Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think about getting a cat but not wanting to do a litter box?

117 replies

Nolitterbox · 21/05/2023 14:46

We had a cat that died about 8 years ago, she was not an indoor cat - but hardly ever went outside. Really only to sunbathe! The good thing was: no dead wildlife. The bad thing was: litter box. I hated it. It was a bane of my life the whole time.

I have a really strong sense of smell and can always smell them when I go to people’s houses who have them and I really dislike them. Also, our house is very small - there’s nowhere “tucked away” it could go.

I told DH we could get a cat and not do the litter box thing. He isn’t so sure. It’s a dealbreaker for me!

So:
if you have a cat and a litter box, vote YABU
If you have a cat and no litter box YANBU

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Gigglemous · 25/05/2023 06:15

2 things, get the cat onto proper good food so the poop doesnt smell. We have quite expensive dry food and its nowhere near as bad on its way out as say wet food is.
Secondly, get a covered litterbox with swing door.
I have an insane sense of smell too, you cannot smell it. The odor stays inside it.
I always get told my home doesn't have a 'pet' smell.
The hair is a different story though 🤣 (I have 2 indoor only floofy cats)

TheHandbag · 25/05/2023 06:05

I keep my cat's tray outside by the backdoor so she goes outside to use the tray. My house doesn't smell of cats at all & my garden is poo free. I clean the tray before I bring it in at night.

Alanisadick · 25/05/2023 02:31

My cats had litter trays as kittens, and then for the first year or so after they started going outside, I kept the trays which they gradually used less and less. After 6 months of not a single tiddle crap in the trays, which were taking up valuable space in my small house, I did away with them. Yes my cats shite outside, but there’s not much I can do about that unless I keep them as indoor cats, which is cruel IMO.

Villagetoraiseachild · 25/05/2023 02:12

If you've got a large garden Op, you've got this. Sand pit or dug over bed. We all managed years ago without litter boxes.
Don't let the neggers grind you down.

magma32 · 23/05/2023 03:05

give your cat decent quality food and their poo should not smell at all. Scoop daily. Wood litter is good for absorbing wee. Dcat does ‘nice’ poos since I changed his diet to high meat/no filler food so basically not the cheap supermarket stuff. Maybe try rather than have no cat toilet.

letthemalldoone · 23/05/2023 02:35

PurpleWisteria1 · 22/05/2023 19:54

As long as you leave the door open on a sunny morning / late afternoon so they can choose weather to go in or out that’s fine.
If not then they are stuck inside your house. Just because they are not clawing at the door doesn’t mean they wouldn’t like some freedom or to run jump and climb in the grass and trees. Not quite the same on carpet and scratching posts.

They are more than happy to bask in the sunshine from inside the house. Our wee 6 year old sprawled out in the sun this afternoon inside our patio doors and was so soundly asleep that she was snoring!

PurpleWisteria1 · 22/05/2023 19:54

letthemalldoone · 22/05/2023 19:39

I have two of the happiest, most contented rescue girls, and they are not "caged". They have the run of the house. We kept them in initially as they had been living rough, so they could get used to living here, and not once in over a year has either of them looked to go out.

I've had outdoor cats, indoor cats and outdoor/indoor cats, and I still have a catflap which is chip-operated from my last cat. I think these two had had their fill of living on the streets in all weathers. If they had been desperate to get out then I would have had to let them.

I am happy that they're unlikely (barring accidents) to go missing, to get into fights, contract diseases or to have to be scraped off the road. There's enough of the neighbours' cats around to kill birds in our back garden - at least ours aren't doing that, or shitting in anyone else's garden.

As long as you leave the door open on a sunny morning / late afternoon so they can choose weather to go in or out that’s fine.
If not then they are stuck inside your house. Just because they are not clawing at the door doesn’t mean they wouldn’t like some freedom or to run jump and climb in the grass and trees. Not quite the same on carpet and scratching posts.

letthemalldoone · 22/05/2023 19:39

PurpleWisteria1 · 22/05/2023 18:02

Keeping an animal caged up is cruel.
Why would you? What’s in it for the animal and is it worth their freedom?

I have two of the happiest, most contented rescue girls, and they are not "caged". They have the run of the house. We kept them in initially as they had been living rough, so they could get used to living here, and not once in over a year has either of them looked to go out.

I've had outdoor cats, indoor cats and outdoor/indoor cats, and I still have a catflap which is chip-operated from my last cat. I think these two had had their fill of living on the streets in all weathers. If they had been desperate to get out then I would have had to let them.

I am happy that they're unlikely (barring accidents) to go missing, to get into fights, contract diseases or to have to be scraped off the road. There's enough of the neighbours' cats around to kill birds in our back garden - at least ours aren't doing that, or shitting in anyone else's garden.

Evaka · 22/05/2023 19:23

Please get a tray for sake of your neighbours and self. My boy got blocked from his tray and flap accidentally a while ago and shat on a lovely wool blanket on the sofa just as I was joining a 3 hour zoom-athon in the same room. This will happen to you if you don't give cats somewhere nice and private to go.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 22/05/2023 19:18

YANBU. I've always had cats but would never have an indoor cat for this very reason. The only time we've had a litter tray was when they were kittens before they were allowed out and when she gad to stay in for 2 months following an injury.

Iminpatchinghell · 22/05/2023 18:59

To all those saying their cat buries their poo, they don’t always. They also dig all the soil out of freshly potted flowers, shit all in there. And they also dig up play bark and shit all over that.
But then, I have a dog and we all know what MN thinks of dog owners…!

MonteStory · 22/05/2023 18:56

I wouldn’t buy a cat specifically to keep it caged. But when rescues are absolutely over run it is at least better than poor treatment or being feral.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 22/05/2023 18:11

PurpleWisteria1 · 22/05/2023 18:05

If you live in a busy area don’t get a cat. Irresponsible and selfish.
If you have lots of fields or quiet roads, get a cat and it gets run over then that’s unfortunate and accidents happen to both humans and animals.
Personally I would rather see a cat live for 2 years free than 15 years caged. But then I literally can’t even walk past goldfish in a tank without feeling desperately sorry for them.

I'm not here to debate the rights and wrongs of indoor/outdoor cats.

I'm just saying you can make your point without calling people cruel.

PurpleWisteria1 · 22/05/2023 18:05

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 22/05/2023 15:09

Well, the flipside of that is how do people live with themselves letting their cats out alone knowing they could easily get run over, or poisoned, or taken by someone else, or lost, or hurt in a fight?

I mean, every week there are threads on here from people who have lost their cats to the roads - some as young as six months old. Letting cats out to roam isn't exactly a dream existence for them.

There are valid arguments for keeping cats inside and for letting them out. Telling one side that they're cruel for their decision isn't particularly helpful - and I'm sure you wouldn't appreciate being told you were cruel for letting your cat out to take their chances on the roads.

If you live in a busy area don’t get a cat. Irresponsible and selfish.
If you have lots of fields or quiet roads, get a cat and it gets run over then that’s unfortunate and accidents happen to both humans and animals.
Personally I would rather see a cat live for 2 years free than 15 years caged. But then I literally can’t even walk past goldfish in a tank without feeling desperately sorry for them.

PurpleWisteria1 · 22/05/2023 18:02

letthemalldoone · 22/05/2023 15:10

Rubbish! It’s not cruel!!

Keeping an animal caged up is cruel.
Why would you? What’s in it for the animal and is it worth their freedom?

Glittertwins · 22/05/2023 16:14

We changed to Katkin and we've not had as many problems with the recipe change as others fortunately. The smell could sometimes be eye watering, even for us when we were used to it but now its genuinely not noticeable and my parents who aren't here enough to become used to it have said the same.

Bargellobitch · 22/05/2023 16:06

Polis · 21/05/2023 15:02

I have a really strong sense of smell and can always smell them when I go to people’s houses who have them and I really dislike them.

My husband is the same. We put the litter tray outside under cover.

Is there any way that you could do that?

I was going to suggest this with a cat flap. We did something similar when we got a cat flap in our old house. As I didn't want her going in neighbours gardens.

We now have 2 kittens and just keep on top of it. Luckily we are both OK with it.

whyisitalwayswindy · 22/05/2023 16:05

@Glittertwins what diet have you changed your cat onto?

whyisitalwayswindy · 22/05/2023 16:01

Some cats are happy without a tray but I think you have to accept that the cat you get might wish to use one. If you don't provide it then you may get accidents/issues and as cats get older they often prefer a tray as the act of pooing makes them vulnerable to attack (in their heads, I appreciate we're not over run with loads of predators that might attack cats).

One of the first posters said it, if you can't cope with dealing with animal poo then don't get an animal. It's not fair on them.

fantasmasgoria1 · 22/05/2023 15:56

We have a cat with litter tray. We use wood pellet litter which is easier to clean and smells much less. As soon as our cat has pooped we use a poop bag and remove it. Hardly and smell at all. Or you could shell out for a robot litter tray which sifts ,cleans and dries! They are really expensive though.

Glittertwins · 22/05/2023 15:40

Get a covered box and decent food and it won't smell. The difference after changing her diet is incredible.

letthemalldoone · 22/05/2023 15:10

PurpleWisteria1 · 21/05/2023 22:01

You will need one whilst the cat settles in or is a kitten. After that the cat will go outside most likely and the litter tray will hardly be used or not used at all. Get decent litter and they don’t smell at all.
Do NOT cage or confine your cat to a house or catio. So cruel. But then I think any animals kept in a cage for human enjoyment is horribly cruel, no matter how well they are treated.

Rubbish! It’s not cruel!!

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 22/05/2023 15:09

PurpleWisteria1 · 22/05/2023 14:38

They mean that cats are not allowed to roam and are effectively in prisoned for the pure enjoyment of the human owner. Awful. Just don’t get a cat at all of you are going to keep it in a guilded cage all of its existence. How do people live with locking an animal up? Look at it every day whilst they go out and the animal can’t? Just don’t get it.

Well, the flipside of that is how do people live with themselves letting their cats out alone knowing they could easily get run over, or poisoned, or taken by someone else, or lost, or hurt in a fight?

I mean, every week there are threads on here from people who have lost their cats to the roads - some as young as six months old. Letting cats out to roam isn't exactly a dream existence for them.

There are valid arguments for keeping cats inside and for letting them out. Telling one side that they're cruel for their decision isn't particularly helpful - and I'm sure you wouldn't appreciate being told you were cruel for letting your cat out to take their chances on the roads.

willowthecat · 22/05/2023 14:58

I have had cats all my life but only ever had a litter box when we were away and catsitters were in or when cat ill. It's far easier and more hygienic for everyone - in my opinion obv

MonteStory · 22/05/2023 14:54

PurpleWisteria1 · 22/05/2023 14:38

They mean that cats are not allowed to roam and are effectively in prisoned for the pure enjoyment of the human owner. Awful. Just don’t get a cat at all of you are going to keep it in a guilded cage all of its existence. How do people live with locking an animal up? Look at it every day whilst they go out and the animal can’t? Just don’t get it.

I think it has become law in some states that they must be in catios because of attacking wildlife. I agree with you though - get a gerbil if you want something in a cage.

I can’t understand the hysteria about cat poo. They’re roamers - you seriously expect owners to know where their cats are going? They bury their poo and there are plenty of ways to deter cats from your garden. If ‘cat proofing’ is so easy then you do it to your garden!

As it happens I’ve seen our cat poo under our hedge and they tend to go in the same place each time. But if I hadnt, I wouldn’t give it a second thought. Foxes, badgers, rodents all poo in your garden. Yes they’re wild animals but surely you accept poo is just part of the outside world?

Our sand/mud tyres are covered to stop cats (including our own who would almost certainly be the culprit) using them. Water is covered so I can be sure it doesn’t have rat wee in it. I know these things are safe for my toddler because I have made them so. If I find fox shit while gardening then, yep, that’s a bit gross but I’ve got a spade in my hand and gloves on - pretty easily solved.

I’m not gonna feel bad about my cat neatly burying her poo in some soil when dog owners frequently leave shit in the literal middle of the path on our way to school. No wonder my kids school have both indoor and outdoor shoes.