Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask why so many child-free people are on Mumsnet?

386 replies

DarlingClementine85 · 21/05/2023 23:26

I already know this is going to be divisive and I'm hesitating before I even type this. I don't mean this in a snarky or judgemental way at all. It's just a straightforward question that I've been pondering. It seems there's a lot of posters on here who are child-free by choice (I'm not talking about people dealing with infertility who would dearly love to be parents). And I was wondering why, as this is predominantly a forum for getting or giving parental advice? For questions about trying to understand their friends with kids, I absolutely get it. But I see plenty of threads about various parenting issues and there's always people saying things like "I don't have kids, but..."

TIA for not taking offence!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 10:26

ilovesooty · 22/05/2023 10:23

Without examples comments like that are pretty meaningless.

I don’t care at this point.

ilovesooty · 22/05/2023 10:25

MinervaSaidThar · 22/05/2023 10:23

I've been getting some threatening personal messages now

Yeah sure you are, OP 😂

Any screenshots?

If she's getting messages like that she needs to report them.

Schroedingersimmigrant · 22/05/2023 10:25

BreviloquentBastard · 22/05/2023 10:16

Congratulations OP you've experienced your first Mumsnet pile on. How do you feel? Any death threats in your inbox yet?

I got told I should kill myself over what I thought was a very innocuous comment about surrogacy once. It can be a hive mind here sometimes and the hive is full of very angry hornets. Don't take it too personally and try and focus on the reasoned and measured responses rather than the bile!

That shouldn't happen and hope the poster got "perma ban" (not like it works lately....)

MinervaSaidThar · 22/05/2023 10:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You do realise that you do not own this forum right? It’s not your job to decide who gets to post or who doesn’t.

Go make your own forum if that’s what you want.

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 10:23

SilentParrot · 22/05/2023 10:20

surely many teachers venting on Mumsnet about the annoying things their students parents do are parents themselves?

Any teacher I know socially is also a parent and it really doesn't stop them giving 'frank opinions' on some of the parents they encounter.

I am talking specifically about the ones who aren’t. It is quite possible that at one point it was just one poster who was a child-free teacher who posted a lot and gave the impression there were many of them. How can you know? Usually teachers who are also parents will say so too.

ilovesooty · 22/05/2023 10:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Without examples comments like that are pretty meaningless.

MinervaSaidThar · 22/05/2023 10:23

I've been getting some threatening personal messages now

Yeah sure you are, OP 😂

Any screenshots?

SilentParrot · 22/05/2023 10:20

surely many teachers venting on Mumsnet about the annoying things their students parents do are parents themselves?

Any teacher I know socially is also a parent and it really doesn't stop them giving 'frank opinions' on some of the parents they encounter.

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 10:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Usetherightgearforthehill · 22/05/2023 10:17

It does happen that childfree posters post on threads about parenting sometimes I've seen it.

But what I have seen at least as often is people with children coming into threads about infertility or IVF to give unwanted advice about a situation they also don't understand (my uncles neighbours sister went on holiday and got pregnant have you tried stopping IVf and just relaxing etc) often on threads where people are equally vulnerable and emotionally fragile.

Parents aren't suddenly some perfect group of people who can do no wrong and childfree people aren't just a bunch of bitches.

I've also seen parents horrifically tear other parents down and childfree posters be the ones to defend them.

People are people, good and bad, someone's ability or willingness to procreate does not dictate whether they are a decent person or not or whether they can add value to a thread or not.

Ive recently posted on threads about a mother struggling with a child's spider phobia and another mother struggling with a child's food avoidance. As someone with a spider phobia and food avoidance I do genuinely think my advice on how I have dealt with both was better than the parents coming out with stuff like:

'Just stop helping her at night and leave her to cope'
'Children won't starve themselves'

Would the threads have gone as well without me, probably. But you could say that of any poster here. I would love to know what value the OP thinks she has added when she is new to the site before she tears into those who may have been adding value for years.

BreviloquentBastard · 22/05/2023 10:16

Congratulations OP you've experienced your first Mumsnet pile on. How do you feel? Any death threats in your inbox yet?

I got told I should kill myself over what I thought was a very innocuous comment about surrogacy once. It can be a hive mind here sometimes and the hive is full of very angry hornets. Don't take it too personally and try and focus on the reasoned and measured responses rather than the bile!

ilovesooty · 22/05/2023 10:12

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 10:07

I really cba. I remember a while back there were a lot of threads on chat by teachers, saying essentially ‘I don’t have any kids, but fellow teachers, what is it that parents do that piss you off the most?’.

As a parent you can completely empathise with another parent’s difficulties and anxieties and many of the ‘annoying’ things parents were said to do were clearly just parents at the end of their tether, possibly with kids with undiagnosed SEN.

This is the thing, you want me to trawl through upsetting things to present you with compelling evidence, before you’ll contemplate that maybe there is something in what I am saying. Seriously, you clearly couldn’t give a shiny one about me, so why expect this from me?

Are you seriously suggesting that child free teachers have no right to comment on parents' behaviour if it impacts on their ability to do their jobs?

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 10:12

DarlingClementine85 · 22/05/2023 10:03

I haven't changed my name and I am new here (and I am not a man, lol). I think you're referring to another poster who said she had to change her name after being "lynched" for asking a similar question.

I feel like this is turning into a witch hunt and I've been getting some threatening personal messages now, which was unexpected because I've looked back at all my comments and there's nothing nasty there, and nothing I wouldn't say to someones face. Sometimes people forget there is a real person behind the anonymity. I've never been on the recieving end of a forum pile up and it's really made me think about group behaviour and how easy mob mentality can be online, because many of the messages are not related to what I actually said at all. So, thank you for this.

OP, hold on to the fact that there are loads of nice posters on this thread both with and without children, taking what you said in good faith, understanding that you meant no harm. I have often wondered about it too. Your op certainly kicked the hornets’ nest though. 😬 Yikes.

BenCoopersSupportWren · 22/05/2023 10:11

Report the PMs to MN, OP, they have the facility to look at PM inboxes and can deal with the transgressors accordingly.

There is a very common pattern playing out here though, which you might want to reflect on. MN gets a LOT of “wide eyed ingenue with a faux-innocent and obviously controversial question, who then claims to be the victim of a bullying pile-on when people disagree” threads, so there is inevitably a certain amount of world-weariness / sharpness when we see it happen yet again. This can be a hugely supportive place but it’s also a place where women don’t have to take any shit or police their tone to be “nice” (so long as we stay within TGs) so there is an element of play stupid games, win stupid prizes.

ilovesooty · 22/05/2023 10:10

Of course no one should be sending unsolicited or threatening PMs to anyone.

Usetherightgearforthehill · 22/05/2023 10:08

DarlingClementine85 · 22/05/2023 10:03

I haven't changed my name and I am new here (and I am not a man, lol). I think you're referring to another poster who said she had to change her name after being "lynched" for asking a similar question.

I feel like this is turning into a witch hunt and I've been getting some threatening personal messages now, which was unexpected because I've looked back at all my comments and there's nothing nasty there, and nothing I wouldn't say to someones face. Sometimes people forget there is a real person behind the anonymity. I've never been on the recieving end of a forum pile up and it's really made me think about group behaviour and how easy mob mentality can be online, because many of the messages are not related to what I actually said at all. So, thank you for this.

Excuse me if I'm finding it hard to believe that childfree people are bombarding you with threatening personal messages. It's a good way to make them look bad without having to do anything to prove it though.

On the plus side its an unexpected bonus for you OP. Because if childfree people are sending you threatening messages you can report them to MN and get them banned thereby ridding the forum of some of the people you think don't belong here.

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 10:07

SilentParrot · 22/05/2023 10:00

can you point to any specific threads? It's just not something I've personally noticed, non-parents striding onto parenting threads and being obnoxious.

I really cba. I remember a while back there were a lot of threads on chat by teachers, saying essentially ‘I don’t have any kids, but fellow teachers, what is it that parents do that piss you off the most?’.

As a parent you can completely empathise with another parent’s difficulties and anxieties and many of the ‘annoying’ things parents were said to do were clearly just parents at the end of their tether, possibly with kids with undiagnosed SEN.

This is the thing, you want me to trawl through upsetting things to present you with compelling evidence, before you’ll contemplate that maybe there is something in what I am saying. Seriously, you clearly couldn’t give a shiny one about me, so why expect this from me?

FuckTheLemonsandBail · 22/05/2023 10:04

People often join when they're considering having children and then stay when they decide not to or aren't able to.

It might be called MumsNet but really it's just a massive, well known forum for primarily adult women. And most of the topics are nothing to do with kids.

DarlingClementine85 · 22/05/2023 10:03

MinervaSaidThar · 22/05/2023 09:54

Looks like she’s had a name change failure already.

Weird that they know how to name change but not search a topic. A quick search would have brought up dozens of threads shaming childless MN users.

I haven't changed my name and I am new here (and I am not a man, lol). I think you're referring to another poster who said she had to change her name after being "lynched" for asking a similar question.

I feel like this is turning into a witch hunt and I've been getting some threatening personal messages now, which was unexpected because I've looked back at all my comments and there's nothing nasty there, and nothing I wouldn't say to someones face. Sometimes people forget there is a real person behind the anonymity. I've never been on the recieving end of a forum pile up and it's really made me think about group behaviour and how easy mob mentality can be online, because many of the messages are not related to what I actually said at all. So, thank you for this.

OP posts:
MinervaSaidThar · 22/05/2023 10:02

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 09:58

I don’t think people can actually change names on the same thread anymore to avoid sock puppets.

You can still name change on a thread.

VickyEadieofThigh · 22/05/2023 10:02

DarlingClementine85 · 21/05/2023 23:32

Oh no I already feel like this is going south lol. I'm very new to Mumsnet and I only really click on the threads that interest me which are about parenting, which most of them seem to be, to be fair? I didn't know this had previously been brought up sorry.

Did you have a look through AIBU before you posted this often-asked question on this particular forum? Because if you did, you'd have noticed that the majority of threads on AIBUY have nothing to do with children.

SilentParrot · 22/05/2023 10:00

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 09:33

I have witnessed it at a very vulnerable time in my life and I can see how someone without kids might not notice and pick up on it, because it doesn’t affect them, it doesn’t sting, it doesn’t smart.

There seem to be posters on this thread claiming “I don’t have kids and don’t go on the parenting threads’ on the one hand, while saying “Parents claiming that people without kids, slag them off on parenting threads, are making it up”. Are you on the parenting threads or not? If you are on them, then you will see it.

can you point to any specific threads? It's just not something I've personally noticed, non-parents striding onto parenting threads and being obnoxious.

HeidiUpTheMountain · 22/05/2023 09:59

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 09:58

I don’t think people can actually change names on the same thread anymore to avoid sock puppets.

No, but you only need two email addresses to have two accounts, and it’s been pretty obvious to me when that happens on some trolling threads.

MinervaSaidThar · 22/05/2023 09:59

magma32 · 22/05/2023 00:26

There is something really messed up about joining a forum for a group of people you don’t belong to, or want to belong to, and then slagging that group of people off while you are there. It is typical of a female led service to just self-abnegatingly put up with that kind of shit in order to be welcoming to everyone.

@DreamingCatTwitches exactly

And yet no one will link to any example threads of child free people slagging off parents.

Because they don’t exist.

DreamingCatTwitches · 22/05/2023 09:58

I don’t think people can actually change names on the same thread anymore to avoid sock puppets.