa · 24/05/2023 07:05

Have you seen the size of the disabled loos they must have by law?

Yes - and that would be fine if they actually stayed working for more than 5 minutes. The last train I was on only had one toilet still working, the one in First Class, so good luck to anyone with impaired mobility having to make their way to it from Standard Class through a crowded train. I left the train at Leeds and it was going to be going all the way to Plymouth with only one toilet. I've rarely been on one that doesn't have at least one toilet not working.

Kazzyhoward · 24/05/2023 07:00

musixa · 23/05/2023 19:18

There's no reason why a loco couldn't be put at each end, surely. Re. being longer, they don't seat any more per coach than a Mk 3 coach, so that's poor design.

It's not poor design. It's the H&S and disability laws. Have you seen the size of the disabled loos they must have by law? Have you seen the size of the door/vestibule areas? Compared to older carriages, you lose at least a full table/set of 8 seats. Then there's the luggage rack required in modern stock that wasn't there in older stock when you put stuff in the larger overhead racks.

musixa · 24/05/2023 06:11

DdraigGoch · 24/05/2023 00:36

With a locomotive at each end that's 40m of space that could have accommodated passengers. Coach A on a Pendolino provides space for 46 passengers and a number of bikes. How many passengers and bikes fit in a locomotive? Locomotives can only provide power to four axles so they can't match the acceleration of a Pendolino where traction is distributed among eight of the eleven coaches.

A Mk3 TSO (in the Arriva Trains Wales configuration) seated 70 passengers. A Pendolino TS seats 76.

The second locomotive wouldn't need to sit at the platform (if we are considering platform length as a barrier to longer trains) so there would be nothing to prevent more carriages being added.

I agree they accelerate more quickly - as do all DMUs - the downside to this is a much noisier ride and more vibration - and they don't go any faster than a loco hauled train once its acceleration is complete. In most places, speed restrictions due to track configuration mean that trains can't use their top speeds anyway.

DdraigGoch · 24/05/2023 00:37

SerendipityJane · 23/05/2023 19:21

It's had 50 years. When will it start ?

When governments finally see the value of investing in public transport.

Sadly they'd rather make cuts to fuel duty or APD.

DdraigGoch · 24/05/2023 00:36

musixa · 23/05/2023 19:18

There's no reason why a loco couldn't be put at each end, surely. Re. being longer, they don't seat any more per coach than a Mk 3 coach, so that's poor design.

With a locomotive at each end that's 40m of space that could have accommodated passengers. Coach A on a Pendolino provides space for 46 passengers and a number of bikes. How many passengers and bikes fit in a locomotive? Locomotives can only provide power to four axles so they can't match the acceleration of a Pendolino where traction is distributed among eight of the eleven coaches.

A Mk3 TSO (in the Arriva Trains Wales configuration) seated 70 passengers. A Pendolino TS seats 76.

Swipe left for the next trending thread