Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not an AIBU but if someone starts a thread about infertility please…

114 replies

PriamFarrl · 21/05/2023 15:43

….. do not do any of the following:

  • Ask if they have considered adoption.
  • Tell them to relax.
  • Tell them about someone you know who was told they couldn’t have children but then went on holiday/booked a round the world cruise/started a new job and found they were pregnant.

This has been a public service announcement on behalf of the childfree/childless women who are sick of hearing this shit society.

OP posts:
SquashPenguin · 21/05/2023 20:22

TeaParty4Me · 21/05/2023 20:13

I see some I just hadn’t seen any about those asking for advice.

But apparently those who have been through the same thing aren’t allowed to say their experiences as multiple posters have said that’s insensitive.

I assume it’s not just about MN and PPs also mean what you say in RL.
I upset my sister by saying what’s meant to be will be (which I thought was s nice thing) but she got offended and so I try and always be careful what to say.

Saying “what will be will be” is pretty awful. The negative test after a cycle of ivf is nothing like a negative after a month of trying naturally. It’s akin to someone dying. That’s the only way I can describe it as the grief is just unbelievable. You’d never say that to someone openly grieving for a lost relative.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/05/2023 20:19

I think it's perfectly fine to say, that's totally shit , I'm so sorry. Something else I have learnt through my adoption work is that it's important to acknowledge sadness and loss. You can't always make people " feel better" or " cheer them up" neither should you try.

TeaParty4Me · 21/05/2023 20:13

TooBigForMyBoots · 21/05/2023 20:08

A number of people on this thread have already provided good suggestions. Another good suggestion is: Don't say anything. And leave it up to people who know and have experienced this problem to help.

You do not have to post on every thread you open.

I see some I just hadn’t seen any about those asking for advice.

But apparently those who have been through the same thing aren’t allowed to say their experiences as multiple posters have said that’s insensitive.

I assume it’s not just about MN and PPs also mean what you say in RL.
I upset my sister by saying what’s meant to be will be (which I thought was s nice thing) but she got offended and so I try and always be careful what to say.

Usetherightgearforthehill · 21/05/2023 20:11

TeaParty4Me · 21/05/2023 19:55

You’ve said what people shouldn’t say but you’ve not said what people should say.

If someone starts a thread asking for advice or saying how sad they are that they’ve just miscarried then what do you say to that?

If someone has miscarried are only things you can think to say really:

Ask if they have considered adoption.
Tell them to relax.
Tell them about someone you know who was told they couldn’t have children but then went on holiday/booked a round the world cruise/started a new job and found they were pregnant.

monsteramunch · 21/05/2023 20:10

TeaParty4Me · 21/05/2023 19:55

You’ve said what people shouldn’t say but you’ve not said what people should say.

If someone starts a thread asking for advice or saying how sad they are that they’ve just miscarried then what do you say to that?

Please read the full thread, a number of people have made suggestions as to what helpful, kind and constructive comments might look like.

TooBigForMyBoots · 21/05/2023 20:08

TeaParty4Me · 21/05/2023 19:55

You’ve said what people shouldn’t say but you’ve not said what people should say.

If someone starts a thread asking for advice or saying how sad they are that they’ve just miscarried then what do you say to that?

A number of people on this thread have already provided good suggestions. Another good suggestion is: Don't say anything. And leave it up to people who know and have experienced this problem to help.

You do not have to post on every thread you open.

CheeseTouch · 21/05/2023 20:07

Bumping the thread for people that need to read the OP. To all living with fertility struggles 💐

BodegaSushi · 21/05/2023 20:03

TeaParty4Me · 21/05/2023 19:55

You’ve said what people shouldn’t say but you’ve not said what people should say.

If someone starts a thread asking for advice or saying how sad they are that they’ve just miscarried then what do you say to that?

There have been multiple suggestions of things on this thread to say instead.

TeaParty4Me · 21/05/2023 19:55

You’ve said what people shouldn’t say but you’ve not said what people should say.

If someone starts a thread asking for advice or saying how sad they are that they’ve just miscarried then what do you say to that?

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/05/2023 19:50

Changingplace · 21/05/2023 19:41

And they’ll be removed at birth largely due to previous children being removed due to neglect, or drug or alcohol abuse during pregnancy.

So, may well still come with significant health issues, it’s not the same as perfectly healthy babies being given up/removed.

That is very true. Occasionally a child relinquished following a rape or a concealed pregnancy in a very young teenager (13 or 14). But yes the majority of babies removed at births mothers have had previous children removed.

Maternal learning needs can be another reason ( more common than you might think) although this usually follows a " mother and baby" placement to assess parenting capacity. So the babies are usually around 3-6 months.

Changingplace · 21/05/2023 19:41

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/05/2023 19:39

Actually the number of children removed at birth is increasing. I have done some adoption work I would say 25% are babies of less than 6 months and are further 25% are between 6 & 18 months.

And they’ll be removed at birth largely due to previous children being removed due to neglect, or drug or alcohol abuse during pregnancy.

So, may well still come with significant health issues, it’s not the same as perfectly healthy babies being given up/removed.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/05/2023 19:39

PriamFarrl · 21/05/2023 17:24

Yes. Gone are the days when you got a healthy newborn that was given up (willingly or unwillingly) by some young woman who had ‘got herself in trouble’.

Actually the number of children removed at birth is increasing. I have done some adoption work I would say 25% are babies of less than 6 months and are further 25% are between 6 & 18 months.

HostaFireandIce · 21/05/2023 19:27

This gets posted fairly often on here and I have absolutely never seen a person who has suffered from infertility disagree.

I think it's interesting that people insist that they are saying these things to be helpful, but despite being told repeatedly that they are not helpful, and in fact quite the opposite, the vast majority of them insist that everyone is wrong. So why do they keep saying it? It's not to be helpful, is it?

TheCosyRain · 21/05/2023 19:21

👏🏻 I used to loathe the stories that people would tell me of someone they knew who, against all odds managed to eventually fall pregnant. I know they all probably felt they were giving me hope but it made zero difference to how I felt. That was their story, not mine.

BodegaSushi · 21/05/2023 19:19

WantToBeHappyAndHealthy · 21/05/2023 18:08

I started a thread last year ranting about my infertility, and was so upset because my period had came, making this our 5th year running of failing to conceive. Dh and I had mutually decided that it was the end of the ttc road for us as we couldn't put ourselves through any more of this pain.

I did ask people to please not give me any advice, I just needed someone to give off to and share my pain with.

I did of course get some people doing the opposite of what I asked, and suggested adoption, getting drunk etc.

It was annoying but what got to me even more was the people who so kindly informed me that they had formerly experienced fertility struggles too, but got their lovely ds/dd in the end "so don't give up."

Literally posted on a thread about me and dh giving up.

I posted the thread on Christmas morning and got some people saying "last Christmas I was in your position and was in tears as I longed for the baby I never dreamt I'd have, this year I am snuggling my newborn dd as we open presents under the Christmas tree."

Very cruel.

I remember this. Some people just can't help but centre themselves at all times. I I'm sorry again.

BodegaSushi · 21/05/2023 19:16

missushbbb · 21/05/2023 17:51

What are people allowed to say then? Why post anything if no one is allowed to say anything in reply?

Drama. It's been said several times a simple 'I'm sorry/it's awful/what do you need?' Type of questions are an alternative. Sometimes people don't want a solution they just want to vent. If you're not sure what type of support they're looking for you could ask.

WantToBeHappyAndHealthy · 21/05/2023 19:12

Saniflo · 21/05/2023 18:51

Maybe if posters are so sensitive they should post somewhere else? Maybe mumsnet and AIBU in particular are not the best place to ask for infertility advice if you are expecting such a specific response?

Maybe posters should be a bit kinder? And have a little bit of consideration and compassion when someone is clearly struggling?🤷‍♀️ it's not difficult.

Newnamenewname109870 · 21/05/2023 19:07

Usetherightgearforthehill · 21/05/2023 15:47

This has been posted on MN before and mostly what happens is most people agree, but there is also usually a flurry of posts of people defending asking about adoption etc because they genuinely think they are the only person in the world who might have thought of it and therefore they have to tell the OP, mixed in with a vein of - what I want to say is more important to me that what the infertile person feels.

Basically this!

PriamFarrl · 21/05/2023 19:07

Saniflo · 21/05/2023 18:51

Maybe if posters are so sensitive they should post somewhere else? Maybe mumsnet and AIBU in particular are not the best place to ask for infertility advice if you are expecting such a specific response?

So if someone wants relationship advice, and infertility is part of the problem she should either ask elsewhere or just have to suck up the unhelpful comments.

OP posts:
Trees6 · 21/05/2023 18:53

Saniflo · 21/05/2023 18:51

Maybe if posters are so sensitive they should post somewhere else? Maybe mumsnet and AIBU in particular are not the best place to ask for infertility advice if you are expecting such a specific response?

But are they asking for “infertility advice” though? These couples will have access to specialist doctors and nurses.

Usetherightgearforthehill · 21/05/2023 18:53

Saniflo · 21/05/2023 18:51

Maybe if posters are so sensitive they should post somewhere else? Maybe mumsnet and AIBU in particular are not the best place to ask for infertility advice if you are expecting such a specific response?

People literally say these things on the infertility board

But yes grieving people should not be so sensitive, how very silly of us.

Saniflo · 21/05/2023 18:51

Maybe if posters are so sensitive they should post somewhere else? Maybe mumsnet and AIBU in particular are not the best place to ask for infertility advice if you are expecting such a specific response?

monsteramunch · 21/05/2023 18:49

It's unthinkably unkind of them to post those things @WantToBeHappyAndHealthy

Sometimes I try to give people the benefit of the doubt but sadly even after it's pointed out how unhelpful and cruel those sort of posts are, people (including a couple on this thread) are unwilling to accept that they shouldn't post such things. It just isn't good enough.

Sending you massive love Flowers

AutumnColour89 · 21/05/2023 18:47

I'm sorry @WantToBeHappyAndHealthy, that's shit💐

I hit my 4 years of ttc in a few weeks. Some people are really supportive, but one of my best friends comes out with some really thoughtless comments.

Didnt start trying until she was 39, paid for first IVF cycle at 41 (partner already has 2 children) and against the odds it worked. Now the implication is that I'm not trying hard enough, and banging on about how amazing it is and she wishes she'd done it years ago.

My first nephew was born this week, and DH and I are going to meet him next weekend. I'm excited and so happy for my sister (who had her own struggles), but I know it will also stir up painful feelings.

GenAndWine · 21/05/2023 18:35

missushbbb · 21/05/2023 17:51

What are people allowed to say then? Why post anything if no one is allowed to say anything in reply?

I’m so sorry
that’s incredibly shit for you
Do you want to talk about how you feel?

Basically giving up on having children is a grieving process. So run it through your head with the filter of ‘if someone close to me had just died would this be an insensitive thing for someone to say to me?’

or say nothing. Leave it to those who’ve suffered infertility. We’re plentiful in number.

Swipe left for the next trending thread