Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL excludes me from conversations

89 replies

Gemmabw · 21/05/2023 20:00

My relationship with my MIL is starting to make me feel stressed and unhappy and I dread seeing her mainly because she completely excludes me from conversations by speaking in her first language with my husband even when they are talking about me or my daughter.

Some background: MIL lives in the UK and has done for 45 years. Her English isn't perfect but she can sustain a conversation and understand as long as people aren't speaking very quickly or with a lot of slang /accent she doesn't know.

She has always just spoken to my husband in her first language (he was born in the UK and is fully bilingual) and makes very little effort to speak to me in English. I have a very basic level of competency in her language - not enough to follow or join in with a natural conversation.

Before we had a baby I didn't really care all that much as she lives about 3 hours away and we used to visit a couple of times a year. I'd grin and bear it and accept that it was her home, her right to speak whatever language she chose and it would just be a long and not very fun visit for me. We were together for over 10 years before baby and I rarely saw MIL so it was no big deal .

Since DD arrived a year ago, she has wanted to see her every 4-6 weeks and has started coming to visit us (she never did this before).
She'll be polite and greet me, ask how I am etc. but mainly ignores me for the 2-3 days that she stays with us and only speaks to DH. When she plays with DD she speaks to her in her own language.

What's upset me is that now the visits are much more frequent it seems like it's more difficult to just grin and bear it. I know that the conversation is often about DD and I frequently hear my name and my daughter's name come up. I love taking about my LO (who doesn't!?) and it would be such an easy way for us to build a better relationship but she doesn't say much back when I start a conversation and addresses all questions/comments to my husband.

When I've tried to broach this with DH he gets very defensive and says it's no different to me and my mum having a conversation about something from my childhood or someone he doesn't know or a topic that interests us but not him. I don't feel it's the same because he understands everything we are saying and has a choice if he takes part in the conversation.
I now dread her visits and DH says I just don't like her.

Am I being unreasonable or is MIL's (and DH's) behaviour just rude?

OP posts:
Cantstandbullshitanymore · 22/05/2023 03:31

Applebyapples · 21/05/2023 21:19

I think your MIL is being rude for sure, and your DH should support you more. However, as a person who speaks another language to a conversational level, it is a big mental strain and hard to do all day long, so I don't think she should have to speak English the entire time. She should try to include you more, but I do think that after more than 10 years you should be able to speak your husband's language to a conversational level

As opposed to MIL who refuses to speak English after 40 years?

Dintananadinta · 22/05/2023 01:03

@bussteward she doesn't have to learn the language. I doubt mother in law and husband are talking about her in their native language. It's just easier for them to converse.

yutu · 22/05/2023 00:41

My in laws speak French to hubby when they visit, they can speak some English, but it is much easier and faster to talk in their own language. It doesnt bother me, im not native English speaker either, so i totally understand why they do it, and my patents would do the same when they visit.

If its something important hubby will always translate, but most convetsation I dont really care. Sometimes its even an advantage because i have an excuse not to deal with them. 😂

MaydinEssex · 22/05/2023 00:40

Get a translater app thingy on your phone, get the MIL to talk to you through that and you do the same

bussteward · 22/05/2023 00:37

Dintananadinta · 22/05/2023 00:29

You said although she has been here for 45years her English isn't very good. Well there's your answer. It's much easier to converse in her native language. Your husband would've grown up speaking the language with his mother. If you don't speak another language you won't understand that words and phrases flow better in your native language. You need to stop being so sensitive. You can always learn the language yourself if you want to know what they're saying.

So MIL’s English isn’t great after 45 years but OP, who has a baby to look after, should learn a second language quickly and well enough to follow a conversation?

mellicauli · 22/05/2023 00:36

Why don't you take the time she comes down as time for yourself and leave your husband and her to look after your daughter? Go to the gym or a swim. Go visit your friends. Find a cosy pub where you can sit comfortably with a drink and a book.

Don't cook her any meals for her or shop for her or tidy up for her. Your husband can do all that. He's the host.

You don't need to make any effort for someone who makes no effort with you.

Dintananadinta · 22/05/2023 00:29

You said although she has been here for 45years her English isn't very good. Well there's your answer. It's much easier to converse in her native language. Your husband would've grown up speaking the language with his mother. If you don't speak another language you won't understand that words and phrases flow better in your native language. You need to stop being so sensitive. You can always learn the language yourself if you want to know what they're saying.

NutellaNut · 22/05/2023 00:25

I’d tell your husband she’s not welcome to visit so often, since she makes you feel uncomfortable in your own home. He needs to step up and take action here. If not, I’d be limiting the number of times she’s allowed to visit and make it clear why.

SkyandSurf · 22/05/2023 00:19

It's exhausting to speak a second language for a prolonged period of time. It would feel unnatural to her to speak to her son in English when presumably she has also used her first language to speak to him. I also think it's nice she is teaching your child a second language and giving her that tie to her heritage.

She's an old lady, it's harder for her to become fluent and comfortable in English now.

You should seek to improve your skills in their language if you want to join in.

Theroad · 22/05/2023 00:14

If she's lived in the UK for 45 years she really has no excuse. She's being incredibly rude - as is your DH. I speak other languages and it can be mentally draining over prolonged periods but she should make a good effort to speak English at least half of the time. I would feel like a stranger in my own home if someone did that. Particularly when your DD gets older and presumably she'll speak the language too. You'll be completely left out.

perhaps make some effort to learn a little bit more of their language and try again to engage MIL by doing your best and switching between the two. Your husband refusing to include you and never speaking English with his mother in your presence is bad though OP... I fear you may have a marriage problem on your hands.

MinervaSaidThar · 22/05/2023 00:03

YANBU, my mum likes to talk to me in our mother tongue sometimes. When DH is there, I answer her in English or another language we all speak, or I quickly translate for him.

You have a H problem, he seems to enjoy excluding too.

I hope he’s the one cooking and cleaning when she visits?

Treesoutsidemywindow · 22/05/2023 00:02

'Sandylanes69' what a ridiculous thing to say, and totally irrelevant! The OP's DH is English, having been born here. Her MIL has lived here for 45 years, and CAN hold a conversation in English, but choses not to in front of her DIL, which is just plain rude! I've said that what MIL does in her own home is up to her, but when she's in the home of her DIL who does not speak her language terribly well, she should make every effort to converse in English so that her DIL can understand.

Anonymouseposter · 21/05/2023 23:04

Can you learn more of your MIL’s language then you can communicate in a mix of the languages. She may not be completely confident in English and I think you both need to make an equal effort.

ShinyShite · 21/05/2023 22:53

I think YABU.

It's your husband's first language yet you're acting like it's somehow inferior to English because that's the language you grew up speaking.

Why don't you make more effort to learn the language to a level where you are fairly fluent instead of expecting your in-laws to make all the effort?

vipersnest1 · 21/05/2023 22:16

I don't think tackling your DH about this is going to help, @Gemmabw.
Go right to the source: 'sorry, MIL, I didn't catch what you said, can you translate it for me so I understand and can learn X language better? I'd like to join in the conversation.' Each and every time. What can she do? If she refuses then yes, she's being rude and in your position I would ask her to leave, telling her so. Otherwise, she has to translate and you can then ask her to repeat it back in X language so you can learn it. The worst that will happen is that she will know you are aware of the game she is playing, and the best is she complies and includes you more - there's no reason why she can't speak in X language and then repeat it in English - it will be good for her too.

Sandylanes69 · 21/05/2023 21:58

Treesoutsidemywindow · 21/05/2023 20:23

How absolutely rude and unacceptable this is OP! You are not being unreasonable at all. Tell them both that they either speak English while in your house, or his mother is no longer welcome, as them speaking a language which you don't understand is just plain rude, and you should not feel excluded in your own home. You can say to his mother that she can do as she wishes in her home, but not while she is a guest in yours, and if your DH doesn't support you, then I'd seriously be thinking of LTB as his failure in this, clearly shows that his mother is higher up in the pecking order than his wife, which is also totally unacceptable!

How many languages do you speak fluently I wonder? If you married a Greek or Italian man would you think yourself rude if you spoke English with your own family?

underneaththeash · 21/05/2023 21:55

Every time she does it, remind her she needs to speak English in front of you.

if she doesn’t cut down visits. I think it’s a good thing too that she’s teaching your DD a second language.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 21/05/2023 21:51

I had this with my FIL OP, he regularly spoke English and was fluent but in front of me spoke Spanish. It is very rude, very. Do please ignore those who are berating you for not having learned your MIL’s language she lives in the U.K. and has done for a long time the onus is on her to learn the language of the country in which she lives.
Your husband by the way is being deeply disrespectful to you.
I think if I had my time again I’d ask my husband to translate every word his father uttered, if he was not prepared to do that I’d take myself and my children out of the home and book us into a rather nice hotel while my FIL was in my home.
Please don’t accept this behaviour from either of them.

Dartmoorcheffy · 21/05/2023 21:50

I would learn the language.

TheShade · 21/05/2023 21:49

Part of the issue is with your partner - he should be making an effort to include you in the conversation and reminding his mum to include you sometimes by replying in English - especially when your name is mentioned/it’s clear you’re being spoken about.

Bluetrews25 · 21/05/2023 21:47

Get him to stop and translate every single sentence.
What did she say?
What did you say?
Really interrupt the flow. To help you learn the language of course, not to cause any disruption. Or annoy them so much that they just talk in English. Oh no.😜

MissyB1 · 21/05/2023 21:39

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 21/05/2023 21:21

Why haven't you put any effort in to learn your husband's language? Surely it is a part of your daughters heritage?

Her husband’s language is English - he was born in UK, he can also speak his mother’s language.

Neodymium · 21/05/2023 21:33

I wouldn’t have an issue with her speaking to dd in her language - being bilingual is a massive advantage.

I think when you enter the room they should speak English. Even if she speaks your husband should switch to English so at least you hear one side.

I have a friend at sport who does this. After the lesson me and her will be chatting. Then the coach will come over and the two of them are native speakers of another language. She will thank her in their language and then they will start chatting while I just stand there awkwardly. It’s really quite rude. I just excuse myself and leave.

s0s0rry · 21/05/2023 21:25

My MIL is the same. Difference is, I’m from the same background and am bilingual so there’s no excuse for it!

It used to bother me and my husband would get defensive about it, so now I don’t hold any expectations. I see mine every week for a few hours or at other family events. I do the obligatory greetings and just focus on those that do make an effort with me.

People who want to make an effort, will, regardless of language barriers.

Escapefromhell · 21/05/2023 21:24

You could fully engage with the conversation. If you don’t understand something, get them to explain each and every point. They should be impressed that you are making the effort. However, they will soon find it all too much like hard work and just speak in English