Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask is it rude to go on your phone?

111 replies

autienotnaughtym · 21/05/2023 06:36

I'm on a 40th birthday weekend. We traveled on the train, went out for lunch. Saw a show . Came back to hotel and had a hour then out for dinner and drinks.

In day to day life I do use my phone a lot- messages, Google, jingle, podcasts,music, tv etc. I'm not really on social media. (Other than mn)

During the trip I've looked at my phone a few times on the train (whe I wasn't in a conversation) just checking / answering messages etc When we came back to hotel after theatre I was sharing with birthday girl, she rang her dh and I rang mine and chatted to our son. I also laid down for ten min and caught up on messages/had a nosy on mn. On the tube for about 20 min I was feeling a bit queasy so distracted myself with phone (we were all sat sporadically and I wasn't with anyone)
Later we went to a nightclub , too noisy to talk so either dancing or sitting , I love to dance, so I danced probably 70% of time with bday girl and everyone, had lots of fun. A few times I'd sit for a rest and would get my phone out as I wasn't with anyone. I noticed bday girl kept coming over if I was sat and asking me to request a song or take a photo , go out with her while she smoked (I don't) or get up to dance. At one point I rang my teen dd (outside) to check in.
Bday girl came up and said she had spoke to her dh but forgotten to speak to her (teen) kids. I said don't worry I'm sure they are fine . She said something along lines of "I just don't feel the need to be on my phone all the time like you" I asked what she meant and she said nothing and walked back in.

I didn't use my phone during meals, or obviously the theatre. Nor when we were walking round or sat in bars talking. And when I did it use it it in nightclub was generally if I was sat alone and would literally by a minute or two. Other than on tube when i was completely alone and in hotel when I laid down for ten min. I do find social situations over stimulating at times and looking at phone does help/distract.

So was I rude?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Q2C4 · 22/05/2023 19:02

@CandidaAlbicans2 I absolutely agree - but being on a tube & separated from your group, or in a nightclub when you can't hear a thing & want to sit down between dances (as in the OP's examples) doesn't fall into that category for me. To me, that's enforced downtime which could be used more usefully.

CandidaAlbicans2 · 22/05/2023 18:35

Q2C4 · 22/05/2023 08:56

Adults should be able to just "be" in their environment without needing the crutch of the internet. Always strikes me as a little emotionally immature and lacking in imagination (yes, I know that's unfairly judgemental of me)

You have the fount of available human knowledge on the internet, and you think it is emotionally immature / lacking in imagination to actually use that? I'm happy to see people learning / exploring new things / seeking new horizons and view points in their downtime rather than dwelling on their own thoughts.

I love the internet. Have used it loads to learn new things, to figure out how to get places, to research, to watch videos, to get inspiration for projects, to buy stuff, to keep in touch with friends, etc. However, I believe there's a time and a place, and I wouldn't dream of scrolling in my own little world when I was in company. And I do find it odd to see people in beautiful settings, with their mates, all on their mobiles. What's wrong with watching real life, being mindful of surroundings? Some people appear to live through screens, which I find limiting. So many people are so easily bored they can't just sit and watch the world go by for a minute.

Q2C4 · 22/05/2023 08:56

Adults should be able to just "be" in their environment without needing the crutch of the internet. Always strikes me as a little emotionally immature and lacking in imagination (yes, I know that's unfairly judgemental of me)

You have the fount of available human knowledge on the internet, and you think it is emotionally immature / lacking in imagination to actually use that? I'm happy to see people learning / exploring new things / seeking new horizons and view points in their downtime rather than dwelling on their own thoughts.

autienotnaughtym · 22/05/2023 05:20

Thanks for your replies. Seems like mostly I was BU. I think going forward I will get my own room for some down time if I need it.

OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 21/05/2023 21:04

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 21/05/2023 16:26

Why? So OP is sat on her own, no one is talking to her, no one is near her. How the hell do her actions impact the group or a reflection of the group or how she feels about them?

I don't always go on my phone during "free time" but I do go inside my head which probably looks even worse/weirder being all glazed over and absent.

What this thread shows is the assumptions people make based on prejudice, and not much else. Oh, the horror a phone! Confused

If you're that needy that someone else's behaviour (that you are not even engaging with) affects you that much/ruins the night , that is your problem.

Because she was telling the group other things were more important to her than spending time with them. It doesn’t matter that OP was briefly on her own. When she was, out came the phone. It was rude.

You clearly don’t like my saying it, but it’s true.

KarmaStar · 21/05/2023 18:20

Think it was a lot,you were supposed to be away with them but you don't sound committed to the group,as if you were bored with them.
if love to hear the other persons pov

Kiwimommyinlondon · 21/05/2023 17:53

Totally rude. I’d be annoyed too if I was her. Comes across like you were bored and uninterested.

GeekyThings · 21/05/2023 17:50

I think this is an interesting scenario, tbh. Because my gut is telling me that you did overuse your phone to the point of being a bit rude, and noticeably so to your friend.

But - SHE was also rude, from the constant interruptions every time she saw you pick up your phone, all the way to the backhanded comments about people who overuse their phones and how much of a better person she is for not doing it. Much as she may have disliked your behaviour, she's not your parent and you're an adult, so it wasn't her place to try and modify that behaviour or pass comment on it.

The alarm may have already been set on her phone, I'm terrible for forgetting to turn mine off as well, so I think that one you probably went a bit OTT about.

In terms of overall phone use I think we all probably use them too much, especially when we should probably be paying more attention to what's going on around us. But, in the end, if you're out with a group at a loud nightclub then there's always going to be people doing things that you don't want to do at that moment in time, and vice versa. Not everyone enjoys the same things, and in a group people won't usually get left completely alone if one person is messing with their phone and another one goes out for a fag.

Willmafrockfit · 21/05/2023 17:42

no point making a mountain out of a molehill.
she doesnt approve
end of story.
no need for repercussions

BodegaSushi · 21/05/2023 17:37

I don't care what other ppl think tbh.

I find big group events overwhelming, I would have struggled at a club. I sit for a bit and look at my phone as a way to calm down and recharge.

Sounds like you were present most of the time. It's fine.

Bearpawk · 21/05/2023 17:35

If someone felt the need to comment on it then yes it's probably too much.

billy1966 · 21/05/2023 17:31

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 21/05/2023 16:26

Why? So OP is sat on her own, no one is talking to her, no one is near her. How the hell do her actions impact the group or a reflection of the group or how she feels about them?

I don't always go on my phone during "free time" but I do go inside my head which probably looks even worse/weirder being all glazed over and absent.

What this thread shows is the assumptions people make based on prejudice, and not much else. Oh, the horror a phone! Confused

If you're that needy that someone else's behaviour (that you are not even engaging with) affects you that much/ruins the night , that is your problem.

I agree with you.

I think SHE was rude and the 6am alarm would piss me off so much.

darjeelingrose · 21/05/2023 17:15

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 21/05/2023 16:26

Why? So OP is sat on her own, no one is talking to her, no one is near her. How the hell do her actions impact the group or a reflection of the group or how she feels about them?

I don't always go on my phone during "free time" but I do go inside my head which probably looks even worse/weirder being all glazed over and absent.

What this thread shows is the assumptions people make based on prejudice, and not much else. Oh, the horror a phone! Confused

If you're that needy that someone else's behaviour (that you are not even engaging with) affects you that much/ruins the night , that is your problem.

The friend kept coming over when she was sitting down, so she clearly wanted to spend time with the OP. The OP wanted to put a bit of distance. That's fine, nobody is getting hysterical about the phone, but it's obviously irked the friend a bit, that's all. I don't see the assumptions myself. The friend was clear about wanting the OP to be more engaged, the OP wanted some time out, neither is wrong particularly, defending the OP is hardly a hill to die on though.

autienotnaughtym · 21/05/2023 16:28

I like you. @AngryGreasedSantaCatcus 😂

OP posts:
AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 21/05/2023 16:26

LittleBearPad · 21/05/2023 12:11

Getting your phone out in the club was rude. If you were part of a group I think looking at it on the tube was too. It sends the signal that whatever is on your phone is more important than the people you are with. You certainly aren’t present with them.

Why? So OP is sat on her own, no one is talking to her, no one is near her. How the hell do her actions impact the group or a reflection of the group or how she feels about them?

I don't always go on my phone during "free time" but I do go inside my head which probably looks even worse/weirder being all glazed over and absent.

What this thread shows is the assumptions people make based on prejudice, and not much else. Oh, the horror a phone! Confused

If you're that needy that someone else's behaviour (that you are not even engaging with) affects you that much/ruins the night , that is your problem.

Womencanlift · 21/05/2023 13:27

I get the need to recharge I really do, I need that too in big groups, but I do think you were really rude.

Although to be honest I think the book thing is so much more rude than scrolling through a phone

As a pp said it does come across as you were not enjoying yourself and as it was her celebration I can see why she was pissed off

CandidaAlbicans2 · 21/05/2023 13:20

JandalsAlways · 21/05/2023 06:48

I think the problem is when you go on it, it's sending a message that you're bored and not interested in those around you. I would have probably found it a bit rude (of everyone)

Exactly how I interpret it @JandalsAlways. I'm always a little WTF when I see people scrolling or texting on their phones in social situations or in beautiful places, as it seems they're more engaged in the phone than the company or environment.

All the excuses here seem to me a bit like giving a child a colouring book to entertain them for a bit, adults with manners should not need this

I like that analogy @squidgybits and agree. Adults should be able to just "be" in their environment without needing the crutch of the internet. Always strikes me as a little emotionally immature and lacking in imagination (yes, I know that's unfairly judgemental of me)

burnoutbabe · 21/05/2023 12:53

I am not autistic but a whole weekend with a group would make me want some downtime during parts (like a tube journey)

At 40, with kids/partner you probably don't enjoy nightclubs as much as when young and actually a weekend away you don't want a massive hangover and look forward to a nice lie in.

But I assume skipping the nightclub would have been rude too?? Even if attending all other parts?

GodisaBC · 21/05/2023 12:47

Wow the 6 am alarm is a million times worse than being on your phone a bit.
I would be so annoyed at that. Extremely selfish of her.

autienotnaughtym · 21/05/2023 12:44

Sererus · 21/05/2023 12:29

I'm autistic too, and admittedly wouldn't even have went on the weekend as I dread even the thought of a nightclub, so I get that these things can be difficult for different reasons. However, most of the time OP mentions being on her phone, it seems like she was on it for the sake of it. Only once or twice does she mention using it due to being overstimulated.
It does sound like you are just generally attached to your phone OP, especially if people are noticing. Sometimes you don't realise these things until someone points it out.

Good point

OP posts:
Hugasauras · 21/05/2023 12:43

You apparently have to be available at all times to mouth 'next stop?' even when you know it's the next stop.

Q2C4 · 21/05/2023 12:41

bussteward · 21/05/2023 09:05

It does sound as though the moment you’re not being entertained – sitting apart from others on the Tube, in the nightclub, etc – you’re whipping your phone out. From her POV it might look like you either can’t wait to be reunited with your phone, or you’re not making the effort to engage in anything and the moment other people aren’t doing the work of conversation etc, you’re giving up and going on your phone.

what do your screen time statistics say about how many hours a day you use it?

So, if you're on the tube but separated from your group, are you obliged to stare at the tube adverts? Count the rivets in the train ceiling?! Or shout across to your group?!
What is wrong with using your phone in that scenario?

Sererus · 21/05/2023 12:29

I'm autistic too, and admittedly wouldn't even have went on the weekend as I dread even the thought of a nightclub, so I get that these things can be difficult for different reasons. However, most of the time OP mentions being on her phone, it seems like she was on it for the sake of it. Only once or twice does she mention using it due to being overstimulated.
It does sound like you are just generally attached to your phone OP, especially if people are noticing. Sometimes you don't realise these things until someone points it out.

Hugasauras · 21/05/2023 12:24

Oh and finally, I think sometimes extroverts just don't understand how unpleasant being 'always on' is for introverts. Your friend constantly trying to drag you to request songs, dance even though you'd done plenty, do this and that. I'm sure in her head she thought she was being nice because she was probably thinking from it from her perspective and how she wouldn't want to be sitting alone for a few minutes etc. But if I'm having a sit down and a recharge after a burst of activity then just leave me alone! I don't need to be marched back into the dancefloor or escorted to request a song or be constantly doing something.

It's often just a fundamental misunderstanding between two people coming from very different perspectives (and again the problem with whole weekends: you don't have this issue for shorter social interactions because you can be 'on' for a whole meal or evening or whatever and then switch off/recharge after, whereas a weekend in a shared hotel room with constant stuff on you just can't get away.

Hugasauras · 21/05/2023 12:19

Also I just saw you are autistic, OP, in which case I'd wager that the social elements of weekends like this can be even more intense and taxing for you than for a lot of NT people. Honestly I really dislike these kind of weekends away in a group, they are just not my thing at all. It's very unusual you get a group of friends who gel that well for a whole weekend anyway, and the constant intensity of interaction is a lot. Every one I've been on, by the Sunday people are ratty, irritated by at least one of the other group members, there is also some 'alarm' scenario where one person has done something to piss off someone else and you all get the train back in a kind of awkward/tense mood.

Swipe left for the next trending thread