Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask why so many child-free people are on Mumsnet?

386 replies

DarlingClementine85 · 21/05/2023 23:26

I already know this is going to be divisive and I'm hesitating before I even type this. I don't mean this in a snarky or judgemental way at all. It's just a straightforward question that I've been pondering. It seems there's a lot of posters on here who are child-free by choice (I'm not talking about people dealing with infertility who would dearly love to be parents). And I was wondering why, as this is predominantly a forum for getting or giving parental advice? For questions about trying to understand their friends with kids, I absolutely get it. But I see plenty of threads about various parenting issues and there's always people saying things like "I don't have kids, but..."

TIA for not taking offence!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
JorisBonson · 23/05/2023 04:59

chickawhoo · 23/05/2023 00:28

No, it's a dismissive remark implying that's the only difference between a parent and non parent.

Nobody's asking for an ode to anything, you're being obtuse on purpose.
The phrase is not required at all,is the point. "Birthed a child" instantly pinpoints it all on that one action rather than any grasp of what being a parent actually means. And nobody expects someone who is not parenting to understand that, that would be equally ridiculous.
But the phrase is regularly tossed around by many CFBC when trying to belittle anyone who doesn't show excitement over their choice.
Be on a mum forum all you wish, that is your prerogative. But don't presume to tell parents that it's fine being reduced to no more than giving birth.

I didn't throw it around because I want someone to "show excitement over my choice", I said it because there is a section of women having to justify posting on an internet forum. Can't you see how downright bizarre that is? Why the gatekeeping of chat and advice about non parenting topics?

kettlebellchips · 23/05/2023 04:23

BrightYellowDaffodil · 21/05/2023 23:32

Perhaps you could do a search for the many many times this has been asked before?

Or are we going to go through it all again? Because I’ll get the bingo cards ready if we are.

This always makes me laugh. It’s a discussion forum. Most things have been discussed before. And they’ll be discussed again. If we applied this rule to real life, we’d all have one or two conversations a month.

coronation2023 · 23/05/2023 04:17

@SparklyBlackKitten

Why do you always chat such shit ?

SargentSagittarius · 23/05/2023 03:23

They’re not going to change the name - the brand is too well known.

And they know full well that the name doesn’t stop anyone from joining in, rediculous (sic) or not.

SparklyBlackKitten · 23/05/2023 03:17

It's rediculous to me to be on a website that is called MUMSnet when you arent a mum. Even when you are a dad I find it beyond weird.

They should change the freaking name already.

It's like id i would go on the black mumsnet sub section and start posting there. Eventhough im not black

Just doesn't make any sense.

MrsMikeDrop · 23/05/2023 02:54

Also we would be poor role models to our children if we can't be inclusive to all people. How would we feel if our children were treated the same way, quite devastated I would think. Mothers all have a shared experience but we are not better than those who have not children, nor are we wiser so I'd welcome others opinions on everything personally

MrsMikeDrop · 23/05/2023 02:51

chickawhoo · 23/05/2023 00:28

No, it's a dismissive remark implying that's the only difference between a parent and non parent.

Nobody's asking for an ode to anything, you're being obtuse on purpose.
The phrase is not required at all,is the point. "Birthed a child" instantly pinpoints it all on that one action rather than any grasp of what being a parent actually means. And nobody expects someone who is not parenting to understand that, that would be equally ridiculous.
But the phrase is regularly tossed around by many CFBC when trying to belittle anyone who doesn't show excitement over their choice.
Be on a mum forum all you wish, that is your prerogative. But don't presume to tell parents that it's fine being reduced to no more than giving birth.

I don't think people are reducing it to that at all, I think you're being overly sensitive tbh! And in context it's probably an appropriate response if someone is being a dick.

Dalekjastninerels · 23/05/2023 02:27

Because I feel like it is why OP.

IAteAllTheTomatoes · 23/05/2023 01:23

I'm just looking to see who leaves their kids unattended and I'm going to get myself two that way!!!!

The only alternative female dominated form is tattle and that appears more gossipy than her.

There's lots topics of where it makes no difference of you have children or not - relationships, aibu, fashion etc.

I've also enjoy reading threads from a mother's perspective too - before this site I would have always given friends a lot time & space after childbirth thinking it was a family time & I would only be in the way but A lot of posters here would say that that reduces after the first month and that they would enjoy a catch up rather than a call or a text, or even offering to do some washing while mum and baby sleep or dropping off some cooked meals etc would be nice. I think I'm a more supportive friend to my friends as a result. Remembering the child's birthday, sending cards etc. Might sound stupid but a lot of that wouldn't occur to me.

I also manage a team at work and the return to work posts and how to be a more supportive boss are helpful too.

Just because we don't have children doesn't mean we aren't interested in those who do.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 23/05/2023 00:48

@chickawhoo It’s my comment you’re taking issue with. A comment where I also referred to my own mum as abusive. Believe you me, I understand that being a good parent is far more than just giving birth to a baby.

My point was that this thread makes it clear that for some on MN, only the act of having had a baby makes it OK for you to comment on the range of sub-forums that have nothing to do with parenting, and where experience of parenting is therefore totally irrelevant.

You don’t need to have been a parent to counsel a person whose teenage daughter is in tremendous pain. I didn’t need to be a parent to do that, and yet many on this thread feel that I shouldn’t be commenting on fucking parking threads because I’ve no experience of childrearing.

Maybe it’s a lazy shorthand and what you’d have preferred was me saying that my opinion is irrelevant because I haven’t birthed a child and then sacrificed decades of my life to the selfless and noble art of raising that child.

But my view is that parenting status is irrelevant to many MN forums to begin with, so how it’s described is even more bloody irrelevant.

chickawhoo · 23/05/2023 00:28

FrostyFifi · 22/05/2023 23:59

the phrase "just because we haven't birthed a child" thrown around in a way that diminishes so much of what it actually is to be a mum

No it doesn't. It's a factual descriptor. Sorry if you'd prefer an ode to motherhood each time.

No, it's a dismissive remark implying that's the only difference between a parent and non parent.

Nobody's asking for an ode to anything, you're being obtuse on purpose.
The phrase is not required at all,is the point. "Birthed a child" instantly pinpoints it all on that one action rather than any grasp of what being a parent actually means. And nobody expects someone who is not parenting to understand that, that would be equally ridiculous.
But the phrase is regularly tossed around by many CFBC when trying to belittle anyone who doesn't show excitement over their choice.
Be on a mum forum all you wish, that is your prerogative. But don't presume to tell parents that it's fine being reduced to no more than giving birth.

FrostyFifi · 22/05/2023 23:59

the phrase "just because we haven't birthed a child" thrown around in a way that diminishes so much of what it actually is to be a mum

No it doesn't. It's a factual descriptor. Sorry if you'd prefer an ode to motherhood each time.

echt · 22/05/2023 23:41

The thing that gets on my threepennies about this topic is the utter lack of imagination on the part of the OP for posting in the first place. Every every time.

Just scroll through the topics. Work it out. How hard can it be?

Usetherightgearforthehill · 22/05/2023 23:36

chickawhoo · 22/05/2023 23:16

Ah the phrase "just because we haven't birthed a child" thrown around in a way that diminishes so much of what it actually is to be a mum, always puts me in mind of the Peep Show quote,
"If there isn't room here for people who stand against everything you believe in, then what sort of hippy free for all is this?"

I have my neice living with me and have done for some time. I may not be a mum but i know far more about what it is to parent a child well than my abusive parents ever did, my mother may have birthed me but she did not parent me.

So you are right birthing a child alone is not the sum total of good parenting. But what I hate on here is how often parents put ALL parents above childfree people. Forgetting that that means they are making out that abusive parents are better than childfree people. So actually sometimes its the parents who distinguish it merely based on who birthed a child.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 22/05/2023 23:22

How does it “diminish” it?

chickawhoo · 22/05/2023 23:16

Ah the phrase "just because we haven't birthed a child" thrown around in a way that diminishes so much of what it actually is to be a mum, always puts me in mind of the Peep Show quote,
"If there isn't room here for people who stand against everything you believe in, then what sort of hippy free for all is this?"

CabbagePatchDole · 22/05/2023 23:14

Shoutinglagerlagerlager · 22/05/2023 20:02

People can do what they want online obviously but I honestly can’t imagine if I were child-free by choice or a bloke why I would spend my time browsing a site called ‘mumsnet’. Perhaps they should rebrand and change the name of the site since it’s not being used as intended.

It’s such a great name though.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 22/05/2023 21:16

I remember once giving a poster advice and support on how to help her suicidal teenager, because I was a suicidal teenager (whose own mother was abusive and therefore utterly useless).

Perhaps I should have made it clear that my experience was irrelevant, having never birthed a child. :O

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 22/05/2023 21:04

IrritableVowel · 22/05/2023 07:36

Same here. Can't say I have noticed any child-free posters ploughing through a parenting thread with their opinions, and I have been here a long time. It is a shame the OP has stumbled across so many that she has formed such a negative view of us.

Ignoring my snarky reply above, I don't have kids. But I have been one. And I have had difficult times with my parents. So occasionally if a poster asks about something their teens are experiencing, I can remember what I did and how I got through it. And I reply. I don't claim to be an expert, but I don't see how my opinion or experience is less valid than someone with a baby, who never went through XYZ. But apparently it is, by virtue of them being a parent

Usually I don't care about posts like this, it is often an innocent (if not well thought) question, but it does piss me off that people can't fathom that adults without kids still have some experience and opinions of being a kid, a childhood, a teenage life, having parents...

Exactly this. If a poster is concerned about her 15 year-old daughter, the mother of boys aged five and seven has no more insight than I do other than by the virtue of being a mother. We can both think back to having been a 15 year-old girl, but neither of us have parented one. Why is my opinion less important or valid?

Frankly, I find the idea that non-parents can never criticise a parenting decision just because they don’t make those decisions themselves bizarre. The whole “But you can’t possibly understaaaand how hard it is, you can’t say what you’d do” routine… why does this only seem to apply to parenting?

If you were unhappy with your medical treatment, you’d be advised to at least question it - you wouldn’t be told “Awwh, but being a doctor is hard though” and be expected to suck it up because you’re not a doctor and therefore don’t understand. And I’d bet my house on the parents who think they should be beyond criticism from non-parents are up at the school quick smart if they think the teachers are treating their child unfairly, despite not being teachers themselves.

sammylady37 · 22/05/2023 20:48

Usetherightgearforthehill · 22/05/2023 18:05

Out of interest what age are childless women "allowed" to join? Is it just an age related thing now not a child related thing?

It's getting to be a complex set of rule

You can join if you are young and have a child
You can join if you are older and tried to have a child but failed (although plenty of users also disagree with this)
What about if you are childfree by choice but had an accidental pregnancy and a miscarriage are you allowed to join or not? Does it depend on whether you are in your 20s or 30s.

I had my miscarriage in my mid 20s and started fertility treatment not long after. I'm very glad I wasn't told I was too young to join then as a woman without a child

There’s another rule now- you can only post here if you have young children who require looking after. If your children are grown then you’ve no business being here. I’ve seen the following on a thread that was, shock horror, nothing to do with parenting and was actually about the royal family:

But you do sound a bit unhappy! Why are you on a website called ‘ Mumsnet ‘ if you don’t have to look after children… is being a mum the only thing you have in your life and even though your kids are grown up and gone you still feel the need to spend hours posting boring opinions on the site Perhaps you need another focus ? Friends perhaps?

Presumably the irony of a poster with the word ‘mum’ in her username policing who can post here based on their status as parent of young children asking someone disparagingly if ‘being a mum is the only thing you have in your life’ is entirely lost on the poster herself 🙄

PurplePineapple1 · 22/05/2023 20:22

Shoutinglagerlagerlager · 22/05/2023 20:02

People can do what they want online obviously but I honestly can’t imagine if I were child-free by choice or a bloke why I would spend my time browsing a site called ‘mumsnet’. Perhaps they should rebrand and change the name of the site since it’s not being used as intended.

So weird 🤣 the threads with the most traffic are absolutely nothing to do with kids.

Jeezuswept · 22/05/2023 20:11

Shoutinglagerlagerlager · 22/05/2023 20:02

People can do what they want online obviously but I honestly can’t imagine if I were child-free by choice or a bloke why I would spend my time browsing a site called ‘mumsnet’. Perhaps they should rebrand and change the name of the site since it’s not being used as intended.

Do you struggle with most things you can't imagine? Or perhaps you just struggle with the basic comprehension that people are different to you. 😉

FrostyFifi · 22/05/2023 20:09

So you can't imagine why someone would want to spend their time browsing here if they're childfree, @Shoutinglagerlagerlager , but a simple rebrand and suddenly the same posts would be fascinating?

Jeezuswept · 22/05/2023 20:09

WTF475878237NC · 22/05/2023 19:58

I do find the name of the site outdated if it isn't for parents anymore.

It's just developed and grown beyond its initial conception, it doesn't need to change it's name.

It has a brand and there's no need to change the name unless their are negative connotations with it, brand-wise.

The foundation of Justine's Mumsnet is definitely still here, there's a lot of support for parents, by parents - but there's also much more.

It's gone far beyond that initial scope and it's now a huge forum, with many voices.

BenCoopersSupportWren · 22/05/2023 20:03

WTF475878237NC · 22/05/2023 19:58

I do find the name of the site outdated if it isn't for parents anymore.

How is it not for parents? It’s not exclusively for parents, but parents are people and all people are welcome here. There are still plenty of boards related to parenting for the posters looking for help and support with that particular aspect of their life - which is a big, but not the sole, part of anyone’s life.