Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sibs think we should sell to pay care home fees

731 replies

SeriouslyTryadifferentstory · 21/05/2023 23:15

Context: Victorian semi, converted into two one bed flats by myself and my parents in the '90s. I married and DH and I have continued to live in and own the ground floor flat, with extension and garden (and paid off the bloody mortgage!) , parents owned (paid for outright) and lived in the upper flat. Mum died a decade ago and Dad has recently moved into a care home so his flat has to be sold to pay the fees. DH is also battling a chronic illness.

My brothers (2 of them) think that we should "just sell the whole house and we'll find you "somewhere to live". My Sis is telling them to back off and I just want everyone to go away and leave me alone.

Sorry, just needed to vent.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fooodie · 28/05/2023 03:52

Given that property prices are at an all time high, if you sold your flat, you could possibly end up homeless as rental properties are expensive and in short supply. Do your DB want to use the money from the sale of both flats for the care home fees? Are they going to match any contribution you make? I very much doubt it. The most equatable solution would be to rent your DF flat out on short term leases and if the tenants are problamatic, you're on the spot to control the situation and cancel the lease. If your DB won't agree to this, tell him he can sell his home or remortgage it. If your DF is competent to make decisions, maybe he could remortgage the flat with a no payment loan and the flat be sold on his death. Any money left after the loan was paid off would go towards the DS inheritance.

Emotionalsupportviper · 26/05/2023 16:04

Can't believe how your brothers have tried to shaft you!

Not to mention the horrible thought of turning your lovely garden into a tarmac'ed space ("They paved Paradise and put in a parking lot" springs to mind).

I can understand you being interested in a valuation - but stand firm against your brothers - unless, of course, it's an offer you can't refuse" and you decide it's worth your while selling, in which case TAKE YOUR FULL SHARE!

What a pair of tossers - mind, I could see my siblings pulling a trick like this. 🙁

Beautiful3 · 26/05/2023 07:21

You owe your brothers nothing. Keep away from them. They're the kind of people to prey on you, while you're vunerable, scamming you out of money. Nothing good will come from them. You're lucky you've seen the real them.

SeriouslyTryadifferentstory · 25/05/2023 21:38

saraclara · 24/05/2023 23:55

To be fair, brother B wasn't the one who called you a selfish biitch, and you don't know that he was the 'mate'. That's pure supposition. At least he was open with your sis about the plan, and presumably came to his senses and realised it was unfair.

If he's not the mate, I'd be tempted to have accepted his flowers on the condition that he was entirely open to you about what his involvement was and what was going on.

He was quite happy to go along with A's plans, to try to persuade me to sell my flat to A at less than market value. I've no idea what was in his mind, not do I care.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 25/05/2023 18:02

Often on MN incorrect things are said about IHT and about deprivation of assets for care home purposes so best to check with a solicitor)

I did. His advice was the reverse of @tonyatotter’s. Not that I’d have done it anyway. My parents saved all their lives for a rainy day so it was only right to use the money for its intended purpose.

Xenia · 25/05/2023 17:39

It sounds like reconciliation with one of the brothers might be wise and would probably keep the whole family happy but don't give in to demands about your own home. As for if the father should sell his leasehold flat for care home fees the sisters who have POA can help decide if father is unable to take own decisions any more. Sometimes equity release is another option,

As to care homes etc only about 1 in 5 people ever need one so I am not that keen taxes might go up even higher to pay for them. As it is already those who pay privately often subsidise those in the same home being paid for by the local authority which is completely unfair.

(tony is correct above. Anyone in these situations should pay for a bit of advice from a solicitor who has all the relevant facts. Often on MN incorrect things are said about IHT and about deprivation of assets for care home purposes so best to check with a solicitor)

ArdeteiMasazxu · 25/05/2023 17:28

Bro B has sent flowers and a "tell her I'm sorry" via his grown-up daughter. She's fine with shoving them up his arse politely returning them on my behalf

Thanks for the update @SeriouslyTryadifferentstory .

Please consider forgiving BroB. It's easy to get carried away trying to please a charismatic bullying older sibling and he's realised he was wrong and being an arsehole. If a forgiven and reconciled BroB is on team "BroA is a wanker" then that's a good thing. Tactfully an politely inserting the apology flowers up BroB's posterior could actually make the opposing "side" in this rift stronger.

T1Dmama · 25/05/2023 16:51

saraclara · 24/05/2023 23:55

To be fair, brother B wasn't the one who called you a selfish biitch, and you don't know that he was the 'mate'. That's pure supposition. At least he was open with your sis about the plan, and presumably came to his senses and realised it was unfair.

If he's not the mate, I'd be tempted to have accepted his flowers on the condition that he was entirely open to you about what his involvement was and what was going on.

This

was thinking the same.. the brother B might not be involved and has made efforts to apologise.

ScribblingPixie · 25/05/2023 09:58

Good update, OP. Glad all the women are together. Thinking about it, your brothers must have always resented the money your parents made from selling you the house and enjoyed on holidays and making their lives more fun and comfortable. They were literally thinking 'that should have been my money' and wanted to bully you into turning back time so they could get it. Just appalling. At least the worst one is isolated now.

saraclara · 24/05/2023 23:55

SeriouslyTryadifferentstory · 24/05/2023 21:48

An update. Had one EA in today who has confirmed better to sell as two flats and that he wants to chat with colleagues before recommending a price for mine as "I've never seen a one bed flat with this much garden before". Fair enough ... I'm just interested in their valuation and not selling. That has been made clear to EA.

For those suggesting renting out Dad's flat, it just won't work. He's got a good pension but even with rent at £1k a month we'll still be trying to find at least another £1k between us and I think it's probably clear why this won't happen! And for those asking about Freehold, it's shared ownership,.

I've heard nothing from Bro A but Bro B has sent flowers and a "tell her I'm sorry" via his grown-up daughter. She's fine with shoving them up his arse politely returning them on my behalf now she knows what he's been up to.

Thank you all for input, suggestions and support.

To be fair, brother B wasn't the one who called you a selfish biitch, and you don't know that he was the 'mate'. That's pure supposition. At least he was open with your sis about the plan, and presumably came to his senses and realised it was unfair.

If he's not the mate, I'd be tempted to have accepted his flowers on the condition that he was entirely open to you about what his involvement was and what was going on.

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 23:21

Blossomtoes · 24/05/2023 23:14

The amount you can leave your spouse without incurring IHT is infinite.

True, but say a couple own £1m of property as tenants in common, each can leave their DD £325,000 (their nil rate band) plus the £175,000 extra for property, no IHT for DD on £1m

Even if they both, say go into care and loose £150,000 of their respective shares, thats still £800,000 which is taxable, but with the approach I have demonstrated (which is all outlined on the HMRC pages) still no tax for DD to pay.

Blossomtoes · 24/05/2023 23:14

The amount you can leave your spouse without incurring IHT is infinite.

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 23:01

Blossomtoes · 24/05/2023 22:37

On larger estates it maximises inheritance tax relief by reducing the value of any one bequest.

That isn’t how IHT works. The only person who can inherit without IHT being incurred is a spouse. Bequests to children are liable.

Children can inherit up to £500,000 without incurring inheritance tax, here it is from the HMRC site

Passing on a home You can pass a home to your husband, wife or civil partner when you die. There’s no Inheritance Tax to pay if you do this.
If you leave the home to another person in your will, it counts towards the value of the estate.
If you own your home (or a share in it) your tax-free threshold can increase to £500,000 if:

  • you leave it to your children (including adopted, foster or stepchildren) or grandchildren
  • your estate is worth less than £2 million
Blossomtoes · 24/05/2023 22:55

I'm sorry if you lost out to duff advice.

I’m not because I didn’t miss out. I’d rather believe a solicitor with decades of experience who understands how IHT works than some random on the internet who doesn’t.

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 22:43

Blossomtoes · 24/05/2023 22:34

My parents’ solicitor warned them against it over a decade ago.🤷‍♀️

Of course it’s deprivation of assets. It removes the possibility of it being used for care, it’s depriving the tax payer.

Well, I'd have to disagree with their solicitor.

Lets say Bernie & Anne get divorced, what percentage would they be entitled too normally? 50%

As Joint Tenants if Anne needs care, her assessment is 50% of the value.

If she lingers in care and Bernie dies, she by default inherits and gains more capital.

If They are tenants in common, that doesn't happen - but Annes 50% assessed share is still available so nothing is deprived.

The care act actually makes provisions for those who are tenants in common. I'm sorry if you lost out to duff advice.

Blossomtoes · 24/05/2023 22:37

On larger estates it maximises inheritance tax relief by reducing the value of any one bequest.

That isn’t how IHT works. The only person who can inherit without IHT being incurred is a spouse. Bequests to children are liable.

Blossomtoes · 24/05/2023 22:34

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 18:35

Sorry to disagree, but it can't be viewed as deprivation of assets because you deprivate nothing, you still have your share, nothing is taken away, given away or hidden.
Deprivation of assets is very tough to prove unless you literally give your home or money to another or sell it for way below its value, a change in the method of joint ownership years before needing care won't raise any eyebrows.
Many many of our clients have done it and I've yet to hear of an LA complaint.
On larger estates it maximises inheritance tax relief by reducing the value of any one bequest.

My parents’ solicitor warned them against it over a decade ago.🤷‍♀️

Of course it’s deprivation of assets. It removes the possibility of it being used for care, it’s depriving the tax payer.

changeme4this · 24/05/2023 21:57

Does your lending laws allow dad to borrow against his asset to fund the ‘gap’ in the monthly charges? And is your property market values likely to increase over time?

if we had kept M & D’s family hone instead of selling it, and rented out the property there would be more asset today than when it was sold 9 years ago to fund the gap. However you would need to work out how much his pension would decrease due to having rental income…

it might be worth thinking about if the lending laws allow this for senior citizens there

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 21:52

SeriouslyTryadifferentstory · 24/05/2023 21:48

An update. Had one EA in today who has confirmed better to sell as two flats and that he wants to chat with colleagues before recommending a price for mine as "I've never seen a one bed flat with this much garden before". Fair enough ... I'm just interested in their valuation and not selling. That has been made clear to EA.

For those suggesting renting out Dad's flat, it just won't work. He's got a good pension but even with rent at £1k a month we'll still be trying to find at least another £1k between us and I think it's probably clear why this won't happen! And for those asking about Freehold, it's shared ownership,.

I've heard nothing from Bro A but Bro B has sent flowers and a "tell her I'm sorry" via his grown-up daughter. She's fine with shoving them up his arse politely returning them on my behalf now she knows what he's been up to.

Thank you all for input, suggestions and support.

Glad to hear its sorting out OP, hope that they both feel very ashamed of themselves - let it pass, sort your dad out and try to mend the relationship with them one day in the distant future, we only get one family, forgive eventually, but don't forget, and always keep out of business/financial dealings with them.

JustBeKindItsEasy · 24/05/2023 21:51

Good news OP
Dont let them walk all over you.

SeriouslyTryadifferentstory · 24/05/2023 21:48

An update. Had one EA in today who has confirmed better to sell as two flats and that he wants to chat with colleagues before recommending a price for mine as "I've never seen a one bed flat with this much garden before". Fair enough ... I'm just interested in their valuation and not selling. That has been made clear to EA.

For those suggesting renting out Dad's flat, it just won't work. He's got a good pension but even with rent at £1k a month we'll still be trying to find at least another £1k between us and I think it's probably clear why this won't happen! And for those asking about Freehold, it's shared ownership,.

I've heard nothing from Bro A but Bro B has sent flowers and a "tell her I'm sorry" via his grown-up daughter. She's fine with shoving them up his arse politely returning them on my behalf now she knows what he's been up to.

Thank you all for input, suggestions and support.

OP posts:
Alinino124 · 24/05/2023 20:36

Agree with this advice.

Alinino124 · 24/05/2023 20:35

That’s true they can put you where they like, other end of the country if it suits them.

changeme4this · 24/05/2023 20:17

Exasperatednow · 24/05/2023 20:07

How much money do you think the average person has? Mortgage, food, pension, fuel.

What is the actual point of paying tax?

So when you drive on the roads, send your children to school, head to hospital in times of emergency, that the money that’s paid for these services hasn’t come from somewhere?

why do you think taxes are refundable via aged care expenses? Esp as we are all living much longer these days?

tonyatotter · 24/05/2023 20:17

Exasperatednow · 24/05/2023 20:07

How much money do you think the average person has? Mortgage, food, pension, fuel.

What is the actual point of paying tax?

But you could also ask, off that tax, how much does the government (pardon my french) piss up the wall? how much of it actually finds its way back to directly benefitting the citizens, pound for pound, not much.

Care is one area thats neglected because its something no one really wants to think too hard about until it happens, and its not flashy like a railway to nowhere that no one wants, for example.