Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sibs think we should sell to pay care home fees

731 replies

SeriouslyTryadifferentstory · 21/05/2023 23:15

Context: Victorian semi, converted into two one bed flats by myself and my parents in the '90s. I married and DH and I have continued to live in and own the ground floor flat, with extension and garden (and paid off the bloody mortgage!) , parents owned (paid for outright) and lived in the upper flat. Mum died a decade ago and Dad has recently moved into a care home so his flat has to be sold to pay the fees. DH is also battling a chronic illness.

My brothers (2 of them) think that we should "just sell the whole house and we'll find you "somewhere to live". My Sis is telling them to back off and I just want everyone to go away and leave me alone.

Sorry, just needed to vent.

OP posts:
Notquitethere60 · 22/05/2023 13:14

If you read the thread and OPs updates there are two entirely separate properties in one building owned by her and her father in their entirety.
Why would anyone sell both just to please a sibling. Don’t know the history but it seems they think that you got a good deal in the past and they think it’s payback. Tell them where to go.

midgemadgemodge · 22/05/2023 13:14

Even if the parents had given the op a house to live in, transferred it to the OP as a gift

The brothers still are being greedy selfish jealous and cheeky to expect the OP to give it back to her dad so they get sone of the value

Life isn't fair
Sometimes parents do favour one child

Even if that is what has happened ( no evidence to support that ) if it was a gift it was a gift , it became hers because that's what her parents wanted

LifeExperience · 22/05/2023 13:14

Your flat is your home that you paid for. It's obnoxious that your siblings think they can tell you what to do with it.

Mirabai · 22/05/2023 13:10

LimeCheesecake · 22/05/2023 12:56

@Mirabai - I also will expect any inheritance to be split 50/50 with my brother - but I’m not planning on asking for a share of his house because when he bought his first house over 20 years ago they gifted him £5k, particularly as they gave me money towards my wedding a couple of years later.

the problem is the brothers don’t see the flat as the OPs, and are annoyed she owns it.

A house bought with 5k gift is a completely different scenario.

We still don’t know what the exact scenario of the OP is.

WickedSerious · 22/05/2023 13:10

SeriouslyTryadifferentstory · 22/05/2023 12:07

My brothers want to sell both flats and split the proceeds 50/50. As I own the bigger flat with its own large garden, I'd effectively be giving money to Dad.

Dad is in his late 90s, has severe dementia among many other health issues and quite honestly could pop off at any moment. Any money he leaves will be split equally 4 ways. So by selling my flat and giving some of the proceeds to Dad I could actually be increasing my brothers inheritance.

Thank you all for your input. Its forced me to think properly about what I want to do, rather than just getting upset about my brothers.

Yeah,you're well within your rights telling them to fuck the fuck off.

Pipsquiggle · 22/05/2023 13:09

CantFindTheBeat · 22/05/2023 12:49

Do your brothers think that your parents gifted you the flat, OP?

What was the commercial arrangement originally?

I bet this is the case.

Your brothers either think you got a freebie flat or a mate's rate flat from your parents.

Time to be transparent about how the house was split up into flats and the finances around it.

It's quite possible that your dad has been telling lots of tales to your brothers that he gave you the flat etc......

tonyatotter · 22/05/2023 13:09

I would have said that you could decline your share of the 4 way split on any residual funds when your dad dies as an act of kindness, but as your brother has called you a bitch I'd cut him off and get on with your lives.

As and when any inheritance comes, either just keep it or give it to your two other siblings.

Mirabai · 22/05/2023 13:07

HowcanIhelp123 · 22/05/2023 13:05

They ARE splitting the inheritance equally. She is quite rightly not including HER property in that, the same as the siblings are not including theirs!

See my post @12.25.

Hayliebells · 22/05/2023 13:07

If anyone called me a selfish little bitch, I'd be going non-contact. Who has Power of Attorney for your dad's finances?

LookingforMaryPoppins · 22/05/2023 13:06

SeriouslyTryadifferentstory · 22/05/2023 12:07

My brothers want to sell both flats and split the proceeds 50/50. As I own the bigger flat with its own large garden, I'd effectively be giving money to Dad.

Dad is in his late 90s, has severe dementia among many other health issues and quite honestly could pop off at any moment. Any money he leaves will be split equally 4 ways. So by selling my flat and giving some of the proceeds to Dad I could actually be increasing my brothers inheritance.

Thank you all for your input. Its forced me to think properly about what I want to do, rather than just getting upset about my brothers.

I am so sorry your brothers are acting like this. It is impossible to fathom how they can consider this a reasonable request. As another poster said, the proceeds from your dads flat will ultimately pay for his care, if that runs out then the council take over, there is no benefit to maximising the sale price other than if your dad were to pass away sooner rather than later and there be money left - which as you say would then be split 4 ways.

Do your brothers have a track record of this such entitled cheek?

tonyatotter · 22/05/2023 13:06

midgemadgemodge · 22/05/2023 13:02

What is an "unfair gift" in legal terms ?

Life ain't fair, brother hasn't got a leg to stand on, OPs name is on the land registry and shes had a mortgage against the title which she has paid off - no way the brother can do anything.

HowcanIhelp123 · 22/05/2023 13:05

Mirabai · 22/05/2023 12:40

This is all speculative. We nothing of this, including any care, as OP hasn’t said.

Despite the care I’ve done for my parents my sister and I are splitting the inheritance from our parents 50/50.

They ARE splitting the inheritance equally. She is quite rightly not including HER property in that, the same as the siblings are not including theirs!

Sugarfree23 · 22/05/2023 13:05

The brother seems to think he'll get more of an inheritance if the two flats are sold together with the garden.

Which is assuming that a buyer will want to put the property back as a single house and that will cost money to convert.

But he is missing that Op owns all the bottom flat. So it wouldn't be a 4 way split. And trying to find someone who wants to reconvert it will probably reduce the potential market.

midgemadgemodge · 22/05/2023 13:02

What is an "unfair gift" in legal terms ?

MargotBamborough · 22/05/2023 13:01

Xenia · 22/05/2023 12:57

Everyone may need to speak to solicitors here. It is possible the parents made an extremely unfair gift of the bottom floor flat to the original poster although a mortgage on that title only that she paid off probably means a large part of the price was via a loan. The parents then survived 7 years I think so no inheritance tax on the gift. If the other 3 siblings were not given a similar amount / value that is very unfair. However if the daughter paid market value for the ground floor flat then it is perfectly fair and no reason she should sell.

If instead the parents had an agreement at the time that the flat was transferred only for so long as they lived in the house or something like that - a mind of conditional gift the position may be different.

Xenia, aren't you a solicitor?

It doesn't matter whether this (hypothetical) scenario was fair or not.

The OP and her husband are the registered owners of the downstairs flat.

If her older brother thinks he has some sort of claim on it (based on the actual law, rather than whether he thinks the situation is fair or not) then he's welcome to spend his own money instructing solicitors. But all the OP needs to do is keep telling him to bog off.

Xenia · 22/05/2023 12:57

Everyone may need to speak to solicitors here. It is possible the parents made an extremely unfair gift of the bottom floor flat to the original poster although a mortgage on that title only that she paid off probably means a large part of the price was via a loan. The parents then survived 7 years I think so no inheritance tax on the gift. If the other 3 siblings were not given a similar amount / value that is very unfair. However if the daughter paid market value for the ground floor flat then it is perfectly fair and no reason she should sell.

If instead the parents had an agreement at the time that the flat was transferred only for so long as they lived in the house or something like that - a mind of conditional gift the position may be different.

rwalker · 22/05/2023 12:56

Emotionalsupportviper · 22/05/2023 12:34

This isn't uncommon when the "sitting pretty" sibling has been living in the same building and has don't he lion's share of parental care.

I live round the corner from my mum when my dad was alive it was me getting the calls in the night me going down to pick up up off the floor me putting him to bed me doing odd jobs me nipping down so my mum could go out
be hand on heart if there’s anything when my mum goes I don’t expect anymore than my sister

LimeCheesecake · 22/05/2023 12:56

@Mirabai - I also will expect any inheritance to be split 50/50 with my brother - but I’m not planning on asking for a share of his house because when he bought his first house over 20 years ago they gifted him £5k, particularly as they gave me money towards my wedding a couple of years later.

the problem is the brothers don’t see the flat as the OPs, and are annoyed she owns it.

NeedToChangeName · 22/05/2023 12:54

midgemadgemodge · 22/05/2023 12:50

Given the op had to take out and pay a mortgage on the flat I think we can assume that she wasn't given the whole thing ?

@midgemadgemodge parents might have gifted her the downstairs half of the house and she took a loan to pay for the renovation costs

bluebeck · 22/05/2023 12:53

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 22/05/2023 12:21

I don't understand why your brothers think they/your father will benefit from the sale of your flat at the same time as the sale of your father's flat? Surely, if you own your flat and have paid off the mortgage, any profit from the sale of your flat belongs to you, not your father? I must be missing an important point here, as I don't understand your brothers' logic at all.

This!

Ask CF Brother if he’s also selling his property and handing over half the proceeds?

I am baffled.

MargotBamborough · 22/05/2023 12:52

SeriouslyTryadifferentstory · 22/05/2023 11:31

Two different flats registered with the Land Registry. Dad's name is on the deeds for the top flat, mine and DHs on the deeds for the bottom flat. The whole family have always been aware of this. I'm not sure why people think we'd pay a mortgage on a property we would never own?

When my oldest brother called earlier for his daily "have you come to your senses yet?" chat I told him I have arranged for a couple of EAs to come and give us a price for Dad's flat only. He called me a selfish little bitch and hung up on me!

Well he sounds like a real charmer...

midgemadgemodge · 22/05/2023 12:50

Given the op had to take out and pay a mortgage on the flat I think we can assume that she wasn't given the whole thing ?

CantFindTheBeat · 22/05/2023 12:49

Do your brothers think that your parents gifted you the flat, OP?

What was the commercial arrangement originally?

NeedToChangeName · 22/05/2023 12:49

If OP and parents shared the cost of buying the whole house & then split it, then absolutely fair for OP to choose to continue to live in her home, and I struggle to understand why DB would think she's unreasonable

But, if parents owned the main house already, and part of it was converted to enable OP to live downstairs, I think that's a bit different. If she keeps the flat, then effectively her parents have given her half of their house. This might be legally permitted, but seems unfair on the siblings

ClawedButler · 22/05/2023 12:48

They're batshit, and they know they're talking balls, and they don't like being called out for it - that's what I'm getting from these brothers.

If you lived in the house next door, it would no more be the same property as the flat upstairs. It's not a case of selling the whole house - it's a case of selling two independent properties. This means that either:
a) it will be bought be two independent buyers (with two sets of fees), probably at different times OR
b) it will be bought by a property developer with a diseased mind who would convert it back into one property and lose a heap of value in the process

"Come to your senses" indeed. Still, he's at least done you the favour of not needing to worry about offending or upsetting him anymore.

Swipe left for the next trending thread