Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why so much fuss over Stella Braverman?

930 replies

lastminutepanicking · 22/05/2023 17:03

I’m just wondering who on earth cares? Can’t understand why this is such big news.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
CabernetSauvignon · 23/05/2023 16:30

Hippyhippybake · 23/05/2023 15:58

Suella was also a KC so clearly a very talented barrister indeed and quite obviously not “thick”.

She didn't get KC through the normal routes, any Attorney General is automatically appointed as KC on taking office. All she had to do essentially was persuade Johnson into appointing her, and as most of the more competent lawyers in his administration had walked or been booted he didn't have a lot of choice.

When she was at the Bar she was not respected. I know a solicitor who still shudders at the memory of the time she dealt with one of their cases because the barrister initially instructed was unavailable; they didn't go into detail, but said that after that experience Braverman went onto the firm's list of barristers who must never be instructed under any circumstances.

On one of the few occasions when she represented the government in court she failed lamentably. Joshua Rosenberg's comment on it is very accurate (the first part of the quote in italics is from the judgment):

"In this case, however, the argument advanced by the attorney is that the sentence of Long, and therefore the sentences on Bowers and Cole, were unduly lenient because the judge erred in failing to depart from the relevant guideline.

That is, to say the least, an unusual submission. It involves the proposition that in the circumstances of this case, a sentence within the guideline offence range was not within the range properly open to the judge, who was instead required to pass a sentence outside that range. We think it regrettable that, in advancing that submission, the structure and ambit of the guideline were not addressed. Nor was any sufficient explanation given why it is contended that the judge was not merely entitled to depart from the guideline but positively required to do so.

Don’t be deceived by the understated language. As many lawyers pointed out on Twitter this morning, this is as scathing as it gets. “Unusual submission” is code for “monumentally bad point”. This was “coruscating”, others added, “damning”, a “judicial kicking” and “hugely embarrassing”.

And she has continued to demonstrate a basic lack of understanding of fundamental principles of law and the constitution ever since.

pointythings · 23/05/2023 16:29

@TheHandmaiden ah, those pesky facts! One of the Suelka fangirls will soon be along to call you a liar. Or perhaps say it doesn't matter because we don't need experts.

TheHandmaiden · 23/05/2023 16:25

Geoffrey Cox, Lucy Fraser, Dominic Grieve are all proper silks.

Usually legal positions in government are done by lawyers at a senior level. Suella Braverman is a notable exception, along with Dominic Raab. Neither of them excelled as lawyers and became MPs quickly.

TheHandmaiden · 23/05/2023 16:21

Haha she's not a KC. They gave her that and she had to mark it hons.

Unlike most Attorney General who are awarded silk, she had to be given this to save embarrassment. She didn't earn it and wouldn't qualify for it by her own legal skills

Notonthestairs · 23/05/2023 16:03

Hippyhippybake · 23/05/2023 15:58

Suella was also a KC so clearly a very talented barrister indeed and quite obviously not “thick”.

The title came with the job.

Hippyhippybake · 23/05/2023 15:58

Suella was also a KC so clearly a very talented barrister indeed and quite obviously not “thick”.

Hippyhippybake · 23/05/2023 15:47

I did correct that to say that Public Health England was the organisation that provided health advice to the NHS and I was referring to early 2020. Did anyone lose their job when it was renamed?

AutumnCrow · 23/05/2023 15:25

Suella Braverman apparently went to Cambridge. Cambridge. Bloody hell.

ADarkInTheLightness · 23/05/2023 15:23

That’s why I used the past tense for Public Health England.

Actually it was the information provided by Public Health England on asymptomatic transmission that led to the decision. The body that runs the NHS.

Aye, right ye are.

Roussette · 23/05/2023 15:14

lieselotte · 23/05/2023 14:31

This. Giving her a Cabinet job was a big mistake by Sunak.

She told him she would drop out the leadership race if she got home sec job

Hippyhippybake · 23/05/2023 15:13

That’s why I used the past tense for Public Health England. As I understand it nobody lost their job when it became the UK Health Security Agency and in the public’s eye it is Matt Hancock who was held responsible for the disastrous care home decision when he was acting on information supplied by PHE. I’m no fan of Hancock or Braverman as it happens but I would prefer that more attention was paid on the dire performance of so many government departments than distractions such as the current Suella issue.

ChrisPNoodles · 23/05/2023 14:51

lieselotte · 23/05/2023 14:32

People on here have said they've worked with her and she has few in the way of brain cells. Goodness only knows how she has qualified as a lawyer and got to the position she has.

Goodness only knows how she has qualified as a lawyer and got to the position she has.

Perhaps she did her law degree in private via zoom.

Asiatoyork · 23/05/2023 14:43

I mean if you can keep your job after leaking top secret confidential information the sky really is the limit

That’s so unfair - she was out of Cabinet for at least a week before she came back as Home Sec😜

TheHandmaiden · 23/05/2023 14:39

@lljkk - okay you floored me with Rory Stewart as they really are chalk and cheese. He's erudite and intelligent, diligent and listens. It's a shame that he isn't in the Tory party now but Johnson rewarded pure loyalty, so no Rory (fairly they disliked each other) and lots of Suella (because, well, she proclaimed her loyalty).

TheHandmaiden · 23/05/2023 14:34

She was an extremely unsuccessful barrister, and does not claim to have any notable cases. She quickly became an MP, so perhaps that tells you a bit about her legal acumen.

lieselotte · 23/05/2023 14:32

countrygirl99 · 23/05/2023 14:00

@jgw1 if she is competent there must be some big achievements. I have to admit I can forgive a few indiscretions if someoneis good at their job. Sort of a positive net worth. I'd rather someone a bit naughty but competent than useless but angelic. Sadly we seem to have naughty and incompetent.

People on here have said they've worked with her and she has few in the way of brain cells. Goodness only knows how she has qualified as a lawyer and got to the position she has.

lieselotte · 23/05/2023 14:31

Arightoldcarryabag · 22/05/2023 17:09

I think the main reason is that she is so deeply unpopular so people are desperate to bring her down.
Her behaviour is unbecoming of her position and is in previous times would have been a resigning matter.

I think people are so sick of this government that they are trying to force members out any way they can so this will gain traction and probably won't be dropped by the press or on socials until she goes.

This. Giving her a Cabinet job was a big mistake by Sunak.

countrygirl99 · 23/05/2023 14:00

@jgw1 if she is competent there must be some big achievements. I have to admit I can forgive a few indiscretions if someoneis good at their job. Sort of a positive net worth. I'd rather someone a bit naughty but competent than useless but angelic. Sadly we seem to have naughty and incompetent.

jgw1 · 23/05/2023 13:55

countrygirl99 · 23/05/2023 13:41

@jgw1 well that's the usual tactics. Divert and deflect.

I just can't believe they don't want to tell us about all the wonderful things the Home Secretary has achieved in her time in office.

lljkk · 23/05/2023 13:52

Rory Stewart considers SB a friend.
I like her dress sense.
Cassiana is a pretty middle name.

See, I managed THREE positive statements (!)

countrygirl99 · 23/05/2023 13:50

Hippyhippybake · 23/05/2023 13:45

Yes if I was a civil servant I would want to divert and deflect too rather than have any light shone on the asymmetry between the way ministers get absolutely flamed for asking a question while civil servants can be responsible for hideous incompetence and face no ramifications at all.

Seeing as PHE no longer exists I'm not sure that's a valid claim

BenCoopersSupportWren · 23/05/2023 13:46

Hippyhippybake · 23/05/2023 13:31

Ok, it didn’t manage the NHS but provided the health related advice for the organisation to follow but naturally it was the Minister not Public Health England who came under fire as is always the case with the civil service.

Please, just stop now, you're embarrassing yourself. Public Health England were so vilified the organisation was disbanded and completely restructured while they were still involved in managing the pandemic. The staff weren't even given the courtesy of being told first, it was announced in the media. (Many subsequently lost their jobs when contracts were brought to a premature end.)

The blame game has started: the downgrading of Public Health England | ARC South London (nihr.ac.uk)

The blame game has started: the downgrading of Public Health England

Perhaps it was inevitable, but I did think the Government would have waited a bit longer into the pandemic, before switching the political emphasis from: “How do we get out of this mess?” into “Who got us here in the first place?”

https://arc-sl.nihr.ac.uk/news-insights/blog-and-commentary/blame-game-has-started-downgrading-public-health-england

Hippyhippybake · 23/05/2023 13:45

Yes if I was a civil servant I would want to divert and deflect too rather than have any light shone on the asymmetry between the way ministers get absolutely flamed for asking a question while civil servants can be responsible for hideous incompetence and face no ramifications at all.

WarningToTheCurious · 23/05/2023 13:44

Hippyhippybake · 23/05/2023 13:31

Ok, it didn’t manage the NHS but provided the health related advice for the organisation to follow but naturally it was the Minister not Public Health England who came under fire as is always the case with the civil service.

Both Hancock and PHE were defendants in the Gardner and Harris case, and both had the claim upheld against them; the claim against NHS England was dismissed.

countrygirl99 · 23/05/2023 13:41

@jgw1 well that's the usual tactics. Divert and deflect.

Swipe left for the next trending thread