Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move to Italy

113 replies

Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 13:58

Hello,

long time lurker. Probably outing but I’m so stuck with what to do…

Due to brexit my husband had to move to Italy. He’s been there a year and things are rocky between us due to lack of intimacy and him not seeing kids often and me doing everything as means us flying there or him here. The only option is divorce or uproot the kids and move to Italy - this long term thing isn’t working. The kids are half Italian but don’t speak much of it. Youngest is about to start at a highly selective secondary school which he worked for 2 years to gain entry and he’s very excited and cries if I mention moving. Eldest is about to start GSCEs but extraordinarily bright and will do well anywhere even if we move mid year. Eldest doesn’t like change but I think would love it. Obviously my elderly parents are here so that’s a consideration too. They’d be devastated if we moved.

cost of living is going up here, I think we would have a better life there. But will my husband and I reconnect? And is it detrimental to the kids to uproot them at crucial stages…. What if they hate it? Are they too old to relocate? I’d have to give up their selective places if we moved, so it is not like we can “try” it and move back if we hate it.

please help. And please be kind. I’m very fragile right now.

thank you

OP posts:
ButterCrackers · 21/05/2023 15:18

Is the job permanent? If so then move there. Your kids can know their other country. Would your dh get school fees paid for international schools? I suppose that the local schools are good as well. What’s healthcare like there? Can you see a GP and dentist easily? Housing ok? Could you rent out your home in the UK? What about getting Italian nationality? All better than staying in the uk.

XelaM · 21/05/2023 15:18

Your marriage doesn't have to break down just because your husband works abroad. My dad lived and worked abroad when I was little for about 2 years but he flew/drove back most weekends and we came to visit him regularly. This was over 30 years ago and my parents are still very happily married all these years later.

maranella · 21/05/2023 15:17

Such a hard decision for you OP. I can't really add anything useful, as while I'm also in an international marriage and lived myself in Italy for a while, I haven't been in the position you're in so can't offer you any advice or insight. I do have DC approx the same age as yours though and I think they'd hate to move countries at this stage. While primary age - I think that would be hard, but doable - but at secondary? Not so much.

OhwhyOY · 21/05/2023 15:16

I work in a career where people move abroad a lot. I've consistently heard from colleagues that moving teenagers abroad to somewhere they don't speak the language, especially around exam years, is best avoided as they struggle to fit in. How motivated are they around language learning as for me if they enjoyed it I would think they would stand a much better chance of fitting in. If they're not keen then I'd think it's more likely they'd struggle, particularly if neither are keen on the move. Is there an option to take an extended holiday there (e.g. 8 weeks) where you could explore life there a bit more, get a sense of what it would be like, and also try to reconnect with your husband a bit more and see if it feels like it's feasible to move there? Can you work ok from there, see what activities/clubs the kids could get involved in, are there other English ex pat kids around etc? And also see how the kids feel about it after that?

So1invictus · 21/05/2023 15:14

What's his living arrangements?

Where would you all live? How close is he to his family? How close are YOU to his family?

You know all those stereotypes about overbearing Italian families? How true is it for your husband's?

Has he said that he'd like you to come over?

Is the house in the UK in both your names? Surely the rent would help cover the mortgage? I own a house in the UK but rent here, as even if I sold the house in England it wouldn't cover squat here. On two decent wages here we'll never earn enough to buy.

But again, none of that really is relevant as if two people want to be together with their children, where there's a will, there's a way. Is there a will?

KickAssAngel · 21/05/2023 15:14

But it sounds like you're expecting to divorce if you stay in the UK. From the info you've given, you won't be able to keep the house and private school sounds unlikely as well.

Think about life in the UK if your DH paid no child maintenance. With him in Italy that could happen. What would life be like then? Then compare it to life in Italy if you divorce. Basically, look at the best case and worst case, and decide which is more likely and can you accept that as your possible future?

ZoeyBartlett · 21/05/2023 15:11

If it's any help on elderly parents, my SIL married an Italian and lives there. She would like parents to move there as well as care is cheaper - they can get a retirement visa. She has looked after a number of Italian elderly relatives and found the health care good and as I said the care cheaper - 24 hour live in caters for less than £20k a year which is much cheaper than a nursing home

My nephew attends an international school and is doing well. My niece is at an Italian school but many of the courses are taught in French so she will have option of England, France or Italy for university.

Both kids bilingual.

Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 15:11

Newnamenewname109870 · 21/05/2023 15:04

What was the discussion like when he left? Was the assumption you’d do long distance forever or were you always planning to move with him? is the job he has stable and longterm? Would you stay in Italy for the rest of your lives?

Your relationship sounds very rocky and I wonder what he really thinks about it all. I think you all need to go and spend lots of time there, whenever you can. Stay in the areas where you’d love and see how your relationship is. It may be worth the move and you could give your children (and yourself) a year to see how it goes. If you are there longterm, your elderly parents could move out too for their retirement.

We stupidly didn’t have that discussion as my youngest was in the middle of exams for this selective school. The job is stable and long term. I think we would probably stay in Italy forever.

my eldest wants to go to an Italian uni - so he’s be there anyway!

the main stumbling block is even if we give it a shot - I have to give up 2 selective school places that they both worked so hard for. The eldest is unhappy there and having counselling though.

OP posts:
dogsanddolphines · 21/05/2023 15:10

I don't think it's fair to uproot the kids. They're teenagers, old enough for you to start thinking about university. Moving away might take the UK option completely off the table depending on the residency requirements.

Also, what are divorce laws like in Italy, should the worst happen? Will you get a fair share of assets?

FairAcre · 21/05/2023 15:09

One thing to consider is that if you move out there and the marriage doesn’t work you may not be able to legally move back to the uk with the children. Especially as their father is Italian.

Mythologies · 21/05/2023 15:09

Please do 😊

Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 15:08

WheresSpring · 21/05/2023 15:01

I’ve also previously lived and worked in Italy. I’m sure I’ll be accused of huge generalisation but I must say that, whilst I’m very happy to go back on holiday, I’m not sure I’d want to bring my kids up somewhere where racism and misogyny is still such an ingrained part of the culture. Admittedly I haven’t been back for about 10years so I really hope it’s moved on. Also, your dh may well have got used to solo life - how useful/hands on do you think he’ll actually be with the kids if you head out to join him?… I’m really sorry you’re having such a rubbish time 💐

I think he is enjoying being solo. So it concerns me that if I get divorced, he will get to enjoy his solo life, with his new very well paid job, while I do all the slog here. At least if we are there, he will have to do his fair share. But then maybe he won’t and resentment will build…FFS. I wish this wasn’t happening.

OP posts:
Newnamenewname109870 · 21/05/2023 15:04

What was the discussion like when he left? Was the assumption you’d do long distance forever or were you always planning to move with him? is the job he has stable and longterm? Would you stay in Italy for the rest of your lives?

Your relationship sounds very rocky and I wonder what he really thinks about it all. I think you all need to go and spend lots of time there, whenever you can. Stay in the areas where you’d love and see how your relationship is. It may be worth the move and you could give your children (and yourself) a year to see how it goes. If you are there longterm, your elderly parents could move out too for their retirement.

Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 15:04

LadyLapsang · 21/05/2023 15:03

It’s a pretty big risk to take two children out of a good secondary school and move to another country for a rocky relationship. In four years time your eldest will probably be going to university if you stay where you are. Also, if you move, will you be stuck in Italy if the marriage breaks down? If you come back to the UK will it be without the children, will they then build their adult life in Italy? What about the cost of HE if your children no longer count as Home Students in the UK? I don’t understand why he can’t fly back every few weeks or once pm.

Thanks @LadyLapsang. It is a concern.

OP posts:
Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 15:03

Mythologies · 21/05/2023 15:01

I lived most of my adult life in Italy and brought up my children there.
DM me if you have any questions

@Mythologies i might DM you actually if that is ok. Thank you

OP posts:
LadyLapsang · 21/05/2023 15:03

It’s a pretty big risk to take two children out of a good secondary school and move to another country for a rocky relationship. In four years time your eldest will probably be going to university if you stay where you are. Also, if you move, will you be stuck in Italy if the marriage breaks down? If you come back to the UK will it be without the children, will they then build their adult life in Italy? What about the cost of HE if your children no longer count as Home Students in the UK? I don’t understand why he can’t fly back every few weeks or once pm.

Mythologies · 21/05/2023 15:01

I lived most of my adult life in Italy and brought up my children there.
DM me if you have any questions

WheresSpring · 21/05/2023 15:01

I’ve also previously lived and worked in Italy. I’m sure I’ll be accused of huge generalisation but I must say that, whilst I’m very happy to go back on holiday, I’m not sure I’d want to bring my kids up somewhere where racism and misogyny is still such an ingrained part of the culture. Admittedly I haven’t been back for about 10years so I really hope it’s moved on. Also, your dh may well have got used to solo life - how useful/hands on do you think he’ll actually be with the kids if you head out to join him?… I’m really sorry you’re having such a rubbish time 💐

Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 14:59

CabernetSauvignon · 21/05/2023 14:58

Is there a possible option around your youngest staying with your parents so he can still go to the English school?

I can’t leave my youngest in the UK while I move to Italy. This is not an option.

OP posts:
CabernetSauvignon · 21/05/2023 14:58

Is there a possible option around your youngest staying with your parents so he can still go to the English school?

Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 14:58

He went for more junior roles but they gave the jobs to the numerous more recently qualified junior people. Most companies felt it was odd he was going for such junior roles. I have a lot of misgivings about how he’s has behaved on certain things. But he did try his hardest.

OP posts:
CabernetSauvignon · 21/05/2023 14:57

How often are you and your husband seeing each other currently? Can you increase the number of visits you both make?

TheThinkingGoblin · 21/05/2023 14:49

ReachForTheMars · 21/05/2023 14:31

I think he made a bad choice. At this stage of his life he should have put his family and the need to keep you together over his dream job.

Did he work during that 3 years or just burn through savings because he wiuldnt take a job beneath him.

Cynically, I wonder if he subconsciously spent the savings before moving to Italy as he was hoping to.

This is a typical attitude that I see in the UK

The "take any job" mentality even if one is vastly over-qualified.

If you wanted to absolutely destroy your marriage that is the one avenue that would absolutely do it.

Being underemployed would generate immense resentment over time. And that doesn't go away.

Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 14:47

Retire50 · 21/05/2023 14:44

I would not be moving happy settled children who are eager to excel in their current schools to a new system unless it was absolutely my last choice.

Give the youngest a chance to at least attend the selective secondary school he worked so hard to get into. You never know he may decide he would like to move to Italy after a year. The international private school in Italy will always be an option. The highly selective secondary school in the UK will not I presume.

Correct. I think this is our only option. This would then give us a chance to improve our Italian.

OP posts:
XelaM · 21/05/2023 14:46

OneFrenchEgg · 21/05/2023 14:20

Why did he have to move due to Brexit? I'm a bit confused why he didn't keep looking for a job here? Sorry if I'm being naive but I thought people living here could stay?

Yes, my brother is a German citizen and works in the UK