Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children on social media

62 replies

ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 20:04

I used to post photos of my son on social media, until I went to some training on children and autonomy/the Internet etc. It opened my eyes to the fact that I had created a digital footprint of my son without his consent, and posted 'cute' photos of him that he may find embarrassing as he gets older. I removed all photographs and won't post any more unless he wants me to when he's older. The training really struck a chord.

I've come across people either friends or 'influencer', that post all sorts, photos of kids in the bath with goggles on, photos of their kids in drama performances, photos of their kids upset or stressed for whatever reason, videos pranking their kids etc.

Does anyone else wonder what the effect of putting photos of our children's daily lives on the Internet might be?

OP posts:
chupachucks · 21/05/2023 21:27

I know people who post every single day pictures of their kids and have done since their scans, kids are now 6+ and below. No thought or care what so ever about their consent or consideration for their future despite me telling them in the past.

Social Media companies own your photos, you give up the right when you post them on their platform. It's a hackers and scammers dream, potentially setting your kids up in the future for fraud identified theft and worse

I tested this once going back on their profiles, date of birth easy their photos are plastered all over social media when they were born including every birthday. Security questions , first school, first pet , where were they born, parents names, best friend, favourite so and so all plastered every where without their consent all information ripe to be sought out farmed and used in the future. 🙄

ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 21:23

ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 21:22

On the training I was on they said any platform or group that had more than 2 or 3 people in it shouldn't be used to share photographs, so if shared by a parent in a group with just maternal grandparents in it is fine, any platform that had more could potentially be damaging to the child. She said 'imagine you were out with your 12 year old and you bumped into a close friend, and you then proceeded to show them a picture from 10 years ago of you sat in your high chair with spaghetti on the wall. Your child probably wouldn't mind. Now imagine you did the same thing but showed a group of 20 people, passing your phone from person to person. Do you think that might make your child feel uncomfortable'. I mean, she was very much of the mindset that you should never, ever put even one photo of your child online before the age that they're allowed to have their own social media profile (usually 13) and not without their consent, but the content made sense.

*a photo of the child sat in their high chair. Brain isn't working today!

OP posts:
ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 21:22

RightWhereYouLeftMe · 21/05/2023 21:11

Is a private online album substantially different to a completely private Instagram account, where the only people who can see any pictures are people who have requested to follow and have been accepted?

That's a genuine question, as I don't know.

On the training I was on they said any platform or group that had more than 2 or 3 people in it shouldn't be used to share photographs, so if shared by a parent in a group with just maternal grandparents in it is fine, any platform that had more could potentially be damaging to the child. She said 'imagine you were out with your 12 year old and you bumped into a close friend, and you then proceeded to show them a picture from 10 years ago of you sat in your high chair with spaghetti on the wall. Your child probably wouldn't mind. Now imagine you did the same thing but showed a group of 20 people, passing your phone from person to person. Do you think that might make your child feel uncomfortable'. I mean, she was very much of the mindset that you should never, ever put even one photo of your child online before the age that they're allowed to have their own social media profile (usually 13) and not without their consent, but the content made sense.

OP posts:
RightWhereYouLeftMe · 21/05/2023 21:11

Sweetandsourdough · 21/05/2023 20:59

I don't think there's any justification for sharing them on public accounts, not unless they are old enough to consent properly. I would love to hear how people who do so manage to justify it. You can't claim it's for family/friends etc as you can use WhatsApp or a private online album for that - which I do think is OK as it's the same as sharing printed photos with people "in the olden days".

Is a private online album substantially different to a completely private Instagram account, where the only people who can see any pictures are people who have requested to follow and have been accepted?

That's a genuine question, as I don't know.

Stabee · 21/05/2023 21:09

I've often felt it's up to DC how they present themselves. It's marketing to me. Many different ways of doing it. Would hate someone to turn them down for a job because we looked too rich, poor, uneducated, unsporty or whatever. People judge. The less they have to go on, the better.

Madeintowerhamlets · 21/05/2023 21:08

I’m not on social media anymore but I’ve never done this. I do really judge parents that overshare about their kids online tbh.

MayBeeJuneSoon · 21/05/2023 21:00

Well if they don't like their facial expressions or clothing they are wearing in photos do you go as far as to remove family photos from around your home? Ask relatives too?

Where does it end?

Sweetandsourdough · 21/05/2023 20:59

I don't think there's any justification for sharing them on public accounts, not unless they are old enough to consent properly. I would love to hear how people who do so manage to justify it. You can't claim it's for family/friends etc as you can use WhatsApp or a private online album for that - which I do think is OK as it's the same as sharing printed photos with people "in the olden days".

bamboonights · 21/05/2023 20:59

I cannot fathom why any parent with an ounce of emotional intelligence would not consider how posting pictures without their children's 'consent' may affect their child in a negative way. Should be a law against it.

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/05/2023 20:57

savehannah · 21/05/2023 20:44

I post pics of my kids though nothing embarrassing or nude. And only on Facebook where I am only friends with people who I actually know in real life. I don't understand sharing anything personal on Instagram where any random can follow you.

I do also think when it's literally just pictures of my kids doing totally normal things,I can't see why it would be of any interest to anyone who doesn't know them. Anyone can see my kids walking down the street or in a park, so not sure how people seeing a photo of them in a park is dangerous. I do think people worry a bit too much.

I guess it's not so much the danger aspect as the privacy and consent. It's people that they do know that will be able to see these pictures. Nothing is truly private on Facebook.

Who benefits when you put pictures online of children too young to consent? Is there another way to achieve that benefit?

CannotDoThisAnymore · 21/05/2023 20:49

I do have pictures of my kids online but tgey are on private accounts where the photos arent public anx only friends/family on my friends list.

i do wonder how the kids feel with all these “mummy bloggers “. Im talking about those who have photographed and videoed them in every situation from birth and how the conversation goes when they hit teen years/high school. I cant get a photo these days with my teen and i cant imagine how unhappy he would be if i had a blog like that.

rainbowsprite2 · 21/05/2023 20:48

I don't post any photos of my children on social
Media for this reason, I'm 10 years time I'm sure my grown don't want photos of everything thing they did out there. Kids can't consent to having their photos out there. I feel a lot of 'influencers' who put their kids lives up there are exploiting their children. Some of the kids have been in social media since the minute they were born and it's scary. People know their children's names, birthdays, interests it's very strange and scary. Have you looked some
Mums who run these accounts they will happy let you buy stuff for their child. Some of them have daughters and you can buy them swim wear and see photos of them in it as a 'thank you'. So gross. You can also have personalised video messages, FaceTimes. It seems everything has a cost. It doesn't matter how the child feels about it.
you also don't know who is seeing your photos, if someone can see your photo they can get your photo

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/05/2023 20:48

ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 20:24

Exactly. I mean, what's the point? So everyone can look at your kid and you get a bit of a kick out of everyone telling you how sweet and lovely they are? I hold my hands up and admit that this was me (being very honest here and might not be coming across well, but that's fine..). Then I took a good hard look at myself and thought 'what the f am I doing?!'

We're all proud of our children and want to show them off, I guess it's the realisation that there's a significant downside for the child that makes the difference. There's a balance to be struck. There's some pictures of me as a child on Facebook, school photos etc, that people have scanned in, and I don't mind those. For me it's just easier to have a blanket rule.

savehannah · 21/05/2023 20:44

I post pics of my kids though nothing embarrassing or nude. And only on Facebook where I am only friends with people who I actually know in real life. I don't understand sharing anything personal on Instagram where any random can follow you.

I do also think when it's literally just pictures of my kids doing totally normal things,I can't see why it would be of any interest to anyone who doesn't know them. Anyone can see my kids walking down the street or in a park, so not sure how people seeing a photo of them in a park is dangerous. I do think people worry a bit too much.

ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 20:37

ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 20:34

That's still a digital footprint. They images are still stores after they're posted (they pop up as memories) and anyone who hacks into an account can find them. Anyone who views them can see them.

*anyone who views them can screenshot them

OP posts:
ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 20:34

Lcb123 · 21/05/2023 20:33

I totally agree with you. It’s not fair until they can consent. I don’t have kids yet but some of my friends post child’s pics / videos on Instagram stories so at least there’s no footprint. The worst are instagram mums posting videos or pics of their kids potty training or having a tantrum-it’s so unfair to that child. How mortified could they be in the future

That's still a digital footprint. They images are still stores after they're posted (they pop up as memories) and anyone who hacks into an account can find them. Anyone who views them can see them.

OP posts:
Lcb123 · 21/05/2023 20:33

I totally agree with you. It’s not fair until they can consent. I don’t have kids yet but some of my friends post child’s pics / videos on Instagram stories so at least there’s no footprint. The worst are instagram mums posting videos or pics of their kids potty training or having a tantrum-it’s so unfair to that child. How mortified could they be in the future

Sarah2891 · 21/05/2023 20:30

My nephew's mum posts lots of pictures of him on Twitter and photos of things he's written in cards etc to her. It makes me feel really uncomfortable. Kids deserve privacy and not to have their photos and personal information posted for all to see online.

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/05/2023 20:29

ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 20:19

Yes someone asked why it was any different to posting online, and the answer was that it's because the child will likely not know that photo was sent and if they did they'd feel safe with that knowledge (only if the parent was sending to trusted friend's who the child knows). Talked about how people in the past would often print photos for family members and close friends and we haven't seen any negative effects of that. They also commented that a lot of people don't have private pages, or they do and their pages are hacked and their photos stolen, so anyone can access the photos and do whatever they want with them.

That's reassuring. Thanks for the info

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 21/05/2023 20:27

DD has started asking me not to post stuff in the last couple of years like when she had her ears pierced etc (not that I would've posted that anyway). I told sil and she said I'm not checking first I'll post whatever I like. I think that's not very respectful as she is 10 and should have a say what goes on the internet

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/05/2023 20:27

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 21/05/2023 20:18

I'm a bit conflicted about this because I love looking back at old photos and I don't post any horrifically embarrassing pics or posts about my children so I hope they won't mind but I would remove them all if they asked. However, I've seen some photos where they've posted their toddlers covered in poo, or some other horrid thing and I just think 'no'. I also think influencers exploiting their children for money is in terrible taste and I can't follow them anymore.

I think there is a balance but I mostly side with your view and I do ask permission before posting nowadays and if they wanted any pics removed I would do so in an instant. My settings are all private too.

The thing about Facebook is that nothing is truly private. People can hack in, and lots of people know how to do that. Only post stuff that you'd be fine with future friends, enemies, in laws, exes, employers seeing.
What gets me is people posting things (in a group containing several thousand people) like "my 8 year old still wets the bed....any tips? Here's a photo of him". School bullies will have a field day with that in a few years.

ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 20:25

msisfine · 21/05/2023 20:22

I'm a teacher and have had so much safeguarding training that when it comes to posting pics of my DC I just don't.

Would you mind elaborating a bit? I'd love to know more about your views as a teacher.

OP posts:
ChildcarePanic · 21/05/2023 20:24

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/05/2023 20:21

I think it's using a child to get attention for yourself that feels wrong to me. Which is basically what it is.
I feel like if you want attention make a bit of an effort and find a cat video or something to share

Exactly. I mean, what's the point? So everyone can look at your kid and you get a bit of a kick out of everyone telling you how sweet and lovely they are? I hold my hands up and admit that this was me (being very honest here and might not be coming across well, but that's fine..). Then I took a good hard look at myself and thought 'what the f am I doing?!'

OP posts:
msisfine · 21/05/2023 20:22

I'm a teacher and have had so much safeguarding training that when it comes to posting pics of my DC I just don't.

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/05/2023 20:21

Dacadactyl · 21/05/2023 20:13

For me, it's nothing to do with the consent thing and my DD is 16 now so has her own insta account, but I just felt weird putting pictures of my kids online from the off and i cant put my finger on why.

I think it's using a child to get attention for yourself that feels wrong to me. Which is basically what it is.
I feel like if you want attention make a bit of an effort and find a cat video or something to share

Swipe left for the next trending thread