Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nursery no longer lets parents in..

183 replies

MaryWhy · 22/05/2023 14:41

I've just been to collect my DD from nursery early as she has a doctors appointment. When I arrive I'm told she's sleeping and I'll have to wait outside for a while whilst they wake her up, take her to the toilet and what not. She's 4 for reference and has long since dropped the naps at home but anyhow.

I was hoping to be able to use the loo quickly (i'm pregnant and was bursting!) so feel mildly annoyed by the new "rules" and lack of hospitality for parents.

No idea why the new rules exist, nursery employee was in a rush to close the door.

AIBU to find this odd?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Overthehill123 · 30/05/2023 21:35

My daughters nursery is a drop off and collect at the door. I’ve never thought it was weird- they do always invite parents into the office to wait if it’s raining though. The staff there are lovely and I’m sure if I was heavily pregnant and bursting for a wee they’d have no problem letting me use the toilet very briefly.

Rosebel · 30/05/2023 21:27

We do handovers at the door. So parents don't come in. If I go to take a child out to their parents either a floating staff member or manager will come in the room to keep the child staff ratio correct.
But even if parents did come in we wouldn't allow random people in or leave them alone with the children.

turtool · 28/05/2023 01:56

@Rosebel you can't be in ratio and keep the children safe if you have random adults there around kids your responsible for. All it takes is that one adult that comes in and does something bad. How do you recover from that

Dodger101 · 28/05/2023 00:54

PurpleWisteria1 · 23/05/2023 12:45
Dodger101 · 23/05/2023 12:40

Would want to be able to drop in at any time to see what was happening. Nobody knows what goes on behind closed doors.
Oh dear. What about school then? Going to expect to drop into the classroom any time because of closed doors?

What an awful manner you have about you.

Rosebel · 26/05/2023 08:30

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 21:29

So for tens of years it was acknowledged how important it was for children and for parents to be able to walk in and see how a child is in a nursery, and to settle them in, but since covid no parent access to nurseries has been normalised and nurseries have been turned into prisons where no parental vigilance is allowed and safeguarding compromised.
It's very poor and some shit nurseries and or in areas with shortage of supply keep making up excuses to keep parents out to stop complaints to ofsted, to stop you observing when they are our of ratios, noticing when someone raises their voice at children, or drags or pulls a child, or to stop you knowing your child sleeps most of the day in there, or has a nappy filled down to the floor for most of the day, or when crying children are left to cry their eyes out.
It is despicable that ofsted and the government has allowed the most vulnerable, voiceless members of society to continue to be mistreated like this, with babies as young as under 1 handed over the gate or door, often with strange staff since the regular ones may be too busy or out if ratios to leave the room to take your child, not settling the child into an activity before leaving, handing the child over to pretty much anyone when it's bank staff or staff from unfamiliar room. What does it teach kids being handed over at the door like this. These are babies and toddlers, and this is all very damaging. Nurseries submit paperwork to ofsted showing parents have access but in fact in some cases it's false. Complain to ofsted and complain to the council, leave reviews. Hopefully they'll close the abusive vicious fuckers who deny parents access down. Many have gone out of business after not reopening during covid when told so in may 2020 and further continuing with this shit, making up ridiculous excuses (e.g that kids settle quicker is a popular one) keeping the parents out, many simply do not send their kids to what's operating like a fucking jail for babies and toddlers. A patent should be able to walk in at any time and see their child in their environment and to assess it without any notice or prompt. Open door has always been and still is best practice. Of course you have security in place, as has always been the case.
You are not assisted by the gullible morons happy with any excuse nursery makes up or limited by the choice in their area. But this needs to stop. There are nurseries that do not allow parents in to phase a child or baby in, and requiring a baby who may have never been away from parents dropped at the door. Vile.

Truly disgusting post which just shows you don't have a clue what you're talking about.
I'm really sorry if your child has suffered like that but not allowing parents in doesn't make staff vile, abusive or anything else.
When we do handovers at the door we are never out of ratio. Either the manager or an extra staff member comes in to the room. Just pointing out that will be the case pretty much everywhere. We're simply not allowed out of ratio. End of.

KateyCuckoo · 26/05/2023 07:27

I should clarify, unfounded accusations.

KateyCuckoo · 26/05/2023 07:25

Gosh if Fairywhale was one of my parents, I'd give notice. Being a bit nosy and wishing you could come in is one thing, but out and out accusations regarding the carers of your children is absolutely not tolerated in my setting.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 25/05/2023 23:46

Fairywhale
You clearly have some personal issues.
Ranting and raving on here, replying to every PP and clogging up the thread with your ravings isn't helpful.

You both suggest parents should turn up at any time to spy and surprise nursery teachers and then say parents won't do that.

The fact you don't see that there can be massive safeguarding risks to letting parents in is worrying. It's been explained. Calm Tf down

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 23:42

This is perhaps more eloquently put by ofsted and cited in the article below, if someone fails to understand risks and disadvantages to children of banning parents from inside the nursery. I honestly cannot imagine someone who actually used a baby/toddler full day childcare setting and saw how it works not understanding the risks and believing shit like "they settle quicker", or any other ridiculous excuse.
A lot of people gave their opinions but it's clear they cannot understand that schools and early years nurseries aren't comparable, and a 1 year old attending a full day setting is completely different to a 4 year old attending the same or a sessional, for instance, 3 hour setting and so on. They also don't seem to grasp the likelihood of risks and safeguarding issues from having/not having parents go inside.
https://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/nursery-safety-risk-parents-stopped-under-covid-rules-oftsed-report-b1013560.html

Nursery ‘safety risk’ as parents stopped going in under Covid rules

An Ofsted report has warned of safeguarding risks for children in nurseries

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/nursery-safety-risk-parents-stopped-under-covid-rules-oftsed-report-b1013560.html

scrivette · 25/05/2023 23:41

I am not allowed into the nursery, it has never been an issue.

The nursery is small and there isn't room for parents to come in, plus there is a no shoe
policy.

Parents can speak to staff in the porch of required.

It has never crossed my mind that it's an issue. I am not allowed into Primary School either.

RandomCatGenerator · 25/05/2023 23:38

Fairywhale, you’re just making shit up. Some of which is upsetting to read - and mostly isn’t true.

@Rosebel ignore. I’m so grateful for my son’s amazing nursery staff. I thought they were amazing when the doors were shut and I still think they are amazing now the doors are open.

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 23:23

Sunnylassie · 23/05/2023 13:00

I wouldn’t want parents dropping into my child’s setting at any time to disrupt their routine! Why on earth do you think people should just be able to drop in whenever? It would possibly cause unnecessary upset, cause activities to be paused while a member of staff attends to the parent and the longer these thing take the more disruption is causes. There is also a safeguarding risk of parents are coming in and out any time of the day. If a parent has to collect their child early it’s much better for everyone that it’s done in a speedy manner so the staff can get back to the other children in their care.

Because there is more risk from staff caring for your child than from parents. I don't think you used a private full day nursery for babies and toddlers before if you can't grasp the risk to the kids from nor having parents walking in.

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 23:20

jimjambob · 25/05/2023 22:17

I actually think this is a good sign and shows good safeguarding. You know that your not a risk to the other children but would you like random parents wandering in and out of a building were your child is kept?

You, and other pps, very well know, that random parents wouldn't be walking around nurseries and schools all day.
Most have jobs to do and there is no reason to be wandering there most of the time. Occasionally, when there is a need, then yes parents should have immediate access to their child in their environment.
This was the case before the bleating started in support of restrictions and now the same are bleating how lovely it is that they aren't allowed to their kids in the setting they pay to use. Probably the same sh..... that were begging for more lockdowns.

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 23:11

troppibambini6 · 22/05/2023 16:03

Is it not because if other little ones see a child being collected it will upset them if their mum/ dad isn't there picking them up? I can imagine it's very disruptive having parents in and out.

It wasn't a known issue for decades till the three years of the novel 19 shitshow after which all sorts of crap excuses started cropping up. Not letting parents in benefits nursery no end. It doesn't benefit the child.

So all of them can be upset now parents aren't settling them in? Not just the ones being collected? Except they probably have learnt to calm down and internalise it instead of crying since carers can now learn to leave them crying indefinitely - how would parents know.

In the years of collecting my kids in person, I've never seen other kids get upset. It wasn't a thing along with any other made up things nurseries have come up with having seen so how lovely it is not having parents snoop around. It's not lovely for the child.

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 22:59

MaryWhy · 22/05/2023 14:41

I've just been to collect my DD from nursery early as she has a doctors appointment. When I arrive I'm told she's sleeping and I'll have to wait outside for a while whilst they wake her up, take her to the toilet and what not. She's 4 for reference and has long since dropped the naps at home but anyhow.

I was hoping to be able to use the loo quickly (i'm pregnant and was bursting!) so feel mildly annoyed by the new "rules" and lack of hospitality for parents.

No idea why the new rules exist, nursery employee was in a rush to close the door.

AIBU to find this odd?

Why don't you ask them what it is they have to hide? They will lie to you but at least they'll know parents will be questioning. You are handing over your precious young child, of course, you should be allowed to go in with your child or come and visit them unannounced. It is absurd, it is your child and you have the right to see what's happening.

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 22:49

SirenSays · 22/05/2023 15:10

Why have they changed it? I've never worked in a nursery with this policy but I can absolutely see why it would be useful in some. We had parents bring the whole family along blocking hallways, spending forever in the loos, wandering into the wrong rooms..

What kind of nursery was it? Private full day nursery for 0-4 y.o., rushed parents going to work or from work won't be bringing in a tribe with them.

It's not about convinience for the staff, or for the nursery owner, it's about what's best for the child. Parents not allowed in is extremely harmful for the child.

Now staff getting your kid ready, getting kid's things ready, bringing the kid to you, talking to you, when the ratio is 1:3 for the under 2s - to ensure their wellbeing, what happens to the other two babies when their carer is doing all of it. This is neglect, breach of ratios and safeguarding. I've seen kids all dressed in coats and waiting for parents by the door for up to an hour.

Would you dress your very young child to go out and make them sit by the door waiting for you for an hour at home? This is probably what your nursery is doing. Or many others.

No good nursery will ban parents, it goes against child wellbeing, and what's best for them, according to modern research and practice.

Rosebel · 25/05/2023 22:49

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 22:23

Oh yes at the best schools you could exactly drop in in the middle of the day and see your child in action, if you were so inclined. They were also schools with some of the best security.

Babies and toddlers are quite a bit more vulnerable than schoolchildren. Did you know some won't have learnt to talk or understand what's right and what's not. That's why parents should be able to pop in. Good nurseries will have nothing to hide.

And of course nurseries and children are partnerships, they get to know you and the other way round, and child benefits from it.

Now many don't even know who collects a child and will hand over a preverbal baby to almost anyone who calls themselves mum or dad. This is a massive breach of safeguarding. Deregistration level and prosecution for owner. But woman and child territory, who cares, particularly not ofsted that elected to monitor nurseries and school over the phone for 3 years.

What are you talking about? Even a fairly crap nursery make sure children go home with the right person. That's basic.
I'm actually really upset that some people think nursery workers go in to a badly paid job with long hours and loads of unpaid overtime just so we can be horrible to children.
Nursery nurses have to love their job. There is absolutely no way you could do it otherwise.
Sure we have unqualified staff but most are working towards being qualified and well over 50% are level three qualified or above.
Not letting parents in at drop off and pick up doesn't mean anything other than making life easier for the children. Many do get upset when parents are coming in and out but their parents are coming later.
If you really believe we are all evil monsters then there is a really simple solution.

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 22:23

redskylight · 22/05/2023 15:00

Different schools have different rules but handover at the door (no going into school) is by no means uncommon.
In your case I assume you would be allowed to look at their classroom by arrangement or when it was empty.
You couldn't turn up at the school at a random time and expect to go and see what your child was doing.

Oh yes at the best schools you could exactly drop in in the middle of the day and see your child in action, if you were so inclined. They were also schools with some of the best security.

Babies and toddlers are quite a bit more vulnerable than schoolchildren. Did you know some won't have learnt to talk or understand what's right and what's not. That's why parents should be able to pop in. Good nurseries will have nothing to hide.

And of course nurseries and children are partnerships, they get to know you and the other way round, and child benefits from it.

Now many don't even know who collects a child and will hand over a preverbal baby to almost anyone who calls themselves mum or dad. This is a massive breach of safeguarding. Deregistration level and prosecution for owner. But woman and child territory, who cares, particularly not ofsted that elected to monitor nurseries and school over the phone for 3 years.

jimjambob · 25/05/2023 22:17

I actually think this is a good sign and shows good safeguarding. You know that your not a risk to the other children but would you like random parents wandering in and out of a building were your child is kept?

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 22:08

Seashor · 25/05/2023 21:37

We aren’t allowed to let parents into school. They would have to have a staff member with them at all times and we don’t have anyone to escort people around. It’s a safe guarding issue and very good practice.

Are the children at school aged 3 months to under 4 years? Are they mostly unable to speak or voice concerns to their parents, or tell them about their day? Are schools money making profit factories? Do schools routinely change nappies and have one on one access, including ability to undress, bathe or provide other intimate care? Do schools use mostly unqualified staff? Developmentally, and emotionally, are children at school at the same stage as a 6 month baby or a 18 month old toddler, who may have never been away from mum or dad? Do school teachers still pull, drag, shout at children, force them to eat lunch, bribe them with sweets?
Best schools do operste open door policy for parents, and open door is the best policy (please educate yourself it - doesn't mean anyone off the streets walks into a classroom at any time), they won't so much as apply suncream and will never be on their own with a child (who is 5+ years old), is independent, typically can talk and had 5 years of preparation for school.
You are comparing bananas with dinosaurs, using schools as an example.

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 21:50

CM1897 · 25/05/2023 10:00

I can see it from the other side. I wouldn’t want a load of parents who don’t have DBS checks in and out of the setting, unless for a planned event. It may be disruptive and upsetting for other children too who are missing their own parents.

I can’t see why you couldn’t go through reception to use the toilet though? I use the toilet in the main reception if I need to

Has there been a case over the many years of operation of private day nurseries (which are quite small, with high staff:child ratios) of parents having done anything untoward to children while picking their own child up, dropping offs or unexpected visits? Unlikely.

But there have been many documented and many undocumented cases of staff abusing, neglecting, mistreating kids. DBS check or not. It just means the person hasn't been caught so far.

The fact that you are mentioning parents without DBS shows shockingly extreme levels of naivety.
You would have security and measures in place for parents, as has been the case for many years.

Don't make shit up. Even a moron understands how safeguarding is compromised when parents are denied access and parental vigilance is gone. Many choose nursery over childminders for open door policy and extra pairs of eyes reasons. Those simple nursery managers who thought wow jackpot let's just do what the fuck we want nobody will find out are going to end up in deep shit once there is an allegation since they for chose not to let parents in. It is poor safeguarding practice. And OFSTEAD most likely doesn't know And such settings will hopefully go out of business eventually.

Seashor · 25/05/2023 21:37

We aren’t allowed to let parents into school. They would have to have a staff member with them at all times and we don’t have anyone to escort people around. It’s a safe guarding issue and very good practice.

fairywhale · 25/05/2023 21:29

So for tens of years it was acknowledged how important it was for children and for parents to be able to walk in and see how a child is in a nursery, and to settle them in, but since covid no parent access to nurseries has been normalised and nurseries have been turned into prisons where no parental vigilance is allowed and safeguarding compromised.
It's very poor and some shit nurseries and or in areas with shortage of supply keep making up excuses to keep parents out to stop complaints to ofsted, to stop you observing when they are our of ratios, noticing when someone raises their voice at children, or drags or pulls a child, or to stop you knowing your child sleeps most of the day in there, or has a nappy filled down to the floor for most of the day, or when crying children are left to cry their eyes out.
It is despicable that ofsted and the government has allowed the most vulnerable, voiceless members of society to continue to be mistreated like this, with babies as young as under 1 handed over the gate or door, often with strange staff since the regular ones may be too busy or out if ratios to leave the room to take your child, not settling the child into an activity before leaving, handing the child over to pretty much anyone when it's bank staff or staff from unfamiliar room. What does it teach kids being handed over at the door like this. These are babies and toddlers, and this is all very damaging. Nurseries submit paperwork to ofsted showing parents have access but in fact in some cases it's false. Complain to ofsted and complain to the council, leave reviews. Hopefully they'll close the abusive vicious fuckers who deny parents access down. Many have gone out of business after not reopening during covid when told so in may 2020 and further continuing with this shit, making up ridiculous excuses (e.g that kids settle quicker is a popular one) keeping the parents out, many simply do not send their kids to what's operating like a fucking jail for babies and toddlers. A patent should be able to walk in at any time and see their child in their environment and to assess it without any notice or prompt. Open door has always been and still is best practice. Of course you have security in place, as has always been the case.
You are not assisted by the gullible morons happy with any excuse nursery makes up or limited by the choice in their area. But this needs to stop. There are nurseries that do not allow parents in to phase a child or baby in, and requiring a baby who may have never been away from parents dropped at the door. Vile.

UsingChangeofName · 25/05/2023 18:42

I can’t see why you couldn’t go through reception to use the toilet though? I use the toilet in the main reception if I need to

well clearly all nurseries are held in different buildings, and overwhelmingly won't have a toilet in the main reception - or even a 'main reception' in many cases.

Magicmama92 · 25/05/2023 10:46

Our nursery used to let you in pick up time but drop off at the door so they didn't get as upset. They changed managers and she stopped us going in which I didn't like as it was nice to go in. But I also do understand it. I'd personally just ask about it.