Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at paying £200 for 40th "surprise" birthday party but not be invited to the "real" party?

367 replies

stanfordpuma · 20/05/2023 21:21

We are a married couple and we have friends, “Eva and Matt”. We invite them to our house frequently and are super-hospitable to them in our home. They have a close circle of friends who live near to them and we know they do a lot of entertaining/socialising without us (obviously fine, we’re all grownups).
Matt recently invited us to Eva’s 40th birthday where we were asked to turn up at a prestigious venue for the “surprise” party and pay £100 each to be part of the party. We were very happy to do this, showed up early for the “surprise”, paid our £200 for the party, brought a present and wished her well.
The party at the venue was at a slightly weird time- 4pm to 8pm on a Saturday- but we didn’t think much of this. We got a babysitter for our kids (he said “no kids”) and showed up to celebrate with her.
Towards the end of the party (as we thought) we were looking for Matt to say goodbye and Eva told us that he had left. We thought this was a bit odd and wondered if they had had an argument. However my husband called Matt and he was on his way home to their house to prepare for the “after party” to which we were clearly not invited.
So- Matt invited us to his wife’s surprise party- for which we paid £200 and couldn’t refuse “because it’s her important birthday”- but didn’t invite us to the “real” party which was clearly taking place from 8pm onwards at their house.
Am I over-reacting to be annoyed that we just got invited to “fill up the numbers” for the surprise in the fancy venue, but weren’t asked to be there at their house? I understand that they’d prefer to have the “after party” with their “real” friends, but it stings a bit that we were only invited to make up the numbers (and the money) at a prestigious venue.

OP posts:
Hellenabe · 21/05/2023 06:49

I seem to be reading this differently to lots here. You've been invited, you went. They were just continuing the party later on, probably for those who couldn't make earlier/wouldn't pay earlier.

I'm one of the former, I'd pay for a nice meal out but don't have the childcare/enthusiasm to have a big late night.

To me, it would be rude if you weren't invited at all to anything.

Glitterblue · 21/05/2023 06:47

I don't think I'd want to be friends with this couple any more. We've recently discovered that some people who we thought were close friends had a completely different side to them and we've decided that life is too short to waste it on friendships that aren't 100% real and two way. We've thinned our friendship circle out over the last 2 years and life is much simpler, less stressful, and we have more time as a family and more time to spend quality time with our real, true friends. It's so nice not to have to go to birthday parties and BBQs with their other friends who we don't know and always felt were their preferred friends and we were just there to make up the numbers!

"Eva and Matt" sound like those ex friends of ours and I honestly think you'd enjoy life more without them.

Newspeaker · 21/05/2023 06:47

JudgeRudy · 21/05/2023 00:19

That would irritate me but I think I'd have questioned the timings at the time. What type of do was it? I'm curious as to what you paid your £200 for.

Why don’t you just look at Op’s previous posts on this thread and find out? Rather than expecting her to repeat for you.

allthewoes · 21/05/2023 06:44

Daisypain · 20/05/2023 23:11

Ok just playing devil’s advocate a bit-

You like them and they like you in the way that happens when kids do an activity but they already have a very close group of friends from whenever back who socialise together and all know each other.

You invite them to yours- they like you so they agree and are perhaps a bit surprised how much effort you go to for an easy get together but hey that’s up to you and you clearly like being the hostess with the mostess vibe.

They return the favour but keep it low key with a take out but you continue to roll out the red carpet. Your choice. You seem to want to win them over.

They don’t invite you to join them with their get togethers with the other group as it’s exactly that- a group who all know each other. They can’t really just invite a new couple in to an existing group with a shared history.

Party is organised- 100% cheeky on the cost per invite- that’s just insane- but they invite you along with lots of other people from work, few family, various people from their lives. Four hour party. All good.

They decide to have the close group back to their afterwards for more drinks etc as that’s always been what happens in that group. It is about 20% at best of the people at the main party. You aren’t part of that group and you even live further away so you aren’t invited back to the house.

Seems not unreasonable to me (party cost aside)

You want and maybe need more from the friendship than they do and they are being sociable and accepting your invites but might feel a bit uncomfortable by how much effort you put in and whilst they like you they don’t need new besties.

Possible?

I think you've hit the nail squarely on the head with this post.

It's common for people to have different sets of friends, and they're all kind of graded in terms of closeness. The issues arise when you think of someone as your grade A/top tier friend, but they have other friends who they've known longer/see more often so you're grade B to them.

I still think it's ridiculous of them to charge people £100 to go to the first party though!

electriclight · 21/05/2023 06:25

Who was at the 8pm house party? Could it have just been close family?

Were the other friends, the ones you sound a bit jealous of, also at the £100pp party?

I think you are jumping to some conclusions. You might be right but can't be certain yet.

TheThinkingGoblin · 21/05/2023 06:22

ShandaLear · 21/05/2023 05:41

OP, my kids did a niche sport and I became friendly with some of the parents - a coffee here and there, the occasional night out/in, or a ‘let’s all go to the sea for a picnic today’ kind of thing, but they were never my ‘best mates’ and I wouldn’t have expected to form part of their own birthday plans.

I think it’s odder that you were even invited to the day event, unless they needed to £200 - are you wealthier than them? Were other people from the sport invited and did they go to the after party? That said, I’d never have done a two tier party because that’s just tacky. These sports friendships are usually casual and fade once the kids stop participating - my DD did a sport at a high level for 7 years so I spent up to 20 hours a week at the venue with about 15-20 other parents so we spent A LOT of time together. My DD left the sport a year ago and I speak to maybe one or two of them on a vaguely regular basis and that’s mainly because our kids are still friends. So be annoyed about the £200, but not the after party, which as others said, probably involved something you didn’t want to take part in anyway.

Pretty much guarantee you that the 4-8pm crowd were the only ones that were convinced to pay up £100 each. That means they likely targeted people that would pay up given the occasion.

My guess is that the later crowd were the ones that paid £0.

Its not the £100 that makes this whole thing stink. Nicer venues can be much more expensive than that but with the caveat that it is the main event. Thats what you are contributing for.

Its how brazen they were in using people that way. They "robbed" Peter to pay Paul. People they don't regard as close friends.

I would be livid because I would feel used (which is obviously true).

silverfullmoon · 21/05/2023 06:21

I'm actually wondering if they over charged you on purpose, so you ended up paying not just for yourself but them/others as well?
Even at a posh place finger food and a few drinks shouldn't be costing in the hundreds!

They are CFs big time, that's for sure

Yes, this is a very good point. They probably thought they could do this as OP has been so generous with her friendship in the past.

Wow- what a pair of horrible, nasty people yuck

Nanaof1 · 21/05/2023 06:17

Hopelesscynic · 20/05/2023 22:00

I'm actually wondering if they over charged you on purpose, so you ended up paying not just for yourself but them/others as well?
Even at a posh place finger food and a few drinks shouldn't be costing in the hundreds!
They are CFs big time, that's for sure

I replied above before I read your post.

ITA! That seems a bit much to me when it wasn't even a meal. Unless it was unlimited drinks but then, it's still only worth it for the heavy drinkers.

Nanaof1 · 21/05/2023 06:15

stanfordpuma · 20/05/2023 21:59

No- they had us over once and ordered Chinese takeaway, but apparently put on huge spreads for their "real" friends and have wonderful nights (which they tell us about when they're at our house- which is weird). I'm the "super-hospitable" type so when people come to our house I'm flying around with ludicrous amounts of food, wine, good-non-wine-options for non-drinkers, non-dairy for the lactose intolerants, gluten free for the gluten intolerants, veggie options, etc. I don't expect other people to be as stupidly welcoming as I am but a little "you're welcome to come back to ours for a glass of wine" would be nice.

I hope, by writing that all out, you have realized one thing. They are users. They set out a spread for people who they wish to suck up to, stay on their good side, impress and curry their favor. You and your DH do not fit into that category, so you aren't worth even basic politeness and hospitality.

Run, do not walk away from these insincere, awful people and consider yourselves lucky it only cost you a couple hundred pounds. I wonder if everyone who went to the party paid 200 pounds/couple? I have my doubts.

electriclight · 21/05/2023 06:11

I don't think you paid £200 to attend their party did you? That was the pp package price for four hours of drinks and sharing platters at the 'prestigious' venue. I'm going to something similar next week but it's £60pp for two hours - private room, food, two cocktails. So I don't think that part is cheeky really.

The timing could also have been the only time the private room was available, or the only time they could accommodate such large numbers. Ours is also a slightly unusual time.

But it's very cheeky to dismiss you at 8pm. I would have assumed we'd all be going on somewhere else. So some guests went back to the house and some didn't? Or was it a completely different crowd?

silverfullmoon · 21/05/2023 05:59

daretodenim · 20/05/2023 22:44

I was thinking this too. How many people were at the drinks and nibbles party?

FWIW I don't think you're humiliating yourself by having been friends with them. I think you're behaving normally and decently and they're not. In situations like that, where you're not a selfish person and you're taken advantage of, it can easily feel like you were somehow stupid for not seeing it sooner. The truth is that we don't see CF sooner because we take people at face value and expect people to be decent. So please, rather than feel bad about this, just know that they've now shown themselves clearly for who they are, so you can get rid of the from your life guilt-free.

You sound like a nice person and a generous host. Loads of us would like to be your friend! And I'm quite sure you have plenty of other friends who no doubt value you for more than free nosh and Guiness. Go and spend more time with them.

I agree with this. OP is acting like a decent friend would and has nothing to feel bad about. You didnt know then that that were rude arseholes but now you do so adjust your behaviour accordingly and drop the rope.

I wouldnt be making any effort with them whatsoever in future now you know what their real unpleasant character is like

Tootootoot · 21/05/2023 05:55

It can be so painful and hurtful when you're a good, honest and sincere person and you run across people who aren't like that themselves. You can get used, like Eva and Matt seem to have done, and you can get your feelings hurt like some people on this thread have tried to do. You have to bear in mind it reflects on those people and.not on you. Please.keep.being so lovely even though it's difficult- but try not to expect that everyone you meet is going to be the same. Just treasure those who are even more whenever you find them.

ShandaLear · 21/05/2023 05:41

OP, my kids did a niche sport and I became friendly with some of the parents - a coffee here and there, the occasional night out/in, or a ‘let’s all go to the sea for a picnic today’ kind of thing, but they were never my ‘best mates’ and I wouldn’t have expected to form part of their own birthday plans.

I think it’s odder that you were even invited to the day event, unless they needed to £200 - are you wealthier than them? Were other people from the sport invited and did they go to the after party? That said, I’d never have done a two tier party because that’s just tacky. These sports friendships are usually casual and fade once the kids stop participating - my DD did a sport at a high level for 7 years so I spent up to 20 hours a week at the venue with about 15-20 other parents so we spent A LOT of time together. My DD left the sport a year ago and I speak to maybe one or two of them on a vaguely regular basis and that’s mainly because our kids are still friends. So be annoyed about the £200, but not the after party, which as others said, probably involved something you didn’t want to take part in anyway.

Pansypotter123 · 21/05/2023 05:35

Have you heard from them since? And what did you buy her for her birthday gift?

2catsandhappy · 21/05/2023 05:05

I would feel so hurt.

My inner Miss Marple would be finding out what the actual ticket price of drinks and nibbles were and letting everyone know how much profit Matt made.
Also that £200 was the cost of paying off fake friends.

Violasaremyfavourite · 21/05/2023 04:56

It's always a really sickening discovery. I remember once driving my son round to a friend's place to drop off a present. There was obviously a party going on to which he equally obviously hadn't been invited. I didn't slow and drove past. I felt awful for him at the time.

Densol57 · 21/05/2023 04:50

I dont think £100 each is a lot for nibbles and free flowing drinks. I could easily “consume” that, so don't feel like a mug at all. You are decent friends who went along, got a baby sitter etc and then get a kick in the teeth like this. Its a horrible feeling.

You say you dont want to create a scene. The best way is to distance yourself, never be available and put this one sided friendship in the bin.

Chin up chick - there are nice people around x

nettie434 · 21/05/2023 04:35

PawsAndReflection · 21/05/2023 02:34

In your shoes I'd be dying to find out if the actual cost was 100pp, I'd be calling the venue this week to ask how much something like that would cost per head. You can say you went this weekend and loved it so much you were thinking of doing it yourself!

But then I always have to get to the bottom of CFuckery GrinBlush

I love the suggestions that Eva and Matt are swingers and/or are known for their drug fuelled parties. It would be easy to phone the venue and say you are thinking about having an all in party there too. There's no need to pretend to be Eva or anything complicated. This way you will know the true extent of Eva and Matt's CFery, although I suspect a swanky venue is quite likely to charge £100 per head.

Stanfordpuma, please don't worry about the posters who would never have paid to go to a party. It's precisely because you are a good host who wants people to have a nice time that you didn't question this. It's not just the fact that you have hosted them but they didn't reciprocate that hurts, it's the evasion about the 2nd party and the fact that they didn't fork out anything for the first party. Hopefully, over time, it will become a funny story that you can regale to your guests as you are being the perfect host and they can all be as appalled as most of us are by Eva and Matt.

PS I do hope you didn't get Eva a generous present, but I expect you did!

TheThinkingGoblin · 21/05/2023 04:02

stanfordpuma · 20/05/2023 23:53

All of this is true. Yes I did give Matt £200 in cash because he said that's what it cost. I don't think that makes me a "mug" as some posters have said- they are/were "friends"; it was the "cost" of the party as we were told.
And yes I need to pull my big girl pants on. No point whinging about money spent/lost. I think in fairness I wasn't moaning about that in any case- just feeling a bit "used".
Thanks to everyone who's been supportive- I needed a few people to agree with me that this whole situation is a bit "dickish".
I won't let myself get pulled into their nonsense again.

You were used by Matt as fillers to pay for the venue (private hire, food, drinks).

You were then discarded as they only view you as acquaintances.

Its a tough lesson to learn. It will hurt for a while.

Boomshock · 21/05/2023 03:43

Swingers or coke heads!

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 21/05/2023 03:26

You lost me at you paid 200 quid to go to a party 😳
WTF

YouJustDoYou · 21/05/2023 03:07

You sound lovely op - no more giving of your generosity and amazing hosting to these people!

PawsAndReflection · 21/05/2023 02:34

In your shoes I'd be dying to find out if the actual cost was 100pp, I'd be calling the venue this week to ask how much something like that would cost per head. You can say you went this weekend and loved it so much you were thinking of doing it yourself!

But then I always have to get to the bottom of CFuckery GrinBlush

Dalriada35 · 21/05/2023 01:44

What @Malificent1 said. These people are not your friends. This is not how friends behave.

coxesorangepippin · 21/05/2023 01:41

I'd be tempted to call the venue and pretend to be 'Eva' asking if my husband 'Matt' owed anything and how much did it come to by the way

^

Oh yeah, my vote too

Swipe left for the next trending thread