Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sibs think we should sell to pay care home fees

731 replies

SeriouslyTryadifferentstory · 21/05/2023 23:15

Context: Victorian semi, converted into two one bed flats by myself and my parents in the '90s. I married and DH and I have continued to live in and own the ground floor flat, with extension and garden (and paid off the bloody mortgage!) , parents owned (paid for outright) and lived in the upper flat. Mum died a decade ago and Dad has recently moved into a care home so his flat has to be sold to pay the fees. DH is also battling a chronic illness.

My brothers (2 of them) think that we should "just sell the whole house and we'll find you "somewhere to live". My Sis is telling them to back off and I just want everyone to go away and leave me alone.

Sorry, just needed to vent.

OP posts:
Alinino124 · 24/05/2023 20:15

100% agree. I believe Teresa May was going to sort out a new scheme where we paid I think it was £82000 tops, towards our care homes fees, but no food etc that was purely for accomodation. That was a few years ago, looks like it’s been put on the back burner and would cost a lot more than that now.
The Gov is just evading the situation. Burying their heads in the sand.
Do they think we are stupid and we have forgotten all about it.

Exasperatednow · 24/05/2023 20:07

changeme4this · 24/05/2023 19:39

I totally agree that people must plan to provide for their aged care needs and not expect the tax payer to fund this expense, however the thing with nursing home/private hospital care costs, at least in my DM’s case, is while her family home funds dwindle to pay for her accommodation and care, the parent company of the facility sponsors opera, ballets and other events outside of the business module.

who benefits from these deals certainly not the residents…. and in these cases I think this sort of thing should be regulated.

How much money do you think the average person has? Mortgage, food, pension, fuel.

What is the actual point of paying tax?

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 20:03

changeme4this · 24/05/2023 19:39

I totally agree that people must plan to provide for their aged care needs and not expect the tax payer to fund this expense, however the thing with nursing home/private hospital care costs, at least in my DM’s case, is while her family home funds dwindle to pay for her accommodation and care, the parent company of the facility sponsors opera, ballets and other events outside of the business module.

who benefits from these deals certainly not the residents…. and in these cases I think this sort of thing should be regulated.

Sadly this is true, if profits in the care industry were regulated and government wastage (which is vast) reduced, there would be less pressure on the system, it's users and families.

Possible change of government next year, what ideas that may bring, the state the NHS and social care has got in, frankly one would hope the only way is up.

changeme4this · 24/05/2023 19:39

I totally agree that people must plan to provide for their aged care needs and not expect the tax payer to fund this expense, however the thing with nursing home/private hospital care costs, at least in my DM’s case, is while her family home funds dwindle to pay for her accommodation and care, the parent company of the facility sponsors opera, ballets and other events outside of the business module.

who benefits from these deals certainly not the residents…. and in these cases I think this sort of thing should be regulated.

Alinino124 · 24/05/2023 19:39

Thank you. They don’t make it easy.

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 18:35

Blossomtoes · 24/05/2023 18:29

they can change ownership of their home to tenants in common, change their wills to girt their tenancy to their child rather than each other, with a life interest for the surviving spouse. If both go into care then both pay fees from their half, if Bernie dies first the kids get his half and when Anne goes into care her half pays - all fair.

Anyone who does this is mad. Firstly because local authorities have been onto it for years and it would be seen as deprivation of assets. Secondly because it’s a good way of not maximising IHT benefits.

Sorry to disagree, but it can't be viewed as deprivation of assets because you deprivate nothing, you still have your share, nothing is taken away, given away or hidden.
Deprivation of assets is very tough to prove unless you literally give your home or money to another or sell it for way below its value, a change in the method of joint ownership years before needing care won't raise any eyebrows.
Many many of our clients have done it and I've yet to hear of an LA complaint.
On larger estates it maximises inheritance tax relief by reducing the value of any one bequest.

Blossomtoes · 24/05/2023 18:29

they can change ownership of their home to tenants in common, change their wills to girt their tenancy to their child rather than each other, with a life interest for the surviving spouse. If both go into care then both pay fees from their half, if Bernie dies first the kids get his half and when Anne goes into care her half pays - all fair.

Anyone who does this is mad. Firstly because local authorities have been onto it for years and it would be seen as deprivation of assets. Secondly because it’s a good way of not maximising IHT benefits.

angstridden2 · 24/05/2023 18:17

I can understand why people are very annoyed about paying for care in old age. The £23,500 the state allows you to retain before stepping is is very little these days. I have worked since 16, funded my degree myself and never claimed benefits. We have never been extravagant.I would like to think that my children would get a reasonable inheritance when I die. My aunt and uncle spent every penny they had and had all care paid for. In fairness, self payers do get a choice of care home but subsidise the council funded residents in many cases. It’s about time the amount taken is capped but the government are being very quiet on this and it won’t cover residential costs. As ever it’s the ‘squeezed middle’ who suffer, if you’re seriously rich it doesn’t matter. If you have nothing you’re paid for.

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 18:10

Theyreallydidaskthat · 24/05/2023 17:53

Hands up who would like their tax to be used to pay someone's care fees whilst they squirrel money away for their children? Its not just the wealthy that are morally bankrupt.

Absolutely not suggesting that, there are some simple and quite legitimate steps that any parent can make to ring fence an inheritance, but it won't deprive the tax payer much in most cases, if anything.

One common method is, say Bernie and Anne want to give their kids the best chance of an inheritance, they can change ownership of their home to tenants in common, change their wills to girt their tenancy to their child rather than each other, with a life interest for the surviving spouse. If both go into care then both pay fees from their half, if Bernie dies first the kids get his half and when Anne goes into care her half pays - all fair.

Another method is gifts, parents can make gifts to the children up to a particular ammount every year. say Bernie and Anne own the home as tenants in common they can create a third tenancy in the childs name and gift a percentage of the equity to them every year, with a life interest.

Nothing illegal or dodgy in either of those, just sound financial planning, many neglect funerals, care, pensions etc., you can't blame those who plan ahead for later life for being prudent.

Theyreallydidaskthat · 24/05/2023 17:53

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 17:41

No idea of your situation, but if you are concerned about preserving at least some inheritance for your children, talk to a solicitor. There are some methods that reduce the likelihood of all the assets being gobbled up, too complex to go into and very case specific in any case - be wary of too good to be true schemes as they don't work!

Hands up who would like their tax to be used to pay someone's care fees whilst they squirrel money away for their children? Its not just the wealthy that are morally bankrupt.

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 17:41

Alinino124 · 24/05/2023 15:19

You do not have any idea what my situation is and yes they will need my inheritance to put down for a deposit on a home. That’s why me and my husband worked so bloody hard for.

No idea of your situation, but if you are concerned about preserving at least some inheritance for your children, talk to a solicitor. There are some methods that reduce the likelihood of all the assets being gobbled up, too complex to go into and very case specific in any case - be wary of too good to be true schemes as they don't work!

postwarbulge · 24/05/2023 16:31

Unlike Holly Golightly who trusted in the generosity of strangers, one can rely on the deviousness of relatives.

Alinino124 · 24/05/2023 15:20

When I worked I never had a rise in 7 years, it was truly tough, so I resent your bloody attitude.

Alinino124 · 24/05/2023 15:19

You do not have any idea what my situation is and yes they will need my inheritance to put down for a deposit on a home. That’s why me and my husband worked so bloody hard for.

Alinino124 · 24/05/2023 15:17

Absolutely

Alinino124 · 24/05/2023 15:16

No shame, disgusting and disrespectful

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 13:52

loislovesstewie · 24/05/2023 12:52

It wouldn't be wise to do a 6 months let, because you would then be in the realms of assured shorthold tenancies. If no fault eviction becomes law you wouldn't be able to repossess the property after the 6 months and could not use it as a holiday let. One or the other not both.

The problem with letting the flat, assuming you take out a DPA, when he dies, the DPA has to be paid back within 90 days (or at least visible action to repay needs to be seen) so, you would end up trying to evict the tennant at the same time as settle the DPA.

Holiday let, Air BnB much better, probably make more too.

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 13:47

Rosscameasdoody · 24/05/2023 10:57

According to the terms of my elderly relative entering care, the home she owns jointly with her husband is disregarded for care fees as he is still living there. However, if the home is sold for any reason - downsizing or similar, the LA will then be able to recover the care costs. What is that if not a charge ?

Its not a charge, because there is no first order charge on the deeds only a claim on assets other than the disregarded house, if he sells whilst she is still living then that liquidates the asset and the financial assessment will be re-calculated. Normally the LA will allow the move and take the excess cash from the sale into account for her fees.
But if she passes away, the arrangement ends then he keeps it (depending on the terms of her will of course) if he then sells at a later point nothing is taken.
Importantly, unlike a DPA the disregard arrangements do not incur any fees, and critically any money released is entirely under his control, with a DPA it is not, so its a better situation for him.

ParadoxicalHippy · 24/05/2023 12:55

I suspect the brothers buying both flats to let out and convert part of the garden into parking is a ruse. For starters BTL mortgages are bloody costly now, does either brother have the means to purchase either flat?

Call me cynical, but I believe brother A is wired with indignation that OP & her DH bought the flat from their parents for market value in the 90s and now enjoy the increase in value and being mortgage free. He wants OP to sell her flat so he and brother B can then continue their bullying tactics by trying to brow beat OP into accepting a smaller property thats not worth much more than what she bought the ground floor flat for in the 90s, then he’ll conveniently suggest that what’s left after they’ve found OP “somewhere to live” isn’t added to the funds from the top flat sale, but divided between the four siblings, so he gets his mawlers on a share of OPs equity 🤔

loislovesstewie · 24/05/2023 12:52

It wouldn't be wise to do a 6 months let, because you would then be in the realms of assured shorthold tenancies. If no fault eviction becomes law you wouldn't be able to repossess the property after the 6 months and could not use it as a holiday let. One or the other not both.

Morgysmum · 24/05/2023 12:32

Stand your ground, your partner isn't well and moving house is really stressful, so this wouldn't help him.
Do you have to sell there flat or could you rent it? If you live in a costal area or somewhere people go on holiday, you could rent it out as a holiday let, yoy can charge daft prices for a holiday let , so would get more than normal rent, then in the off season, maybe do a short term rent 6 months to cover his bills.
You live close by so could keep an eye on the property.

LittleOwl153 · 24/05/2023 11:29

I expect your brother 'finding you somewhere to live' would be renting back your flat as an easy sitting tenant... at full rent of course! But you would loose access to the garden as of course it isn't yours anymore. (Of and by the way can you look after the flat above as you are nearer...)

I'de be tempted to get the estate agent to value your flat separately and the whole building as one... I think you'll find the value of the two separate flats is higher. (Who has the freehold in all of this?)

Shamsie24 · 24/05/2023 11:27

Take independent legal advice - do not allow yourself to be bullied by your brothers - as you say, your partner has a chronic illness so moving will have a deep impact on him - the State will use funds from the estate of your father to pay his care home fees, after that they will step in - they will not come after your assets IF those assets are LEGALLY yours - from the information you've give about your mortgage etc, it sounds as if the property is wholly yours. Keep your sister onside, she sounds like she's sticking up for you. Try not to get too stressed about this unpleasantness - inheritances can have a toxic effect on the most surprising people! I wish you the very best of luck.

ClementDrive · 24/05/2023 11:20

I just wanted to add a cautionary tale re siblings and wills. I had a situation a few years back when I had taken a career break and moved back home to look after my elderly parents. My father wanted to keep the house in the family but we had spent a lot of money on care in the home and taken on debt and it was logical to sell the house after my father died. My father's will provided that should it be necessary to sell the family home, that a property be bought for me from the proceeds. My siblings and the executors agreed to honour that provision if I moved out of the family home into temporary accommodation. So I agreed to do this, thinking I was protected by the provisions in the will. The home was then sold (against my wishes) for significantly less than the probate value, there was not enough money left over after all the other bequests and three years on, I am still in the temporary accommodation. The moral of the story is you definitely can't trust your siblings to do the decent thing in such circumstances.

postwarbulge · 24/05/2023 11:05

The world is full of people, especially relatives telling you what You should do