Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think about getting a cat but not wanting to do a litter box?

117 replies

Nolitterbox · 21/05/2023 14:46

We had a cat that died about 8 years ago, she was not an indoor cat - but hardly ever went outside. Really only to sunbathe! The good thing was: no dead wildlife. The bad thing was: litter box. I hated it. It was a bane of my life the whole time.

I have a really strong sense of smell and can always smell them when I go to people’s houses who have them and I really dislike them. Also, our house is very small - there’s nowhere “tucked away” it could go.

I told DH we could get a cat and not do the litter box thing. He isn’t so sure. It’s a dealbreaker for me!

So:
if you have a cat and a litter box, vote YABU
If you have a cat and no litter box YANBU

OP posts:
Jarstastic · 21/05/2023 16:54

I think all cats should have access to a litter tray. Even if they spend most of their time going outdoors if they are not well or the weather is bad they should be able to go indoors. Also I think cats should stay in at night. I always thought this over decades of cat ownership. We recently stopped locking the cat flap at night and our cat went missing at night within a few weeks.

Ladybirdlashes · 21/05/2023 16:40

My neighbours cat is using my daughters mud kitchen tyre and out flower bed as a litter tray. Yesterday it had diarrhoea over my freshly planted raised bed, it was vile.

It absolutely disgusts me to be honest, I don’t have a cat or dog and a large part of the reason for that is that I don’t like to clear up animal poo, however now I have to make sure I always check the garden for cat poo before my children can go out to play and make sure I always have poop bags in so I can deal with it. People like you are the problem - if you have an animal you should be responsible for it, not passing it off to your neighbours.

ghostyslovesheets · 21/05/2023 16:34

Depends on the cat - I have 6 - 2 of them use the tray - one likes to wee where the tray is and it’s only there because otherwise he would wee there anyway! (Weeing came before we put a tray there). Our 7 nth kitten comes inside to USE the tray! Just won’t go outside.
my big issue with you plan would be winter - when it’s cold! They can’t be out 24/7 in the ice! Unless you have a cat flap - we can’t have one and I prefer it as I don’t like scrappy neighbour cats coming in.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 21/05/2023 16:31

Kitkatfiend31 · 21/05/2023 16:27

If the cat will always be able to access the outside you should only need a litter tray while they get used to the house. Neither if our cats continued to use a litter tray once they were going out.

The issue is, there's no guarantee OP's cat will be the same as yours.

I'm a cat sitter and look after loads of indoor/outdoor cats - the vast majority have access to a litter tray - and they do use it - especially in bad weather and as they get older.

If you get a cat, you do need to at least be prepared to have and maintain a litter tray, because if you don't and the cat won't go outside, the only alternative is that they'll piss and shit all over your house, which is far more unpleasant to clean up than a litter tray Grin

SussexSeaGal · 21/05/2023 16:28

Feed your cat good quality raw food from somewhere like Katkin or Purrform and the poo doesn't stink at all!

Kitkatfiend31 · 21/05/2023 16:27

If the cat will always be able to access the outside you should only need a litter tray while they get used to the house. Neither if our cats continued to use a litter tray once they were going out.

Floralnomad · 21/05/2023 16:22

Even with an outdoor cat you will need a litter box at the start as kittens shouldn’t go out until they are neutered / a rescue cat needs to stay in for a while until it knows where home is / how it smells etc .

meatballsoup · 21/05/2023 16:21

It is something to really think about because no matter what litter you use or how often you clean the tray cat piss is pungent!. My husband has 2 cats ( they are definitely his, I never agreed to having them & I have nothing to do with the cleaning of the tray). He buys worlds best cat litter and keeps it clean but I can still smell cat piss. I hate it and will never have a cat in the house again after these two finally pop off.

Disclaimer: I'm not cruel to the cats I just really dislike them and don't have anything to do with them

ittakes2 · 21/05/2023 16:21

We have a male and a female cat - its only the male cat which brings in wild life the female cats likes to eat insects. We get what's called the world's best cat litter and I think it really is!

ImthatBoleyngirl · 21/05/2023 16:21

My cat was an outdoor cat with no litter tray for 6 years, and then the neighbours got a very friendly kitten ............let's just say that my cat is very unsociable and refused to go outside anymore. She's is now 11 and we still have the bloody litter tray! It's the bane of my life!!

Beneficialchampion2 · 21/05/2023 16:19

A litter box is a necessity, get an enclosed one, feed the cat a decent diet (blink etc) and their poo won't stink.

Youknownorhing · 21/05/2023 16:14

I have had cats for over 50years.. no litter boxes ever. With the exception of kittens between arriving (8/10 weeks) and vaccinations .. then they have gone outside. The only difference this time round is a cat flap.. as got fed up being a footman !

Garden isn't 'cat proofed' not even really sure what that means. Nearest neighbours a quarter of a mile away and don't think they could be arsed to go looking for poo... but we are v rural so probably makes a difference.

ColdHandsHotHead · 21/05/2023 16:14

It doesn't matter how much of an outdoors cat your cat is, there will always be times when you need to keep it in. For example, in case of illness. Mine is in overnight and at the moment not allowed out until about 10am because it's the nesting season and he has to be in from late afternoon until dark. He greatly prefers to use my garden BUT if he's indoors and needs a poo, he's got a litter tray.

GloriousintheArctic · 21/05/2023 16:11

As others have said, you can provide an outdoor litter tray. I have a large one for my cats and they do use it, obviously you need to clean it out regularly. It contains a mix of sharp sand and the old compost from last year's pots (or you can use garden soil). It gets wet in the rain but that doesn't matter, it dries out again.

crazycatladyof6 · 21/05/2023 16:07

I have 6 cats and no litter boxes apart from when any of them have been poorly

TulipCat · 21/05/2023 16:06

My cat started going outside instead of using the litter tray once he was old enough to be allowed outside. We have so many foxes round here - people's gardens are already full of fox poo anyway.

Nolitterbox · 21/05/2023 16:05

SittingNextToIt · 21/05/2023 15:56

Hiya

If your cat doesn’t have a litter tray, where would it shit, please?

I was thinking our back garden, and that the cat would bury it! But it seems others do not have that experience!

OP posts:
Nolitterbox · 21/05/2023 16:03

Villagetoraiseachild · 21/05/2023 15:46

Hi Op, I get it.

I've been researching sand pits for cats. It means that their toileting is contained and outside. One I saw had a privacy hedge, to help the cat feel more secure.You can easily self build them, apparently. Obviously this sand pit facility is only for the cat, not DCs!

I also like the suggestion of outside the back door, either hooded or in a kennel.

I agree with previous poster that an elderly cat is probably going to need an indoor/close to door litter tray.

Sand pits for cats - this is interesting! I will look this up too.

OP posts:
Cillmantain · 21/05/2023 16:03

Where do you think the cat will crap if you don't have a litter tray...more than likely other people's gardens.
Very unfair

Nolitterbox · 21/05/2023 16:01

We have a very long garden which backs onto field - so I’m not expecting that the cat would poop in other people’s gardens. Also I thought cats liked to bury their poo?

I’ve only noticed cat poo in my own garden once in all these years (it was on the patio - while that probably should have been gross, I was actually fairly glad as it seemed to scare off the garden rats for a while so I left it there!).

Fox poo on the other hand…

But - fair point - I don’t want to get a cat and make their poo someone else’s problem! I naively hoped it would bury its poo in my garden unnoticed!

When I was a child we had one cat after another, and never once had a litter box and I also never noticed cat poo anywhere. But we lived in the countryside so, on the other hand, we did have dead wildlife to deal with.

Ahh maybe at a cat impasse. I don’t want a killer cat, but I also don’t want an indoor litterbox!

OP posts:
Seaweasel · 21/05/2023 15:59

We always have one but she hasn't used it for about a year when she was poorly and couldn't go outside. She goes in a spot in our garden which is very convenient. I wouldn't take it away though, just in case.

Findyourneutralspace · 21/05/2023 15:58

My cat prefers to go behind the bushes at the end of the street (they are against a wall, so literally no one ever goes there) but he still uses his tray if it’s raining or I’m not here to let him out.

SittingNextToIt · 21/05/2023 15:56

Nolitterbox · 21/05/2023 14:46

We had a cat that died about 8 years ago, she was not an indoor cat - but hardly ever went outside. Really only to sunbathe! The good thing was: no dead wildlife. The bad thing was: litter box. I hated it. It was a bane of my life the whole time.

I have a really strong sense of smell and can always smell them when I go to people’s houses who have them and I really dislike them. Also, our house is very small - there’s nowhere “tucked away” it could go.

I told DH we could get a cat and not do the litter box thing. He isn’t so sure. It’s a dealbreaker for me!

So:
if you have a cat and a litter box, vote YABU
If you have a cat and no litter box YANBU

Hiya

If your cat doesn’t have a litter tray, where would it shit, please?

Pippylongstock · 21/05/2023 15:55

Floralnomad · 21/05/2023 14:53

If you aren’t prepared to clean up an animals poo then you shouldn’t have an animal

This! Sorry you are being ridiculous

AcrossthePond55 · 21/05/2023 15:55

I'm in the US and we had an automatic litter box. It 'self-scooped' and dumped the poo & wee clumps into a little plastic disposable bin liner with a lid and then shut the lid each time after the cat used the box. There was even a little charcoal 'deodorizer' that you could stick to the inside. Minimum smell and no scooping. All we had to do was pop the plastic bin out & seal it with the lid, replace the liner and lid, and take the 'full' one to the outside bin. Easy peasy.

Unfortunately I can't remember the name of it, so I can't check to see if they have the same in the UK. But I'd think they'd have something similar.