Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask why so many child-free people are on Mumsnet?

386 replies

DarlingClementine85 · 21/05/2023 23:26

I already know this is going to be divisive and I'm hesitating before I even type this. I don't mean this in a snarky or judgemental way at all. It's just a straightforward question that I've been pondering. It seems there's a lot of posters on here who are child-free by choice (I'm not talking about people dealing with infertility who would dearly love to be parents). And I was wondering why, as this is predominantly a forum for getting or giving parental advice? For questions about trying to understand their friends with kids, I absolutely get it. But I see plenty of threads about various parenting issues and there's always people saying things like "I don't have kids, but..."

TIA for not taking offence!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MinervaSaidThar · 22/05/2023 09:56

Nanny0gg · 22/05/2023 09:54

Surely though, if you looked around and saw the different topics it would be obvious that there's everything as well as the kitchen sink on here?

Home & Garden, Feminism, Slimming, TV and Film, Money, Pets, Travel... And you're ON AIBU!

Not rocket science (new Topic idea there MN!)

She thinks only mums would he interested in those topics. Bizarre.

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 09:55

I don’t think op said anything nasty at all.

MinervaSaidThar · 22/05/2023 09:54

Schroedingersimmigrant · 22/05/2023 09:48

I would like MN to confirm whether posters starting these or any "it will be divisive blah, but I am new" threads are actually new.
Because I don't believe that line at all

Looks like she’s had a name change failure already.

Weird that they know how to name change but not search a topic. A quick search would have brought up dozens of threads shaming childless MN users.

Nanny0gg · 22/05/2023 09:54

DarlingClementine85 · 21/05/2023 23:40

Thank you! It was a genuine question and I'm not sure why I'm getting such snarky responses. I wasn't criticising people for not having kids or trying to gatekeep or whatever. I just genuinely thought this was a parenting forum. But I haven't been here as long as some, and haven't had the pleasure of being part of what is clearly a warm and welcoming community of women 🥱

Surely though, if you looked around and saw the different topics it would be obvious that there's everything as well as the kitchen sink on here?

Home & Garden, Feminism, Slimming, TV and Film, Money, Pets, Travel... And you're ON AIBU!

Not rocket science (new Topic idea there MN!)

MinervaSaidThar · 22/05/2023 09:52

DarlingClementine85 · 22/05/2023 07:56

No, obviously that's not what I'm referring to, come on now! I'm referring to "Silly little cow. Idiots like you really shouldn't breed". Can you imagine someone shouting that at you in the street and not thinking they were a little unhinged? It's a HUGE overreaction to my initial question, which if you read in the neutral way it was intended, you would see 😬

If you say nasty things you should accept that you may get nasty responses back.

Not everyone will turn the other cheek.

Schroedingersimmigrant · 22/05/2023 09:48

I would like MN to confirm whether posters starting these or any "it will be divisive blah, but I am new" threads are actually new.
Because I don't believe that line at all

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 09:42

Isthisexpected · 22/05/2023 07:56

The logo above the OP literally says " by parents for parents"

Indeed. Obviously the posters who don’t have kids or are not TTC who are really aggressive about their sense of entitlement to be here on equal terms with parents, kind of drown out all the sensible, mild posters, without kids, who get the fact that sometimes their input might not be welcoming on the parenting threads.

It does seem to be a hobby for some aggressive ones to see how many times they can call parents ‘vile’ in any given week on a parenting forum. It’s only natural to wonder why they choose to come here, why they choose parents, mums in particular, to vent at.

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 09:33

Yuasa · 22/05/2023 07:54

There is something really messed up about joining a forum for a group of people you don’t belong to, or want to belong to, and then slagging that group of people off while you are there. It is typical of a female led service to just self-abnegatingly put up with that kind of shit in order to be welcoming to everyone.

This - and the op’s agreement with it - is what irritated me. Quite clearly states childfree women are outside the group that belong here and goes on to suggest that the group who do belong are going above and beyond by tolerating their presence. And, you know, perhaps shouldn’t if they step outside what they are permitted to talk about.

That’s before we get to the fact most of us are unfamiliar with the ‘really messed up’ behaviour described.

I have witnessed it at a very vulnerable time in my life and I can see how someone without kids might not notice and pick up on it, because it doesn’t affect them, it doesn’t sting, it doesn’t smart.

There seem to be posters on this thread claiming “I don’t have kids and don’t go on the parenting threads’ on the one hand, while saying “Parents claiming that people without kids, slag them off on parenting threads, are making it up”. Are you on the parenting threads or not? If you are on them, then you will see it.

CabbagePatchDole · 22/05/2023 09:32

DarlingClementine85 · 22/05/2023 07:56

No, obviously that's not what I'm referring to, come on now! I'm referring to "Silly little cow. Idiots like you really shouldn't breed". Can you imagine someone shouting that at you in the street and not thinking they were a little unhinged? It's a HUGE overreaction to my initial question, which if you read in the neutral way it was intended, you would see 😬

Okay… I really want to be polite but your initial question was frustratingly divisive, insensitive and ignorant. As you now know there are so many reasons people are on here. Some were pregnant when they joined but sadly miscarried and stayed; others joined by chance and stayed for some of the interesting and funny posts etc etc. Most of us live in a world with children in it. Do you get it now? MN is for all women and it is absolutely brilliant.

This thread reminds me of a time when colleagues at work were talking about their children going through a particular phase. I am very close to my nephews and nieces and chimed in about them and was cold shouldered by one person in particular who, because I wasn’t a mother, saw my views as invalid. It was awful to be so deliberately excluded. Interestingly it was a man who did this. The women were all much kinder and inclusive.

You’re not a man are you, OP? (Apologies to any lovely men who I may offend)

FrostyFifi · 22/05/2023 09:10

It’s a parenting forum so why aren’t dads welcome?

It's become one of the rare predominantly female discussion spaces online. That is valuable and what draws all women to it, even the dreaded child free ones.

PregnantQuestions · 22/05/2023 09:03

SargentSagittarius · 22/05/2023 05:08

MN started out as a forum for parents, but it’s much more than that now, years later.

I’m a parent, but I don’t come here for parenting chat or advice.

I come here because it’s predominantly a women’s site, which I really like.

Mumsnet is, now, an international discussion forum for women to virtually meet and chat about all sorts. All women welcome. I personally have far more issue with men who come here than non-parents. Smile

It’s a parenting forum so why aren’t dads welcome?

SmirnoffIceIsNice · 22/05/2023 08:53

Literally 30 seconds of researching the site would show you it's not predominantly a forum for getting or giving parental advice any more. It's much more diverse than that.

Regardless of the subject matter, we shouldn't exclude non-parents from having an opinion. They may have contact with children in many different ways (nanny, childminder, nursery worker, aunt/uncle, babysitter...) and are entitled to present an opinion of their own, even if other posters don't agree with it.

Usetherightgearforthehill · 22/05/2023 08:40

DarlingClementine85 · 22/05/2023 00:44

Thank you for your genuinely lovely reply, it's restored my faith in this community. There really are a lot of surprisingly angry people on here.

Are you really suprised that people are angry when you make divisive comments? Because for a lot of us your thread is the kind of thing that destroys our faith in this community not restores it.

I spend a lot of time in my life both on here and through my work trying to make life/work better for mothers. I've campaigned for it, I speak out about it a lot.

I've helped mothers out of abusive relationships and made sure their children are safe.

But apparently I'm still not good enough to talk to mothers.

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 22/05/2023 08:36

Tiredalwaystired · 22/05/2023 08:14

Ignore those that say “here we go again”. Some people forget that they were new here once too. And surprise surprise, I bet they didnt know there were “a million and one threads like this before” when they joined either.

it’s a valid question given the website name. Some people have been polite enough to share their answer in a straightforward way without trying to somehow make you feel like a fool.

the others are dicks.

Why not feel like a fool? You only need to peruse the site for a few moments to see its not all about parenting, and momentarily engage your brain to think maybe that's what it originally was and it changed, expanded, evolved Hmm

BenCoopersSupportWren · 22/05/2023 08:26

ShandaLear · 22/05/2023 06:26

Parts of it are about parenting, and some men post on here, but mostly it’s a diary of what it means to be a woman in the 21st century. We discuss our problems, ideas and views. We give and seek advice. We laugh, and sometimes cry. We range widely in our thinking, backgrounds, and approaches to life, and that makes the discussions rich and varied. I read posts ranging from higher education, feminism and books, right through to nice handbags and what lipstick to wear to a wedding - and all are interesting to me, and very little of it is about my kids. It’s likely called Mumsnet because it has its roots in being a space to give and receive parenting advice, but the name no longer accurately reflects what it is and does. Overall, it’s a force for good and has supported many women to set boundaries and leave relationships that make them unhappy, as well as get legal and employment advice.

This is a great post.

I’m CFBC. I came for the feminism and stayed for the…umm, feminism.

IME it’s other parents who are most judgemental about parents anyway. I’ve seen a lot more unspoken (and sometimes more overt) “of course my little darlings would never dream of behaving like that because I brought them up properly” type comments than I ever have “childfree but you’re parenting wrong” ones.

Bargellobitch · 22/05/2023 08:25

NewPinkJacket · 21/05/2023 23:37

Lol it's not divisive, just very repetitive.

This 😂

Daisrose · 22/05/2023 08:22

Do you also realise op, that the entire world is driven by pronatalism - so you’re essentially claiming yet another place where women are divided by the their ability to have children. Some people who are child free by choice made that decision due to trauma - not because they hate all little people and their families as you seem to think

PixieLaLa · 22/05/2023 08:18

You do realise being ‘child free by choice’ doesn’t take away the ability to read about a situation and give advice or an opinion? Not birthing a child doesn’t mean you don’t have experience in dealing with kids, nieces/nephews, step kids, teaching etc.

Also you have posted in AIBU so don’t be surprised when you get told yes you are being unreasonable (which you are).

Daisrose · 22/05/2023 08:18

Couldn’t have children and wasn’t particularly offended but some of your replies op, wow - talk about divisive

Tiredalwaystired · 22/05/2023 08:14

Ignore those that say “here we go again”. Some people forget that they were new here once too. And surprise surprise, I bet they didnt know there were “a million and one threads like this before” when they joined either.

it’s a valid question given the website name. Some people have been polite enough to share their answer in a straightforward way without trying to somehow make you feel like a fool.

the others are dicks.

Jeezuswept · 22/05/2023 08:04

DarlingClementine85 · 22/05/2023 07:56

No, obviously that's not what I'm referring to, come on now! I'm referring to "Silly little cow. Idiots like you really shouldn't breed". Can you imagine someone shouting that at you in the street and not thinking they were a little unhinged? It's a HUGE overreaction to my initial question, which if you read in the neutral way it was intended, you would see 😬

It's not a neutral question though, is it?

It's loaded with judgement and your fake confusion isn't fooling anyone.

You even clarified what you really meant was 'why are non parents criticising parents?' but that's never been my experience.

You've offended several posters and tried to 'other' a group of women (and men), that's not on.

Isthisexpected · 22/05/2023 07:56

The logo above the OP literally says " by parents for parents"

Doggymummar · 22/05/2023 07:56

DarlingClementine85 · 21/05/2023 23:26

I already know this is going to be divisive and I'm hesitating before I even type this. I don't mean this in a snarky or judgemental way at all. It's just a straightforward question that I've been pondering. It seems there's a lot of posters on here who are child-free by choice (I'm not talking about people dealing with infertility who would dearly love to be parents). And I was wondering why, as this is predominantly a forum for getting or giving parental advice? For questions about trying to understand their friends with kids, I absolutely get it. But I see plenty of threads about various parenting issues and there's always people saying things like "I don't have kids, but..."

TIA for not taking offence!!

I hide all the parent and child boards as I am not interested in them. My question to you is why do parents keep posting in AiBu and other places than they already have designated?

DarlingClementine85 · 22/05/2023 07:56

CabbagePatchDole · 22/05/2023 03:05

Unhinged? To say that the child free are allowed to function? What is your problem?

No, obviously that's not what I'm referring to, come on now! I'm referring to "Silly little cow. Idiots like you really shouldn't breed". Can you imagine someone shouting that at you in the street and not thinking they were a little unhinged? It's a HUGE overreaction to my initial question, which if you read in the neutral way it was intended, you would see 😬

OP posts:
Yuasa · 22/05/2023 07:54

There is something really messed up about joining a forum for a group of people you don’t belong to, or want to belong to, and then slagging that group of people off while you are there. It is typical of a female led service to just self-abnegatingly put up with that kind of shit in order to be welcoming to everyone.

This - and the op’s agreement with it - is what irritated me. Quite clearly states childfree women are outside the group that belong here and goes on to suggest that the group who do belong are going above and beyond by tolerating their presence. And, you know, perhaps shouldn’t if they step outside what they are permitted to talk about.

That’s before we get to the fact most of us are unfamiliar with the ‘really messed up’ behaviour described.