Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this incredibly racist or am I being sensitive

641 replies

Restaurantlover · 22/05/2023 15:10

Have had to nc as incredibly outing.

I enquired about a blossom tree installation in my restaurant, someone got back to me with a quote and I said great what’s his timescales. He let me know a date and I told him it would be suitable but nothing yet agreed.
Next thing I know he says he requires a 50% deposit because he’s ordered the blossom for the tree.
I never asked him to order the blossom, never agreed that the work would actually be done and certainly didn’t agree to give him 50% upfront.

I’ve had to block him as he is continuously ringing and messaging me and is just being plain nasty, to both my husband and I.

I think he’s gone a step too far with this Facebook post though, the reference to scrubbing korma pans and polishing shoes just gets to me, I feel he’s being racist, we have an Indian restaurant but I don’t actually go/work there so he’s obviously made that up to be spiteful.

Is this incredibly racist or am I being sensitive
OP posts:
SchoolQuestionnaire · 22/05/2023 17:30

Helloword · 22/05/2023 16:33

How am I supposed to know he said Indian owners when OP hid it with some red marker.

He is being nasty but he is aggrieved about his loss.
Op, polishing your own shoes is not same as kneeling over to polish shoes of white master.

I would assume OP is a rich restaurant owner , who can afford to spend £8000 on a decorative item for her business and for tradesman it is a lot of money to stock an item like that.
He may or may not be racist. But op should also be careful to not string along and not cause a business loss by using misleading language.

Perhaps one party is racist and the other is capitalist. Both seems to lack empathy for others, given this scenario.

I’d be reluctant to fork out 4K deposit to an unknown ‘tradesman’ with no record on Companies House who isn’t even VAT registered. If he doesn’t want to incur a ‘business loss’ he should probably bother to actually establish a proper business.

Op he is a nasty racist who’s clearly bitter about your success and seems to think you owe him a living. You don’t need to reply to the post or defend yourself. He’s doing a great job in fucking up his own pretend business with his horrible attitude.

Divorcedalongtime · 22/05/2023 17:30

I often do quotes and ask for payment of materials upfront for this reason but then I wouldn’t actually buy anything until I’ve had payment. You are both unreasonable

namitynamechange · 22/05/2023 17:29

Weirdly sexist too, the way it was you dealing with him but he just posted an (apparently made up) spiel about his dealings with your husband and relegated you to "the wife". He seems... odd. To be honest if he hadn't asked for a deposit and had done all the work (as agreed) and was wanting to be paid I would think you should pay. But the way this all turned really strange and aggressive BEFORE he officially started and before he actually seems to have done the work would make me want to walk away.

Restaurantlover · 22/05/2023 17:28

justteanbiscuits · 22/05/2023 17:26

You admitted ignoring phone calls about it. Did you check his website? You could have visited the showroom and paid?

I ignored his phone calls, not about the deposit, because they were constant, one after another, 15 odd at a time. He only started doing that after he demanded I pay 50% deposit. He flat out refused to accept 20%, even though he hadn’t told me he wanted a 50% deposit

OP posts:
PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 22/05/2023 17:27

He let me know a date and I told him it would be suitable but nothing yet agreed.

Did you write

yes, this is suitable but I do not agree yet

Or

yes, this is suitable

?

You did make it sound as if definitely agreed if you chose the 2nd answer. It is perfectly alright and normal for him to be very upset (If this was indeed your reply...)

His messages are however racist. And that's definitely not okay.

purpleboy · 22/05/2023 17:26

Redebs · 22/05/2023 16:54

Why did you pay a 20% deposit if you didn't want the tree?

She didn't pay,

He asked for 50%, op wasn't happy with that as 50% is £4k. His only business page is on Facebook, she has no way of knowing if this guy is legit so wasn't happy paying £4k to a potential scammer, so she offered 20% and for the materials to be delivered to her restaurant as the tree was being made there, he refused this, so op refused to continue with the purchase, he then started harassing op and was racist.

It's not that hard to follow!

justteanbiscuits · 22/05/2023 17:26

Restaurantlover · 22/05/2023 16:59

We didn’t pretend to be on holiday, and couldn’t if we wanted to. Dh works every evening, 7 days a week. He’s not had a holiday since 2016, locals very much know this because he’s always there. It’s an absurd thing for us to say.

No deposit was mentioned when we first started communicating, he sprung it on me after saying he’d ordered the blossom, I didn’t know he was going to order it as he’d already told me he was doing it cheaper because it was leftover stock from his previous jobs

When I said 20% would be better he got nasty.

You admitted ignoring phone calls about it. Did you check his website? You could have visited the showroom and paid?

Wheresthebeach · 22/05/2023 17:25

The phone calls are harassment and with the racists element I think the police would be interested. Call them.

Scirocco · 22/05/2023 17:24

Whatever the dispute with regards a deposit, what he posted was unprofessional and fairly obviously racist. If he'd actually wanted to resolve things like a grown-up, he probably shouldn't have opted for racist rants on social media.

Ignore him, block him and report any harassment to the police.

MidnightMeltdown · 22/05/2023 17:23

Ofcourseshecan · 22/05/2023 16:57

You had a contract, you seem to be trying to back out of paying for the item you ordered, and as a result the trader got angry and nasty.

You should do the right thing and pay him. His rudeness does not give you the right to break your contract or refuse to pay the bill. He would not have been rude if you had paid as expected.

But it wasn't expected. OP wasn't told about the deposit. The point of a deposit is that you obtain it before you start anything. You can't start and then complain that someone hasn't paid.

NewPinkJacket · 22/05/2023 17:22

Have you seen your latest Google review OP, from Daniel Carter?

WisherWood · 22/05/2023 17:21

Brown people are not known for polishing white people's shoes. Also, in recent times brown people are leading many global conglomerates, so if someone sees a brown person polishing shoes, most likely they are dreaming.

I know. But there is a racist stereotype around shoe shining. I think what this person's done is to take various racist stereotypes about different ethnicities and just kind of scattergun them. As I said, it's dog whistling. It's about making it clear that the OP and her husband are other than his usual audience. So some of it (korma pans) is a bit more specific and some of it's just 'pick a racist trope, any one will do'.

Also, there is nothing wrong with the person who does a so-called menial job.

I quite agree. But jobs such as shoe shining are portrayed as 'menial' and seen in a poor light, because they're either done by non-whites or very poor white people. So the people are denigrated because of the jobs they do and the jobs are denigrated because of the people doing them. It's wrong. But I was writing against the use of these stereotypes rather than trying to feed into them. Sorry I didn't make that clearer.

SunnyEgg · 22/05/2023 17:19

Restaurantlover · 22/05/2023 17:07

He didn’t agree to 20%, I offered 20% after he sprung 50% on me.

He then got nasty because he wanted 50%

Ok actual payment of the deposit is the point where the order kicks in surely

If it didn’t happen I’m not sure the order is there

Paradise404 · 22/05/2023 17:19

Helloword · 22/05/2023 17:09

Brown people are not known for polishing white people's shoes. Also, in recent times brown people are leading many global conglomerates, so if someone sees a brown person polishing shoes, most likely they are dreaming.

Also, there is nothing wrong with the person who does a so-called menial job.

Ah, the 'ideal immigrant' stereotype... this thread has it all.

Redebs · 22/05/2023 17:18

User1432423532 · 22/05/2023 17:01

Because MN is full of racists too. Sad but true. Lots of conservative, upper middle class, brexit-voting people so it's exactly the demographic that happily sweep racial micro-aggressions as being too sensitive or woke under the rug. In their eyes, racism can't exist because brown people are not called slurs or attacked in the street anymore. So this is as good as it gets and references to shoe shining or korma pans is fully ok. Again, nobody will leave a bad review for a French restaurant saying they saw "the owner's wife is scrubbing their Le Creusets" in the back, but people here just don't seem to understand that.

Normally I'm really sensitive to racism, having experienced it for decades. I've been spat on, harassed, subject to racist violent attack and had to move house due to racism. I've campaigned against it, marched against it and debated for many a long hour. I've seen thousands of subtle and not subtle instances of the bloody crap.

But when someone says they have a photo of the owner of an Indian restaurant cleaning pans after cooking korma, I'm not immediately convinced.

Rowthe · 22/05/2023 17:18

Hes clearly racist and obnoxious to boot.

I do think I would report it to the Police even if they wont do anything but he is currently harassing you, and I would get this on record with the Police.

RB68 · 22/05/2023 17:18

Start asking for 50% deposits

Paradise404 · 22/05/2023 17:18

OP I am not only shocked and saddened by the level of racism on here (even from well known posters... whom I previously respected).

But the number of idiots who don't understand basic business. You do not start any work BEFORE a deposit is paid, so you saying 'great' is irrelevant. It's all on him for supposedly ordering the tree before money had changed hands.

AND those who believe the Dubai etc... which is clearly madness. As your later posts have showed.

Maybe people just want to kick you because you're Asian and/or a business owner. But I wouldn't be disheartened by the posts on here. You know you're right, he's a racist bully and I'd report for harassment.

ferntwist · 22/05/2023 17:17

OP this is terrible. You must report to the police to stop him doing this to anyone else. What a sicko

MayThe4th · 22/05/2023 17:13

What are his reviews like on google?

Racism aside, I can’t believe that people are blindly believing someone who writes that kind of message (the writing style says everything about the kind of person he is), talking about range rovers, and people going on holiday to Dubai, as a strategy to warn people away from doing business with them. It’s childish and unprofessional and nobody should be engaging in business with a person like him.

People are questioning why the OP has a Range Rover and accusing her of breaking the contract when she has made it perfectly clear in her subsequent posts that the stuff about the photo’s were made up, and and the work was never agreed and neither was the deposit amount.

And no. OP doesn’t have to put everything in the OP, if she’ had there would have been cries of “I couldn’t read all of your OP because it was too long.” People are capable and should be reading the OP’s posts at least, and if they don’t, then that’s on them.

OP he’s clearly a racist but tbh he’s just a nasty cunt anyway and is probably a misogynist ablist bigot irrespective of all that.

And anyone who slags off potential customers on facebook should be given a wide birth.

Restaurantlover · 22/05/2023 17:13

Tellmeimcrazy · 22/05/2023 17:10

OP this is harassment and I would get the police involved

Dh and I have had over 50 phone calls since yesterday, constant nasty messages and then prank calls and fake orders to the restaurant. But I very much doubt the police would be interested.

OP posts:
Schroedingersimmigrant · 22/05/2023 17:12

Tellmeimcrazy · 22/05/2023 17:10

OP this is harassment and I would get the police involved

If the police get involved they might actually investigate the matter....
One sm post does not constitute harassment though. It's very common for people and businesses to put up warnings.
Anything from non payments to booking 4 separate restaurants for 8ppl on sat night and deviding ladt minute which to go to...

ferntwist · 22/05/2023 17:10

Of course it’s racist. Very unpleasant. No way would I want him anywhere near my business. Sue for libel

Tellmeimcrazy · 22/05/2023 17:10

OP this is harassment and I would get the police involved

SpeckledlyHen · 22/05/2023 17:10

LibertyFloral · 22/05/2023 17:07

I've always thought that the best way to deal with silly or insulting posters is to give like for like, which is exactly what I have done in your case with this response.

Also, such a pity that you are not quite bright enough to realise that I was highlighting your user name to point out to you that almost anything can be seen as 'subtly racist'. In fact, so subtle, sometimes you really have to look for it.

You don't sound nut,s so I won't return your insult but you sound a little bit dim and I won't be engaging any more with someone operating at your level.

I think wisdom has been chasing her but she was moving faster @LibertyFloral