Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move to Italy

113 replies

Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 13:58

Hello,

long time lurker. Probably outing but I’m so stuck with what to do…

Due to brexit my husband had to move to Italy. He’s been there a year and things are rocky between us due to lack of intimacy and him not seeing kids often and me doing everything as means us flying there or him here. The only option is divorce or uproot the kids and move to Italy - this long term thing isn’t working. The kids are half Italian but don’t speak much of it. Youngest is about to start at a highly selective secondary school which he worked for 2 years to gain entry and he’s very excited and cries if I mention moving. Eldest is about to start GSCEs but extraordinarily bright and will do well anywhere even if we move mid year. Eldest doesn’t like change but I think would love it. Obviously my elderly parents are here so that’s a consideration too. They’d be devastated if we moved.

cost of living is going up here, I think we would have a better life there. But will my husband and I reconnect? And is it detrimental to the kids to uproot them at crucial stages…. What if they hate it? Are they too old to relocate? I’d have to give up their selective places if we moved, so it is not like we can “try” it and move back if we hate it.

please help. And please be kind. I’m very fragile right now.

thank you

OP posts:
Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 17:04

JMSA · 21/05/2023 16:50

OP, could you leave the children with your parents for a few days, and spend some time in Italy with your husband? I'd treat it as a 'make or break' weekend, with some very frank chat on both sides. You both need to be completely honest about how you see the move, and if you even want it to happen. You could even take the time to visit some schools. This is what I'd do before even considering uprooting my children.

I think this is possible and a good idea. Thank you

OP posts:
Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 17:03

amberisola · 21/05/2023 16:57

Hi OP, sounds like a very tricky decision. I live in Italy and am married to an Italian myself, we have two young DC and marriage is on the rocks. I’m planning to take DC back to UK for a year to start with. DH can’t move because of his job but can do extended visits. Not exactly the same situation as yours, but I understand how complex and hard it all is.

I personally think in your place I would look at finding a way to stay in the UK and lower costs. Not only because your kids are settled, but think about yourself and what you want as well.

Your husband’s employment situation is understandable but how keen is he really to make the relationship work? He sounds pretty disengaged from your post. If your marriage is in a bad place, what are the chances of you ending up living in Italy on your own? Would you be happy with that? Bear in mind that getting a divorce in Italy, if it came to that, would be so much harder than doing so in your current position.

I’ve lived in six different countries as an adult and Italy has been by far the hardest to settle in. You probably know all about this, but I find the need to be completely fluent in the language, the bureaucracy (especially if you’re not an Italian citizen) and general xenophobic and misogynistic attitudes here very difficult to deal with. I often feel like I’m at a major disadvantage compared to DH. Plus he has his family and childhood friendship group, whereas I have to fly to see mine and they can’t babysit etc. Will he share the load enough to compensate for you losing the rest of your support network?

The cost of living depends on where in Italy you’re moving vs where you are in the UK but I find the whacking great taxes on everything means life is also pretty expensive here. Like you I’m a freelancer and had to nearly double my rates when I moved here, since more than 25 percent of my income goes on social security payments alone.

The important question though is what do you want? Where do you see yourself in five or ten years? Your kids will no doubt do well at either school and will be able to choose the uni they want in either country. The answer to the question seems to lie in how you honestly see things going with your marriage and what sort of life YOU really want.

Hi @amberisola

Do you think you will stay in the UK, then? Leave your husband? PM me if you’d like to chat.

We had such good times together and I would like that again. 😞

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 21/05/2023 16:58

Betterbear · 21/05/2023 16:50

Your probably basing your opinion on fluffy stereotypes and what you have seen on tv. Real Italy is not like that. Real Italians are far from the welcoming mamas that films portray. My comment is based on real life and experience.

Fucking LOL. I am also basing my statement on my own experience. Having emigrated twice already I’m quite aware of not relying on stereotypes.

What ‘real Italy’, incidentally? It’s culturally a very diverse country, the obvious divides being between the north and south. The culture of Venice is distinct from the culture of Rome, which is again distinct from the culture of Turin or Milan.

amberisola · 21/05/2023 16:57

Hi OP, sounds like a very tricky decision. I live in Italy and am married to an Italian myself, we have two young DC and marriage is on the rocks. I’m planning to take DC back to UK for a year to start with. DH can’t move because of his job but can do extended visits. Not exactly the same situation as yours, but I understand how complex and hard it all is.

I personally think in your place I would look at finding a way to stay in the UK and lower costs. Not only because your kids are settled, but think about yourself and what you want as well.

Your husband’s employment situation is understandable but how keen is he really to make the relationship work? He sounds pretty disengaged from your post. If your marriage is in a bad place, what are the chances of you ending up living in Italy on your own? Would you be happy with that? Bear in mind that getting a divorce in Italy, if it came to that, would be so much harder than doing so in your current position.

I’ve lived in six different countries as an adult and Italy has been by far the hardest to settle in. You probably know all about this, but I find the need to be completely fluent in the language, the bureaucracy (especially if you’re not an Italian citizen) and general xenophobic and misogynistic attitudes here very difficult to deal with. I often feel like I’m at a major disadvantage compared to DH. Plus he has his family and childhood friendship group, whereas I have to fly to see mine and they can’t babysit etc. Will he share the load enough to compensate for you losing the rest of your support network?

The cost of living depends on where in Italy you’re moving vs where you are in the UK but I find the whacking great taxes on everything means life is also pretty expensive here. Like you I’m a freelancer and had to nearly double my rates when I moved here, since more than 25 percent of my income goes on social security payments alone.

The important question though is what do you want? Where do you see yourself in five or ten years? Your kids will no doubt do well at either school and will be able to choose the uni they want in either country. The answer to the question seems to lie in how you honestly see things going with your marriage and what sort of life YOU really want.

JMSA · 21/05/2023 16:50

OP, could you leave the children with your parents for a few days, and spend some time in Italy with your husband? I'd treat it as a 'make or break' weekend, with some very frank chat on both sides. You both need to be completely honest about how you see the move, and if you even want it to happen. You could even take the time to visit some schools. This is what I'd do before even considering uprooting my children.

Betterbear · 21/05/2023 16:50

whumpthereitis · 21/05/2023 16:45

There are arguably more opportunities in Italy than there are here. I have never found it to be an insular country, either.

I would go. Imo it would be more important to me to have the family I chose united.

Would your children be likely to go to Italy anyway? Either to be with their father now, or after their exams?

Your probably basing your opinion on fluffy stereotypes and what you have seen on tv. Real Italy is not like that. Real Italians are far from the welcoming mamas that films portray. My comment is based on real life and experience.

LaDamaDeElche · 21/05/2023 16:48

Sorry, just saw the private school thing. Well, it's a big adjustment culturally for teens/pre teens, but people make it work. We moved to Spain when DD was 7, so it's been much easier for her to integrate etc, but if they're going to an international school then it shouldn't be too much of a problem. I'm sure job prospects etc will be good going to a school like that too.

LaDamaDeElche · 21/05/2023 16:46

Eldest is about to start GSCEs but extraordinarily bright and will do well anywhere even if we move mid year It's a very different school system than the U.K., you said they don't really speak the language, so even for the brightest child this will have a massive impact on their education, unless you're planning to put them in an international school.

whumpthereitis · 21/05/2023 16:45

There are arguably more opportunities in Italy than there are here. I have never found it to be an insular country, either.

I would go. Imo it would be more important to me to have the family I chose united.

Would your children be likely to go to Italy anyway? Either to be with their father now, or after their exams?

Betterbear · 21/05/2023 16:40

You need to stay. Life in Italy is terrible for children. They will have no opportunities whatsoever. It is very insular despite what the stereotype would have you believe. It would likely be a very lonely and depressing existence.

Outofthepark · 21/05/2023 16:34

Italyoruk · 21/05/2023 14:11

Pros
I would have support with the kids from DH
We would do more family things
Food, weather etc
cost of living better in Italy
ive always wanted to live in Italy
could improve my Italian and skiing

cons
I would miss my family
not be around to support elderly parents (they’re not elderly yet)
kids would miss their friends
kids would be less independent
I would be in a country where English would be a second language for me
Id have to sell our family home
more time with in laws…

no change
I would keep my job (freelancer)

I'd do it because long distance is just completely impossible IMO! Amazing that you can keep your job, and your parents aren't properly elderly yet. It's a cheap and pretty quick flight to Italy as well I'm thinking, not like travelling to the Caribbean or Canada or something. So all in all I'd go for it. Especially if secondary school not started yet.

Yes it's a big uproot for your kids, no denying that but a H can't move and just leave his family behind. That's madness!

But tbh, and you know your DH, is he very serious about making this work and does he understand the implications long term of school changes, etc? You need to have a really open honest conversation.

Justmeandthedog1 · 21/05/2023 16:24

This is only my experience from living in Europe and teaching at an international (private) school. Children go backwards initially, then take time to catch up before they begin to move forward, I’d say allow 2 years.
The GCSEs or equivalent might be ok as they’re in English but the curriculum might not be the same and the other students are well cemented in their friendship groups.
The younger the children, the easier they adapt, your 11 year old might find it difficult.
But does separating your family outweigh the difficult settling in period? Look at extra tuition possibilities to offer your children extra support and be prepared for tears. I found some of the schools less than sympathetic towards new arrivals.
Good luck with whatever you decide.

Newnamenewname109870 · 21/05/2023 16:01

KittyAlfred · 21/05/2023 15:59

It sounds to me as if your marriage is over and you’d be uprooting your kids for nothing. They will never forgive you. Crazy idea.

My main concern from reading this is that it sounds like a very desperate last chance situation and you kind of need it to be more solid than that if you’re making such a move.

How desperate is he for you to come? What work is he putting in? Is he moving heaven and earth to see you all? Is he taking as much A/L as possible to see you and find the perfect home for you all?

KittyAlfred · 21/05/2023 15:59

It sounds to me as if your marriage is over and you’d be uprooting your kids for nothing. They will never forgive you. Crazy idea.

Alaimo · 21/05/2023 15:59

How easy will it actually be for you to move to Italy? I'm in another EU country, and the processing time for spousal visa here is currently 9-12 months. Hopefully Italy is better than that, but it's something to look into if you haven't already.

On the whole though I agree with pps, I really question whether moving is a good thing. Movie to a new country is hard. Working freelance you won't have local colleagues. How will you meet people, make friends? I'm worried it could be a very isolating experience for you, even more so with an already rocky marriage.

On the other hand. If you got divorced, would you be able to keep the house where you live now? You mention maybe mortgage payments. How much would your lives change if you stayed in the UK and got divorced?

RoseMarigoldViolet · 21/05/2023 15:54

I don’t think that uprooting the children at these ages is a good idea.

You may also find yourself stuck in Italy forever if your marriage ends down the track and the children are then settled in the country. Your husband may be able to prevent you and the children from leaving.

diddl · 21/05/2023 15:51

It seems so odd that he just moved without you.

Why wouldn't you have gone with him rather than getting more entrenched in life in UK?

What was the point of exams for a school in UK if the intention was to leave?

Seems to me that your marriage s over either way.

So will your husband pay for you & your sons to stay?

TomatoSandwiches · 21/05/2023 15:38

I would already resent him enough to ask for a divorce so there's my answer.
I absolutely would not move when my youngest had put so much effort into obtaining a prestigious placement for secondary either.
I think you DH has gotten away with some pretty manipulative behaviour and you wouldn't succeed in getting him to do his fair share on Italy either.
I would concentrate on building more connections in the UK.
I feel quite angry for you op.

SerafinasGoose · 21/05/2023 15:36

I'm biased. I love Italy, so much so that we even got married there. I'm also very aware I have an idealistic view of the place.

On the surface life's happier, sunnier, and there's lots of culture and fascinating history. Children are not treated as pariahs the way they are in the UK. But it's ludicrously socially conservative. I have four Italian female friends in my profession: all ended up in the UK because opportunities for women in their home country were so severely restricted. We are talking here about professional academics.

A PP mentions upthread that racism and misogyny are rife. I'd personally not want to risk moving into that situation for the sake of saving a fragile and precarious marriage. Should things with the social and professional situation not work out as you hope, the one thing you need behind you is a strong support system and a solid marriage.

Sounds lovely on the face of it but I'd be thinking twice, three and four times about any such move.

Violasaremyfavourite · 21/05/2023 15:35

Sorry if I sounded unkind. Will you be able to afford to pay for an international school for your children? I assume they are not free. Regardless of the state of your marriage I think your children may resent you very badly for a long time if you do move them. I'm not trying to be horrible at all but I was estranged for a long time from one of my children because of some choices I made. I am grateful that the rift was healed but it hurt me and probably him very badly for years.

I understand you probably feel overwhelmed. Making life changing decisions in a fragile state is not usually conducive to good decision making. Can you give yourself more time to decide? Good luck with things.

Augend23 · 21/05/2023 15:33

If you can't afford to rent the house out, and you can't afford for your husband not to have a "big" job, how will you afford to live if you divorce him?

So1invictus · 21/05/2023 15:29

Good point about university. Up to starting university in 2028 British citizen children living in the EU will be eligible for home fee status. But the younger child of the OP will miss that deadline. I'm not sure if the same legislation applies to those leaving the UK after the withdrawal agreement came into force. I presume so, but it's something else to consider.

NBLarsen · 21/05/2023 15:25

How often are you and the kids seeing DH?
That will tell you more about the state of the marriage than any pros and cons of moving.
Do you all regularly go over to Italy for weekends and school holidays? Does he come over to the UK for weekends in between? If you are all making the effort to spend time together I think you can make long distance work for longer so that your kids can benefit from their settled education.
I would be reluctant to move them at the stage they are at - starting secondary and starting GCSEs.

If you aren't making the effort to spend time together already then I think that gives an indication that the marriage is waning.

Your parents are not actually elderly and in need of care yet from what I understand so that shouldn't be a factor yet. Fine to say you will miss them, but use that as the real reason, not that they need care if they don't.

I'm a bit confused about the original situation. Because of brexit? But you are married, and he was already living here? So he would have been able to stay, but chose to move to Italy for his dream job instead of continuing to pursue work here.
Now he's been working in the job, is he continuing to look for work in the UK?

Monkeymonkeymoo · 21/05/2023 15:23

Honestly I’m not sure I’d make the decision to move in your circumstances (and I say this as someone who has moved abroad to be with my partner).
If things are already rocky then moving to another country is only going to put additional pressure on your marriage. This is especially if you and your sons feel like you’ve sacrificed a lot to be there or if things don’t go to plan (which at times they won’t). You don’t go into what the issues are in your marriage but you need to consider whether they’re actually likely to be improved by you moving to Italy to be with him.

You also need to consider whether you will resent him if you move out there. It sounds like it might be quite isolating for you if you don’t speak Italian and will be working as a freelancer. I understand the reluctance to leave your parents, but Italy is only a short flight (it’s probably quicker to get back than if you lived in another part of the UK), however it sounds like a big concern for you which suggests that it might be another thing that you resent him for.

Have you actually done tours of the schools that would be an option- International schools can really vary in quality.
I assume you’ve already looked at the curriculum and whether it matches with what your eldest is currently studying. Were we are the English speaking international schools offer a range of curriculum options- IB, GCSE/A-level, American etc and whether they offer the subjects that he is currently taking (here they offer a much more limited range of subjects than most UK schools and sixth forms).
If they are likely to go to university and want to study in the UK then you also need to look at what their situation will be if they are not UK residents (EU students no longer pay the same as UK students so they may be liable for international fees).

If I’m totally honest then if I were you then I’d try to find an alternative. Could your husband come home every other weekend during term time and then you spend all of the school holidays with him in Italy (it sounds like you can work anywhere).
Then have a plan for you to move there permanently once they finish school (I found long distance much easier when I knew there was a definite plan in the future for us to live together again).

Wallywobbles · 21/05/2023 15:20

Keep the family home and rent it out. Move. Try it for a decade.

Can DS2 board?